- 1 - ! " #$ %#&!#!# '!(#) ! ! " # $ % % !&&& ' !&&' ( (% !&&') % Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & %% ! % ) " &&&&&&&& #* %'!+ % %(+ %$ , % ''! % %$ % , % , , , % % -- $ , % %, ' '&' ('&' . ' $ % % - 3 - % , / * ORAL ORDER 012123405526758 952:;<1;50 50=21 33>05712?0 3:20182@A0B3501C2@ 3;51@00D249B3<<3E24950<20B@ ! " #$%&% ' ( # $)$$)*)& $+$$ )*)& ' ' ",#$) - ' # . / ' 012123405 2@ 7 526758 952:;<1;50 50=21 3 3>05712?03:20185092@1050= 24 1056@ 3B1C0>53?2@234@3B 754717D7 33>05712?0 3:20120@ :1 -- #B35 @C351 F1C0 :1 --G$ :34@2@1249 3B 1792 ;97< 71>7<<2 - 4 - C2DD75787D;6>22505787D;6>27@C87<7<D87>;574= C2DD7A;=;5?2<<790@ ( C71 50@>34=041 33:2018 E7@ 40E<8 B3560=C0=2@>;102@:34:0542497>;5>3510=>53:00=249@ 3B 1C0 >0121234053:2018 0H157:1 3B EC2:C E7@ 7<<090=<8 92?04 A8 1C0 C20B H0:;12?0 BB2:05 3B 1C0 >012123405 3:20181350@>34=04133:2018EC2:C2@>53=;:0=71 440H;50 24 EC2:C 1C0 C20B H0:;12?0 BB2:05 3B 1C0 >0121234053:2018C05024C7@>;5>3510=<834A0C7<B3B1C0 375=3B250:135@3B1C0>0121234053:2018C7@92?0443 3AI0:1234 B35 1C0 40E<8 B3560= 3:2018 13 C7?0 21@ 7=6242@15712?0 :34153< 3?05 2505787D;6>2 ?2<<790 EC2:C 3529247<<8 :360@ E21C24 1C0 I;52@=2:1234 3B 1C0 >012123405 3:2018 07540= :3;4@0< B35 1C0 >0121234053:2018 @;A621@1C711C0>53:00=249@71440H;50750B7<@074= B7A52:710= 3 @;:C 50@3<;1234 E7@ 0?05 >7@@0= A8 1C0 375=3B250:135@3B1C0>0121234053:2018C71A7@0=34 - 5 - 1C0@72=B7<@074=B7A52:710=0H157:13B1C050@3<;12341C0 50@>34=041;1C352120@ C7?0 >53:00=0= 13 5092@105 50@>34=041 33:2018 7<<3E249 13 C7?0 @72= 2505787D;6>2?2<<790E21C2421@I;52@=2:1234 0 B;51C05 @;A621@ 1C71 1C0 50@>34=041 ;1C352120@C7?0431B3<<3E0=1C0>53?2@234@3B;<0(3B 1C0 754717D7 33>05712?0 3:20120@ ;<0@ EC2:C >53?2=0@B357>53:00=24913A0:34=;:10=241C00?0413B 3?05<7>>2493B1C0I;52@=2:1234 ! 4@;>>3513BC2@:341041234C050<20@;>341C0 35=05 3B 1C0 335=24710 04:C 3B 1C2@ 3;51 =710= >7@@0=24 74= :3440:10= 671105@ 50B055249 13 >757957>C 3 3B 1C0 @72=35=05C0@;A621@1C7121E7@24:;6A041;>341C0>751 3B 1C0 50@>34=041;1C352120@ 13 C7?0 2@@;0= 4312:0 74= :34=;:10= 74 04J;258 A0B350 7::35=249 >0562@@234 13 5092@105 50@>34=041 33:2018 0 B;51C05 @;A621@ 7 50>50@04171234 92?04 A8 1C0 >0121234053:2018 24 1C2@ - 6 - 50975= 13 1C0 50@>34=041 3! 7@ >05 440H;50 @0520@ C7@431A004:34@2=050= ) 07540= :3;4@0< B35 1C0 >0121234053:2018 71 1C2@I;4:1;50 @;A621@ 1C710?042B @;:C 04=35@06041 E7@ 2@@;0= EC2:C 2@ @;A@0J;041 13 B2<249 3B E521 >0121234 C0 C7@ 43 0BB0:12?0 5060=8 247@6;:C 7@ 1C0 @72= 04=35@060412@>;5>3510=<82@@;0=A81C0092@1575A0B350 EC361C07>>07<2@:34106><710=0?0C06041<8@;A621@ 1C71 1C0 >0121234053:2018 C7@ 43 7<105712?0 0BB2:7:23;@ 5060=8247@6;:C7@>53:0=;50:34106><710=;4=05;<0( C7@ 