Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63236 (KAR)
MIYASAB S/O FAKIRSAB PINJAR v. BAVAJI DADABASHA AND ANR
MFA/200073/2019 · 2025-08-29
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63236 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63236 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!" !#"
$ %""&"&
""''
(&) *
!"#" $
%
&
! "
' !"!##"
(
' %)#& * *
+ !#,-
!##"#
$ % (. "
/&
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"0%"&
/
+
("'#(#" ##'(#"
/
1
/
2
%! " 345 677869 45 :498; <= >38 6778996?>@964A6?> 588B4?C 8?36?@8A8?> D: @DA78?56>4D? 65 6E6F;8; <= >38 >F4<G?69 4? >38 G;CA8?> 6?; 6E6F; ;6>8; ##'(#" 76558; 4? D("'#(#" <= >38 ;;4>4D?69 8?4DF 4H49 G;C8 6?; )+ 4I6=67GF6 %:DF 53DF> ,>38 >F4<G?69-&
( 38:6@>5986;4?C>D:494?CD:>38@964A78>4>4D?<= >386778996?>@964A6?>6F8>36>D?("#((#"6>6<DG>'# 7A E38? >38 6778996?>@964A6?> E65 5>6?;4?C D? >38 8J>F8A898:>54;8D:>38FD6;?86F88>6D>896>6F6C6>>4 E64>4?C :DF >38 <G5 6> >36> >4A8 D?8 9DFF= <86F4?C
- 3 -
F8C45>F6>4D? D
)#()'' @6A8 :FDA DB6B 54;8 4? 6 34C3 5788; F653 6?; ?8C94C8?> A6??8F ;F4H8? <= 4>5 ;F4H8F 6?; E3498 >GF?4?C >38 9DFF= >38 ;F4H8F 9D5> @D?>FD9 6?; >38 H834@98F6?DH8F>3898:>:DD>D:>3878>4>4D?8F656F85G9>>38 6778996?>@964A6?>-5 98:> :DD> E65 6A7G>8; 38 6778996?>@964A6?> 365 :498; >38 @964A 78>4>4D? <8:DF8 >38 >F4<G?69588B4?C@DA78?56>4D?38>F4<G?69677F8@46>4?C>38 8H4;8?@8 D? F8@DF; 6558558; >38 @DA78?56>4D? 38 6778996?>@964A6?> 588B4?C 8?36?@8A8?> 365 :498; >345 677869
86F; >38 986F?8; @DG?589 :DF >38 6778996?> 6?;
>38 986F?8; @DG?589 :DF >38 F857D?;8?> D()?5GF6?@8 @DA76?=
86F?8;@DG?589 :DF >38 6778996?> EDG9; @D?>8?; >36>>386778996?>E65EDFB4?C656A8@36?4@4?>38 6?;;G8>D>386@@4;8?>6?;6A7G>6>4D?D:>3898:>:DD>38 @DG9;?D>ID4?>38;G>=38;456<494>=>6B8?<=>38>F4<G?696>
"#K45D?9DE8F54;838>F4<G?69DGC3>>D36H8>6B8?>38 4?@DA86578FJ
(048>3876=5947D:>38D>38FA8@36?4@
- 4 -
48 G?;6FC4EDFB4?C4?>3838@DA78?56>4D? 6E6F;8;:DF764?6?;5G::8F4?C45D?9DE8F54;838>F4<G?69 365 ?D> 6E6F;8; 9D55 D: 4?@DA8 ;GF4?C >38 964; G7 78F4D;
D?54;8F4?C >38 6A7G>6>4D? D: >38 98:> :DD> D: >38 6778996?>@964A6?> >38 9D55 D: 6A8?4>485 6E6F;8; <= >38 >F4<G?6945D?>389DE8F54;8
! 86F?8; @DG?589 :DF >38 F857D?;8?> D() ?5GF6?@8 @DA76?= EDG9; @D?>8?; >36> >38 6778996?>@964A6?> E65 86F948F ;45A4558; :FDA >38 58FH4@8 6?;6578F>38DF;8FD:>386<DGFDGF>38E65F84?5>6>8; 6?;38@DG9;?D>ID4?>38;G>485386778996?>@964A6?>E65 C8>>4?C 76= D: 5'!0) 65 78F 76= 5947 6> J
( :DF GCG5> (#"# 6?; @D?54;8F4?C >38 56A8 345 76= ;GF4?C
8<FG6F=(#"A6=<894>>9834C38F>36?>36>6?;?D>6578F J
(0 48 76= 5947 D: D>38F 8A79D=88 8 :GF>38F 5G<A4>5 >36> >38 78F@8?>6C8 D: ;456<494>= >6B8? <= >38 >F4<G?69 45 7FD78F 6?; @DFF8@> 38 @DA78?56>4D? 6E6F;8; 45 IG5> 6?; 7FD78F/4>3>345387F6=5:DF;45A45569D:>38677869
- 5 -
6H4?C386F;>38986F?8;@DG?5895>345DGF>365 78FG58;>384A7GC?8;G;CA8?>6?;>38>F469DGF>F8@DF;5
0 38 6778996?>@964A6?> E65 EDFB4?C 65 8@36?4@ 4? >38 5 78F J
( >38 76= 5947 :DF >38 GCG5> (#"#>38CFD555696F=455'!0)578FJ
(38365 <88?53DE?65A8@36?4@J
(045>3876=5947D:D?8F4
G?;6FC4E3D58CFD5576=E655(0(")6?;38E65 EDFB4?C 65 / A8@36?4@ 38 @964A6?> E65 EDFB4?C 65 A8@36?4@ 6?; >38564;
G?;6FC4E65 EDFB4?C 65/ A8@36?4@ 38F8:DF8 >38 76= D: >38 6778996?>@964A6?> @6??D> <8 @D?54;8F8; D?
