Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63243 (KAR)

SHABOOJ @ SABUJ SIKDAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/201378/2025 · 2025-09-24

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $"%"" " & &'() &(( * ! " ! # $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # % ! % & " '! (! ! )* - 3 - + !!! + ,"$& (!* '! ( !* ! + #" + !*#" + ! ! ! ! ! )+ $$$ +!+++! "(* (* $(* %(* (* &(* &# (* $ + ! + + ) + ! + + - (!- * ./0/121234/567/2489::;6/<36&13#94<%24 52=/ 3$$$ 5/8261/5/< 7> 24<94335 ;59? !3?2:/ 191234 0/4<248 34 1./ @2?/ 3@ 1./ ?/954/< <<212349? 2A2? ;<8/ 94< + 24<.94;5 26152:1 92:.;5 - 4 - 5/8261/5/< @35 1./ 3@@/4:/6 0;426.97?/ ;4</5 /:12346 "(*(*$(*%(*(*&(*&# (* 5/9< B21. /:1234 $ 3@ 1./ .95912>9 >9>9 94.219 $ (@35 6.351 --* 26 7/@35/ 1.26 3;51 6//C248859413@9412:209135>792? /95< 52 >>94983;<9 !912? 94< 52 !;421. 95C9? ?/954/< :3;46/?6 @35 1./ 0/121234/56 94< 52 9=9<95 .9.97;<<24 ?/954/< 28. 3;51 3A/54=/41 !?/9</5 @35 1./ 5/6034</41,191/ !/5;6/< 1./ =91/529?6 345/:35< 4 A2/B 3@ 1./ 52A9? :341/412346 ;58/< 7> 1./ ?/954/<:3;46/?6@35731.1./09512/61./032411.91B3;?< 9526/@35=>:3462</59123426 # > 946B/5 13 1./ 973A/ 03241 26 24 1./ @351./@3??3B248 - 5 - ./ 24<.94;5 ;59? !3?2:/ 5/8261/5/< 1./ + 34 1./ 79626 3@ 1./ @2561 24@35=91234 ?3<8/< 7> 1./ 24@35=941,52</A 95<95 ./ 24@35=941 6191/< 1.91 .26 @91./5269?973;5:34159:13594<973;19=341.983./ 9?348 B21. 1./ .;6794< 3@ 9::;6/< 3 , 4831. 2C<95 .9< 7//4 13 9.9596.159 ./ 692< 4831. 2C<95 .9< <2/<96./B969<<2:1/<13<524C6+9?6/9::;6912346B/5/ =9</98924611./@91./53@1./24@35=9411.91./.2=6/?@ =;5</5/<1./692<4831.2C<954$$"$91&$ 0=B./41./@91./53@1./24@35=941B96053://<24824 .26:35023A/.2:?/9::;6/<3613@35=/<94;4?9B@;? 966/=7?>B21.94241/4123413:9;6/.26</91.B9>?92<1./ :35023 A/.2:?/ <5988/< .2= 94< 1./ B2@/ 3@ 1./ 24@35=941 9669;?1/< ./5 B21. .94<6 94< B./4 1./ 24@35=941 94< 31./56 B.3 95/ 24=91/6 3@ 1./ :35023 :9=/13./55/6:;/1./9::;6/<B21.1./:3==3437D/:1 9669;?1/<1./=B21..94<6::;6/<36&13#94<% B21. 94 241/41234 13 :9;6/ 1./ </91. 3@ 1./ @91./5 3@ 1./ - 6 - 24@35=941 <5988/< .2= 4/95 ;589</A2 1/=0?/ 0;4:./< 94< 9669;?1/< .2= 94< 152/< 13 :9;6/ .26 </91. 7> 615948;?91248 .26 4/:C ./> .9A/ 0;??/< 1./ 695// 3@ 9<.949 26B96 94< 9<.2C9 95<95 94< 1354 1./ 7?3;6/ B354 7> 9<.949 26B96 B21. 94 241/41234 13 3;1598/ 1./25=3</61>1266191/<1.919@1/5C43B248973;11./ 24:2</411./24<.94;5;59?!3?2:/5;6./<131./603194< 152/< 13 241/5A/4/ 24 1./ =911/5 ./ 9::;6/< 98924 9669;?1/< 94< :52=249??> 2412=2<91/< 1./ 24@35=941 94< 31./56 24 1./ 05/6/4:/ 3@ 1./ !3?2:/ ./5/@35/ 1./ 24@35=941 5/E;/61/< 1./ !3?2:/ 13 5/8261/5 1./ :96/ 94< 2421291/?