431 A004 B3<<3E0= 0 @;A621@ 24 1056@ 3B 1C0 35=05 >7@@0=A81C0 335=2471004:C3B1C2@ 3;5150B0550=13 7A3?01C0E521>0121234A0=2@>3@0=3B3460521@ 07540= ==212347< 3?0546041 =?3:710 ;>34 @0:;5249 1C0 50:35=@ @;A621@ 1C71 4312:0@ >5235 13 5092@1571234 3B 50@>34=041 33:2018 E050 24=00= 2@@;0= 13 1C0 >0121234053:2018 7@ B75 A7:D 7@ 24 1C0 6341C 3B 75:C '&' 13 1C0 606A05@ 7@ E0<< 7@ C20B - 7 - H0:;12?0 BB2:05 3B 1C0 >0121234053:2018 0 @;A621@ 34<8 ;>34 @0:;5249 1C0 43 3AI0:1234 B536 1C0 >012123405 3:2018 1C0 5092@1571234 3B 50@>34=041 33:2018 E7@ >53:00=0= E21C 7@ @;:C 1C050 2@ 43 05535 74= 2<<097<218 :3662110= A8 1C0 50@>34=041;1C352120@ 0 B;51C05 @;A621@7@50975=@1C050>50@0417123467=071440H;50 74 04=35@06041 C7@ 7<507=8 A004 2@@;0= 34 -'&' 50<0971249 1C0 >0121234053:2018 13 C7?0 50:3;5@0 ;4=05 0:1234 &! 3B 1C0 :1 -- 2B 1C08 750 799520?0=A81C05092@15712343B50@>34=04133:2018 - 07540= 3;4@0< B35 50@>34=041 33:2018 34 1C0 31C05 C74= @;A621@ 1C71 1C0 =2@>;10= =3:;6041 A0249 440H;50 2@@;0= A8 1C0 ?058 C20B H0:;12?0 BB2:05 3B 33>05712?0 3:2018 2@ 7 =2@>;10= J;0@1234 3B B7:1 EC2:C 400=@ 13 A0 9340 2413 34<8 24 7 >53>05<8 :34@121;10= 7>>07< >53?2=249 3>>351;4218 B35 1C0 50@>34=04133:2018 & 075=05;@0=1C050:35=@ - 8 - C0=2@>;102@E21C50975=1324:<;@2343B?2<<790 2505787D;6>2 ?2<<790 E21C24 1C0 7507 3B 3>05712?0I;52@=2:1234 3B 50@>34=041 33:2018 EC2:C E7@3529247<<8E21C241C075073B>0121234053:2018C050 2@ 7 @0523;@ =2@>;10 E21C 50975= 13 0H157:1 3B 50@3<;1234 >53=;:0= 71 440H;50 24 1056@ 3B EC2:C >012123405 3:2018C7@7<<090=<892?04:34@041C0@72==3:;60412@ @0523;@<8 =2@>;10= A8 1C0 >0121234053:2018 50>50@04171234 92?04 A8 1C0 >012123405 C7@ 7<507=8 A004 50@>34=0= 50<0971249 1C0 >0121234053:2018 13 >50B05 74 7>>07< @@;0 24?3<?0= 2@ 3B =2@>;10= J;0@1234 3B B7:1 50975=249 7;1C0412:218 3B 440H;50 EC2:C :74431 A0 93402413241C2@E521>0121234 ' 24:0 1C0 04=35@06041 2@ 7<507=8 2@@;0= >;5@;741 13 1C0 50>50@04171234 92?04 A8 1C0 >012123405 >012123405 2@ 71 <2A0518 13 @00D 5060=8 7@ :34106><710= ;4=050:1234&!3B1C0:1-- - 9 - ( ,21C 1C0 7A3?0 E521 0121234 2@ 0<0971249 1C0 >0121234053:2018 13 C7?0 50:3;5@0 ;4=05 0:1234 &! 3B 1C0 >53?2@234@ 3B 1C0 754717D7 3 3>05712?03:20120@:12B@37=?2@0=26>;942491C035=05 >7@@0= A8 1C0 50@>34=041 3!092@1575 5092@105249 50@>34=04133:20187@E0<<7@1C004=35@0604143E 2@@;0= 24 B;51C0574:0 13 1C0 50>50@04171234 92?04 71 440H;50@0520@ B@;:C7>>07<2@B2<0=A81C0>0121234053:2018 1C0@760@C7<<A0=2@>3@0=3B7@0H>0=2123;@<87@>3@@2A<0 7B105 7BB35=249 3>>351;4218 13 A31C 1C0 >75120@ E21C24 74 3;105<26213B@2H6341C@B5361C0=7103B50:02>13B7:3>8 3B1C2@35=05 !*( '#!#) & SDU LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 34;CT:PK