- 1 - ! "! #$!%!$$ $&& ' '(&)* '!!)) + !! " # $ ! % % % & !' " # (!) & ( $ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( *+# $( & ( ( # , $ - . & ( #$ #$ ' ' ! ' ' ( /( '! //#$( %( ( ( & % - & % $ # - & $ 01 233144256 71859 601 2::;<1= 85 31:824 2<1 #$' ' !5601>841>==8685248<6?8:625= 1<<85<&;=9125=( #$2427;?298#>?<0?6 @ ?824 ;?6A$ 8< 8B3;95859 601 C;=9B156 > :5D8:685 =261= ' ' 25= ?=1? > <15615:1 =261= ' ' :5D8:6859 08B >? 601 >>15:1< 3;58<02741 ;5=1?1:685/>601?61:685>084=?15>?B1E;24 >>15:1<:6 '! #>?<0?6@A$25=;5=1?1:685 - 3 - //>601 5=8251524=1!/'#>?<0?6@ A$25= <15615:85908B #8$ ;5=1?9?89?;<8B3?8<5B156>?231?8= > 'F12?<>?601>>15:13;58<02741;5=1?1:685/> 601:625=632F>851>< '''') #88$ ;5=1?9?89?;<8B3?8<5B156>?231?8= >>8D1F12?<25=632F>851><'''>?601>>15:1 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685 // > G860 =1>2;46 <15615:1< 01 ?824;?602<2G2?=1=<*'''''2< :B315<26856601D8:68B98?4H%! 01:2<1>6013?<1:;685857?81>8<60265 !' ' !26I''2BG015%!601B85?98?4291= >8D1 F12?< G2< 342F859 85 >?56 > 601 51G4F :5<6?;:61= ?B71=J2? <614 <86;261= 26 2C23;? 2= 2427;?2986012::;<1=3?:;?1=01?G86025856156856 :BB86 ?231 25= :BB8661= 299?2D261= 31516?268D1 <1E;242<<2;46 01?17F:BB8661=601>>15:13;58<02741 - 4 - 25= ;5=1? 1:685< // 25= */#$ > 25= ;5=1? 1:685<+25=/>601:6 5 ?198<6?2685 > 601 ( 5 601 72<8< > 601 >8?<685>?B26854=91=7F% G08<601B601?>601 D8:68B 98?4 601 85D1<6892685 G2< ;5=1?62J15 25= :02?91 <0116 :2B1 6 71 >841= 01 412?51= 298<6?261 6J :958K25:1>601>>15:1<25=?198<61?1=601<31:824:2<1 012::;<1=23312?1=71>?1601 ?824;?625=3412=1= 569;846F25=:428B1=6716?81= + 01 3?<1:;685 6 3?D1 601 9;846 > 601 2::;<1=1E2B851=%!6%!/25=96B2?J1= E<! 6 + 85 <;33?6 > 86< :5615685 01 2::;<1= 02< =1581=24460185:?8B8526?FB261?824<2D28427415?1:?= 7;6 02< 56 41= 25F 1D8=15:1 85 <;33?6 > 08< =1>15:1 01 ?824 ;?6 2>61? 62J859 856 :5<8=1?2685 244 601<1 B261?824< 5 ?1:?= :2B1 6 601 :5:4;<85 6026 601 3?<1:;685 8< <;::1<<>;4 85 3?D859 601 9;846 > 601 2::;<1= 71F5= 244 ?12<52741 =;76< >? 601 >>15:1< - 5 - 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685< // 25= */#$ > 25= ;5=1?1:685<+25=/>601:6::?=8594F01 G2< :5D8:61= 25= <15615:1= 2< <6261= 27D1 1859 299?81D1= 7F 601 <2B1 601 2331442562::;<1= 8< 71>?1 608<;?6 12?= 412?51= :;5<14 ?8 25=J8<0?1 7 23312?859 >?601 2331442562::;<1=25= ?8 324J?8<052 2=2D 412?51= 890 ;?6 D1?5B156 412=1? >? ?1<35=156!62611?;<1=601B261?824<5?1:?= 85:4;=859601 ?824;?6?1:?