- 1 - !" #! $%!!&!& !!'' (&) * !" # $ " $ % $&'$$( $$) *&+,& - "*&)&$+ !" " %. $ $/+)+# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % % $/,!$# % % ' " ' ' $+$/ $+/+$) %' % % ' 0"' % "1234 544621718 9: ;<1 =>84?13; 538 5@568 85;18 $+/+$)A5BB1823 C$+$/9:;<1 132C6 272D '>841 538 ' 58426 !EC6 B<C6; F;<1 629>35DG# ;<1 5AA1DD53;HD52?53; 2B 91EC61 ;<2B C>6; B11I234 13<53H1?13;CEHC?A13B5;2C3 "621EE5H;BCE;<1H5B1561;<5;HD52?53;5DC34 @2;< C;<16B @161 A6CH118234 E6C? 585B<275A1; ;C 5882I>3;5 23 >;C 9156234 14C $&'$$( 3156 5882I>3;572DD541D2?2;B;<1862716CE;<1B5285>;C86C71 ;<1B52871<2HD123565B<538314D2413;?53316@2;<<24< BA118;>6318;>6;D1538H5>B18;<15HH2813;>1;C;<2B - 3 - ;<1 HD52?53; B>EE1618 46217C>B 23=>621B <1 HD52?53; HC3;13818 ;<5; <1 <57234 B>EE1618 ;<1 23=>621B 2B 13;2;D18 EC6HC?A13B5;2C3E6C?;<161BAC3813;B , 1568 D156318 HC>3B1D EC6 5AA1DD53;HD52?53; 538 D156318 HC>3B1D EC6 61BAC3813; C3B>653H1 C?A53: 156318 HC>3B1D 5AA156234 EC6 ;<1 5AA1DD53; HD52?53;@C>D8B>9?2;;<5;;<1HD52?53;@5B@C6I2345B5 H56A13;16538<12B541859C>;):15B5BC3;<185;1CE ;<1 5HH2813; <1 23HC?1 ;5I13 9: ;<1 629>35D 5; B(+++A16?C3;<2BC3;<1DC@16B281 C3B2816234;<1 3C;2C35D23HC?1E2J18EC6;<1:156+$(EC6B1;;D1?13;CE 82BA>;1B 23 ;<1 CI85D5;< @<2H< 2B 5; B)/&+ 1 E>6;<16 B>9?2;B ;<5; ;<1 8CH;C6 <5B B;5;18 82B592D2;: 5; $K9>;;<1629>35D<5B;5I1382B592D2;:5;$&K@<2H< 2B C3 ;<1 DC@16 B281 1 E>6;<16 B>9?2;B ;<5; ;<1 HC?A13B5;2C3 5@56818 23 5 B>? CE B&+++ ;C@568B A523 538 B>EE16234 2B C3 ;<1 DC@16 B281 HC3B2816234 ;<5; - 4 - ;<161 561 ;@C E65H;>61B 538 ;<1 HD52?53; 2B 13;2;D18 ;C B&+++JLB&++++;C@568BA523538B>EE16234 CBBCE23HC?18>6234D528>AA162C8C>4<;;C<571;5I13 EC65A162C8CE;<611?C3;<BHC3B2816234;<123HC?1CE;<1 HD52?53; @<2H< HC?1B ;C B(&+ !B)/&+ J , ?C3;<B# 5B 54523B; B$+++ 5B 5@56818 9: ;<1 629>35D<15?C>3;;C@568BDCBBCE5?132;21B5@56818 9: ;<1 629>35D EC6 5 B>? CE B&+++ 2B C3 ;<1 DC@16 B281 C3B2816234;<1E5H;;<5;;<1HD52?53;<5BB>B;52318 ;@CE65H;>61B538<1@5B5H56A13;162B13;2;D18EC6DCBBCE 5?132;21BCEB++++2;<;<2B<1A65:18EC65DDC@234 ;<2B5AA15D53813<53H1;<1HC?A13B5;2C35@568189:;<1 629>35D & 156318HC>3B1DEC661BAC3813;C3B>653H1 C?A53:@C>D8HC3;138;<5;;<1HC?A13B5;2C35@56818 9:;<1629>35D2BA6CA16538581M>5;1 13H1A65:18;C 82B?2BB;<15AA15D - 5 - ( 57234 <1568 D156318 HC>3B1D ;<2B C>6; A16>B18;<12?A>4318=>84?13;538625D C>6;1HC68B / <1 HD52?53; @5B 5418 ) :156B <1 @5B @C6I234 5B 5 56A13;16 C3B2816234 ;<1 B5?1 ;<1 629>35D C>4<; ;C <571 ;5I13 ;<1 23HC?1 CE ;<1 HD52?53; 5B A16 ;<1 H<56; A61A5618 9: EC6 B1;;D1?13; CE 82BA>;1B EC6 ;<1 :156 +$( 23 5 B>? CE B)/&+ 5B 54523B;B(+++;5I139:;<1629>35D<1629>35D<5B ;5I13 82B592D2;: 5; $&K @<2H< 2B =>B; 538 A6CA16 B HD52?53;2B5418):156B;<1?