- 1 - !"# ## $% & !" # $%&" ! ' # $%&" ( ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !) !") '' * ' +!"!" !) !") ' , , - ' " ./0 122314 /0 253635537 89 :.3 ;0<51;=3 =>?21;91@1/;0::.3'<7@?3;:1;71A15771:37+!"!" /; >!) !") 89 :.3 77/:/>;14 3;/>5 /B/4 '<7@3 1;7 ' 1;7 >??/00/>;35 6>5 >5C?3;D0 >?23;01:/>; 1/=.<56>50.>5:E:.3>??/00/>;35D ! .3 =41/?1;: A10 A>5C/;@ 10 75/B35 >6 3?2> >>61; 8315/;@ 53@/0:51:/>; >F $F% <;735 5302>;73;: > ; ")"!") 7<5/;@ :.3 =><503 >6 3?24>9?3;:.3?3:A/:.1==/73;:1;70<663537/;G<5/303 6/437 =41/? 23:/:/>; 836>53 :.3 >??/00/>;35 033C/;@ =>?23;01:/>; >6 0$""""" 14>;@ A/:. /;:3530: 1: :.3 - 3 - 51:3 >6 !H 235 1;;<? 65>? :.3 71:3 >6 23:/:/>; :/44 5314/I1:/>; >;0/735/;@ :.3 3;:/53 3B/73;=3 >; 53=>57 :.3 >??/00/>;35 1A15737 1 0<? >6 0$F%)) 14>;@ A/:. /;:3530: 1: :.3 51:3 >6 FH 235 1;;<? 65>? :.3 71:3 >6 1==/73;: :/44 /:0 5314/I1:/>; 3/;@ 1@@5/3B37 89 :.3 01/7 '<7@?3;:1;71A157:.3 ;0<51;=3=>?21;9.10253635537 :.325303;:122314 302>;73;: >! /0 :.3 >A;35 >6 3?2> >>61; 8315/;@ 53@/0:51:/>; >F $F% 302>;73;: > =41/?1;:0:1:37:.1:.3A10A>5C/;@<;7355302>;73;: >!>A;35 10 1 75/B35 1;7 >; ")"!") 7<5/;@ :.3 =><503 >6 3?24>9?3;: A./43 .3 A10 75/B/;@ ./0 B3./=43 8315/;@ 53@/0:51:/>; >F $F% 10 0>?3 0:533: 7>@0 A353 0<773;49 =1?3 1=5>00 :.3 5>17 .3 1224/37 851C3 1;7 7<3 :> :.3 01/7 0<773; 851C3./0B3./=43 :<5;37 :<5:431;7 :.3=41/?1;: 5302>;73;:>0<0:1/;37/;G<5/301;70./6:37 :>.>02/:14 & .3 >A;35 >6 :.3 B3./=43 5302>;73;: >! 12231537 836>53 :.3 >??/00/>;35 1;7 17?/::37 :.3 - 4 - 5341:/>;0./283:A33;./?1;7:.3=41/?1;:36<5:.350:1:37 :.1: 5302>;73;: > =41/?1;: A10 1 75/B35 1;7 .3 A10 219/;@014159>6 0!""" 235?>;:.1;7 0$" 1081::1 235719J:.3B3./=43A10/;0<537:.32>4/=9A10/;6>5=310 0<=..3/0;>:4/1843:>219:.3=>?23;01:/>; $ ;B/3A>6:.317?/00/>;>6:.35302>;73;:>! :.353/0;>3?24>9351;73?24>9335341:/>;0./283:A33;:.3 =41/?1;: 1;7 :.3 >A;35 >6 :.3 B3./=43 <5:.35 /: /0 0:1:37 :.1: 5302>;73;: > =41/?1;: A10 ;>: .1B/;@ B14/7 1;7 3663=:/B375/B/;@4/=3;=31;7140>:.32>4/=9A10;>:/;6>5=3J :.353 /0 73419 >6 6><5 7190 /; 6/4/;@ :.3 =>?241/;: > 53=>57015325>7<=37:>0.>A:.1:.3.100<0:1/;37/;G<5/30 7<5/;@ :.3 =><503 >6 3?24>9?3;: /; :.3 5>17 1==/73;: <: :.3 >??/00/>;35 A/:.><: =>;0/735/;@ :.3 3B/73;=3 >; 53=>57.10144>A37:.3=41/?23:/:/>; F 0 235 K :.3 >A;35 >6 :.3 B3./=43 /0 :.3 85>:.35 >6 :.3 =41/?1;: 10 0<=. L<30:/>; >6 3?24>935 1;7 3?24>933 7>30 ;>: 15/03 B3; /; K =>?241/;: /: /0 =431549?3;:/>;37:.1::.353A106<;=:/>;/;:.3/5.