=< / 5 D81G > 601 :5615685< ;?91= 7F 412?51= :;5<14>?60132?681<60138566026G;4=2?8<1>?BF :5<8=1?26858< - 6 - F 25<G1? 6 601 27D1 3856 8< @ A>?601>44G859 !! * 68<601:5615685>6013?<1:;6856026%! HD8:68B98?48<291=>8D1F12?<G08<601=2;9061?>601 85>?B256 % %015 601 D8:68B 98?4 G2< 342F859 85 >?56 > ?B71=J2? <614 26 2C23;? 2= 2427;?2986012::;<1=02=J8=52331=601D8:68B98?4G860 25 85615685 6 :BB86 <1E;24 2:6 25= 01 02< :BB8661= 299?2D261=31516?268D1<1E;242<<2;46501? 3?D1608<:5615685601D8:68B8<1E2B851= 2< %! 08< G8651<< 71859 :084= 291= >8D1 F12?< 02< =13<1= 71>?1 601 ;?6 85 2 B2551? <626859 6026 <01 G2<<;7C1:61=6<1E;242:6 I % 8<60185>?B256G08<601B601?>601 D8:68B98?401<6261<602601?=2;9061?G2<B8<<859>?B 601 0;<1 25= <01 G2< >;5= G113859 G0841 :B859 ;6 >?B 601 <01= > 601 2::;<1= 5 15L;8?F <01 <6261= - 7 - 6026<01G2<<;7C1:61=6<1E;242:67F6012::;<1=01 =13<1= 27;6 >84859 > 601 :B342856 25= <;7C1:6859 601 D8:68B 98?4 >? B1=8:24 1E2B852685 08< G8651<< G2< :?<<1E2B851=264159607;656085902<7115148:861=6 =8<71481D101?D1?<85 !' % 25=%+2?1601 <8<61?<> % 01F 02D1 24< <;33?61= 601 :2<1 > 601 3?<1:;685 85:1 601D8:68B8<291=>8D1F12?<6011D8=15:1>%!H601 :6?G01E2B851=601D8:68B98?4342F<258B3?6256 ?4185=13?1:826859601B261?824<5?1:?= 08<G8651<< <6261< 6026 601 D8:68B 98?4 G2< 3?=;:1= 71>?1 01? 5 !' ' !G86060108<6?F><1E;242<<2;46:BB8661= 5 01? 5 !+' ' ! 01 1E2B851= 601 D8:68B 98?4 25= 8<<;1= :1?68>8:261 2< 31? E! ?1:18D1= ( ?13?6 2< 31? E!I25=92D101?>8524385852<31? E ' 08< G8651<< G2< 24< <;7C1:61= 6 :?<<1E2B852685 7F 601 412?51= :;5<14 >? 601 2::;<1= 7;6 560859 02< 7115 148:861=6=8<71481D101?D1?<85 - 8 - !! E! 8< 601 B1=8:24 ?13?6 27;6 <1E;24 D8415:1 7;6 5 38585 G2< 1E3?1<<1= 7F 601 1=8:24 >>8:1? 68<<6261=6026<;3341B1562?F?13?6G844>44G 2>61? ?1:18D859 601 85D1<6892685 ?13?6 6 8< 24< >;5= 6026 601 >8524 38585 G2< J136 315=859 >? ( ?13?6 E!I8<601(?13?6::?=8596G08:05<1B8524 <6285<?<31?B26K2G1?1=161:61=8525F>6012?68:41< 6026G1?1<156>?1E2B852685 E '8<601>852438585 98D157F%!66011>>1:66026601?18<51D8=15:1> ?1:156<1E;242:6:BB8661=5601D8:68B98?4 >26244601 2::;<1= 02< :BB8661= 299?2D261= 31516?268D1 <1E;24 2<<2;465601D8:68B291=F12?<=1>858614F%!G;4= 02D1 >;5= <895< > ?1:156 <1E;24 2:6 6 8< 31?685156 6 561 6026 601 85:8=156 02= ::;??1= 5 !+' ' ! 25= 601 D8:68B G2< <;7C1:61= 6 1E2B852685 5 !' ' ! D15 6015 601?1 8< <31:8>8: 38585 1E3?1<<1= 7F 601 1=8:24>>8:1?6026601?1G2<51D8=15:1>?1:156<1E;24 2<<2;46 5=1? <;:0 :8?:;B<625:1< 2B > 601 38585 60266013?