>D;2AD2165AAD2H59D1;C<2B 541 46C>A 2B F$/G C3B2816234 ;<1 59C71 5BA1H;B ;<1 HD52?53; 2B 13;2;D18 ;C 53 5?C>3; CE B(//&+ !B)/&+ J $ J $&K J $/# ;C@568B DCBB CE E>;>61 23HC?1 ) <1 HD52?53; <5B B>EE1618 ;@C E65H;>61B 538 HC3B2816234 ;<1 B5?1 <1 2B 13;2;D18 ;C HC?A13B5;2C3 ;C@568B A523 538 B>EE16234 23 5 B>? CE B&++++ - 6 - !&+++ J E65H;>61B# 5B 54523B; B$&+++ 5B 5@568189:;<1629>35D C3B2816234;<1;@CE65H;>61B53857CH5;2C3CE ;<1HD52?53;5BH56A13;16<1H533C;@C6IEC6;<611?C3;<B 538;<161EC61<12B13;2;D18EC6DCBBCE23HC?18>6234D528 >AA162C8235B>?CEB(&+!)/&+J,?C3;<B#5B 54523B;B$+++5@568189:;<1629>35D $+ <1629>35D<5B5@568185B>?CEB&+++ ;C@568B DCBB CE 5?132;21B @<2H< 2B C3 ;<1 DC@16 B281 C3B2816234 ;<1 ;@C E65H;>61B B>B;52318 9: ;<1 HD52?53; HC3B2816234 ;<1 B5?1 ;<1 HD52?53; 2B 13;2;D18 ;C HC?A13B5;2C3 ;C@568B DCBB CE 5?132;21B 23 5 B>? CE B++++ 5B 54523B; B&+++ 5B 5@56818 9: ;<1 629>35D $$ <1629>35D<5B5@568185B>?CEB$)$& ;C@568B ?182H5D 1JA13B1B. B&+++ ;C@568B ECC8 538 3C>62B<?13; B&+++ ;C@568B HC371:53H1 H<5641B - 7 - B$+++;C@568B5;;13853;H<5641B@<2H<561=>B;538 A6CA16538;<1612B3C3118;C23;16E1613H1 $ <>B ;<1 A1;2;2C316 2B 13;2;D18 EC6 ECDDC@234 5?C>3;CEHC?A13B5;2C3 !+ ,-./ 0123 -4-5.,.67 38,59612-+ 0123 -4-5.,.67 389/153 $ 523538B>EE16234 B$&+++ B&++++ 182H5D1JA13B1B B$)$& B$)$& , CBBCEE>;>6123HC?1 B$),(++ B(//&+ %CC85383C>62B<?13; B&+++ B&+++ & CBBCE5?132;21B B&+++ B++++ ( C371:53H1H<5641B B&+++ B&+++ / CBBCE23HC?18>6234D528 >AA162C8 B$+++ B(&+ ) ;;13853;H<5641B B$+++ B$+++ 3-+ / ":; / ; /::; 28-2<,0,23 /: ; $, 3;<161B>D;;<15AA15D81B1671B;C915DDC@18 23A56;538<13H1;<1ECDDC@234 !2# <15AA15D2B5DDC@1823A56; !22# <1 5AA1DD53;HD52?53; 2B 13;2;D18 ;C HC?A13B5;2C3 CE B,,$& 54523B; - 8 - B,,/& 5B 5@56818 9: ;<1 629>35D 5DC34 @2;< 23;161B; 5; ;<165;1 CE (K A5 E6C?;<185;1CEA1;2;2C3;2DD2;B81ACB2; !222# <161BAC3813;C3B>653H1HC?A53:2B 8261H;18 ;C 81ACB2; ;<1 HC?A13B5;2C3 5?C>3; @2;<23 5 A162C8 CE 124<; @11IB E6C?;<2B85:E52D234@<2H<;<1HD52?53;2B 13;2;D18 23;161B; 5; ;<1 65;1 CE K A16 533>?C3;<113<53H18HC?A13B5;2C3 !27# 1B; CE ;<1 C6816 CE ;<1 629>35D B;538B >35D;1618 !.; (!&!&) % $ $