Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63251 (KAR)
SUNDARABAI AND ORS v. THE CHAIRMAN AND ORS
MFA/203916/2023 · 2025-10-25
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63251 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63251 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$ "
#$ !$%! ""
&%' ()
""
*&%'
(
)
!"#$%
$
! !"#$$
$"
!"#$$
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
$&
!"#$%
$%
!"#$%
#
$$ '((
! !"#$'
) *
+
, $( -
* , $"!!&"&(+
$
$,
!"#'
)
*
, . , $+
- 3 -
, , &*+, ("" +, +, $#'#$'$ '"
$'$ , , ,
, $&%'''
! + , ,
(
*
)
, $( - !"#'
'
/"#'
)
*
+
!"#$%
$
! "#$$
- 4 -
"#$$
%
$(
"#$%
$#
"#$%
#
$% '(( ! ! "#$'
&
$,
!"#'
) *
, #. , &+
, , &*+, , $##$'$
'"
$'$
- 5 -
,
0
0
$ * 0 +
, 1$'(#
$'$ 23 42567 89 :;6 <5=2>=?:3 @;6A6=3,1$'$#
$'$%234256789:;61@?6A14:;6 1446?72?B C6;2<56 D?76A 6<:21? &*+ 14 :;6 1:1A 6;2<563 <: *41A 3;1A: E:;6 <:F+ 862?B =BBA26C67 89 :;6 GD7B>6?: =?7 =@=A7 7=:67 $#'#$'$ H=3367 2? 1'"
$'$ 89 :;6 772:21?=5 6?21A 2C25 D7B6 =?7 6>86A ! 2G=9=HDA= *41A 3;1A: E:;6 A28D?=5F+ 2?<6 :;6 <;=556?B6 23 :1 :;6 3=>6 GD7B>6?: 81:; :;6 =HH6=53=A6<5D8867:1B6:;6A;6=A7=?7<1>>1?GD7B>6?: 23862?BH=3367 $ ,=<:3 B2C2?B A236 :1 :;6 4252?B 14 :;6 =HH6=53 8A264593:=:67=A6:;=:1?&'%$'$=:=81D:''=> =:=BB17C255=B62?=>HD31413;=56142G=9=HDA=:=5DI
- 6 -
@;6?:;676<6=367=?=>=?:@=33566H2?B=::;=::2>6=
C6;2<56 86=A2?B A6B23:A=:21? 1!$"
!&"&( <=>6 :;6A6 862?B 7A2C6? 89 2:3 7A2C6A 2? ;2B; 3H667 =?7 2? A=3; =?7?6B52B6?:>=??6A=?7A=?1C6A=?=>=?:3=A63D5:
14 :;6 =41A63=27 =<<276?: :;6 76<6=367 3D3:=2?67 4=:=5 2?GDA263=?77267=:''=>@;256D?76AB12?B:A6=:>6?:
2? ;13H2:=52G=9=HDA=
;6<5=2>=?:342567=H6:2:21?D?76A6<:21?## 14 :;6 <: 366I2?B <1>H6?3=:21? 41A :;6 76=:; 14 :;6 76<6=367=51?B@2:;2?:6A63: % ? HDA3D=?<6 36AC2<6 14 ?1:2<6 81:; :;6 A63H1?76?:3 =HH6=A67 :;A1DB; :;62A <1D?365 =?7 42567 @A2::6?3:=:6>6?:36H=A=:659
