- 1 - !"! #"$$ %% &$' ( !" # $% % & ! '% (!"" )*!+,,, , ( - % %"",. !/",, ,(""!!( )!.!","! !!","!/ # Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $% % ),' ! & ) ) !/$!&) ) ,(!!,",! % *+!"!,"!/ ) ) ) 0% " 1233456756 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: ,(!!,",! ?2@@4: AB ::3 457C> 7D73 9:64 25: *+ 782B2?9>2 755C!"!,"!/ <17@2??4237@E734: , >7 %2@2D2>28 2<1 342>54: FC95@43 @9A;7<<4: 2??423 =2@ AB F327;25< EC> 45125F4;45< CE FC;?45@2<7C5 < =2@ @9A;7<<4: C5 ,,!,,"! @1CG F327;25<H@ E2<14> =2@ >7:75617@A7FBF34C5212D44>1C=G C32?9> =145:>7D4>CE <>9FG 5C*!+*,,, :>CD4 7< 75 >2@1 25: 54637645< ;2554> 25: :2@14: 26275@< A7FBF34 F29@756 2FF7:45< 5 @27: 2FF7:45< @1CG@9@<2754:6>74DC9@7589>74@25::74:C5=2B<C 1C@?7<23 3346756 3C@@ CE :4?45:45FB C5 2FFC95< CE 95<7;43B - 3 - :42<1 17@95;2>>74::2961<4>E734:F327;?4<7<7C595:4> 4F<7C5 ! CEC<C>417F34@F<26275@<C=54>25:75@9>4>CE<>9FG 5 @4>D7F4 C=54> :7: 5C< 2??42> 25: =2@ ?32F4: 4I*?2><45@9>4>C??C@4:F327;?4<7<7C5:45B756CFF9>>45F4CE 2FF7:45< 23346756:4F42@4:<CA454637645<75F29@7562FF7:45< 2@=4332@F327;A47564IF4@@7D4%2@4:C5?342:756@ <>7A9523 E>2;4: 7@@94@ 25: >4FC>:4: 4D7:45F4 327;25< 4I2;754: 14>@43E2@!25:6C<;2>G4:I@*!<C*/5@9>4>:7:5C< 342:4D7:45F4 ( 5 FC5@7:4>2<7C5 >7A9523 143: 2FF7:45< 12: CFF9>>4::94<C>2@125:54637645<:>7D756CE<>9FGAB7<@:>7D4> 342:756<C:42<1CEF327;25<H@E2<14>25:F327;25<A475645<7<34: EC>FC;?45@2<7C5E>C;75@9>4>2@EC33C=@ 7@@2<7@E74: =7<1 @2;4 2??423 =2@ E734: < =2@ E7>@<3B @9A;7<<4: <1C961 <>7A9523 12: >761<3B 2@@4@@4: 264 CE :4F42@4: 2< B42>@ 25: FC5@7:4>4: ;C5<13B 75FC;4 2< 3C 42:@ ;C95< ! C=2>:@3C@@CE:4?45:45FB @( /, ""* , )954>234I?45@4@25:CA@4J974@ @," """* C@@CE4@<2<4 @!" """* C<23 @ ", ""* - 4 - @ /"* <>7A9523 4>>4: 75 :4:9F<756 "K CE @2;4 <C=2>:@ ?4>@C523 4I?45@4@ CE :4F42@4: 75@<42: CE !>: 2@ :4F42@4: =2@ ;2>>74: < =2@ E9><14> @9A;7<<4: <>7A9523 E2734: <C 2:: E9<9>4 ?>C@?4F<@ <C ;C5<13B 75FC;4 12< 2?2>< <>7A9523 :7: 5C< 2=2>: 2:4J92<4 FC;?45@2<7C5 95:4> FC5D45<7C523 142:@ 5@27:6>C95:@ @C961<EC>45125F4;45< 5 C<14> 125: >7 9A12@1 2332?9> 342>54: FC95@43EC>>4@?C5:45<*75@9>4>C??C@4:2??423 / 42>:342>54:FC95@434>9@4:7;?9654:89:6;45< 25:2=2>: )>C; 2ACD4 25: @75F4 C53B F327;25< 7@ 75 2??423 C53B?C75<<12<=C93:2>7@4EC>FC5@7:4>2<7C57@ . 