- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&'$( )*'$)) + !"#"$ % %" !"#"$ $ %# !"#"& & ' %% ( ) !"#"& * ( + ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"#", * ( ) $,&(%) %#!,!%%% - &#%% . #! ( . ) /0 1220331456 70849 1::;60< =6% 5= " 84 =&#%% =4 5/0 >830 => 5/0 301?40< <<858=413 865?8:5 14< 0668=46 ;<90 1317;?198 @>=? 6/=?5 A5/0 ?813 =;?5BC 1?0 8D2;94849 5/0 E;<9D045 <150< %#,%%% :=4F8:5849 5/0D >=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 - 3 - ;4<0? 0:58=46 $ &G# 14< "& => 5/0 4<814 0413 =<0 # @>=? 6/=?5 A5/0 BC 14< 604504:849 5= ;4<0?9= 68D230 8D2?86=4D045 >=? 1 20?8=< => 5H= I01?6 14< 5= 21I >840 => 6%"! 01:/ >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 &G#!(1) => J 5= ;4<0?9= 68D230 8D2?86=4D045 >=? 1 20?8=< => 68K D=45/6 >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 "& => J 14< 5= ;4<0?9=68D2308D2?86=4D045>=?120?8=<=>60F04I01?6 14< 5= 21I >840 => 6"! 01:/ >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 $ => H85/ <0>1;35 604504:06 % 5 86 5/0 :=450458=4 => 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 5/15 1::;60<=D1??80<5/0<0:0160<!1/16/8417=;5>=;? I01?6 70>=?0 %, 14< 1>50? D1??8190 6/0 651?50< ?068<849845/0D15?8D=4813/=;6013=49H85//0?/;6714< !1::;60<=/0?D=5/0?!84!31H!1::;60<=%14</0? 68650?6!84!31H!1::;60<=6$5="335/01::;60<H0?0 17;6849 /0? 14< 833!5?015849 /0? 7I 846865849 /0? 5= 301F0 5/0 /=;60 14< 9= 1H1I 14< 5/0?07I 5?015849 /0? H85/ - 4 - :?;035I58665150<5/15=4%#%,15G$1DH/04 5/0<0:0160< H16 84 /0? /=;60 1::;60< =6% 5= " H85/ 5/0 :=DD=4 =7E0:5 17;60< /0? 84 >835/I 3149;190 14< 8450458=4133I 846;350< /0? /0I 136= 846589150< /0? 5= 301F0 5/0 /=;60 14< 2?=:318D0< 5/15 6/0 H833 4=5 70 20?D8550< 5= 38F0 84 5/0 /=;60 5/0?07I 170550< :=DD8668=4=>6;8:8<061?06;356/02=;?0<L0?=6040 =4 /0? 14< 605 >8?0 =4 5/0 61D0 <1I 15 $ 2D /0 84E;?0< H166/8>50< 5= 5/0/=628513 H/0?06/0 6;::;D70< 5=5/061D0=4%$#%,15$/=;?6/0?0>=?0 85 86 5/0 :=450458=4 => 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 5/15 5/0 1::;60< 70849 5/0 /;6714< 14< /86 >1D83I D0D70?6 5?0150< /0? H85/ :?;035I 17;60< 14< /;D838150< /0? 14< 170550< :=DD8668=4=>6;8:8<0 $ /0 65150D045 => 5/0 84E;?0< H16 ?0:=?<0< 7I 5/0 01< =4651730 H/04 6/0 H16 70849 5?0150< 84 5/0 /=6285131620?K!,14<=45/071686=>5/061D05/0 16 20? K!# :1D0 5= 70 ?098650?0< 150? 5/0 1/1683<1?!!:1D05=5/0/=62851314<?0:=?<0<5/0 - 5 - 65150D0451620?K!15$"2D=45/061D0<1I DD0<81503I 5/0?01>50? 80 15 $ /=;?6 5/0 84E;?0< 6;::;D70<5=5/084E;?80614<<80<>50?:=D23058495/0 84F06589158=4:/1?906/005:1D05=70>830< & 01?40< 19865?150 5==L :=948M14:0 => 5/0 =>>04:0614<:=DD8550<5/0D1550?5=5/00668=46=;?5 /01::;60<12201?0<70>=?05/0?813=;?52301<0<4=5 9;835I14<:318D0<5=705?80</02?