? :;6 @A2::6? 3:=:6>6?: 14 A63H1?76?: 1 76?267 =55 :;6 >=:6A2=5 =C6A>6?:3 14 :;6 H6:2:21? 2?<5D72?B :;6 =<<276?: 2? JD63:21? 2?GDA263 3D3:=2?67 =?7 HA1K2>=:6 <=D36 14 76=:; 14 =?=>=?: ;23 =B6 =C1<=:21? =?7 2?<1>664DA:;6A<1?:6?767:;=:=<<276?:2?JD63:21?@=3
- 7 -
1<<DAA677D6:1?6B52B6?:=<:14:;676<6=367;2>3654=3;6 @=33566H2?B1?:;6A1=73276,DA:;6A2:23<1?:6?767:;=: <1>H6?3=:21?<5=2>67238=365633=?72>=B2?=A94=:=5524 :;23 A28D?=5 <1>63 :1 :;6 <1?<5D321? :;=: <5=2>=?:3 =A6 6?:2:56741A<1>H6?3=:21?2: 23?3DA=?<6 1>H=?9@;1 23 52=856:12?76>?24986<=D36;23 @=3C=527592?3DA67@2:; 2:=31?:;67=:614=<<276?:6?<6HA=967:1723>23367 :;6H6:2:21?=B=2?3:;2> # ? @A2::6? 3:=:6>6?: 14 A63H1?76?: 1$ 6K<6H: =7>2::2?B:;6233D=?<614H152<9:1:;61446?72?BC6;2<56=?7 H152<9 @=3 C=527 =?7 2? 41A<6 =3 1? :;6 7=:6 14 =<<276?:
;=C6 76?267 =55 :;6 >=:6A2=5 =C6A>6?:3 2?<5D72?B :;6 =<<276?:2?JD63:21?2?GDA2633D3:=2?67HA1K2>=:6<=D3614 76=:; =3 =<<276?:=5 2?GDA263=B6 =C1<=:21?=?7 2?<1>614 :;6 76<6=367 ,DA:;6A A63H1?76?: 1$ ;=3 <1?:6?767 :;=: =<<276?: 2? JD63:21?
@=3 1<<DAA67 7D6 :1 A=3; =?7 ?6B52B6?: =<: 14 76<6=367 ;2>3654 ,DA:;6A >1A6 :;6A6 23 C215=:21?14:6A>3=?7<1?72:21?314:;6H152<63=3:;67A2C6A 14 :;6 2?3DA67!C6;2<56 @=3 ?1: H1336332?B C=527 =?7
- 8 -
6446<:2C6 7A2C2?B 52<6?<6 ;6 <1>H6?3=:21? <5=2>67 23 6K<6332C6 =?7 1? 2>=B2?=A9 BA1D?73 6?<6 HA=967 :1 723>233:;6H6:2:21?@2:;<13:3 & ?:;68=32314:;6H56=72?B314:;6H=A:263:;6 A28D?=5 4A=>67 :;6 233D63 =?7 :;6A6=4:6A A6<1A767 :;6 6C276?<6 ;6 <5=2>=?:3 2? 1A76A :1 HA1C6 :;62A <=36 <5=2>=?: 1 6K=>2?67 =3 ! =?7 =?1:;6A @2:?633 6K=>2?67 =3 !$ =?7 B1: 6K;282:67 71<D>6?:3 ?=>659 K :1 K& ? 86;=54 14 A63H1?76?:3 1?6 @2:?633 @=3 6K=>2?67 =3 ! =?7 =?1:;6A @2:?633 6K=>2?67 =3 !$ =?7 B1: 6K;282:67 71<D>6?:3 ?=>659 K :1 K ;6A28D?=589:;62>HDB?67GD7B>6?:2?:6A=52= ;657 :;=: :;6 =<<276?: :11I H5=<6 1? =<<1D?: 14 A=3; =?7 ?6B52B6?:7A2C2?B14:;61446?72?BC6;2<56892:37A2C6A=3= A63D5: 14 @;2<; :;6 76<6=367 3D3:=2?67 2?GDA263 =?7 3D<<D>867 :1 :;6 2?GDA263 ;6 A28D?=5 4DA:;6A ;657 :;=: :;6 <5=2>=?:3 =A6 6?:2:567 :1 = <1>H6?3=:21? 14 3'''''
