- 1 - !!"!#! $ % "&"'""! ""'' ()* ""'' ()* !"#"$ % &' $' ( ! "$ ' $ ' ' ""!$ )$ ' ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"#"$ % & $ )* " ( $"&"( ' ) $#!$)#) ' ' + $$ $")#",$ "$ -, )$ -) ' ' "#"$ $$$ &' $' ( ! "$ $ ' $ ' ' ""!$ )$ ' - 3 - ' !"#"$ $$$ & $ )* " ( $"&"( ' ) $#!$)#) ' ' + $#)#" $ .' $$ &! "$ /010 2330241 250 50130678904: ;840< =: 7/0 6428>2?712@28?177/06A>>A?BC<@>0?72?<2D25<<270< ) $#!$)#)32110<=:7/0<<878A?240?8A58984C<@0 2?< $$$$+8B2:23C52E;A51/A57F58=C?24GH8? A1$")#", 2?< #)#" 100I8?@ 0?/2?60>0?7 A; 6A>30?1278A?$ )$ /0 8?BC50< 6428>2?7 8? A$")#", >07 D87/ 2? 2668<0?7 A? #-$#!$)#" 2?< 1C1728?0< @5809AC1 - 4 - 8?BC5801$?7/012>02668<0?77/01A?A;7/06428>2?718? A$#)#" <80<$/0:;840<6428>307878A?1=0;A50 7/058=C?24100I8?@6A>30?1278A?;5A>7/05013A?<0?71$ /0 58=C?24 2;705 6A?18<058?@ 7/0 0?7850 098<0?60 A? 506A5< 2D25<0< 7/0 6A>30?1278A? A; 1$)### 8? A$#)#" 2?<1$" ##8? A$")#", D87/8?70501727!J3052??C>;5A>7/0<270A;307878A?1 7844 50248K278A? 2?< <850670< 5013A?<0?7 A$) ?1C52?60 A>32?: 7A 32: 7/0 6A>30?1278A?$ @@58090< =: 7/0 12>0 6428>2?71 250 =0;A50 7/81 AC57 8? 7/085 5013067890 2330241100I8?@0?/2?60>0?7A;6A>30?1278A?$ $ 025< 25@C>0?71 A; =A7/ 7/0 3257801 2?< 305C10< 7/0 >27058241 292842=40 A? 506A5< 8? =A7/ 7/0 2330241$ -$ /0>28?6A?70?78A?A;7/02330442?716428>2?71 8?=A7/7/02330241817/277/06A>30?1278A?2D25<0<=: 7/0 58=C?24 818?2<0LC270 2?< 100I1 ;A5 0?/2?60>0?7A; 6A>30?1278A?$ - 5 - $ 025?0< 6AC?104 ;A5 7/0 2330442?7 8? A$)#"! )#)- /21 6A?70?<0< 7/27 2330442?76428>2?7 /21 1C1728?0< 6C7 42605270< DAC?< A905 58@/7 I?00 >021C58?@ M 6> 6C7 42605270< DAC?< A905 ;A5025> >021C58?@M)6>2?<=84270524?2124=A?0;5267C502?< A7/058?BC5801$0D21/A1387248K0<;A5!<2:12?<130?7 >A50 7/2? 1$)##### ;A5 >0<8624 0M30?101$ N A67A5/2117270<7/276428>2?7/211C;;050<C37A"#J7A "J <812=8487: =C7 7/0 58=C?24 /21 ?A7 2D25<0< 2?: 6A>30?1278A? ;A5 4A11 A; ;C7C50 025?8?@ 6232687: 2?< 401105 6A>30?1278A? D21 2D25<0< C?<05 A7/05 /0251$ /050;A50 /0 50LC0170< ;A5 0?/2?60>0?7 A; 6A>30?1278A?$ !$ 025?0<6AC?104;A57/02330442?716428>2?718? A$)#)! )#)- /21 6A?70?<0< 7/27 <060210< D21 7/085 1A? 2@0< " :0251 /240 2?< /0247/: 2?< D21 2 =584482?7 17C<0?7 /298?@ =58@/7 ;C7C50$ /0 6A>30?1278A? 2D25<0< =: 7/0 C?<05 6A?90?78A?24 /02<1 81 >02@50 2>AC?7 2?< 7/C1 50LC0170< ;A5 0?/2?60>0?7 A; - 6 - 6A>30?1278A?D87/,J8?7050178?1702<A;!J2D25<0<=: 7/058=C?24$ ? A$)#"! )#)- $ ? 7/0 2668<0?7 2330442?76428>2?7 /21 1C1728?0<7/0;A44AD8?