5 D74= CE 2ACD4 F7>F9;@<25F4@ CFF9>>45F4 CE 2FF7:45< 75DC3D756 75@9>4: D417F34 :94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7D756 CE 2> AB 7<@ :>7D4> :42<1 CE F327;25<H@ E2<14> 75 @27: 2FF7:45< 25: F327;25< A4756 45<7<34: EC> FC;?45@2<7C5 E>C; 75@9>4>2>45C<75:7@?9<4327;25<@<2<4:<12<:4F42@4:=2@ - 5 - B42>@CE26425:@43E*4;?3CB4:C5HA34 9?>4;4C9><75 F2@4 CE 12@ 143: ;C5<13B 75FC;4 CE :4F42@4: 5C<7C5233B F327;25< =C93: A4 45<7<34: EC> 2::7<7C5 <C=2>:@ E9<9>4 ?>C@?4F<@ =17F1 75 ?>4@45< F2@4 =C93: A4 2< !"K )9><14> 2@ ?4> @27: :4F7@7C5 75 F2@4 CE :4F42@4: A4756 ;2>>74: :4:9F<7C5<C=2>:@?4>@C5234I?45@4@=C93:A4!>: 14>4EC>4 FC;?9<2<7C5 CE 3C@@ CE :4?45:45FB =C93: A4 2@ EC33C=@ L$@ /"*M!"K&!>:NI!,I.O@ ., ..* !" ?2>< E>C; @27: FC;?45@2<7C5 F327;25< =C93: A4 45<7<34: EC> 2=2>: CE @(" """* <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CE ?2>45<23 FC5@C><79; @! """* <C=2>:@ E954>23 4I?45@4@ 25: @! """*<C=2>:@3C@@CE4@<2<4@?4>:4F7@7C575 $@9?>2& F327;25< =C93: A4 45<7<34: EC> !"K 4@F232<7C5 EC> 4D4>B <1>44 B42>@ 75F4 ;C>4 <125 @7I B42>@ 12D4 32?@4: 2E<4> :4F7@7C5 75 $@9?>2& F327;25<=C93:A445<7<34:<C,"K4@F232<7C574 @!( """* $@/" """*I,"K&19@ F327;25<=C93:A445<7<34:<C<C<23 ! !""! - 6 - FC;?45@2<7C5 CE @/ / ..* >C95:4: CEE <C @/ // """* 2@@4@@4:2@EC33C=@ )*+,-./)0,*120 .301 C@@CE:4?45:45FB @ ., ..* C5D45<7C523142:@ @/" """* @F232<7C5$,"K& @!( """* 1*4 ,55678 30+)+ ,5558 !! 19@ ?C75< EC> FC5@7:4>2<7C5 7@ 25@=4>4: ?2><3B 75 2EE7>;2<7D4C5@4J945<3B EC33C=756 7 ??4237@233C=4:75?2>< 89:6;45<25:2=2>: :2<4: ,(!!,",! ?2@@4: AB C<C> FF7:45< 327;@ >7A9523 C+ 782B2?9>2 75 5C!"!,"!/ 7@ ;C:7E74: F327;25<@ 2>4 143: 45<7<34: EC> <C<23 FC;?45@2<7C5 CE @/ // """* 2@ 26275@< @ ", ""* 2=2>:4: AB >7A9523 =7<1 75<4>4@< 2< K ?4> 2559; E>C; :2<4 CE F327; ?4<7<7C5 <733 :4?C@7< 4IF39:75675<4>4@<EC>:432B?4>7C:CE.!:2B@ 2@ ?4> @4?2>2<4 C>:4> CE <17@ C9>< :2<4: !"/,", - 7 - 77 5@9>4> 7@ :7>4F<4: <C :4?C@7< 45125F4: FC;?45@2<7C5A4EC>4>7A9523=7<175@7I=44G@ 777 5 :4?C@7< FC5:7<7C5 7;?C@4: AB <>7A9523 EC> :4?C@7<>4342@4 =C93: 2??3B <C 45125F4: FC;?45@2<7C5?>C?C><7C52<43B +8 &$$' " % 7@<C! 3C, <G