!=51?B@2:;2?:6A63:=::;6A=:614#LH==?7 72A6<:67 :;6 2?3DA=?<6 <1>H=?9 :1 76H132: :;6
- 9 -
<1>H6?3=:21?=>1D?:=51?B@2:;2?:6A63: 62?B=BBA26C67 89:;63=>6:;636=HH6=53;=C6866?42567
" ;656=A?67<1D?36541A:;6=HH655=?:3;=3A=2367 :;641551@2?B<1?:6?:21?3 =+ ,2A3:59 :;6 1446?72?B C6;2<56! 23 = ?1?! :A=?3H1A: C6;2<56 =?7 2: 23 = 2B;: 1:1A 6;2<56 *+ =3 7642?67 D?76A 6<:21? $*$+ 14 :;6 1:1A 6;2<563 <: (""?C26@14GD7B>6?:141?F856H6K1DA:2?<=3614
A6H1A:67 2? !" :;6 7A2C6A 14 :;6 1446?72?BC6;2<56;=3;1572?B?1?!:A=?3H1A:52<6?<6<=? =531 7A2C6 :;6 C6;2<56 ;6A641A6 ?3DA=?<6 1>H=?9 ;=3 6AA67 2? 4=3:6?2?B :;6 52=8252:9 1? :;6 1@?6A 14 :;6 1446?72?BC6;2<56=?772A6<:67:1H=9:;6A6<1C6A9=>1D?: ?3DHH1A:14;23<1?:6?:21?;6;=3A652671?:;6GD7B>6?:
14 :;23 1DA: 2? , 1#&"( 14 $'' @=3 723>23367 1? '($'$'
- 10 -
8+ 6<1?759 ;6 ;=3 <1?:6?767 :;=: 6C6? :;6 2?<1>6 14 :;6 76<6=367 =3363367 89 :;6 A28D?=5 23 1? ;2B;6A3276 <+ =3:59<1?3276A2?B:;6=B6=?7=C1<=:21?14:;6 76<6=367 :;6 1C6A=55 <1>H6?3=:21? =@=A767 89 :;6 A28D?=5231?;2B;6A32766?<6;6HA=9341A=551@2?B:;6 =HH6=54256789:;61@?6A ( ;656=A?67<1D?36541A:;6=HH655=?:3;=3A=2367 :;641551@2?B<1?:6?:21?3 =+ ,2A3:59 ;6 ;=3 <1?:6?767 :;=: :;6A6 =A6 32K <5=2>=?:3 2? C26@ 14 :;6 5=@ 5=27 71@? 89 :;6 1?F856 DHA6>6 1DA: 2? :;6 <=36 14 # $ %%A6H1A:672?&'(
":;6A28D?=5;=3:1767D<:
%:;14:;62?<1>614:;6 76<6=367 41A H6A31?=5 6KH6?363 D: :;6 A28D?=5 ;=3 <1>>2::67=36A21D36AA1A2?767D<:2?B;=5414:;62?<1>614 :;676<6=36741AH6A31?=56KH6?363
- 11 -
8+ 6<1?759 ;6 ;=3 <1?:6?:67 :;=: 2? C26@ 14 GD7B>6?: 14 1?F856 DHA6>6 1DA: 2?
:;6 <=36 14
)*) %+ $ $A6H1A:672? ,
,"'L14 :;6 2?<1>6 14 :;6 76<6=367 ;=3 :1 86 =7767 41A E4D:DA6 HA13H6<:3F <+ =3:59 ;6 ;=3 <1?:6?767 :;=: 2? C26@ 14 GD7B>6?: 1?F856 DHA6>6 1DA: 2? :;6 <=36 14
-) A6H1A:67 2? ! . !" 6=<; 14 :;6 <5=2>=?:3 =A6 6?:2:56741A<1>H6?3=:21?14 3%%'''