=60:;58=40K1D840< 6! 5= 9=5 D1?L0< K6! 5= ! 14< 8<0458>80< ! ::;60< <0480< 133 5/0 84:?8D8415849 D150?8136 1F1831730 =4 ?0:=?< 7;5 /1F0 4=5 30< 14I 0F8<04:0 84 6;22=?5=>5/08?<0>04:0/0?813=;?51>50?51L849845= :=468<0?158=4 133 5/060 D150?8136 =4 ?0:=?< :1D0 5= 5/0 :=4:3;68=4 5/15 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 86 6;::066>;3 84 2?=F849 5/09;835=>5/01::;60<70I=4<?016=41730<=;75>=?5/0 =>>04:062;486/1730;4<0?0:58=46$&G#14<"&=> 14< 1::=?<8493I 21660< 5/0 8D2;940< E;<9D045 => :=4F8:58=414<=?<0?=>604504:0;?8495/0204<04:I=> 5/0 5?813 70>=?0 5/0 ?813 =;?5 1::;60< = <80< /0 - 6 - ?813=;?52?=:00<0<5=:=4F8:51::;60<=6%5=">=?5/0 =>>04:061665150<17=F0 0849199?80F0<7I5/061D0 1::;60<=6%5="1?070>=?05/86=;?5 " 01?< ?8 ?1<002 ;D1? 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0122033145614<?8 =213L?86/41 1<1F301?40<89/ =;?5 =F0?4D045 301<0? >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 N 5150 0?;60<5/0D150?8136=4?0:=?<84:3;<8495/0?813=;?5 ?0:=?<6 4 F80H => 5/0 ?8F13 :=450458=46 ;?90< 7I 301?40<:=;4603>=?7=5/5/021?58065/02=8455/15H=;3< 1?860>=?DI:=468<0?158=486 I 146H0? 5= 5/0 17=F0 2=845 86 A B>=?5/0>=33=H849 - 7 - , 5865/0:=450458=4=>5/02?=60:;58=45/155/0 <0:0160< 70849 5/0 H8>0 => 1::;60< = H16 84 5/0 D15?8D=4813 /=;60 13=49 H85/ 1::;60< =6% 5= " 70849 /0? D=5/0?!84!31H 14< 68650?6!84!31H 4 5/0 <150 => 84:8<045 80 =4 %#%, 15 G$ 1D 133 5/0 1::;60< 17;60< /0? 84 >835/I 3149;190 846589150<14< 170550< /0? 5=:=DD856;8:8<07I/;D83815849/0? 45/061D0<1I15 $2D6/02=;?0<L0?=604014<605>8?061?06;35=> H/8:/6/06;651840<7;?484E;?806150?6/0H166/8>50< 5= 5/0 /=628513 0? 65150D0456 H0?0 ?0:=?<0< 7I 5/0 =38:016H033167I5/01/1683<1?1620?K6!,14<! ;5=45/061D0489/580=4%$#%,15$ /=;?66/06;::;D70<5=5/084E;?806 # ! 86 5/0 D1/1M1? H854066 5= 5/0 62=5 14< 608M;?0 D1/1M1?6 ! K! !% 86 5/0 H854066 5= 5/0 84O;065D1/1M1?K!$6!$14<&1?05/0D=5/0?14< ;4:30=>5/0<0:0160<!"865/04089/7=;?!865/0 - 8 - 68650? => 5/0 <0:0160< /0I 62=L0 17=;5 5/0 :?;035I D050<5=5/0<0:0160<7I5/01::;60< G !, 86 5/0 <=:5=? H/= 5?0150< 5/0 <0:0160< H/8306/0H16>8?651<D8550<5=5/0/=628513K!"865/0 D0<8:13 ?0:=?< 20?5184849 5= 5/0 <0:0160< 1::=?<849 5= H/8:/ H/04 6/0 H16 1<D8550< 5= 5/0 /=628513 6/0 H16 :=46:8=;6 =?80450< 14< 513L849 5 86 136= 04<=?60< =4 K!" 5/15 5/0 2158045 H16 >85 5= 98F0 65150D045 !, 5/=;9/ <02=60< 70>=?0 5/0 =;?5 5/15 5/0 2=38:0 /1< :=D0 5= 5/0 /=628513 =4 ?0:0825 => 84>=?D158=4 /0 =2840< 5/15 5/0 2158045 H16 :=46:8=;6 =?80450< 14< 513L84914<1::=?<8493I5/02=38:0?0:=?<0</0?65150D045 8540666515065/158462850=>98F84940:0661?I5?015D045 6/0<80<845/0D8<489/5;?849:?