Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63226 (KAR)
THE PRESIDENT HOTAGI v. THE ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WA/200050/2025 · 2025-09-03
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63226 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63226 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #"$! #"$" %"!! &' '!! ()
&
'
!"# $
% &
'
'
!"#(
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% & $
)
)
* $ )
% '
) &
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
# ###"#+! )
)
)'
' &
'
'
*"#( '*"# $ % )
' &
- 3 -
)
*"#
)
!"#
(
))% & *"#
!"#
$
% '
)
(,
) &
)
)
'
# # ##"#
) ## ###
"-
)'
) )
. '
. ' )
- 4 -
% . '&
/012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 78<=50>6063 5/016/27896:/5;8134/0==/55063!87>/3?>634/@1>30==/05 062 5/016/2
8A/16</63 2A8703/ 0==/01>6B ;81 34/ 1/:=862/63!303/
>67/34/7863/<=3=/3>3>8606234/@1>30==/05 01/ 01>:>6B 893 8; 34/ 812/1 203/2 ##"# =0::/2 C? 34/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/>68# #C83434/ <033/1: 01/ 30D/6 9= 38B/34/1 062 2>:=8:/2 8; C? 34>: 78<<86812/1
( 4/7863/<=3=/3>3>86>:;>5/2C?34//<=58?// @81D>6B >6 830B> 10460<034 1> 8B>10E/6210 4>A07401?029703>860519:3%;81:4813F87>/3?G&=10?>6B 38 >6>3>03/ 7863/<=3 =187//2>6B: 0B0>6:3 34/ 87>/3? ;81 2>:8C/2>/67/ 062 686!78<=5>067/ 8; 34/ 812/1 203/2 ##"# =0::/2 C? 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ >6 8# # @4/1/0: 34/ @1>30==/05>: ;>5/2C? - 5 -
34/ 87>/3? H9/:3>86>6B 34/ 812/1 8; 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/<0>65?7863/62>6B340334/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/40:
78<<>33/2 06 /1181 >6 2>1/73>6B 34/ 87>/3? 38 =0? 34/ :9C:>:3/67/0558@067/
)073905 <031>I 8; 34/ 70:/ 8; 34/ 78<=50>6063! /<=58?//C/;81/34/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/>:34034/@0:
:9:=/62/2 291>6B 34/ 7891:/ 8; 4>: /<=58?</63 062 6/>34/1 34/ 060B/</63 681 34/
8A/16</63 40: =0>2 :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ >6:=>3/ 8; :/A/105 2/<062: C/>6B <02/ /67/ 4/ 0==18074/2 34>: 8913 C? ;>5>6B @1>3 =/3>3>868# #=10?>6B38>::9/@1>38;7/13>8101> ;81 :/33>6B 0:>2/ 34/ 812/1 203/2 ### =0::/2 C? 1/:=862/63 8 >6 ==/05 8 # 062 812/1 8
%& 40189400 8<=50>63 6H9>1? J #! ( 203/2 ### =0::/2 C? 1/:=862/63 8( 34/1/>6A>2/66/I91/!3834/@1>3=/3>3>86786:/H9/635? 38 2>1/73 34/ 1/:=862/63: ;81 =0?</63 8; :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 062 812/1 ;81 06? 834/1 1/5>/; 38 @4>74 34/ =/3>3>86/1>:/63>35/238
- 6 -
4/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ 40: 786:>2/1/2 34/ B18962: 91B/2 >6 34/ =/3>3>86 062 ;073905 0:=/73: 8; 34/ 70:/ 3403 0 71><>605 70:/ @0: 1/B>:3/1/2 0B0>6:3 34/ =/3>3>86/1 >6 1></ 8" # 8; 050C910B>
10<//6 85>7/303>86062786:/H9/633834/:0</4/@0:30D/6 38 E92>7>05 79:382? 062 @0: :/63 38 E92>7>05 1/<062 4/ 87>/3? C? 812/1 203/2 ## D/=3 34/ =/3>3>86/1 962/1 :9:=/6:>86 @>34 1/318:=/73>A/ /;;/73 ;18< ##0:=/134/2>1/73>868;34//=93?>1/73818;
9C5>7 6:31973>86: %;81 :4813 FG& A>2/ 5/33/1 203/2 ## C93 C834 34/ 87>/3? 062 34/ 1/:=862/63! 303/ 40A/ 683 =0>2 :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 38 34/ =/3>3>86/1 /<=58?///67/4/4020==18074/234>:8913 C?