/89?9:123498924611./=::35<248?>1./!3?2:/ .9A/5/8261/5/<1./:96/94<133C;024A/612891234 % 1 26 6191/< 1.91 9::;6/< 3 .96 @2?/< 9 62=2?95:3=0?924198924611./24D;5/<241./05/6/41:96/ ./69=/:9=/137/5/8261/5/<34$#$"$2452=/ 3$$3@24<.94;5;59?!3?2:/191234 - 7 - & 1 26 6191/< 1.91 24<.94;5 ;59? 03?2:/ 5/8261/5/<9:52=249?:96/989246196=94>96"0/56346 B.3 95/ 9::;6/< 24 1./ 05/6/41 :96/ 6191248 1.91 B./4 1./> 152/< 13 241/5A/4/ 24 1./ =911/5 24 1./25 3@@2:29? :909:21> 1./ 9::;6/< .9A/ 97;6/< 9669;?1/< 94< =94 .94<?/< 1./= 05/A/41248 1./= @53= <26:.958248 1./25 3@@2:29?<;1> " A/41.3;8.2126:341/4</<7>1./?/954/<28. 3;51 3A/54=/41 !?/9</5 1.91 96 =94> 96 0/56346 .9A/ 6;61924/< 24D;52/6 24 1./ 24:2</41 24 E;/61234 1./ 3;4</512@2:91/6B.2:.95/053<;:/<7/@35/1./3;51 <26:?36/ 1.91 34?> 1B3 .9A/ 6;61924/< 852/A3;6 24D;52/6 7;1 1./> 95/ 9?5/9<> <26:.958/< @53= 1./ .360219? ./ 31./56.9A/6;61924/<34?>62=0?/24D;52/6 A/4 1.3;8. 1./ ?/954/< :3;46/? @35 1./ 0/121234/56 6;7=211/< 1.91 1./ 9::;6/< .9A/ 9?63 6;61924/< 24D;52/6 94< 1./5/@35/ 1./> .9A/ @2?/< 1./ 62=2?95 :3=0?9241 @2?248 3@ 1./ :96/ 94< :3;41/5 :96/ - 8 - 9892461 34/ 9431./5 26 94 9<=211/< @9:1 ;1 ?/954/< :3;46/?6 @35 1./ 0/121234/56 .96 431 053<;:/< 94> <3:;=/41 13 6.3B 1.91 1./ 9::;6/< .9A/ 6;61924/< 94> 24D;52/61264311./:341/412343@1./0536/:;12341.91 1./6/0/121234/5695/5/E;25/<@35:;613<29?241/55389123435 1.911./>95/.9A248:52=249?941/:/</416/4:/9=3@ 1./ 3024234 1.91 1./ 0/121234/56 =9> 7/ 85941/< 9412:209135>792?6;7D/:113:34<212346B.2:.B2??19C/:95/ 3@1./0536/:;1234 $ ::35<248?> 946B/5 1./ 973A/ 03241 24 1./ 94<053://<1309661./@3??3B248 (2* ./0/12123426 (22* ./ 0/121234/56 95/ 35</5/< 13 7/ /4?958/< 34 792? 24 1./ /A/41 3@ 1./25 955/61 2452=/ 3$$$ 3@ 24<.94335;59?!3?2:/191234 - 9 - (222* ./ 0/121234/56 95/ <25/:1/< 13 900/95 7/@35/ 1./4A/612891248@@2:/5 B21.24 <9>6 @53= 1./ <91/ 3@ 5/:/201 3@ 1.26 35</5 94< 34 1./25 900/9594:/ 1./ 4A/612891248@@2:/56.9??/4?958/1./=34792?6;7D/:113 1./@3??3B248:34<212346, 9 ./0/121234/566.9??@;5426.1./734<249 6;= 3@ 6$$$$$, (;0//6 B3 9C.6 34?>* /9:. B21. 1B3 6;5/12/6 @35 1./ ?2C/6;= 13 1./ 69126@9:1234 3@ 1./ 4A/612891248@@2:/5F 7 ./ 0/121234/56 6.9?? 431 :3==21 62=2?95 3@@/4:/6F : ./ 0/121234/56 6.9?? 900/95 7/@35/ 1./ 4A/612891248 @@2:/5 35 1./ 3;51 96 94< B./45/E;25/<F94< < ./ 0/121234/56 6.9?? 431 1.5/91/4 35 19=0/51./0536/:;1234B214/66/6 4 @;5426.248 1./ 6;5/12/6 7> 1./ 0/121234/56 1./ 4A/612891248@@2:/52691?27/51>13A/52@>1./:355/:14/66 3@ 1./ 9<<5/66 94< 9;1./412:21> 3@ 1./ <3:;=/416 - 10 - @;5426./<7>1./=469126@9:12343@1./692<<3:;=/416 1./> =9> 053://< 13 9::/01 1./ 6;5/12/6 B21.24 9 5/963497?/12=/ +) &""( % 2613?3# !