=66!0K1D84158=48586 6;990650< 5/15 684:0 5/0 <0:0160< /1< 6;651840< # 5= #"P7;?484E;?8066/0H164=58412=6858=45=6201L586 136=6;990650<5/156/0H16;4:=46:8=;6=?6/0H164=5 84 1 >85 :=4<858=4 5= 98F0 65150D045 0 <0480< 5/060 6;990658=46 14< 136= 5/0 6;990658=4 5/15 5/0 2=38:0 /1F0 - 9 - 4=5 F86850< 5/0 /=628513 4=? 5/0I /1F0 51L04 5/0 =2848=4 ?091?<849:=4<858=4=>5/021580455=?0:=?</0?65150D045 K!, 86 5/0 65150D045 => 5/0 <0:0160< ?0:=?<0<7I!G!5/001<=4651730H/8:/865?0150< 165/0>8?6584>=?D158=4>=?5/02;?2=60=>?098650?8495/0 4 K!, 5/0 <0:0160< ?0>0?6 5= 5/0 833!5?015D045 14< :?;035I D050< 5= /0? 7I 01:/ => 5/0 1::;60< /0 620:8>8:133I 651506 5/15 1::;60< =6$ 5= " 70849 5/0 68650?6=>/0?/;6714<H0?0?068<849H85//0?845/061D0 /=;60 14< 5/0I E=840< /14<6 H85/ 1::;60< =% ! 5/0 D=5/0?!84!31H 84 833!5?015849 14< 17;6849 /0? /0 136= ?0>0?6 5= 5/0 84:8<045 5/15 /1< =::;??0< =4 %#%, H/04 133 5/0 1::;60< 17;60< 14< 846589150< /0? 5= 301F0 5/0 /=;60 =? 0360 6/0 H833 4=5 70 20?D8550< 5= ?068<0 5/0?084 /0?0>=?0 6/0 5?80< 5= :=DD85 6;8:8<0 15 $ 2D 7I 2=;?849 L0?=6040 14< 6055849 >8?0 /0 84E;?0< 136= 651506 5/15 6/0 H16 6/8>50< 5= 5/0 /=628513 84 # 1D7;314:0 14< ?0O;0650< 5/0 2=38:0 5= ?098650? 5/0 :160 14<5=848581501:58=41918465133=>5/0D - 10 - !G!5/001<=4651730H/=?0:=?<0<K! ,<02=60<70>=?05/0=;?517=;55/061D0;?849:?=66! 0K1D84158=4 H854066 65150< 5/15 5/0 84E;?0< H16 70849 5?0150<7I5/0<=:5=?/04/0?0:=?<0<5/065150D045=> 5/0 84E;?0< 4085/0? /0? 21?0456 4=? 14I => 5/0 1::;60< H0?0 2?06045 DD0<81503I 1>50? ?0:0825 => 84>=?D158=4 /0 ?;6/0< 5= 5/0 /=628513 /0 04O;8?0< H85/ 5/0 <=:5=? 17=;5 5/0 :=4<858=4 => 5/0 2158045 14< 2?=:00<0< 5= ?0:=?< 5/0 65150D045 150? /0 ?098650?0< 5/0 :=4<;:50< 62=5 14< 608M;?0 D1/1M1? =5/849 /167004038:850<>?=D/8D5=<8670380F0/86F0?68=4 % ! 86 5/0 1/1683<1? H/= ?0:=?<0< <I849 <0:31?158=4=>5/0<0:0160<15$"2D1620?K! K! 86 84 5/0 >=?D => O;0658=4 14< 146H0? 14< >=? 13D=65 133 O;0658=46 5/0 84E;?0< /16 98F04 ?158=413 146H0?6 /0 620:8>8:133I 65150< 5/0 ?016=4 >=? 5?I849 5= :=DD856;8:8<0F045/=;9/K!864=568940<7I5/0 0<8:13 >>8:0? 5/0 61D0 :144=5 70 5/0 6=30 9?=;4< 5= ?0E0:585!?0:=?<0<5/065150D045=>5/0<0:0160< - 11 - 16 20? K! H/= <02=60< 70>=?0 5/0 =;?5 5/15 /0 ?0:08F0< 84>=?D158=4 >?=D 5/0 2=38:0 14< 8DD0<81503I /0 H045 5= 5/0 /=628513 0 0K1D840< 5/0 84E;?0< 14< :=4>8?D0< 5/15 6/0 H16 O;850 >85 5= 98F0 65150D045 ::=?<8493I/016L0<>=?5/0=2848=4=>5/0<=:5=?17=;5 /0? :=4<858=4 14< H16 61586>80< H85/ 5/0 61D0 =5/849 0360 /16 7004 038:850< >?=D 5/0 H854066 5= <8670380F0 /86 F0?68=4K!865/02=65D=?50D?02=?520?51848495=5/0 <0:0160< 1::=?<849 5= H/8:/ 6/0 <80< <;0 5= /I2=F=30D8:6/=:L161?06;35=>7;?46 $ > 133 5/060 D150?8136 1?0 51L04 845= :=468<0?158=4 85 86 :301? 