;>5>6B @1>3 =/3>3>86 /:=862/63 8: 062 ( 0==/01/2 34189B434/>11/:=/73>A/7896:/5/:=862/63834/1/>6 ;>5/2 78963/1 0;;>20A>3 :303>6B 3403 86 34/ 2>1/73>86 8; 1/:=862/638(34/1/>6>3:9:=/62/234/=/3>3>86/193 1/:=862/63 8( 34/1/>6 40: 683 ;>5/2 06? :303/</63 8;
8CE/73>86: 4/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ 30D>6B 683/ 8; 34/
- 7 -
;0739050:=/73:8;34/70:/8C:/1A/2340396;8139603/5?>6 34>: 70:/ 34/ /<=58?// @0: :9:=/62/2 @0? C07D >6 34/ ?/01 # >/ 86 ## 062 4/ @0: 30D/6 >638 :/1A>7/86###06234/1/:=862/63:40A/683=0>2 34/:9C:>:3/67/0558@067/4/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/40:
05:88C:/1A/234036/>34/134/87>/3?68134/
8A/16</63 >: @>55>6B 38=0?:9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 834 8; 34/< 01/ =0::>6B 86 34/ 1/:=86:>C>5>3? ;18< 86/ 38 34/ 834/1 077812>6B 38 34/
8A/16</63 0: 34/ /<=58?// @0:
:9:=/62/2 C? 34/ 87>/3? @>34893 >6;81<03>86 38 34/ 8A/16</6334/?01/6835>0C5/38=0?77812>6B3834/ 87>/3? 34/
8A/16</63 >: 5>0C5/ 38 =0? 34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ :>67/ 34/ :0</ >: B1063!>6!0>2 >6:3>393>86 062 :9:=/6:>86 812/1 >: >::9/2 86 34/ @1>33/6 2>1/73>86 8;
4/ =/3>3>86/1 >: /63>35/2 ;81 34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/;8134/=/1>824/@0:=507/2962/1:9:=/6:>86 062 2/6>05 8; :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 0<8963: 38 2/=1>A03>86 8; 1>B43 38 5>;/ 062 5>C/13? B901063//2 962/1 13>75/ 8; 34/ 86:3>393>86 8; 62>0 062 05:8 4/52 3403
- 8 -
34/=/3>3>86/1>:/63>35/2;8134/:0</0586B@>34>63/1/:3 3 @0: 05:8 8C:/1A/2 3403 34/ =/3>3>86/1 >: /63>35/2 ;81 :9C:>:3/67/0558@067/06234/87>/3?@4840:=507/234/ =/3>3>86/1 962/1 :9:=/6:>86 >: 34/ 093481>3? 7867/16/2 @>34 34/ =0?</63 8; 34/ :0501? >: 5>0C5/ 38 =0? 34/ :9C:>:3/67/0558@067/
/>6B0BB1>/A/2C?34/:0</34/=1/:/63@1>3 0==/05>:;>5/2C?34/87>/3? J 6 34/ @1>3 0==/05 >3 >: 7863/62/2 C? 34/ 0==/55063!87>/3? 3403 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ 40:
/1186/89:5?=0::/234/812/12>1/73>6B34/87>/3?38=0? :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 062 34/ A/1? 0==18074 8; 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ >: /1186/89: 8@/A/1 >6 34/ B18962:8;0==/05>3>:7863/62/2340334/5/016/2>6B5/ '92B/ 402 683 /I=1/::/2 06?34>6B 1/B012>6B 34/ ;0953 8;
34/ 87>/3? >6 =0?</63 8; :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 38 /<=58?//0624026830::>B6/206?1/0:86@4>5/2>1/73>6B
- 9 -
34/ 87>/3? 38 =0? 34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ /I7/=3 3@8 5>6/812/18;2>1/73>6B34/87>/3?38<0D/=0?</63
" 4/ 1/:=862/63!303/ ;>5/2 2879</63: 0586B @>34 34/ </<8 >6 34/:/ <033/1: 1/;/11>6B 38 34/ 5/33/1 203/2 "#"# 062 05:8 =013>795015? >179501 203/2
"###062C189B433834/683>7/8;34>:891395/ 8;34/016030D029703>86056:3>393>86:%/719>3</63062 /1<:062862>3>86:8;/1A>7/:8;<=58?//:>61>A03/ >2/2 1><01? 062 /786201? 29703>8605 6:3>393>86:& 95/:%;81:4813F95/:&@4/1/>6>3>:=18A>2/2 3403 /A/1? 812/1 8; =1>A03/ <060B/</63 1/7/>A>6B 0>2 ;18<
8A/16</63 D//=>6B /<=58?//: 02<>33/2 38 B1063! >6!0>2 962/1 :9:=/6:>86 ;18< :/1A>7/: /37 :4055 C/ 786;>1</2 C? 34/ 78<=/3/63 093481>3? @48 40: 0==18A/2 34/ 0==8>63</63 4/ 5/016/2
8A/16</63 2A8703/ <0>65? 7863/62/2 3403 @4/6 34/ :9:=/6:>86 8; 34/ =/3>3>86/1 @0: 683 0==18A/2 C?
