Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63249 (KAR)
SHIVAKUMAR v. THE ADDL CHIEF SECRETARY AND ORS
WA/200252/2024 · 2025-09-04
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63249 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63249 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #"$! #"$" !! %&
! " #
$ $
$
%
" #
&
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' (
(
! "
(
)
%* &)
*
#
'
+$
' %% $% + " #
''
( , ' %% $% +
" # %&
+
%%
(
( '
-
- . (
. (
- 3 -
$"
" -. (
#
/01 02345 6743 8895: 72;94 9<3062 6= 3/9 542535>5 0?/ 6743 <3 +$ <5::02? 02 @7913062 3/9 64;94 ;539; %&
+
%% 85119; AB 3/9 :95429; 02?:9 (7;?902'
6
%% $% +AB491862;9236
023/9 C40389303062 % /9854309154949=9449;36518943/904452>02?1 A9=6493/9:95429;02?:9(7;?9 & A409= 673:029 6= =5<31 :95;02? 36 3/9 =0:02? 6= 3/0158895:5495172;94- 2 8741752<9 6= 3/9 2630=0<53062 01179; AB 3/9 0;54 21303739 6= 9;0<5: <092<9 <5::02? =64 588:0<530621 =64 49<4703D9236=46=911641116<053946=91164152;92064
910;9231=64E540671;01<08:0291C/949026296=3/98613 =64 C/0</ 588:0<530621 C949 <5::9; C51 =64 3/9 8613 6= :020<5: 1B</6:6?013
7A19@7923 36 3/9 011752<9 6= 2630=0<53062 3/9 491862;923021303739 01179; 3/9
- 4 -
<6440?92;7D;539;%
% FC/9490216=54513/98613 6= :020<5: 81B</6:6?013 01 9G<:7;9; =46D 3/9 C5:>02 02394E09C=64E540671861316= 0;5436A9/9:;62 +
% F 53 92?5:747 52; 3/9 8613 6= :020<5:
1B</6:6?013 C0:: A9 <5::9; 19854539:B
1 <67:; A9 1992 =46D 3/9 D93/6; 6= 19:9<3062 <4039405 02 394D1 6= 2630=0<5306201179;62
% F36E54067186131C/0</01 17DD9;7872;943/9D93/6;6=19:9<3062<4039405C/0</ C949846;7<9=6449=9492<9495;15172;94-
! "
# !$
% ! "
# !$
&'()
*
"+,
% !$
'-. ! # !$
- 5 -
/
0 ! "
# !$
/
*1 !$
2
$2
-345
--- ! .-
6 ! * $ 2 !* 7%46
*
/
- -
"4 !$
%# ! "
# !$
/
0 8 ! " # !$
/
*1 !$
2
$2
-345
--- ! .-
6 ! * $ 2 !* 7%46
* 9 2-:$ '
7% ! 9 $;4!$
'-<
$;4!$
- 6 -
/
/
*;4!$ ! 2
$2
-345
--- ! .-
6 ! * $ 2 !* 7%46
*
'-<
7/$:=!$
,
<- %!$
9 >?0
@
,
$ 7'! 9$;4!$
/
/
*;4 !$A
7A19@7923 36 3/9 <6440?92;7D 13539; 17845
01179; 5263/94 2630=0<53062 ;539;
+
% F C/94902 C5:>0202394E09C /9:; =64 3/9 8613 :020<5: 1B</6:6?013 19854539:B 74840102?:B 3/01 30D9 3/9 D93/6; 6= 19:9<3062 01 13539; 72;94 3/9 /95; D93/6; 6= 19:9<3062 C/0</ C9 49846;7<9 =64 49=9492<9 495;1 51 72;94- 92'(:()09B92( 2
345 .-
!%45* !$2
!
