- 1 - !"# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) ! " # $ ! " " $$% ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $! ! & '$ $( $$$ )* $ * * ' + +,$ -# -**( $ $ $ $. ***# & '"**# $! ( + + )'( + + + $ + ! ** $ ! $ ! ) *" - 3 - + ! /$! /$! ! & '/$! ( 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 )'( => <05 =<=: 501;652;<'05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32?<05;<@>=: 20=:<(032A558>1659AB<05;631C38<2A518D3DD:15E59AB <05F79DC58<3893G3:993<59 **432259AB<05 -996 12<:1;< !79D5 389 - 18 =) *" +3;<2 D1E18D :125 <= <05 >1618D => <05 344536 A:15>6B2<3<593:5<03<=8**"3<**3C853: E3:23 8H=63 <<3:H388393 =8 -"" <05 9:1E5: => G1>< 9I1:5 3: A53:18D =-# -** 9:=E5 <05 23C5 18 :320 389 85D61D58< C3885: <:159 <= =E5:<3H5 38=<05: E501;65 6=2< ;=8<:=6 =E5: <05 ;3: 932059 <= <05 95;53259789344323:5276<=><053>=:523193;;1958< - 4 - <05 95;53259 272<31859 D:15E=72 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59 <=<0518F7:152 05;631C38<2>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8""=> <05 ;< 255H18D ;=C45823<1=8 >=: <05 953<0 => <05 95;53259789344336=8DG1<018<5:52< 8 25:E1;5 => 27CC=82 :524=8958< = 12 463;595J-43:<5524=8958<=03234453:59<0:=7D0 1<2 ;=78256 389 >1659 G:1<<58 2<3<5C58< 958B18D <05 3E5:C58<2C39518<05;631C45<1<1=8 # 8<05A3212=><054653918D2=><0543:<152<05 631C2:1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055E1958;505;631C38<218=:95:<=4:=E5<05;325 5J3C1859;631C38<=G1>5=><0595;5325932 -389 =85 5B5G1<8522 32 - 389 D=< 5J01A1<59 9=;7C58<2 83C56BJ <=J 8<05 =<05: 0389:524=8958<2 9198=<;0==25<=3997;538B5E1958;5=8<051:A5036>A7< D=< 5J01A1<59 =85 9=;7C58< 83C56B 1827:38;5 4=61;B 32 J 05 631C2 :1A7836 AB <05 1C47D859 F79DC58< 0569<03<<053;;1958<<==H463;5=83;;=78<=> - 5 - :320 38985D61D58< 9:1E18D => <05 =>>58918D E501;65 AB 1<2 9:1E5: 32 3 :5276< => G01;0 <05 95;53259 272<31859 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59 <= <05 18F7:152 05 :1A7836 >7:<05: 0569 <03< <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2*** - 36=8D G1<0 18<5:52< 3< <05 :3<5 => "K 43 389 91:5;<59 <05 :524=8958< = <= 954=21< <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8D G1<0 18<5:52< $518D3DD:15E59<012344536032A558>1659 " 05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 ;631C38<2 032 :31259<05>=66=G18D;=8<58<1=82 3( +1:2<6B<0595;53259G323D593A=7< B53:2 3< <05 <1C5 => <05 3;;1958< 389 05 G32 53:818D 2**** - 45: C=8<0 = 4:=E5 <05 23C5 4:=97;59 9:1E18D 61;58;5'(32 J <05 :1A7836 03232252259 8=<1=836 18;=C5 => 95;53259 32 2)*** - 45: C=8<0 G01;012=8<056=G5:21955>7:<05:;=8<5895918E15G => F79DC58< => =8@A65 74:5C5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => - 6 - !! "##K=><0518;=C5=><0595;53259 032<=A539959>=:?>7<7:54:=245;<2@ A( 32<6B 05 032 ;=8<58959 <03< 18 E15G => F79DC58< => <05 =8@A65 74:5C5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => $%&' ()&* + *"# 53;0 => <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => 2 **** - 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 6=E53893>>5;<1=8389;=82=:<17C@58;5052=7D0<>=: 58038;5C58<=>;=C45823<1=8 ) <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: 34453:18D <05 827:38;5 =C438B 032 27AC1<<59 <03< <05 5E58 <0=7D0;631C38<203E5;631C59<03<95;53259G3253:818D 2**** - 45: C=8<0 5J;54< 4:=97;18D <05 <05B 03E5 8=< 4:=97;59 38B 9=;7C58< <= 20=G <03< 05 G32 G=:H18D 32 3 6=::B 9:1E5: 389 53:818D 