<1:;6858<56<;::1<<>;4853?D8596019;846 - 9 - >6012::;<1=18601?>?1:685*/#$> ?1:685< +25=/>601:6 ! 531?;<24>601B261?824<5?1:?=85:4;=859 601 1D8=15:1 > 601 D8:68B %! 601 B1=8:24 ?13?6 E! 25= 601 1D8=15:1 > %! 2B > 601 38585 6026 601 3?<1:;685 8< <;::1<<>;4 85 3?D859 601 9;846 > 601 2::;<1= >? 601 >>15:1 ;5=1? 1:685 * 3;58<02741 ;5=1?1:685>601:6 ! 68<601:5615685>6013?<1:;6856026601 2::;<1= 02< :BB8661= 601 >>15:1 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685 //#$ > G08:0 ?1>1?< 6 3?:;?2685 > 601 B85?98?47F85=;:85901?G8602585615685?J5G41=91 6026 <01 G844 71 >?:1= 6 8448:86 8561?:;?<1 G860 25601? 31?<5 01 <28= 3?D8<85 :2556 71 266?2:61= 85 601 3?1<156:2<1 01?1>?16013?<1:;6858<56<;::1<<>;4 85 3?D859 601 9;846 > 601 2::;<1= >? 601 >>15:1 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685 //#$ > 01 2::;<1= 8< - 10 - 482741 >? :5D8:685 54F ;5=1? 1:685 > 601 :6 !+ 02D195160?;906018B3;951=C;=9B156> :5D8:68525=?=1?><15615:132<<1=7F601 ?824;?6 6 02< 3?:11=1= 6 :5D8:6 601 2::;<1= >? 601 >>15:1< 3;58<02741;5=1?1:685/>601:625=1:685 //#$ > 25= <15615:1=08B 2< <6261= 27D1 = 56 >85= 25F C;<68>8:2685 >? 601 ?824 ;?6 6 32<< 601 C;=9B156>:5D8:685>?6012>?1<28=>>15:1<895?859 601B1=8:24 1D8=15:1 > %! 25==:;B156< E<! !I 25= ' 01?1>?1 2B > 601 38585 6026 601 8B3;951= C;=9B156 > :5D8:685 >? 601 >>15:1< 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685< // > 25= 1:685 / > :6 8< 482741 6 71 <16 2<8=1 7;6 601 2::;<1= 8< 482741 >? :5D8:685 >? 601 >>15:1 ;5=1? 1:685 * 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685 > 601 :6 ::?=8594F 25<G1? 601 27D1 3856 @32?64F 85 601 2>>8?B268D1A25=3?:11=632<<601>44G859 - 11 - #8$ 012331248< #88$ 018B3;951=C;=9B156>:5D8:685=261= ' ' 25= ?=1? > <15615:1 =261= ' ' 32<<1= 7F 601 ==868524 8<6?8:6 25= 1<<85< &;=91 25= ( #$2427;?2988<01?17F #888$ ::;<1= 8< :5D8:61= >? 601 >>15:1 ;5=1? 1:685 * 3;58<02741 ;5=1? 1:685 > 601:6 #8D$ 1 8< <15615:1= 6 ;5=1?9 ?89?;< 8B3?8<5B156>?231?8=>>;?F12?<25= 8< 482741 6 32F 2 >851 > < ''' M;311< G156F (8D1 0;<25= 54FN 85 =1>2;46>32FB156>>85101<0244;5=1?9 >;?601? 8B3?8<5B156 >? 2 31?8= > 51 F12? #D$ 01 2::;<1= 8< 1568641= >? <16 >> >? 601 31?8=G08:00102<24?12=F;5=1?951 #D8$ 01 ?=1? ?192?=859 :B315<2685 6 601 D8:68B98?48<<;<62851= - 12 - #D88$ 198<6?F 6 <15= 72:J 601 ?824 ;?6 ?1:?=< 2459 G860 :3F > 608< C;=9B156 >?85>?B268525=511=>;42:685 !,* '$$) % % 8<6!4 I