- 1 - !!" !#" $ %"&"%% %'" ()(*+, ( ""++ - ! " # ! $ $$ % ! % # % " $ &' ( ) $ !)& $ **&# ( " % " '*** " % ** ( %$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % )** " %$ % *&* $ $$ *'&&' &)! # $ $ %" % $ $ ( % % + %%% ! ! + %%% # ,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 6-037 5,- 899:1-; 03 2*&* 23 5,- <0=- 2< 5,- =-8.3-; -302. 0/0= :;7- 83; %$ :>3868; !<2. 1,2.5 ?.08= 2:.5@# 01 0>4:73037 5,- A:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39-;85-;)**923/0950375,-899:1-;<2.5,- 2<<-39-1 4:301,86=- :3;-. -950231 *' &&' 83; &)! # 2<5,-3;083 -38=2;-B!<2.1,2.5? @#83;:3;-. -95023 2< 5,- 3;083 %252. "-,09=-1 95 !<2. 1,2.5 ?%" 95@# 83; 1-35-39037 52 48C <03- 2< 1 <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 *' 2< D 52 48C <03- 2< 1 <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023&&'2< D52:3;-.7210>4=-0>4.0123>-35<2.8 - 3 - 4-.02; 2< 10E >235,1 <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 &) 2< D 83;52 48C <03-2< 1 <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 2< %" 95 F05, ;-<8:=51-35-39-1F,09, F81>2;0<0-;03.0>038= 44-8= 2**4811-;6C5,-=-8.3-; ;;050238=015.095 83; -110231 :;7- 0;8. 1055037 85 818/8G8=C83 !<2. 1,2.5 ?$0.15 44-==85- 2:.5@# /0;- A:;7>-35 ;85-; '*** * ,- <8951 2< 5,- 981- 03 6.0-< 8.- 5,85 23 *** 5,- 899:1-; 180; 52 6- 5,- .0;-. 2< 5,- >252.9C9=- 6-8.037 .-7015.85023 2 &*B ,8; .0;;-35,-18>-038.81,83;3-7=07-35>833-.128152 -3;837-.,:>83=0<-83;;81,-;87803155,-;-9-81-;81 8 .-1:=5 2< F,09, ,- 1:15803-; <858= 03A:.0-1 83; 1:61-H:-35=C1:99:>6-;525,-18>-,-899:1-;6-037 5,- .0;-. 2< 5,- >252.9C9=- F81 325 ,8/037 /8=0; ;.0/037 =09-39- 52 .0;- 5,- 18>- 32. F81 ,- ,8/037 031:.839- 92/-.87-525,->252.9C9=-83;5,-.-6C,-,8192>>055-; 5,-862/-180;2<<-39-1 - 4 - & 30508==C (I5,-1232<5,-;-9-81-;=2;7-; 5,-<0.1503<2.>85023814-.E ,-$814-.E 98>-526-.-7015-.-;3/-150785023F81:3;-.58G-383; 8<5-.92>4=-50375,-03/-150785023<038=.-42.598>-526- <0=-; ,- =-8.3-; %87015.85- 522G 92730J839- 2< 5,- 2<<-39-183;.-7015-.-;5,-9.0>038=981-,-899:1-;,8; 844-8.-; 6-<2.- 5,- .08= 2:.5 4=-8;-; 325 7:0=5C 83; 9=80>-; 52 6- 5.0-; ,- 4.21-9:5023 -E8>03-; ( 52 ( 83; 725 >8.G-; E1 52 03 1:442.5 2< 051 9235-35023 ,- 899:1-; ,81 ;-30-; 8== 5,- 039.0>0385037 >85-.08=18/80=86=-23.-92.;6:5,81325=-;83C-/0;-39- 031:442.52<,01;-<-39- ) ,- .08= 2:.5 8<5-. 58G037 0352 92310;-.85023 8==5,-1->85-.08=123.-92.;98>-525,-9239=:10235,85 5,- 4.21-9:5023 01 1:99-11<:= 03 4.2/037 5,- 7:0=5 2< 5,- 899:1-;6-C23;.-812386=-;2:6583;8992.;037=C4811-; 5,- 0>4:73-; A:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- -037877.0-/-;6C5,-18>-5,-899:1-;,8; 4.-<-..-; .0>038= 44-8= 2** ,- $0.15 - 5 - 44-==85- 2:.5 23 .-844.-9085023 2< 5,- >85-.08=1 23 .