!D?76A:;6;6=714 E5133 14 51C6 =?7 =446<:21? =?7 <1?31A:2D>F 6?<6 ;6 31DB;: 41A =551@2?B :;6 =HH6=5 89 6?;=?<2?B :;6 <1>H6?3=:21? ' ? :;6 1:;6A ;=?7 :;6 56=A?67 <1D?365 41A :;6 =HH6=A2?B 41A :;6 ?3DA=?<6 1>H=?9 ;=3 A=2367 :;6 41551@2?B<1D?:6A!<1?:6?:21?3
- 12 -
=+ ,2A3:59 ;6 ;=3 <1?:6?767 :;=: :;6 23 = <1?3:AD<:21?C6;2<56@;2<;A6JD2A63=36H=A=:6=?73H6<242< 7A2C2?B52<6?<61@6C6A:;67A2C6A14:;61446?72?BC6;2<56 @=3 ?1: ;1572?B 1?59 = 7A2C2?B 52<6?<6 6?<6 :;6 7A2C6A 14 :;6 1446?72?B C6;2<56 @=3 ?1: H1336332?B = C=527 =?76446<:2C67A2C2?B52<6?<6:11H6A=:6:;6 ;6A641A6 :;6A28D?=5;=3A2B;:594=3:6?67:;652=8252:91?:;61@?6A 14 :;6 1446?72?B C6;2<56 =?7 ;=3 A636AC67 5286A:9 :1 :;6 ?3DA=?<6 1>H=?9 :1 H=9 :;6 <1>H6?3=:21? =>1D?: =?7 :;6A6=4:6A :1 A6<1C6A :;6 3=>6 4A1> :;6 1@?6A 14 :;6 1446?72?BC6;2<56 8+ 6<1?759;6;=3<1?:6?:67:;=:<1?3276A2?B:;6 =B6 =?7 =C1<=:21? 14 :;6 76<6=367 :;6 1C6A=55 <1>H6?3=:21? =@=A767 89 :;6 A28D?=5 23 1? ;2B;6A 3276 6?<6;631DB;:41A723>233=51481:;:;6=HH6=53
6=A7 :;6 56=A?67 <1D?365 41A :;6 H=A:263 =?7 H6AD367GD7B>6?:=?7=@=A714:;6A28D?=5
- 13 -
$ : 23 ?1: 2? 723HD:6 =?=>=?:; 7267 2? A1=7 :A=442<=<<276?:1<<DAA671?&'%$'$=:=81D:''=> 7D6 :1 A=3; =?7 ?6B52B6?: 7A2C2?B 14 7A2C6A 14 C6;2<56 86=A2?BA6B23:A=:21?1!$"
!&"&(
:23=531?1:2?723HD:6:;=::;67A2C6A14:;6
C6;2<56;=3;1572?B?1?!:A=?3H1A:7A2C2?B52<6?<6;23 1DA: <1?3276A2?B :;6 GD7B>6?: 14:;61?F856H6K1DA: 2?<=3614/0/123451651&#/785(;=3;657:;=:
23 = C6;2<56 6C6? 7A2C6A ;1572?B = ?1?!:A=?3H1A:
7A2C2?B 52<6?<6 <=? =531 7A2C6 :;6 C6;2<56 3 H6A :;6 GD7B>6?: 14 :;23 1DA: 2? , 1#&"(
$'' @;2<; @=3 723>233671?'($'$':;6A656C=?:H=A=BA=H;31":1 ':;63=>6=A66K:A=<:67;6A6D?76A41A6=39A646A6?<6
! "
#$$
%&
' (
) *#* ! "+
#$
(
, (
(-
- 14 -
. +/
/0/12 3451651 #
8931:5; 1#
3:
&
( (
-
( . ( - 0 (
( - $ 1
. !2+ 3 #4454#4
-
-
. (&
(
( 6
- . - ( - - %
#4 6
' (
#$47#$$&
(
( 6 (- (
( . (
(- --%& +/
!8
9- .