*$A
- 7 -
/9 8930306294 C/6 C03/ 52 5<5;9D0< @75:0=0<53062 19<749; F%
& D54>1 02 3/9 @75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 "H 6= D54>1 6A35029; 02 9?499#
/9 8941621 C/6 /5E9 A992 <5::9; =64 02394E09C 549 10G 02 27DA941 02<:7;02? 3/9 8930306294 51 C9:: 51 491862;923 6
I/0E5>7D5419<749;:91194D54>1023/9@75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 91862;923 6
/5; 19<749; $
% 02 3/9 @75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 "H 6= 9?499 D54>1# 52; 3/9 63/94 8941621 19<749; A93C992 +
% 36 $
% C/0</ 01 :911943/92<6D8549;363/95889::523/94902
23/9D9403 :013 6= C5:>0202394E09C <62;7<39; 62 $
% F 53 229G749 5:: 3/9 <52;0;5391 9G<983 3/9 8930306294 C949 ?45239; /0?/94 D54>1
'/94951 3/9 8930306294 C51 5C54;9;D020D7D3/499D54>1AB5::3/9D9DA9416=3/9 <6DD0339952;3/95E945?9011/6C251&HC03/H6= 3/9@75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 5:62? C03/ 3/9 5E945?9 D54>1 5C54;9; 72;94 95</ <539?64B AB 3/9 D9DA941 3/9 3635:
C511/6C253$
+
'/94951491862;9236
C03/H
- 8 -
02 3/9 @75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 0
9
%
$ C51 ?0E92 /0?/913 %
AB 629 D9DA94 %
$ AB 5263/94 52; 3/9 5E945?9<6D9136 %
F52;5;;02?3/915D9C03/H6= 3/9 @75:0=B02? 9G5D0253062 5??49?539 <6D91 36 $
& C/0</01J713
D6493/523/98930306294
7A19@7923:B 3/9491862;9236
C5101179;C03/64;946=5886023D923 ;539; %
%
% AB 491862;923 6
%
/9 8930306294 <5::9; 02 @7913062 3/9 64;94 6= 5886023D923 01179; AB 491862;923 6
% 02 =5E674 6= 491862;923 6
16 5:16 167?/3 5 C403 6= D52;5D71 ;049<302? 491862;923 61
% 52; & 36 19:9<3 52; 5886023 3/9 8930306294 51 :020<5: 1B</6:6?01372;943/9<539?64B63/9418741752336 49<4703D923 2630=0<53062 A95402? 6 '
% F ;539;
+
% FE0;9229G749 $ 5E02? <6210;949; 3/9 40E5: <6239230621 6= 3/9 8543091 3/9 :95429; 02?:9 (7;?9 =672; 3/53 3/9 923049 846<9116=19:9<3062499>1D5:5=0;94951629;538545?458/ 61
36 &85430<7:54:B538545?458/6
%<:954:B13539; 3/533/919:9<3062<6DD03399C923A9B62;3/9394D16=3/9
- 9 -
49<4703D923 2630=0<53062 52; /51 5C54;9; D54>1 36 491862;923 6
C/0</ /9 ;0; 263 6AE0671:B ;9194E952;
3/01 /51 4917:39; 02 C462?=7: 5886023D923 /5E02? A992 D5;9
/95886023D9236=491862;9236
015<<64;02?:B @751/9; F /9 15D9 01 =743/94 4951629; 02 8545?458/ 6
&C/949023/9:95429;02?:9(7;?9/51<:954:B13539;
3/530=3/9D54>15C54;9;36491862;9236
0191</9C9;
52;03015117D9;3/53/9C51?0E92 D54>1AB5::3/9 =0E9D9DA9416=19:9<3062<6DD033999E923/92/9C67:;
A992303:9;3662:B$%
&515?50213$
&52;3/01C67:;
4917:3 02 3/9 8930306294 A902? D649 D9403640671 /5E02?
19<749; $
+
02<9 3/9 8930306294 C67:; A9 3/9 D613 D9403640671<52;0;5399E92518943/9D54>15C54;9;AB 3/9 19:9<3062 <6DD03399 5 ;049<3062 /51 A992 01179; 36 491862;923 6
% 36 5886023 3/9 8930306294 51 5 :020<5:
1B</6:6?013 02 3/9 8:5<9 6= 491862;923 6
3 01 3/01 64;94 85119; AB 3/9 :95429; 02?:9 (7;?9 <5::9; 02 @7913062AB491862;9236
023/0158895:
- 10 -
/9491862;92361
%52;&023/9C40389303062 =0:9; '
6
%%&%% A9=649 3/01 6743 <5::02? 02 @79130623/9E94B15D964;9485119;AB3/9:95429;02?:9 (7;?9
/9664;0253992</6=3/01674362%
+
%% /5E02? <6210;949; 3/9 923049 846<911 135?9; AB 3/9 19:9<3062 <6DD03399 =672; 85430<7:54:B 53 8545?458/ 6
