Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63242 (KAR)

SMT SARUBAI W/O REVANSIDDAPPA @ SHIVASHARANAPPA BIRADAR @ MULIMAI v. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER

MFA/200976/2021 · 2025-10-15

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) ! "#"$% & ' ! ! ( !! "#"$%) & ' ( * * $+'$( * %%)%$" ! #))%$ ! * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! * , $ -./0 12- ./345-617 89 :-./6-0 ;8467-: 98/ <812 12- =./1>-7 ) 2>7 .==-.: >7 =/-9-//-0 .3.>671 12- ?4035-61 .60 .@./0 0.1-0 %%)%$" >6 8#))%$ =.77-0 <A 12- />6;>=.:-6>8/>B>: 403-.60!.:.<4/.3> 2- 9.;17 89 12- ;.7- ./- 12.1 86 %%))%$ .1 .<841 #% =5 12- .==-::.61 .60 2-/ </812-/ >6 :.@ @-/- 38>63 18 >00.63.63. 87=>1.: 18 5--1 12->/ /-:.1>B- 86 12->/ 5818/ ;A:- <-./>63 /-3>71/.1>86 8!) )+# 1 12.1 1>5-.! 47<-./>63/-3>71/.1>86 8!)9$#%%'$( ;.5- 9/85 <.;C >6 . 2>32 7=--0 .60 >6 . /.72 .60 6-3:>3-61 5.66-/ 0.72-0 18 12- .==-::.61D7 B-2>;:- 04- 18 @2>;2 12- - 3 - .==-::.619-::08@6.607471.>6-03/>-B847>6?4/>-7.6072>91-0 1872@>6>87=>1.:8:.=4/98/1/-.15-61 6?4/-0;:.>5.61@.7.3-0"A-./7.60.1.>:8/<A =/89-77>862-@.75-1@>12.6.;;>0-6186%%))%$.60 9>:-0.;:.>5=-1>1>86;:.>5>63;85=-67.1>86897$+%%%%% 2- /><46.: .91-/ ;867>0-/>63 -61>/- 5.1-/>.: 86 /-;8/0 3/.61-0;85=-67.1>86897#%%%@>12>61-/-71.112-/.1- 89E=-/.66459/8512-0.1-89=-1>1>861>::/-.:>F.1>86 " 33/>-B-0<A12-7.>08/0-/12>7.==-.:>7=/-9-//-0 >6 @2>;2 >1 >7 ;861-60-0 12.1 12- /.1- 89 >61-/-71 .@./0-0<A 12-/><46.:>78612-:8@-/7>0-.60>12.718<--62.6;-018 $"E 2- .==-::.61 2.7 7499-/-0 9/.;14/-7 89 5>00:- 72.91 89 :-919-54//>3219881<812:8@-/:>5<7.60812-/=./178912- <80A .60 =/804;-0 G7 18 >- 0>7.<>:>1A ;-/1>9>;.1- @8460 ;-/1>9>;.1- 0>7;2./3- ;./0 .60 G/.A/-=8/1 ==-::.61 .:78 -G.5>6-0 ) .60 2- .77-77-0 12- 0>7.<>:>1A .1 %E 18 "E1812-@28:-<80A.60""E18:8@-/:>5<<4112-/><46.: 2.71.C-612-7.5-.7$"E.602-/>6;85-@.7@/863:A1.C-6 .7 7"%% =-/ 58612 2- 5-0>;.: -G=-67-7 .60 12- - 4 - .584613/.61-0460-/.::12-2-.07./-8612-:8@-/7>0-.60 1247/-H4-71-098/-62.6;-5-61 -1>1>86-/ 5-1 @>12 .6 .;;>0-61 .60 7471.>6-0 98::8@>63>6?4/>-7.7=-/@8460;-/1>9>;.1- i) 85=8460 9/.;14/- 89 12- :-91 9-54/ @>12 2-5.185. ii) </.7>86786<812:8@-/:>5<7 iii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