34/
8A/16</63 962/1 95/8;34/95/:34/H9/:3>868;<82>;?>6B34/ 812/18;34/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/062:4>;3>6B34/C912/6
- 10 -
8634/
8A/16</6328/:68301>://67/34/@1>30==/05 >:5>0C5/38C/2>:<>::/2
0A>6B 4/012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 78<=50>6063 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 0==/55063!87>/3? >6 @1>3 0==/05 062 34/ 5/016/2
8A/16</63 2A8703/ 0==/01>6B;8134/1/:=862/63!303/34/=8>63:3403@8952 01>:/;81891786:>2/103>8601/
8>638:062
# 0A>6B4/01234/5/016/27896:/50==/01>6B;81 34/ 1/:=/73>A/ =013>/: 062 86 =/19:05 8; 34/ <03/1>05 86 1/7812 >3 >: 683 >6 2>:=93/ 3403 34/ 78<=50>6063 >: 06 /<=58?//8;34/87>/3?3>:05:8683>62>:=93/340334/
- 11 -
=8:3@4>7434/78<=50>6063 /<=58?//>:4/52>::9CE/73/2 38B1063!>6!0>24/1/7812:05:82>:758:/3403071><>605 70:/40:C//61/B>:3/1/20B0>6:334/78<=50>60630624/ @0::/633834/E92>7>0579:382?06234/:0</>:05:8683 >6 2>:=93/ 3 >: 05:8 ><=813063 38 683/ 3403 0: =/1 66/I91/!203/2##@4>74@0:;>5/2>634/@1>3 =/3>3>86 0 2>1/73>86 @0: B>A/6 38 34/ 87>/3? 38 >6>3>03/ 2>:7>=5>601? 073>86 0B0>6:3 34/ 2/5>6H9/63 /<=58?// 062 >63><03/ 34/ :0</ 38 34/ 8;;>7/ 8; 1/:=862/63!303/ 062 34/ 85>7/ /=013</63 86:/H9/63 9=86 34/ 2>1/73>86 >::9/2 C? 34/
8A/16</63 34/ 87>/3? >::9/2 34/ :9:=/6:>86812/1203/2##8634/A/1?6/I320? @4/1/>6 0 1/;/1/67/ @0: <02/ 38 34/ 5/33/1 203/2 ## >::9/2 C? 34/
8A/16</63 062 78=? 8; 34/ :0</ @0: :/63 38 34/ /=013</63 0: >6:31973/2 >6 34/ 5/33/1 03 66/I91/! 49: 2>1/73>86 B>A/6 03 66/I91/!@0:78<=5>/2@>34
8@ 34/ <0>6 7863/63>86 8; 34/ 5/016/2 8A/16</632A8703/0==/01>6B;8134/1/:=862/63!303/
- 12 -
>:3403>63/1<:8;95/8;34/95/:34/87>/3? 89B43 38 40A/ :/63 34/ :9:=/6:>86 812/1 ;81 0==18A05 93 A>2/ 812/1 203/2 #(## 03 66/I91/! 34/ 303/ 40: =0::/2 34/ 812/1 :0673>86>6B 34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/@4/1/>605:801/;/1/67/@0:<02/3834/5/33/1 203/2 ## 4/ :0</ >: C189B43 38 34/ 683>7/ 8;
34>:8913C?34/5/016/27896:/50==/01>6B;8134/87>/3? 7863/62>6B 3403 >6 34/ A/1? 812/1 =0::/2 C? 34/ 8A/16</63203/2#(##01/;/1/67/@0:<02/3403 060==18A05@0:<02/86##4/1/;81/68@34/ 303/ 706683 3916 018962 062 :0? 3403 68 :974 0==18A05 @0: :89B43 0A>6B 786:>2/1/2 34/ 2879</63 03 66/I91/!>3>:75/01340334/1/@0:060==18A05C?34/ 8A/16</63 A>2/ 5/33/1 203/2 ## 38 >6>3>03/ 34/ 2>:7>=5>601? =187//2>6B: 4/6 34/ :9:=/6:>86 812/1 @0:
=0::/2 03 34/ >6:3067/ 8; 34/