@8?BC5801 "( A90558@/7I?00M6>* )( A905;A5025>M)6>*2?< ( '84270524?2124=A?0;5267C50$ ?BC5: A1$"2?<) 250 18>340 8?BC58012?< 8?BC5: A$81 @5809AC18?BC5:$?1C33A57A;/8162106428>2?70M2>8?0< 7/0 A67A5 21 D/A 811C0< M$" N 812=8487: 0578;86270 2110118?@ "# 7A "J 7A 7/0 D/A40 =A<:$ 'C7 7/0 58=C?24 /21 ?A7 6A?18<050< 7/0 12>0 ;A5 7/0 5021A? 7/27 /0 /21 ?A7 1C;;050< 2?: ;C?678A?24 <812=8487:$ <>8770<4: 6428>2?7 1C1728?0< ?2124 =A?0 ;5267C50 D87/ >24C?8A? 2?< <0;A5>87: 2?< /0 D21 1C@@0170< 648?8624 6A550678A?2?<3A8?7A;>2M8>C>70?<05?011$A?18<058?@ 7/0 098<0?60 A; A67A5 7/81 AC57 ;8?<1 87 BC17 2?< - 7 - 5021A?2=407A72I0"5<A;"J<812=8487:J7A>007 7/00?<1A;BC17860$ $ /0 6428>2?7 /21 ?A7 35A<C60< 2?: <A6C>0?7 7A35A90/818?6A>0$17/02668<0?781A;7/0:025)#" 21 305 7/0 6/257 3503250< =: 7/0 25?272I2 7270 0@24 0598601 C7/A587: 7/81 AC57 <00>1 87 2335A358270 7A 211011 7/0 8?6A>0 A; 7/0 6428>2?7 27 1$""# 305 >A?7/$77/078>0A;2668<0?77/06428>2?7D212@0< :0251 2?< 2335A358270 >C47834805 2334862=40 7A /81 2@0 @5AC381F"!G$66A5<8?@4:7/06428>2?7810?78740<;A54A11 A;;C7C50025?8?@6232687:21C?<05 1$""#M")M"!MJO1$"") ## ,$ /06428>2?7D212<>8770<8?7/0/A138724;A5! <2:1$A?18<058?@7/03058A<A;/A1387248K278A??27C50A; 8?BC5801 2?< A7/05 504092?7 ;267A51 7/81 AC57 ;8?<1 87 5021A?2=40 7A 0?/2?60 2>AC?7 7A 1$#### ;A5 4A11 A; 2>0?87801$C57/05<C07A8?BC58017/06428>2?7>8@/7?A7 /2902770?<0<2?:DA5I2740217;A523058A<A;>A?7/1 - 8 - /0?607/81AC57;8?<1875021A?2=407A2D25<1$)# ;A5 4A11 A; 8?6A>0 <C58?@ 428< C3 3058A<$ AD0905 7/0 6A>30?1278A? 27 1$#### ;A5 328? 2?< 1C;;058?@1 1$!#### ;A5 >0<8624 0M30?101 2?< 1$#### ;A5 752?13A57278A?0M752?AC581/>0?72?<2770?<2?76/25@01 ?00<1?A8?705;050?60$ "#$ /0 6A>30?1278A? 2D25<0< =: 7/0 58=C?24 81 >A<8;80<21C?<05 4$ A$ 02<1 D25<=:7/0 58=C?24 D25<=:7/81 AC57 " 28? 2?< 1C;;058?@ 1$#### 1$#### ) 0<8624 M30?101 1$!#### 1$!#### A11 A; ;C7C50 025?8?@6232687: 1$"") ## - 52?13A57278A? 0M752 ?AC581/>0?7 2?< 2770?<2?7 6/25@01 1$#### 1$#### - 9 - A11 A; 2>0?87801 1$)#### 1$#### ! A11 A; 8?6A>0 <C58?@ 428< C3 3058A< 1$)## 1$)# A724 1$" ## 1$" ## /050D844=00?/2?60>0?7A;1$"-# ? A$)#)! )#)- ""$ 025?0< 6AC?104 ;A5 7/0 2330442?716428>2?71 504:8?@ C3A? 7/0 <06818A? A; 7/81 AC57 8? A$"#))! )#",8?7/06210A; <813A10< A; A? D/0508? 7/0 ?A78A?24 8?6A>0 A; 7/0 >8?A5 <060210< D21 72I0? 21 305 7/0 @C8<048?01 811C0< =: 7/0 25?272I2 7270 0@24 0598601 C7/A587: 2?