5/15 5/0 <0:0160< /1< D1??80< 1::;60< = 17=;5 & I01?6 01?380? 5= 5/0 84:8<045 1::;60<=65="H0?0?068<849H85/5/0<0:0160<845/0 D15?8D=4813/=;60/0<0:0160<H166;7E0:50<5=:?;035I 7I 5/0 1::;60< /0?0 H16 1 O;1??03 =4 5/0 <150 => 84:8<045 15 G$ 1D 14< 15 $ 2D 6/0 2=;?0< L0?=604014< 605>8?0 16 1 ?06;35=> H/8:/ 6/06;651840< 7;?484E;?806DD0<81503I6/0H166/8>50<5=5/0/=628513 - 12 - 0?65150D0451620?K6!,14<!H0?0?0:=?<0<14< 155/08450?F04849489/5=>%$#%,15$/=;?6 6/06;::;D70<5=5/084E;?806<D8550<3I5/0<0:0160< H16845/0/=;60=>1::;60<=6%5="==5/0??016=46 1?01668940<7I5/01::;60<165=H/I5/0<0:0160</1< 51L046;:/140K5?0D06502=>04<849/0?38>07I2=;?849 L0?=604014<6055849>8?0=620:8>8:<0>04:0H1651L04 7I 5/0 1::;60< <;?849 5?813 /0?0 1?0 4= ?016=46 5= 6;620:5 K6!, 14< ! /0?0>=?0 5/0?0 86 4= =5/0? /I2=5/0686 5= 6;620:5 5/0 :=450458=4 51L04 7I 5/0 2?=60:;58=4/02?=60:;58=4866;::066>;3842?=F8495/0 9;835 => 5/0 1::;60< 70I=4< ?016=41730 <=;75 >=? 5/0 =>>04:062;486/1730;4<0?0:58=46$&G#14<"&=> 14<5/0I1?0381730>=?:=4F8:58=4 & 55/8665190301?40<:=;4603>=?5/01220331456 6=;9/5 >=? 6/=H849 304804:I 84 >1F=;? => 5/0 1220331456 684:0 5/0 84:8<045 /1< =::;??0< <;?849 %, 089/5 I01?6 /1F013?01<I31260<1::;60<=708495/0/;6714</16 - 13 - 13?01<I <80< 1::;60< =6% 5= " 1?0 D=5/0?!84!31H 14< 68650?6!84!31H=>5/0<0:0160< " 4F80H=>5/0<86:;668=46/03<17=F01D=> 5/0 =2848=4 5/15 5/0 8D2;940< E;<9D045 => :=4F8:58=4 21660< 7I 5/0 ?813 =;?5 86 381730 5= 70 :=4>8?D0< =H0F0? 51L849 845= :=468<0?158=4 5/0 6;7D8668=4 D1<0 7I 5/0 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 1220331456 6=D0 304804:I D1I706/=H484>1F=;?=>5/01220331456H/830604504:849 5/0D::=?<8493I146H0?5/017=F02=845A21?53I845/0 1>>8?D158F0B14<2?=:00<5=21665/0>=33=H849 (8) /0?8D84132201386 (88) /0 E;<9D045 => :=4F8:58=4 <150< %#,%%% 21660< 84 =&#%% 7I 5/0 301?40< <<858=413 865?8:5 14< 0668=46 ;<90 1317;?198 86 /0?07I - 14 - (888) ?<0? => 604504:0 >=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730;4<0?0:58=46&G#14<"&=> 86:=4>8?D0< (8F) ?<0? => 604504:0 >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 $ => 86 D=<8>80<16;4<0? 1 /0 12203314561::;60< =6% 5= " 1?0 604504:0< 5= ;4<0?9= ?89=?=;6 8D2?86=4D045 >=? 1 20?8=< => 5H= I01?614<5=21I>840=>6"! 01:/ 84 <0>1;35 5= 21I >840 5= ;4<0?9= 68D230 8D2?86=4D045 >=? 1 20?8=<=>5H=D=45/6>=?5/0=>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 $ => (F) /012203314561?00458530<>=?605=>>;4<0? 0:58=4&%#=>? (F8) /0 6;7651458F0 604504:06 6/133 ?;4 :=4:;??0453I - 15 - 09865?I 86 <8?0:50< 5= 604< 71:L 5/0 ?813 =;?5 ?0:=?<6 13=49 H85/ :=2I => 5/86 E;<9D045 >=? 84>=?D158=4 14<400<>;31:58=4 ,* $!!) # 865=3=%