- 1 - !! ""#""$%! ! &! #'#(##" # #(( )%* !+ ! " " # $ %&'%(&' %(")' * "$ + %(")" $*, *)-*)* " ! $ $ ".& "! $ $ # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )')-*)". # $ "--*)" $ # /# '" 01 2345678 97::1; 7 <=>>=6 ?5;@>16A 36 =:"--*)" 76; *))*)" 03: 799178 3: B381; 7@736:A A01?5;@>16A76;7C72;;7A1;)')-*)".97::1;4DA01 ;;3A3=678 3:A23<A #5;@1 76; 73<052 36 ="--=B*)" * 01B7<A:=BA01<7:1721A07A =6*")-*)"& C0381 A01 <873>76A 78=6@ C3A0 =A012 E3887@12: C121 92=<11;36@ 36 76 75A= B2=> 127@127 A= 7:41 7>9 B=2 <==831C=2F A01;23E12=BA0127<A=2417236@21@3:A27A3=6 =%&'%(&' 7AA7<01; C3A0 A2=881D ;23E16 3A 36 03@0 :911;76;27:076;61@83@16A>7661276;;7:01;A=A01 75A= ;51 A= C03<0 <873>76A B188 ;=C6 76; :5:A7361; @231E=5: 36?5231: 0121B=21 01 B381; 7 <873> 91A3A3=6 - 3 - 41B=21 A01 2345678 <873>36@ <=>916:7A3=6 =B :"( ) )))% & 012345678 <=6:3;1236@A0116A3211E3;16<1=6 21<=2; @276A1; <=>916:7A3=6 =B :& )% C3A0 36A121:A7A'G97B2=>A01;7A1=B91A3A3=6A38821783:7A3=6 76; ;321<A1; 21:9=6;16A =*%6:5276<1 =>976D A= ;19=:3AA01:7>1 @@231E1;4DA01:73;?5;@>16A76;7C72; A01 36?521; <873>76A 07: 921B1221; A03: 799178 36 C03<0 3A 3: <=6A16;1;A07A 01C7:;=36@7@23<58A527876;<==831C=2F 76;172636@:") )))%912>=6A0 45AA0123456781221; 36A7F36@03:36<=>17A: )))%912>=6A0,A01=<A=2 07:7::1::1;A01;3:74383AD7A')GA=A01C0=814=;D 45A A01234567807:A7F16A01;3:74383AD=68D7A*G,01:916A :* )) )))% B=2 03: A217A>16A 45A A01 81::12 7>=56A C7: @276A1; 56;12 A01 017; H>1;3<78 1I916:1:J, A01 7>=56A 7C72;1; 56;12 =A012 017;: 3: >17@21 76; 6= 7>=56A C7: @276A1; B=2 1I916:1: A=C72;: 72A3B3<378 83>4 - 4 - 76; 8=:: =B 36<=>1 ;5236@ 873; 59 9123=; 0121B=21 21K51:A1;B=216076<1>16A=BA01<=>916:7A3=6 172;A0172@5>16A:=B4=A0:3;1: ' 0=5@0 A01 79918876A <=6A16;1; A07A 01 C7: ;=36@<==831C=2F76;172636@:") )))%912>=6A0 01 07:6=AB381;76D36<=>192==B 16<1 7:01>1AC3A076 7<<3;16A 36 A01 D172 *)"& 7: 912 A01 @53;18361: =B A01 7267A7F7 A7A1 1@78 12E3<1: 5A0=23AD 03: 6=A3=678 36<=>13:A=41A7F167A:. )))%912>=6A0 . :3A3:7<7:1=B7>95A7A3=6 7:912A01<3A7A3=6 =B A01 =6J481 91I =52A 36 A01 ;3<A5> =B ")G =B A01 36<=>1 3: A= 41 7;;1; A=C72;: B5A521 92=:91<A: 05: 03: >=6A08D 36<=>1 <=>1: A= :. .))