C/0</C949846;7<9;5172;94-
%=$ '- @@ * @C
C 0
* $= *
C
-345
!%4 ! *
-
*- ! C * @D
$
0
$ 9 0
*
;E ! * -
@DC*
- - ! F#$E45 C * . * *
- !** $ 2
C !- C 0- - - *
$A
- 11 -
<<64;02?:B;01D0119;3/9C40358895:C03/9G9D8:54B<613 6=
1 ;049<302? 36 85B H 673 6=
1
36 3/9 8930306294 52; H 1/5:: E913 02 =5E6746=3539 + 954;40
/539:95429;<67219:58895402? =643/95889::52352;40 5::0>54J72
51549;;B:95429;
6E942D923 ;E6<539 =64 491862;923 6
40 5E0 530::95429;<67219:58895402?=64491862;92361
%52;
& 52; 40 /5452A515885
530: 52; 40
9:5152?0 :95429; <67219: 58895402? =64 491862;923 6
"8930306294# /67?/ 3/9 :95429; <67219: 58895402? =64 3/9 5889::523 35>02? 19E945: ?4672;1 74?9; 36 1/6C 3/53 3/9 64;9485119;AB3/9:95429;02?:9(7;?90194462967151 C9::51 5?50213 3/9 1933:9;861030626= :5C AB3/962.A:9 89G 6743 3/53 3/9 67431 :5<>1 J7;0<05: 49E09C 62 3/9 19:9<3062D93/6;5;6839;AB3/919:9<3062<6DD0339952;
3/9 19:9<3062 846<911 01 3/9 84946?530E9 52; 01 51 894 ;01<4930626=3/9D9DA9416=3/9150;<6DD03399
- 12 -
'9 549 ;9<:029; 36 5<<983 150; <6239230621 02 E09C6=3/958895:849=9449;AB3/902130373062/5E02?A992 ;01D0119; C03/ 9G9D8:54B <6131 C/94902 3/9 923049 846<911 6= 19:9<3062 <6DD03399 E0175::B =45D9; 36 A9 350239; C03/ D5:5=0;91 62:B 36 846E0;9 8:5<9D923 36 491862;923 6
C/6 5;D0339;:B 9E92 5<<64;02? 36 3/9 5889::523 /94902 51 C9:: 51 3/9 5889::523 02 3/9 58895:
13539; 17845 AB 3/9 491862;923 61
% 52; & 02 3/9 C403 89303062 01 C64>02?
62 39D86454B A5101 02 3/9 150; 021303730621 %
3 01 26 ;67A3 <:954 52; 34039 3/53 3/9 67431 /5E926J7;0<05:49E09C6E943/9;01<4930626=3/919:9<3062 846<911 4916439; 36 AB 3/9 <6DD03399 D9DA941 53 3/9 15D9 30D9 0= 3/9 15D9 01 350239; 52; 499>1 C03/ D5:5 =0;91 E010A:9 36 3/9 9B9 51 A465; ;5B :0?/3 3/52 72;94 430<:9 %%$ 6= 3/9 62130373062 6= 2;05 3/9 6743 C67:;
9E9236?602363/919:9<3062846<91136@79133/93473/
3 01 ?:5402?:B <:954 36 3/9 25>9; 9B9 3/9 C5B 02 C/0</ 491862;923 6
C51 ?45239; D54>1 02 3/9 02394E09C
- 13 -
894162C/601D649@75:0=09;025<5;9D0<894=64D52<9C51 ?0E92 3/9 D020D7D D54>1 AB 95</ 6= 3/9 D9DA941 C/94951 3/9 894162 C/6 01 8664 C/92 <6D8549; 36 3/9 8930306294 02 5<5;9D0< 894=64D52<9 C51 ?0E92 /0?/913 D5G0D7DD54>1AB5::3/9D9DA941
'/533/4713D64901 95</6=3/9<52;0;539185430<08539;023/902394E09C63/94 3/52 3/9 8930306294 C51 5C54;9; D54>1 D649 3/52 3/9 8930306294
3 01 62:B 3/9 8930306294 C/6 C51 5C54;9; 3/9 D020D7DD54>1
/01<:954:B499>1D5:5=0;9623/985436= 3/9 02130373062 135?9; 62:B 36 846E0;9 5 861302? 36 491862;9236 &
2 E09C 6= 3/9 64;94 85119; 02 C403 58895: 17845 3/67?/ 3/949 01 26 =743/94 495162 49@7049; 02 3/9 8491923 58895:
/919 4951621 549 178945;;9; 36 3/9 4951621 ?0E92 AB 3/9 664;02539 92</ 02 3/9 58895:
=0:9;AB491862;92361
%52;&02130373062 5E02?<6210;949;3/9923049<51962D94031C9 =02; 26 02=04D03091 02 3/9 64;94 85119; AB 3/9 :95429;
02?:9 (7;?9 C03/ 947;039 4951621
/9 15D9 ;691 263
- 14 -
49@7049 52B 02394=9492<9 53 3/9 /52;1 6= 3/01 6743 /67?/ 3/01 6743 01 6= 3/9 6802062 36 0D8619 3/9 E94B 15D9 <613 02 3/9 58895: /6C9E94 :66>02? 0236 3/9 =5<31 52; <04<7D1352<91 C9 49=4502 67419:E91 =46D 0D86102? 52B<613 /9 58895: 1521 D9403 52; 5<<64;02?:B ;01D0119;
'( %!& $
'( %"& $
0136
- :6
-