76F E4>3 >38 76= D: >38 564;
G?;6FC46578FJ
(0D?54;8F4?C>38CFD555696F=D:
5'!0)6578FJ
(:DFGCG5>(#"#34576=A6=<8 @D?54;8F8; :DF
8<FG6F= (#" 65 5"(###) 38 6778996?>@964A6?> E65 36H4?C 6 78FA6?8?> ID< 6?; 38 45 6C8;<8>E88?!#>D#=86F548!0=86F58458?>4>98>D :G>GF8 7FD578@>5 6> "!K 78F 6??GA 65 78F >38 ;8@454D? D:
D?-<98 78J DGF> 4? >38 @658 D:
F87DF>8; 4? !! - 6 -
5 78F >38 8H4;8?@8 D:
/()D@>DF >38F8 45 6 6A7G>6>4D? D: 98:> :DD> >D >38 8J>8?> D: :DF8:88> 5 78F J
();456<94>= @8F>4:4@6>8 >38 ;456<494>= 45 (!K 38 564; ;456<494>=@8F>4:4@6>845455G8;<=>38?D?)>F86>8;D@>DF38 73D>DCF673D:>38@964A6?>6F86>J
"6?;D?5884?C>38 56A8 4> 45 @986F >36> >38 :FD?> 7DF>4D? D: >38 98:> :DD> 365 <88?6A7G>8;6<DH8>38:4?C8F5D?54;8F4?C>386C8D:>38 @964A6?> 48 !0 =86F5 65 D? >38 ;6>8 D: >38 6@@4;8?> 6?;
>38 ;456<494>= @8F>4:4@6>8 6> J
( >38 ;456<494>= 365 >D <8 >6B8?6>(!K38>F4<G?69365F4C3>9=>6B8?>38AG9>47948F6> ,'- ? H48E D: >38 6<DH8 >38 9D55 D: :G>GF8 4?@DA8 45 @69@G96>8;65G?;8F
5"(###)+"!K%:G>GF87FD578@>5&L5"##)
5"##)+"(+'+(!KL50(##)
' D?54;8F4?C>386A7G>6>4D?D:>3898:>:DD>6<DH8 >38:4?C8F5>38764?6?;5G::8F4?C56E6F;8;<=>38>F4<G?69 4? 6 5GA D: 5####) 6?; 9D55 D: 6A8?4>485 4? 6 5GA D:
5####) 6F8 D? 9DE8F 54;8 38 6778996?>@964A6?> 45 8?>4>98 >D 5!####) 86@3 :DF 764? 6?; 5G::8F4?C5 6?; >DE6F;56A8?4>48538>F4<G?69365F4C3>9=6E6F;8;65GA
- 7 -
D: 5"####) >DE6F;5 :DD; 6?; ?DGF453A8?> 6 5GA D:
5"####) >DE6F;5 6>>8?;6?> @36FC85 6?; 5"####) >DE6F;5 @D?H8=6?@8 @36FC85 38 >F4<G?69 365 ?D> 6E6F;8; 9D55D:4?@DA8;GF4?C964;G778F4D;386778996?>@964A6?> 458?>4>98>D9D55D:4?@DA8;GF4?C>38964;G778F4D;4?65GA D:5"(###)+AD?>35L5###)
"# ? H48E D: >38 6<DH8 >38 6778996?>@964A6?> 45 8?>4>98>D@DA78?56>4D?65G?;8F
"+ ,-./012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/ ;74
" D55D::G>GF84?@DA8 50(##) ( 64?6?;5G::8F4?C5 5!####)
8;4@698J78?585 5(0)
DD; 6?; ?DGF453A8?> 6>>8?;6?> 6?; @D?H8=6?@8 @36FC85 5####) ! D55D:6A8?4>485 5!####)
D55 D: 4?@DA8 ;GF4?C 964; G7 78F4D; 5###)
4-+ /<
=
"" 38 6778996?> 45 8?>4>98 >D >D>69 @DA78?56>4D? D:
5#"#0) 65 6C64?5> 5(!(##) 65 6E6F;8; <= >38 >F4<G?69
"( ?H48ED:>386<DH8>38:D99DE4?C
- 8 -
! %4& 3867786945699DE8;4?)76F>. %44& 38 6778996?>@964A6?> 45 8?>4>98 >D >D>69@DA78?56>4D?D:5#"#0)E4>34?>8F85> 6> >38 F6>8 D: K 78F 6??GA :FDA >38 ;6>8 D:
78>4>4D?>499F8694M6>4D?. %444& 857D?;8?> D( ?5GF6?@8 @DA76?= 53699 ;87D54> >38 6E6F; 6ADG?> E4>3 4?>8F85> E4>34? 6 78F4D; D: 84C3> E88B5 :FDA >345 ;6= :6494?CE34@34>45946<98>D76=4?>8F85>6>'K78F 6??GA. %4H& 38 8?>4F8 6ADG?> 45 DF;8F8; >D <8 F898658;4?:6HDGFD:>386778996?>@964A6?>.
%H& 8C45>F= >D 58?; <6@B >38 >F469 DGF> F8@DF;569D?CE4>36@D7=D:>345G;CA8?>
".= ("&"&) %! 45>D"9D"