% . ))) L ")G! ( 01;=<A=27::1::1;A01;3:74383AD7A')GA3: 7<7:1=B7>95A7A3=6=B23@0A81@418=CF611=6:3;1236@ 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 5 - A01 67A521 =B 36?52D 76; A01 =<<597A3=6 =B A01 79918876A A03:=52AB36;:3A217:=67481A=A7F1A01;3:74383AD7:')G - =6:3;1236@ A01 7@1 =B A01 79918876A 7: ) D172: A01>58A398312=B"&7;=9A1;4DA0123456783:?5:A 76;92=912 ") 05: A01 8=:: =B B5A521 172636@: <=>1: A= :. .))I"*I"&I')GM:. *) .*)% "" 01 2345678 07: @276A1; 76 7>=56A =B :&" )% A=C72;: >1;3<78 1I916:1: 76; 3A 611;: 6= 36A12B1216<1 "* =6:3;1236@ A01 67A521 =B 36?5231: A03: =52A B36;:3A217:=67481A=@276A767>=56A=B:" )) )))%B=2 9736 76; :5BB1236@ :&) )))% B=2 8=:: =B 7>163A31: 76; :) )))% B=2 A276:9=2A7A3=6 1IA27 6=523:0>16A 76; 7AA16;76A<072@1: "& 01 79918876A >3@0A 6=A 07E1 7AA16;1; 76D C=2F7A817:AB=279123=;=B:3I>=6A0:;51A=A0136?5231: :5:A7361;36A017<<3;16A0121B=21 013:16A3A81;B=276 - 6 - 7>=56A =B :* )))% :. ))) I '! B=2 8=:: =B 36<=>1 ;5236@873;599123=; " 1 3: 78:= 16A3A81; B=2 76 7>=56A =B :* )) )))%B=2B3I7A3=6=B72A3B3<37883>4 " 16<1 A0179918876A3:16A3A81;B=2A01>=;3B31; <=>916:7A3=656;12;3BB1216A017;:7:418=C 73676;:5BB1236@ :" )) )))% 1;3<781I916:1: :&" )% =::=BB5A521172636@: :. *) .*) 276:9=2A7A3=6 1IA27 6=523:0>16A 76;7AA16;76A<072@1: :&) )))% =::=B36<=>1;5236@873;599123=; :* )))% =::=B7>163A31: :) )))% 2A3B3<37883>4 :* )) )))% =A78 1::7C72;1;4D2345678 6076<1>16A :"" . ".)% :& )% , % 05: A01 79918876A 3: 16A3A81; B=2 16076<1; <=>916:7A3=6 =B :( *( .*)% C3A0 36A121:A 7A 'G 912 7665>76;A0121B=21 A01799178;1:12E1:A=41788=C1;36 972A "' 6A0121:58A A01B=88=C36@=2;123:97::1; - 7 - 3! 991783:788=C1;36972A 33! 01 79918876A<873>76A 3: 16A3A81; B=2 A01 16076<1; <=>916:7A3=6 =B :( *( .*)% C3A0 36A121:A 7A 'G 912 7665> B2=> A01 ;7A1 =B 91A3A3=6 A388 A01 ;7A1 =B 21783N7A3=6 =C1E12 7: 912 A01 =2;12: =6 "*)* ;7A1; *)-*)* 76; **)* ;7A1; )&""*)* A01 79918876A3:6=A16A3A81;B=236A121:AB=2A01;187D1;9123=; =B"-*;7D:36B3836@A0179917876;3621<78879983<7A3=6 21:91<A3E18D 333! 1:9=6;16A =*%6:5276<1 =>976D 3: ;321<A1; A= ;19=:3A A01 7B=21:73; <=>916:7A3=6 7>=56A C3A036=61>=6A0B2=>A01;7A1=BA03:?5;@>16A 3E! 6 :5<0 ;19=:3A A01 79918876A 3: 912>3AA1; A= C3A0;27C A01 16A321 7>=56A 78=6@ C3A0 36A121:A 7<<251; =63A ,-. )(##"* '" 3:A="8="&