8A/16</63 3403 388 86 0 2>1/73>86 062 /A/6 >6 66/I91/! 34/1/ @0: 0 :=/7>;>7 1/;/1/67/ 38 5/33/1 8; 34/
8A/16</63 >/ 66/I91/! :303>6B340334/?40A/1/7/>A/2078<<96>703>8638>6>3>03/
- 13 -
2>:7>=5>601? 073>86 :>67/ 34/ /<=58?// @0: >6 E92>7>05 79:382?34/A/1?7863/63>868;34/303/3403680==18A05 >:8C30>6/2706683C/077/=3/206234/5/33/1:0?:>6>3>03/ =187//2>6B: 062 >63><03/ 77812>6B5? =/62>6B /=013</6305 /6H9>1? :9:=/6:>86 812/1 >: >::9/2 062 >63><03/2
634/70:/86406234/2>:7>=5>601?073>86@0: 683 >6>3>03/2 03 34/ >6:3067/ 8; 34/ 87>/3? 86 34/>1 8@6 C93>3@0:C0:/28634/2>1/73>868;1/:=862/63!303/6 3/1<: 8; 66/I91/!
>3 >: 75/01 3403 34/ 0==18A05 @0: <02/ 86 ## 062 06 812/1 ;81 =0?</63 8;
:9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ @0: =0::/2 4/ :0</ @0:
78<<96>703/2 38 34/ 87>/3? 8@/A/1 34/ 812/1 8;
=0?</63 8; :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ @0: @>344/52 C? 812/1 203/2 #J## 062 :9C:/H9/635? C? 812/1 203/2 ### 2>1/73>6B 34/ 0==/55063 87>/3? 38 =0? :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ @8952 683 6/B03/ 34/ /015>/1 2>1/73>86 38 >6>3>03/ 0==18=1>03/ /=013</6305 073>86 062 34/ 87>/3? 077812>6B5? >6 78<=5>067/ 8; 2>1/73>86 >::9/2
- 14 -
:9:=/6:>86 812/1 1/318:=/73>A/5? =0::/2 /=013</6305 /6H9>1?4/6:974C/>6B34/70:/34/A/1?7863/63>868; 34/1/:=862/63!303/340334/:0</@0:6830==18A/2062 340334/:0</>:683>678<=5>067/@>3495/8;95/:
706683 C/ 077/=3/2 0: 34/1/ >: 0 1/;/1/67/ 8;
0==18A050:=/166/I91/! ( /40A/30D/6683/8;34/=18A>:>86:8;95/ 06295/J8;34/95/:@>341/B01238B1063>6B8; :9C:>:3/67/0558@067/0A>6B30D/6683/8;34/:0</062 05:8 34/ 66/I91/! @4/6 34/
8A/16</63 >3:/5; 40:
=0::/2 34/ 812/1 02<>33>6B ;81 =0?</63 8; :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/68@34/?7066837863/62340334/87>/3?40: 38=0?:9C:>:3/67/0558@067/
4/ 812/1 203/2 ### =0::/2 C? 1/:=862/63!303/ >6 3/1<: 8; 66/I91/!" 4852>6B 3403 34/87>/3?40:38=0?34/0<89630:34/0==18A05>:683 8C30>6/2 C? :/62>6B 34/ =18=8:05 ;81 0==18A05 8;
:9:=/6:>86 @0: 74055/6B/2 C/;81/ 34/ 8<<>::>86/1 ;81
- 15 -
9C5>76:31973>86:
95C01B0C?34/87>/3?>/0==/55063 >6 @1>3 0==/05 062 34/ :0>2 0==/05 @0: 2>:=8:/2 8; A>2/ 812/1 203/2 ### 4852>6B 3403 34/ :9:=/6:>86 =/1>8231/03/20:2>/:68668338C/1/7D86/20::/1A>7/ />6B 0BB1>/A/2 C? 34/ :0</ 34/ 78<=50>6063!/<=58?// 402 0==18074/2 34>: 8913 C? ;>5>6B 34/ @1>3 =/3>3>86 7055>6B>6H9/:3>86C83434/812/1::303/2:9=10
