- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '&( ) !" # # $ % # && # ! % '' ( )!%' ' &*&& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + )& )) ' + * )) ' ' +&&( ' " &)&& ' , ' " - '. . /" #% 012 344536 12 71658 9: 8575;83;< =) 3>31;2< <05 =?85? 83<58 &*&& 432258 =; = 71658 @;85? ?85?+@65)$&=73;8=71658@;85??85? + @65 * =7 9: <05 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 3;8 "' @B;39381;=+&&3;8<05?565A3;<4=?<1=;=7 <052318=?85??5382327=66=C2. ! !"# $ ! % - 3 - & ?157 73D<2 =7 <05 D325 3?5 <03< <05 4631;<177 3;1E ?390@ 71658 =+&& 7=? 43?<1<1=; 3;8 2543?3<5 4=225221=; =7 )))<0 203?5 1; <05 2@1< 2D058@65 4?=45?<: 5 362= 71658 =) 255E1;> 3; 1;<5?1B 1;F@;D<1=;;&381;<5?1B1;F@;D<1=;C32>?3;<581; 01273A=@??52<?31;1;>8575;83;<=)7?=B3615;3<1;><05 2@1< 2D058@65 4?=45?<: =; ))&& 575;83;< =) 34453?58957=?5<05=@?<3;871658=&<=A3D3<5<05 2318 & 1;<5?1B =?85? =; )&& 5 362= 71658 C?1<<5; 2<3<5B5;< 3;8 B5B= <= <?53< <05 C?1<<5; 2<3<5B5;< 32 =9F5D<1=;2 <= =) =; &*&&& 2 <05 =?85?2 3?5 ;=< 432258 C1<01; 83:2 05 71658 =&)&&&& 3;8 81?5D<1=; C32 >1A5; 9: <012 =@?<=;+&&<=<055;1=?1A16"@8>53;8"' @B;3938 <= 8124=25 =7 <05 B3<<5? C1<01; 83:2 DD=?81;>6: <05 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 366=C58 =) 3;8 ?52<?31;588575;83;<=);=<<=3615;3<5<052@1<4?=45?<: 3;8 ?5F5D<58 =& 71658 7=? A3D3<1;> <05 & - 4 - 381;<5?1B 1;F@;D<1=; =?85? >>?15A58 9: <05 2318 =?85? <0123445361271658 53?8<053?>@B5;<2=79=<021852 * ; ))&& 3;1E ?390@ 71658 3 2@1< 7=? 43?<1<1=; 1; =+&& 9@< <05 4?=45?<: 12 =C;58 3;8 4=2252258 9: <01?8 43?<152 15 2 ?1 31 01<?3 3;81?352<3<58<03<<054631;<1773;88575;83;<23?5 <05 F=1;< =C;5?2 3;8 4=22522=?2 =7 <05 2@1< =45; 243D5 953?1;> =&& D=??524=;81;> =) <=<366: 38B532@?1;> +&&) 2G@3?5 B5<5?2 21<@3<58 39@<<1;> 3<1=;36 1>0C3: 9:4322 ?=38 1; @B;3938 12<?1D< 183? 05 4631;<177 2<3<58 <03< 8575;83;< =) 3;8 01B2567 3?5 ?536 9?=<05?2 05: 3?5 <05 B5B95?2 =7 1;8@ F=1;< 73B16: 05 2318 31 01<?3 3;81?3 C324@?D032587?=B F=1;73B16:7@;82 2 2@D0 05 12 5;<1<658 7=? 5G@36 203?5 1; :=)H C01D0 12 D=;A5?<58 ;=;3>?1D@6<@?36 63;8 71< 7=? 63:=@< 5 2<3<58 <03<8575;83;< =) 12 ;=<>1A1;>3;: 203?5<=01B 05 4?=45?<: 12 3; 3;D52<?36 4?=45?<: C01D0 C32 ;=B1;366: - 5 - 2<3;81;> 1; <05 ;3B5 =7 8575;83;< =) 5 2<3<58 <03< <054631;<1778575;83;<=2)&<=0@293;8=7 8575;83;<=&73<05?=78575;83;<=3;8<050@293;8 =7 8575;83;< =+ 7=?B58 3 43?<;5?2014 71?B 7=? 52<3961201;> 31 01<?3 3;81?3 <0?=@>0 ?5>12<5?58 43?<;5?2014855883<58&+)+ 0571?B0323DG@1?58 ;=;3>?1D@6<@?36D=;A5?<5863;81;:=)HB532@?1;>) 3D?5 ) >@;<3 1; 3 4@961D 3@D<1=; D=;8@D<58 9: #0381 3;8 1663>5 ;8@2<?152 =3?8 183? 1; <05 ;3B5 =7 8575;83;< =* I 18?3B3::3 05 =3?8 032 5J5D@<58 <05 ?5>12<5?58 2365 8558 1; <05 ;3B5 =7 8575;83;< =* A185 8=D@B5;< =)*) 83<58 ))&)+ 3;8 366 <05 43?<;5?2 =7 <05 71?B 3?5 03A1;> 5G@36 203?5 1; 1< 05 0@293;8=78575;83;<=5J41?58=;))&)05;D5 8575;83;< = 95D3B5 012 2@DD522=? 05 73<05? =7 8575;83;< = 5J41?58 =; &))&) 3;8 8575;83;< =95D3B52@DD522=? 050@293;8=78575;83;<=) 5J41?58 =; &)&&) 3;8 8575;83;< =) 95D3B5 2@DD522=? 0@2 8575;83;< = 8575;83;< = 3;8 - 6 - 8575;83;< =) 2@DD55858 )))<0 203?5 =7 <051? 0@293;873<05?2<05<053<?5C32;=<?