2**** - 05:5>=:5:1A7836032:1D0<6B32252259<058=<1=836=><05 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 32 2)*** - 18;5 <05 ;631C38<2 03E5 >31659 <= 52<3A6120 <05 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 :1A7836 032 :1D0<6B 8=< 3G3:959 >7<7:5 - 7 - 4:=245;<2+18366B05032;=8<58959<03<;=82195:18D<05 3D5 389 3E=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3G3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 F72< 389 :532=83A6558;5054:3B2>=:912C12236=><05344536 ) 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05F79DC58<3893G3:9=><05:1A7836 < 12 8=< 18 91247<5 <03< 7893443 9159 18 <05 :=39 <:3>>1; 3;;1958< =;;7::59 =8 **" 975 <=:320 389 85D61D58< 9:1E18D => <05 9:1E5: => 01>< 521:5 G1>< 9I1:53:A53:18D=-# -**AB1<29:1E5: E58<0=7D0<05;631C38<2;631C<03<95;53259 G32 53:818D 2**** - 45: C=8<0 32 3 9:1E5: 5J;54< 4:=97;18D<05=>8=8<:3824=:<;631C38<203E58=< 4:=97;59 38B 9=;7C58< <= 20=G <03< <05 95;53259 G32 D5<<18D C=8<06B 18;=C5 => 2**** - 5E58 8= A38H 2<3<5C58<032A5584:=97;598<053A258;5=>4:==>=> 18;=C5<058=<1=83618;=C5032<=A5322522593245:<05 D719561852 122759 AB <05 3:83<3H3 <3<5 5D36 5:E1;52 7<0=:1<B 05 :1A7836 032 :1D0<6B 32252259 <05 8=<1=836 - 8 - 18;=C5 => <0595;53259 3< 2)#* - 45: C=8<0 =<05 3>=:52319 18;=C5 #K 032 <= A5 39959 =8 3;;=78< => >7<7:5 4:=245;<2 18 E15G => <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 =82<1<7<1=8$58;0=><0574:5C5=7:<18,- '274:3( 389 <0 => <05 18;=C5 032 <= A5 9597;<59 >=: 45:2=836 5J458252 072 <05 C=8<06B 18;=C5 ;=C52 <= 2*) - 05 95;53259 G32 3D59 3A=7< B53:2 3< <05 <1C5 => <05 3;;1958< 389 C76<14615: 34461;3A65 <= 012 3D5 D:=74 12 ? @ 072 <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2)*" - '2*)LL L ( =83;;=78<=>?6=22=>95458958;B@ * 8 3991<1=8 <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8=>2#*** -=83;;=78<=>?6=22=>52<3<5@ 389 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2#*** - =8 3;;=78< => ?>785:36 5J458252@ 8 E15G => <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 74:5C5 =7:<18<05;325=>,$%&' -'274:3( ;631C38< = 12 58<1<659 2 **** - >=: 24=7236 ;=82=:<17C;631C38<=23893:558<1<6592 **** - - 9 - 53;0 >=: 43:58<36 ;=82=:<17C ;631C38< = 389 # 3:5 58<1<659 362= 2 **** - 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => >16136;=82=:<17C@ 072<05;631C38<23:558<1<659<=<05>=66=G18D ;=C45823<1=8 *+,-./01- 2-3,431,4,-0 ,/3. *2-01-'.( =22=>95458958;B 2)*" - +785:365J458252 2#*** - =22=>52<3<5 2#*** - 4=7236;=82=:<17C 2 **** - 3:58<36;=82=:<17C 2**** - =22=>+16136 ;=82=:<17C 2**** - 0/5 . 6 8<05:5276<<05>=66=G18D=:95:12432259 3( 0534453612/557,31-+/40 A( 05 F79DC58< => <05 631C2 :1A7836 12C=91>159 - 10 - ;( 05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=C45823<1=8 => . 6 32 3D3182< 2*** -3G3:959AB<05:1A7836 9( 05827:38;5=C438B1291:5;<59<= 954=21< <05 58038;59 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8DG1<018<5:52<3<"K43>:=C<0593<5=> >1618D => <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361I3<1=8 G1<018 3 45:1=9 => >=7: G55H2 >:=C <0593<5=>:5;514<=>;=4B=><012F79DC58< 5( 05 344=:<1=8C58< 954=21< 389 :565325=>3C=78<20366A5C39518<5:C2=><05 3G3:9=><05:1A7836 >( 8E15G=><05=:95:93<59"**# 432259 AB <012 =7:< <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 8=< 58<1<659 >=: 18<5:52< =8 <05 58038;59 ;=C45823<1=8 >=: <05 9563B59 45:1=9 => 93B218>1618D<05344536 !36 '$!( & !36 '"&# "( & 12<=6= $