-92.;8==2F-;5,-844-8=0348.56C>2;0<C0375,-2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- 4811-; 6C 5,- .08= 2:.5 0312<8. 81 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-.-95023&) 2< 83; 1-35-39-;5,- 899:1-; 52 :3;-.72 10>4=- 0>4.0123>-35 <2. 8 4-.02; 2< 5,.-- >235,1 0315-8; 2< 10E >235,1 83; 2.;-.-; 6C 5,- .08= 2:.5 -037 877.0-/-; 6C 5,- 18>- 5,- 899:1-; ,814.-<-..-;5,01.-/010234-505023 -8.; .0 ,8781,-550 =-8.3-; 92:31-=<2. 5,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 83; .0 8>8;8. ,8,86:;;03 =-8.3-; 07,2:.52/-.3>-35 =-8;-.<2.5,-.-1423;-35 585- -.:1-;5,->85-.08=123.-92.; B 3 /0-F 2< 5,- .0/8= 1:6>0110231 >8;- 6C 5,- =-8.3-;92:31-=<2.625,5,-48.50-15,-420355,85F2:=; 8.01-<2.>C92310;-.8502301 - 6 - %C 831F-. 52 5,- 862/- 42035 01 <2.5,-<2==2F037 "" ' 5015,-9235-350232<5,-4.21-9:50235,855,- 899:1-; F81 .0;037 5,- >252.9C9=- 6-8.037 .-7015.85023 2 &*B235,-;85-2<5,-8990;-3583;,-,8; .0;;-35,-18>-038.81,83;3-7=07-35>833-.128152 -3;837-. ,:>83 =0<- 83; ;81,-; 8780315 5,- ;-9-81-; F,2F814.29--;0376C5,-10;-2<5,-.28; 18.-1:=5 ,- 1:15803-; <858= 03A:.0-1 83; =85-. ;0-; F,0=- 6-037 1,0<5-;525,-,214058= (&01180;526-5,--C-F053-11 52 5,- 8990;-35 03 H:-15023 - 03<2.>-; 5,- <8952< 5,- 8990;-3583;5,855,-03A:.-;6-0371,0<5-;525,-,214058= 52 ( F,2 01 5,-1232< ;-9-81-; 681-; :423 F,09, (,81=2;7-;5,-<0.1503<2.>85023814-.E 5 01 4-.503-35 52 325- 5,85 5,- 8990;-35 ,8; 299:..-;23***85862:5&4>,-$F81 <0=-; 0>>-;085-=C 85 B& 4> 3 5,- <0.15 03<2.>85023 - 7 - 051-=< 5,- 03<2.>835 ,81 .-<-..-; 52 5,- 38>- 2< (& 6-037 5,- -C-F053-11 F,2 03<2.>-; ,0> 862:5 5,- 8990;-35 ,- 38>- 2< 5,- 899:1-; 81 5,- .0;-. 2< 5,- 2<<-3;037 >252.9C9=- 01 8=12 >-35023-; 03 5,- $ ,- $F81<0=-;F05,035,.--,2:.12<5,-8990;-35 (&6-0375,--C-F053-11,81<:==C1:442.5-; 5,-981-2<5,-4.21-9:5023/-35,2:7,5,-F053-11F81 9.211-E8>03-; 85 =-375, 325,037 ,81 6--3 -=0905-; 52 ;016-=0-/-,01/-.1023 (,8192..262.85-;5,-18C2< (&6C15850375,85,-F8103<2.>-;6C (&.-78.;037 5,- 8990;-35 83; 681-; :423 F,09, ,- <0=-; 5,- <0.15 03<2.>850235014-.503-3552325-5,85 (015,-2F3-. 2< 5,- 2<<-3;037 >252.9C9=- 83; 5,- 6.25,-. 2< 5,- 899:1-; - 985-72.098==C 1585-1 5,85 81 23 5,- ;85- 2< 5,- 8990;-35 5,- 2<<-3;037 >252.9C9=- F81 58G-3 6C 5,- 899:1-;F,09,F811:61-H:-35=C1-0J-;6C5,-42=09- () 01 180; 52 6- 5,- 40==023 .0;-. 2< 5,- >252.9C9=-35,-8990;-35,-,8;8=121:15803-;03A:.0-1 83;5,-F2:3;9-.50<0985-4-.580303752,0>014.2;:9-;81 - 8 - 4-. E & ,01 F053-11 ,81 325 1:442.5-; 5,- 981- 2< 5,-4.21-9:5023<2.5,-.-812316-15G32F352,0> :5 5,-.-018612=:5-=C32-E4=8385023811073-;6C,0>525,- F2:3; 9-.50<0985- I E & 8992.;037 52 F,09, () ,8; 1:15803-;10>4=-03A:.0-10-86.810231035,-.28;5.8<<09 8990;-35 E )015,-F2:3;9-.50<0985-4-.5803037525,- 899:1-; 992.;03752F,09,-/-3,-,811:15803-;5,.