< 241A ;C7C50 35A130671 D21 7A =0 2<<0<$?7/08?172?76210217/02668<0?781A;7/0:025 )#" 213057/0@C8<048?01811C0<=:7/025?272I27270 0@24 0598601 C7/A587: 7/81 AC57 <00>1 87 2335A358270 7A6A?18<057/08?6A>0A;7/0<060210<271$""#305 >A?7/$?980DA;358?68324A;42D428<<AD?=:7/030M - 10 - AC57 8? 7/0 6210 A; ! -#J;C7C5035A130671817A=0 2<<0<$ 66A5<8?@4: -#J A; 1$""# 6A>01 7A 1$-## 2?< 7A724 8?6A>0 A; 7/0 <060210< 6A>01 7A 1$"!-#$ C7A;7/81#JA;7/812>AC?781<0<C670< 7AD25<17/03051A?240M30?101A;7/0<060210<$/C17/0 4A11 A; <030?<0?6: 6A>01 7A 1$"!-# M ") M " M #JO1$"!!##$ ")$ <>8770<4: 6428>2?71 250 3250?71 A; 7/0 <060210<$0?607/0:2500?78740<4A11A;;848246A?1A578C> 271$- ###026/8?7A7241$,!###2?<2?2>AC?7A; 1$!### C?<05 7/0 6A?90?78A?24 /02<1 21 305 7/0 687278A? 8? 7/0 6210 A; "# " $ !$ /0 6428>2?71 250 241A 0?78740< ;A5 1$")### 7AD25<1 >0<8624 0M30?101 8?6C550<$ 1 2017 ACJ 2700 SC - 11 - "$ 66A5<8?@4:7/06428>2?712500?78740<;A57A724 6A>30?1278A? A; 1$",)#!## 21 2@28?17 1$)### 2D25<0<=:7/058=C?2421C?<05 02<1 D25<=:7/0 58=C?24 D25<=:7/81 AC57 " A11 A; <030?<0?6: 1$-)#### 1$"!!## ) A11 A; ;84824 6A?1A578C> 1$ #### 1$,!### 52?13A57278A? ;C?05242?<4A11 A;017270 1$"### 1$!### - 0<8624 0M30?101 1$")### 1$")### A724 1$)### 1$",)#!## /050D844=00?/2?60>0?7A;1$",!## "-$ 013A?<0?7 A$) N ?1C52?60 A>32?: /21 24502<:<03A1870<7/02>AC?72D25<0<=:7/058=C?248? 7/0=A7/7/06428>307878A?1$ "$ A57/02;A50128<5021A?17/0;A44AD8?@ - 12 - ! &8( 'A7/7/02330241250244AD0<8?3257$ &88( /0 2330442?7 8? A$)#"! )#)- &307878A?05 8? A$")#",( 81 0?78740< ;A5 6A>30?1278A? A; 1$"-# D87/ 8?705017 27 !J 305 2??C> ;5A> 7/0 <270 A; 307878A? 7844 50248K278A? &0M64C<8?@ 8?705017 ;A5 " <2:1 7/0 <042: 62C10< 8? ;848?@ 7/0 233024( 8? 2<<878A? 7A 7/0 6A>30?1278A?2D25<0<=:7/058=C?24$ &888( /0 2330442?71 8? A$)#)! )#)- &307878A?051 8? A$#)#" ( 250 0?78740< ;A5 6A>30?1278A? A; 1$",!##D87/8?70501727!J3052??C> ;5A> 7/0 <270 A; 307878A? 7844 50248K278A? &0M64C<8?@ 8?705017 ;A5 " <2:1 7/0 <042: 62C10< 8? ;848?@ 7/0 233024( 8? 2<<878A? 7A 2>AC?72D25<0<=:7/058=C?24$ - 13 - &89( 013A?<0?7 A$) N ?1C52?60 A>32?: 81 <850670< 7A <03A187 7/0 6A>30?1278A? 2>AC?7 D87/8? ;AC5 D00I1 ;5A> 7/0<270A;7/81BC<@>0?78?=A7/7/0>277051$ &9( ? 1C6/ <03A187 7/0 2330442?7 8? A$)#"! )#)-81305>8770<7AD87/<52D 7/00?78500?/2?60<6A>30?1278A?D87/8?705017 2?<7/02330442?718? A$)#)! )#)-250 305>8770< 7A D87/<52D 7/0 0?7850 0?/2?60< 6A>30?1278A? 0LC244: 24A?@ D87/ 8?705017 2665C0<A?87$ +, ('""!* &! ' 817A$"4A$