><031;7 - 5 - :.3 =41/?1;: .10 :>>C :.3 B3./=43 :> 85/;@ :.3 5341:/B30 :> :.3/5 .><03 .353 /0 73419 /; 6/4/;@ :.3 =>?241/;: 1;7 ;> 3K241;1:/>;A10@/B3;6>5:.373419.3536>53:.36>44>A/;@ 0<80:1;:/14L<30:/>;0>641AA><4715/03, + 3157:.315@<?3;:065>?8>:.0/730 % ./0 122314 /0 253635537 89 :.3 ;0<51;=3 =>?21;9>;:.3@5><;7:.1::.3=41/?1;:.1061/437:>25>B3 :.35341:/>;0./2>63?24>9351;73?24>9331;7:.31==/73;: .10 ;>: >==<5537 7<5/;@ :.3 =><503 >6 :.3 3?24>9?3;: 10 0<=. :.3 ;0<51;=3 =>?21;9 /0 ;>: 4/1843 :> 219 :.3 =>?23;01:/>; - 6 - ) .353 /0 ;> 7/02<:3 53@157/;@ :.3 61=: :.1: /;G<537=41/?1;: 1;7 5302>;73;: >! 153 85>:.350 .3 =41/?1;:.100:1:37:.1::.39153:.53385>:.3501;731=.>6 :.3?153.1B/;@B3./=4300235:.3=>?241/;:>;:.371:3 >61==/73;::.353A1016<;=:/>;/;:.3/5.><031;7:>85/;@ :.3/55341:/B30:.3=41/?1;:.10:>>C:.3B3./=43834>;@0:> ./0 85>:.35 :> :.3 B/441@3 .353 /0 1 73419 >6 6><5 7190 /; 6/4/;@ :.3 =>?241/;: .3 >??/00/>;35 >8035B37 :.1: /??37/1:349 16:35 :.3 1==/73;: ./0 85>:.35 0./6:37 :.3 =41/?1;: :> :A> 7/66353;: .>02/:140 1;7 41:35 :.39 @1B3 =>?241/;: >; !"!") 10 0<=. :.353 A10 73419 >6 6><5 7190.3>??/00/>;35=>;0/735/;@:.33B/73;=31;761=:0 >6 :.3 =103 .10 0:1:37 :.1: ?353 73419 /; 6/4/;@ :.3 =>?241/;:/0;>:15310>;:>7/0=157:.3=41/? :/06>5:.3 =41/?1;: :> 25>B3 :.1: .3 A10 A>5C/;@ 10 1 75/B35 <;735 5302>;73;: >! 1;7 :.3 1==/73;: .10 >==<5537 7<5/;@ :.3 =><503>63?24>9?3;:/;=3:.35302>;73;:>!17?/::37 :.1: .3 A10 219/;@ 014159 1;7 81::1 :> :.3 =41/?1;: /: =1;;>: 83 01/7 :.1: :.353 3?24>935 1;7 53?24>933 5341:/>;0./2 83:A33; :.3 =41/?1;: 1;7 :.3 >A;35 >6 :.3 - 7 - B3./=43 7?/::3749 :.353 A10 1 6<;=:/>; /; :.3/5 .><03 .3;:.3=41/?1;::>>C:.3B3./=43:>85/;@:.35341:/B30:> :.3/5 .><03 .3 ?3: A/:. 1==/73;: :.3536>53 :.3 >??/00/>;35 .10 35537 /; 12253=/1:/;@ :.3 3B/73;=3 25>23549 1;7 144>A37 :.3 =41/? 23:/:/>; .3 '<7@?3;: 1;7 1A15721003789:.3>??/00/>;35/04/1843:>8303:10/73 " ==>57/;@49:.36>44>A/;@, / .3 122314 6/437 89 :.3 ;0<51;=3 =>?21;9/0144>A37J // .3 '<7@?3;: 1;7 1A157 71:37 +!"!" 210037 /; >!) !") 89 :.3 77/:/>;14 3;/>5 /B/4 '<7@3 1;7 ' 1;7 >??/00/>;35 6>5 >5C?3;D0 =>?23;01:/>; 1/=.<5/003:10/73J /// .31?><;:732>0/:3789:.3 ;0<51;=3 =>?21;983536<;737:>:.3 ;0<51;=3=>?21;9 '() $#% " /0:>,4>,&)