( -
0 (
1% - . / . - 15 -
%& &
: % ? C26@ 14 :;6 =81C6 :;6 A28D?=5 ;=3 6AA67 2? 4=3:6?2?B:;652=8252:91?:;61@?6A14:;61446?72?BC6;2<56 2?<6 1446?72?B C6;2<56 @=3 2?3DA67 @2:; C=527 2?3DA=?<6 H152<9 :;6 ?3DA=?<6 1>H=?9 23 52=856 :1 H=9 :;6 6?:2A6 <1>H6?3=:21?=>1D?:@2:;2?:6A63:
? A63H6<: 14 JD=?:D> 6C6? :;1DB; <5=2>=?:3 ;=C6 <5=2>67 :;=: :;6 76<6=367 @=3 6=A?2?B 3'''
! H6A >1?:; 89 712?B 11526 D: :;69 ;=C6 ?1: HA17D<67 =?971<D>6?:3:1HA1C6:;63=>6?:;6=836?<614HA114 142?<1>6:;6?1:21?=52?<1>6;=3:186=33633673H6A :;6BD27652?63233D6789:;6=A?=:=I=:=:66B=56AC2<63 D:;1A2:9 41A :;6 =<<276?: :=I6? H5=<6 2? :;6 96=A $'$ :;6?1:21?=52?<1>6;=3:186:=I6?=: 3%$'
!1:;6 =41A63=27 2?<1>6 'L ;=3 :1 86 =7767 1? =<<1D?: 14 4D:DA6HA13H6<:32?C26@14:;65=@5=2771@?89:;61?F856 H6K1DA:2?:;6<=3614<%+$=*3DHA=+;D3
- 16 -
:;6 >1?:;59 2?<1>6 <1>63 :1 3#&
! * 3%$' K 'L+ # 2?<6 :;6A6 =A6 32K 76H6?76?:3 :;6 <5=2>=?: 1=?7=A676H6?72?B1?:;62?<1>614:;676<6=367 ;6A641A6
A7 14 :;6 2?<1>6 14 :;6 76<6=367 ;=3 :1 86 767D<:6741AH6A31?=56KH6?363=?7A6>=2?2?B=>1D?:;=3 :186:=I6?=3;23<1?:A28D:21?:1:;64=>259;676<6=367 @=3 =B67 =81D: #' 96=A3 =: :;6 :2>6 14 =<<276?: =?7 :;6 >D5:2H526A =HH52<=856 :1 ;23 =B6 BA1DH 23 E(F <<1A72?B59 E51331476H6?76?<9F;=3866?A6!=3363367=341551@3 + ,
(* 3#&M$M(M
+ & ? =772:21? :;6 <5=2>=?:3 =A6 6?:2:567 41A <1>H6?3=:21? 14 3#''
! 41A E5133 14 63:=:6F =?7 <1>H6?3=:21?14 3#''
!41AE4D?6A=56KH6?363F
" ?C26@14GD7B>6?:14:;61?F856H6K1DA:2? <=36 14 < = *3DHA=+ :;6 <5=2>=?: 1 @246 14 :;6 76<6=367 23 6?:2:567 41A <1>H6?3=:21? 14 3%%'''
! D?76A :;6 ;6=7 14 05133 14
- 17 -
3H1D3=5<1?31A:2D>0:;6<5=2>=?:13$:1#<;257A6?14:;6 76<6=367=A66?:2:56741A<1>H6?3=:21?14 3%%'''
!6=<; 41AEH=A6?:=5<1?31A:2D>F ( ;D3:;6<5=2>=?:3=A66?:2:567:1:;641551@2?B <1>H6?3=:21? -./0+1230 405/653/6/02 /15+ -40230 &+' 1331476H6?76?<9 $"#'''' ,D?6A=56KH6?363 #'''' 1331463:=:6 #'''' 133143H1D3=5 <1?31A:2D> %%''''' 13314=A6?:=5 <1?31A:2D> *%%'''K$+ $$'''''' 217 * (
$' ?:;6A63D5::;641551@2?B1A76A23H=3367
- 18 -
= ;6=HH6=53=A61778/530.162 8 ;6GD7B>6?:14:;65=2>3A28D?=523>1724267 =341551@3 < ;6 <5=2>=?:3 =A6 6?:2:567 :1 = :1:=5 <1>H6?3=:21? 14 +* ( =3 =B=2?3:
3'''''
!=@=A76789:;6A28D?=5;62?3DA=?<6 <1>H=?9 23 72A6<:67 :1 76H132: :;6 6?:2A6 <1>H6?3=:21? =>1D?: @2:; 2?:6A63: @2:;2? 32K @66I3 4A1>:;67=:614A6<62H:14<1H914:;231A76A 7 ;6 1442<6 23 72A6<:67 :1 A6:DA? :;6 76H132:
=>1D?::1:;6=HH655=?:2?,1$'$#
$'$%=4:6A 7D6C6A242<=:21? 5( &" ' $
5( &!$%!' $
23:151