-- 03A:.0-1 0- 86.810231 83; 23- =89-.85-; F2:3; 03 5,- .28;5.8<<098990;-355,85299:..-;23***85&& 4> ,- 899:1-; 83; () ,8/- 325 2<<-.-; 83C -E4=8385023-05,-.52E1 &2.52E ) * $.2>8==5,-1->85-.08=123.-92.;8>2<5,- 2403023 5,85 5,- 4.21-9:5023 01 1:99-11<:= 03 4.2/037 5,- 7:0=5 2< 5,- 899:1-; <2. 5,- 2<<-39-1 4:301,86=- :3;-. -950231*'&&'83;&) 2< 83;:3;-.-95023 2< %" 95 5 01 1585-; 5,85 899:1-; F81 325 ,2=;037 8 /8=0; =09-39- 52 .0;- 5,- 2<<-3;037 >252.9C9=- 83; 32 ;29:>-351 8.- 4.2;:9-; 6-<2.- 5,- 3/-150785037 <<09-. - 9 - 2. 6-<2.- 5,01 2:.5 3;-. 1:9, 90.9:>15839-1 5,- 899:1-;01=086=-<2.923/095023 & ,8/-723-5,.2:7,5,-0>4:73-;A:;7>-352< 923/09502383;2.;-.2<1-35-39-4811-;6C5,-.08=2:.5 83; 5,- $0.15 44-==85- 2:.5 25, 5,- 2:.51 ,8/- 4.24-.=C844.-9085-;5,->85-.08=23.-92.;83;923/095-; 5,- 899:1-; <2. 5,- 862/- 180; 2<<-39-1 2F-/-. 5,-C ,8/-92>>055-;-..2. 03 1-35-390375,-899:1-; 625, <2. 5,- 2<<-39-1 4:301,86=- :3;-. -950231 *' 83; &) 2< /-35,2:7,5,-4.21-9:5023011:99-11<:=034.2/037 5,85 5,- 899:1-; F81 .81,83; 3-7=07-35 F,0=- .0;037 5,- >252.9C9=-F,09,.-1:=5-;035,-03A:.0-152 ()83;5,- ;-85, 2< 5,- ;-9-81-; 03 /0-F 2< 5,- ;-901023 2< 5,- 23@6=- 4-E 2:.5 03 -95023 *' 2< >-.7-1 F05, -95023 &) 2< -39- 5,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 01 =086=- <2. 1-35-39- 23=C <2. 5,- 2<<-39-1 4:301,86=- :3;-. -950231 &&' 83; &) 2< 1 (2012) 8 SCC 734 - 10 - 83; :3;-. -95023 2< %" 95 039- 5,- .81, 83; 3-7=07-35 895 2< 5,- 899:1-; .-1:=5-; 03 98:1037 10>4=- 03A:.0-1 52 () 83; 5,- ;-85,2< ;-9-81-; 5,- 2.;-.2< 1-35-39- 4811-; 8780315 5,- 899:1-; <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 *' 2< 01 =086=- 52 6- 1-5 810;- ) 992.;037=C831F-.5,-862/-42035 83;4.29--;5248115,-<2==2F037 0# .0>038=.-/010234-50502301 ! 00# ,- A:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 ;85-; )** 4811-; 03 2*&* 23 5,- <0=- 2< =-8.3-;-302.0/0=:;7-83;%$ :>3868; 83; 5,- A:;7>-35 ;85-; '*** 4811-; 03 .0>038= 44-8= 2** 23 5,- <0=- 2< =-8.3-; ;;050238= 015.095 83; -110231 :;7- 0;8. 1055037 85 818/8G8=C83 <2. 5,- 2<<-39-1 4:301,86=- :3;-. -950231 *' &&' - 11 - 83; &) 2< 83; :3;-. -95023 2< %" 9501,-.-6C923<0.>-; 000# ,- 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- <2. 5,- 2<<-39-1 :3;-. -950231 &&' 83; &) 2< 83; :3;-. -950232<5,-%" 95018=12923<0.>-; 0/# 2F-/-. 5,- 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- 4811-; 6C 5,- .08= 2:.5 <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023*'2< 01,-.-6C1-5810;- /# ,- <03- 8>2:35 0< 83C ;-42105-; 6C 5,- 899:1-;4-505023-. <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 *' 2< 01 2.;-.-; 52 6- .-<:3;-;52,0>:3;-.;:-0;-350<0985023 -7015.C 01 ;0.-95-; 52 1-3; 689G 5,- .08= 2:.5 .-92.;1 8=237 F05, 5,- 924C 2< 5,01 A:;7>-35 <2. 03<2.>8502383;3--;<:=895023 "., (%%+ &! 0152=2*