Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63172 (KAR)
UPENDRA S/O RANGAYYA @ BISHAPATHI v. SUDEEP AND ORS
MFA/201233/2021 · 2025-08-29
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63172 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63172 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $ $
%%
&$' (
!"#"
$
%
&
"
'( ) *# *(+#
(*"*"# , -%&####
-
- '
)
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*# *(+#
- - % &*##
'
))(# ) . %&!###'"
$
%
)'/
" &
) ) "('%"& ) ) )
,#### ,
" #" ) ) +"" ## * ) ,
) ) ,
0, -
- 3 -
#
" 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 4556774=< >742?4=< 366@2=A 6=14=>6?6=< B8 >B?56=34<2B= 43 4C4D969 2= <16 ,E9A?6=< 4=9 4C4D9 94<69 #### 543369 2= B" #" :;<16992<2B=4723<D2><4=9 6332B=3,E9A6 4=942>1ED%8BD31BD<F<16<D2:E=47G&
64D9 <16 764D=69 >BE=367 8BD <16 4556774=< 4=9 <16 764D=69 >BE=367 8BD <16 D635B=96=< B'*=3ED4=>6 B?54=;
' 64D=69 >BE=367 8BD <16 4556774=< CBE79 >B=<6=9 <14<<16=B<2B=472=>B?6<4@6=:;<16<D2:E=474<3 ### * 56D?B=<123B=7BC6D3296>B=3296D2=A<1684><<14<4356D <16 >14D< 5D654D69 8BD 36<<76?6=< B8 9235E<63 2= <16 B@ 9474<1 <16 =B<2B=47 2=>B?6 82H69 8BD <16 ;64D #" 23 3 (# *16B><BD '1433<4<69<14<<169234:272<;23 I8BD<16C1B76:B9;4=9<16<D2:E=471436DD692=<4@2=A <16 9234:272<; 4< "#I 16 >B?56=34<2B= 4C4D969 8BD 542= 4=93E886D2=A7B33B82=>B?69ED2=A7429E556D2B94=97B33
- 4 -
B8 4?6=2<263 4D6 B= 7BC6D 3296 2<1 <123 16 5D4;3 8BD 477BC2=A<16455647
! 64D=69 >BE=367 8BD <16 D635B=96=< B' CBE79 >B=<6=9 <14< <16 56D>6=<4A6 B8 9234:272<; 43 <4@6= :; <16 <D2:E=4723B=12A16D329616<D2:E=47143D2A1<7;43363369 <16>B?56=34<2B=16D64D6=BADBE=938BD6=14=>6?6=<B8 >B?56=34<2B=435D4;69:;<164556774=< >742?4=<2<1<123 165D4;38BD923?23347B8<16455647
4J2=A164D9<16764D=69>BE=3673<123BED<143 56DE369<162?5EA=69,E9A?6=<4=9B<16D?4<6D2473574>69 B=D6>BD9
+ 164556774=< >742?4=< C43 4A69 ;64D3 43 B= <16 94<6 B8 <16 4>>296=< 4=9 <16 4>>296=< B>>EDD69 2= <16 ;64D#"+164A6B8<164556774=< >742?4=<4=9<16;64DB8 4>>296=< 4D6 =B< 2= 9235E<6 16 724:272<; B8 <16 D635B=96=< B'=3ED4=>6>B?54=;23473B=B<2=9235E<6
( ' <16 B><BD 143 43363369 <16 9234:272<; 4< I<B<16C1B76:B9;=J26CB8<1684><<14<'23=B<
- 5 -
4<D64<699B><BD<16<D2:E=47143D2A1<7;<4@6=<169234:272<; 4<"#I16=B<2B=472=>B?682H698BD36<<76?6=<B89235E<63 2=<16B@9474<18BD<16;64D#" 233 (# *56D?B=<1 4=9 <16D68BD6 <16 =B<2B=47 2=>B?6 <4@6=:; <16<D2:E=474< 3 ### * 56D ?B=<1 23 B= 7BC6D 3296 16 <D2:E=47 143 D2A1<7;<4@6=<16?E7<25726D4<F" G=J26CB8<164:BJ6<16 7B33B88E<ED62=>B?62343E=96D
3 (# *."." ."#IK3" ### *
B=3296D2=A <16 84>< <14< <16 4556774=< >742?4=< 1433E3<42=6974>6D4<69CBE=9B=D2A1<76A2=<167BC6D" 'D9 C2<1<6=96D=6332=>6DJ2>47352=64=9924A=B369C2<1;56* B56=>B??E=2<698D4><ED6B8D2A1<<2:244=916C43<D64<69 43 4= 2=54<26=< 8BD "" 94;3 <16 >B?56=34<2B= 4C4D969 8BD 542= 4=9 3E886D2=A 4=9 7B33 B8 2=>B?6 9ED2=A <16 7429 E5 56D2B94D6B=7BC6D3296
164556774=< >742?4=<236=<2<76<B>B?56=34<2B= 8BD 542= 4=9 3E886D2=A 2= 4 3E? B8 3#### * 4=9 7B33 B8 2=>B?6 9ED2=A 7429 E5 56D2B9 2= 4 3E?
B8 3+# * %3 (# *.'?B=<13&
- 6 -
"# B=3296D2=A <16 =4<ED6 B8 2=LED; 4=9 9234:272<;
<16 >B?56=34<2B= 4C4D969 E=96D <16 1649 B8 7B33 B8 4?6=2<2632=43E?B83"### *23B=7BC6D32964=9<16 4556774=< >742?4=< 23 6=<2<76 <B 3!#### * <BC4D93 7B33 B8 4?6=2<263
"" 16>B?56=34<2B=4C4D969:;<16<D2:E=47E=96D B<16D16493235DB56D4=9>BDD6><
" = J26C B8 <16 4:BJ6 <16 4556774=< >742?4=< 23 6=<2<768BD>B?56=34<2B=E=96D92886D6=<1649343E=96D ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /0*1-+231 +4+5,*, 67 283-952
" B33B88E<ED664D=2=A3 3" ### *
42=4=93E886D2=A3 3#### * ' 692>476H56=363 3!!"# * ! )BB9=BED231?6=<4=9>B=J6;4=>6 3"### *
<<6=94=<>14DA63 3"#### * + B33B82=>B?69ED2=A7429E556D2B9 3+# * ( B33B84?6=2<263 3!#### *
)E<ED6?692>476H56=363 3"### *
2+) -
::;
"' 16 4556774=< >742?4=< 23 6=<2<76 <B <B<47 >B?56=34<2B= B8 3'!++# * 43 4A42=3< 3 ## * 4C4D969:;<16<D2:E=47
"! =J26CB8<164:BJ6<168B77BC2=A
- 7 -
%2& 1645564723477BC692=*54D</
%22& 164556774=< >742?4=<236=<2<76<B<B<47 >B?56=34<2B=B83'!++# *C2<12=<6D63<4<<16 D4<6B8+I56D4==E?8DB?<1694<6B856<2<2B=<277 D6472M4<2B=B8<166=<2D6>B?56=34<2B=4?BE=</
%222& 16 D635B=96=< B'*=3ED4=>6 >B?54=; 31477 965B32< <16 4C4D9 4?BE=< C2<1 2=<6D63< C2<12= 4 56D2B9 B8 62A1< C66@3 8DB? <123 94; 84272=A C12>1 2< 23 724:76 <B 54; 2=<6D63< <16 D4<6B8I56D4==E?/
%2J& 16 4556774=< >742?4=< 23 6=<2<76 <B A6< D676436<166=<2D64?BE=<B8>B?56=34<2B=
,; & $ $' #
23<B" 7B'