4/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/@4>5/786:>2/1>6B34/ B1>/A067/ 8; 34/ =/3>3>86/1!/<=58?// 3489B4 <02/ 06 8C:/1A03>86 3403 C834 8; 34/< >/ 34/ 87>/3? 062 34/ 303/ 01/ :4>;3>6B 34/>1 1/:=86:>C>5>3? ;81 =0?</63 8;
:9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 86 /074 834/1 @>34893 2>:79::>6B @>34 1/B012 38 ;>I03>86 8; 34/ 5>0C>5>3? 86 34/ 87>/3? 8C:/1A/2 3403 34/ =/3>3>86/1 >: /63>35/2 ;81 :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ 062 34/ 87>/3? @48 40: =507/2 34/ =/3>3>86/1 962/1:9:=/6:>86062@48>:34/093481>3?7867/16/2@>34 =0?</63 8; 34/ :0501? >: 5>0C5/ 38 =0? 34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/
- 16 -
4/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/40:6832>:79::/2@>34 1/B0123895/8;34/95/:0:7863/62/2C?34/ 1/:=862/63!303/
J 3 >: 683 >6 2>:=93/ 3403 34/ 78<=50>6063! /<=58?//>:@81D>6B>634/0>2/2>6:3>393>8606234/:0501? >: =0>2 C? 34/
8A/16</63 / 40A/ 8C:/1A/2 3403 6/6I91/!>:>::9/20334/>6:3067/8;34/
8A/16</63 062786:/H9/639=8666/I91/!66/I91/!>:>::9/2 C? 34/ 87>/3? / 40A/ 05:8 8C:/1A/2 3403 34/ 2>:7>=5>601? 073>86 >: >6>3>03/2 03 34/ >6:3067/ 8; 34/ 1/:=862/63!303/062@4/6:974C/>6B34/70:/34/A/1? 7863/63>86 8; 34/ 1/:=862/63!303/ 3403 34/ 87>/3? 40: 68330D/634/0==18A058;34/303/706683C/077/=3/2
" 4/634>:8913;89623403/015>/1:0501?>:=0>2 C?34/
8A/16</6306205:8073>86>:30D/60334/>6:3067/ 8;34/
8A/16</6306234/87>/3?40:073/2>63/1<:8; 34/2>1/73>868;34/303/34/><=9B6/2812/1=0::/2C?
34/5/016/2>6B5/'92B/1/H9>1/:38C/<82>;>/22>1/73>6B
- 17 -
34/303/38=0?34/:9C:>:3/67/0558@067/>6:3/028;34/ 87>/3? /67/ @/ 06:@/1 =8>63 8 >6 0;;>1<03>A/ 062 =8>638>66/B03>A/
6A>/@8;34/0C8A/2>:79::>86@/=187//238 =0::34/;8558@>6B
> 4/ 1>3 ==/05 ;>5/2 C? 34/ 87>/3? >: 0558@/2
>> 4/ 812/1 203/2 ##"# =0::/2 C? 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/ '92B/ >6 1>3 /3>3>86 8# #>::/30:>2/
>>> 4/ 812/1 203/2 ### =0::/2 C? 34/ 22>3>8605 8<<>::>86/1 ;81 9C5>7 6:31973>86: 050C910B> A>2/ 66/I91/! 062 34/ 812/1 203/2 ### =0::/2 C? 34/ /=93? >1/7381 8; 9C5>7 6:31973>86: 050C910B>A>2/66/I91/!01/H90:4/2
>A 4/1/:=862/63!303/>:2>1/73/238=0?34/ :9C:>:3/67/ 0558@067/ ;18< ## 38 ### 0586B @>34 >63/1/:3 8; "- =/1 0669< @>34>6 0 =/1>82 8; ;891 @//D: ;18<
- 18 -
34/ 203/ 8; 1/7/>=3 8; 7/13>;>/2 78=? 8; 34>: 812/1
A 6 A>/@ 34/ 0C8A/ 2>1/73>86 062 >6 A>/@ 8;
:/33>6B 0:>2/ 8; 34/ 812/1 8; 34/ 5/016/2 >6B5/'92B/34/7863/<=3=/3>3>86;>5/2C? 34/78<=50>6063!/<=58?// 28/:683:91A>A/ ;81786:>2/103>86;8134/=1/:/63
*& (!) $
*& (") $
>:3858