@;;1;>4?=45?6: <05: ?52=6A58 <= 85B=6120 <05 5;<1?5 2<?@D<@?5 3;8 4?525;<6:1<123;=45;243D5 05:03A5362=?52=6A58<= 8122=6A5<0543?<;5?201471?B3;84318366<058@52=7<051? D?581<=?2 05 4631;<177 344?=3D058 <05 8575;83;<2 7=? )))<0203?5;1<1366:8575;83;<23>?5587=?1<9@<63<5? 4=2<4=;1;><0523B5=;=;5=?=<05?4?5<5J< 054631;<177 ?5G@52<58 <05B 71;366: =; **&&* 575;83;< =) 71658 =)&&* 5 362= 71658 3; 34461D3<1=; 7=? C1<08?3C36 =7 <05 2@1< >31; D3@25 =7 3D<1=; 3?=25 =; )&&&* 05 5;1=?1A16"@8>5 @B;3938 >?3;<58 3; &381;<5?1B=?85??52<?31;1;>8575;83;<=)7?=B 3615;3<1;> <05 4?=45?<: =; ))&& 9@< <05?5 C32 ;= D=B4613;D5 =7 ?85? (((( @65 =7 <05 =85 =7 1A16 ?=D58@?53<5?8575;83;<=)716583;34461D3<1=;I =&<=A3D3<5<05&381;<5?1B=?85?3;8362=71658 C?1<<5; 2<3<5B5;< 2 <05 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 032 ;=< - 7 - 8124=258 =7 <05 B3<<5? C1<01; <1B5 <05: 344?=3D058 <05 1>0=@?<3;8>=<=?85?23;83DD=?81;>6:<055;1=?1A16 "@8>5366=C58=)9@<?5F5D<58=& ; &&* <05 4631;<177?524=;85;< =) 05?51; 71658 3; 1B465381;> 34461D3<1=; <= 1B46538 01B 32 8575;83;<=)1;=)&&*;A15C=725<<65B5;< =@<2185 <05 =@?< C1<08?3C36 34461D3<1=; 12 71658 1; =)&&* 05?524=;85;<05?51;71658=9F5D<1=;2=; *)&&3;8<05B3<<5?C3238F=@?;58<=)&&&& 3<5?2@1<C328124=258=7=;))&&3225<<658=@<=7 <05=@?< H 012 344536 12 71658 9: 8575;83;< =) 3>31;2< <05=?85? =7<055;1=?1A16 "@8>5 3;8 "' @B;3938 83<58 &*&& D=;<5;81;> <03< <05 4631;<177 12 3 2<?3;>5? <= <05 2@1< 2D058@65 4?=45?<: 3;8 05 12 ;=< 3 43?<;5? 1; <05 43?<;5?2014 71?B 05 ?5A5;@5 8=D@B5;<2 3?51;<05;3B5=78575;83;<=*3;8<0@2?5G@52<58<= 25<32185<05=?85?83<58&*&&432258=;=2) 3;8&1;=+&& - 8 - ; 34461D3<1=; C32 71658 9: <05 4631;<177 3;8 8575;83;<2 =; )&&&* 2<3<1;> <03< <05 B3<<5? 12 25<<658 =@<2185 <05 D=@?< 3;8 4631;<177 3;8 8575;83;<2 3>?558<==C;3;85;F=:<052@1<4?=45?<1523;8<0@2<05: 1;<5;858 <= C1<08?3C <05 2@1< 1; =)&&* < C32 8124=258 =7 =; ))&& 32 45? <05 8316: 2<3<@2 05 45?@236=7<0543?<;5?2014855820=C2<03<3;1E?390@ 12 ;=< 3 43?<: <=1< @< <05 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 =925?A58 <03<<054631;<1773;88575;83;<23?59?=<05?23;81<C32 38B1<<58 9: <05 71?2< 8575;83;< 05 2@1< 4?=45?<: C32 4@?D032589: <05 71?2< 8575;83;< 7?=B F=1;< 73B16:7@;82 7<5?7161;>=7<05=9F5D<1=;2<05&=?85?4322581; =) C32 ;=< 5J<5;858 3;8 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 =925?A58 <03< 17 <05 8575;83;< 2566 <05 2@1< 4?=45?<: 4631;<177 C166 2@775? 6=22 3;8 83B3>5 3;8 3DD=?81;>6: ?52<?31;58<058575;83;<27?=B25661;><052@1<4?=45?<:<166 <05 8124=236 =7 <05 2@1< =? <166 ))&& C01D05A5? 12 53?615? 054631;<1771239?=<05?=78575;83;<=)9@<1< D3;;=<952318<03<05125;<1<6587=?)))<0203?51;<05 - 9 - 4?=45?<: 5 12 3 2<?3;>5? <= 43?<;5?2014 8558 < 12 7=? 01B<=4?=A5<03<<054?=45?<:124@?D032587?=B<05F=1;< 73B16: 7@;82 3;8 <05 4?=45?<: 12 3; 3;D52<?36 4?=45?<: ;73D<4631;<1773;88575;83;<21;=)&&*25<<658 <05B3<<5?=@<2185<05=@?<3;8<05:03A5C1<08?3C;<05 2@1< 05?57=?5<05=?85?4322589:<055;1=?1A16"@8>5 12 C1<0=@< 344?5D13<1=; =74?=45? 73D<2 3;8 12 613965 <= 95 25<32185 + ;<05?52@6<<0534453612 05=?85? 83<58 &*&& 432258 9: <05 5;1=? 1A16 "@8>5 3;8 "'@B;3938=;=2)3;8&1;=+&&12 05?59:25<32185 *+, '&!! ( % 12<=.)6=.*