Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63145 (KAR)
BALATAPASVI DVITIYA SAMBASWAMY v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/200508/2016 · 2025-09-03
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$
%# & &"##
' (
!
"#$#!%!
&& ' "#$#!%!
#
'
"#$#%(
) &!'*
&&
Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
+
,& &
&
& -.
/012345678934:6/2;3<32020683/18=>2/5;181 0?1/01468@?02;/0;39;1=/0)109;18A1/:6/ /39<68=3829!18=;1B31<<31/3=08<3/968 <3/7914 6: 2;3 6::053 8623 =3<0529 2;12 862053 26 /39<68=382609;34=97::050382B0=36/=3/=123=!%$%( 3 ;19 8302;3/ 38@1@3= 2;3 93/B0539 6: 18 1=B65123 6/ 568=7523=2;35193191<1/2C08<3/968
;39;6/2:15291/32;393 209910=2;122;3<32020683/092;36?83/6:418=D31/08@ C6+>3197/08@26183E23826:%$5/39%#782199027123= 12
1@1=1/0 0441@3 418= 147A 141D7/1@0 092/052 ;3 6B3/8>382 6: 1/8121A1 15F70/3= 2;3 418= :6/ <3/56412068 218A 620:0512068 78=3/ 352068 (! 18= +! ?3/3 09973= ;3 <35014 418= 5F70902068 ::053/ <1993= 2;3 1?1/= 68
- 3 -
%(%#%%G 08 2;3 81>3 6: 2;3 <32020683/ 1?1/=08@ 56><389120686:9$#%%"<3/15/3 83 /;0B191>D1 61;1=3B1CC1 :043= 6DH3520689 08 2;3 6::053 6: 2;3 :6/ 2;3 =09D7/93>382 6: 2;3 56><38912068 1>6782 ;3 141D7/1@0 /3:3//3= 2;3 >1223/262;30B04 67/23806/ 0B09068418=78=3/352068 % 6: 2;3 18= 5F70902068 52 :6/ 2;3 1<<6/2068>382 6: 56><38912068 ;3 2;0/= /39<68=382 :043= 1 <3202068 78=3/ 352068%6:2;3525410>08@56><389120681>678218=2;3 91>3?19/3@0923/3=190956!%%G089231=6:/3@0923/08@ 19 ;3 /3:3/3853 67/2 1:23/ /356/=08@ 2;3 3B0=3853 6: D62;2;3<1/2039<1993=2;36/=3/68!%,%!#18=/3H3523= 2;35410>6:2;32;0/=/39<68=382 9 2;3 >1223/ 9266= 2;79 2;3 <32020683/ >6B3= 18 1<<40512068262;3/3:3/385367/268!!%$%!#:6//3431936:
=3<69023= 1>6782 1?1/=3= DC 2;3 78=3/ 352068 !! 6: 2;318=5F709020685218==3<69023=78=3/352068%6:2;3 52 ;3 3:3/3853 67/2 /3H3523= 2;3 1<<40512068 6: 2;3 <32020683/ 68 %!!%%!# 8=3/ 2;393 50/57>9218539 2;3 <32020683/09D3:6/32;0967/2
- 4 -
678934 :6/ 2;3 /39<3520B3 <1/2039 7/@3= 93B3/14 5682382068931/=2;31/@7>382918=<3/793=2;3
/02<1<3/9 ?02;51/3 ( ;3 :1529 1/3 97::0503824C 910= 18= =6 862 /3F70/3 /3023/12068;309973:1449?02;08181//6?56><19918=/341239 26 2;3 /3H352068 6: 2;3 5410> :6/ /343193 6: 2;3 =3<69023= 1>678208:1B6/6:2;3<32020683/ 20986208=09<7232;122;3 418=08F7392068?1915F70/3=18=181?1/=?19<1993=082;3 81>36:2;3<32020683/08%%G;33:3/385367/21:23/2;3 /3530<2 6: /3:3/3853 78=3/ 352068 % 6: 2;3 18= 5F70902068 521=H7=05123=2;3=09<72318=/3H3523=2;35410>6:2;32;0/= /39<68=382 ;3 /3F7392 6: 2;3 <32020683/ 26 /343193 2;3 =3<69023= 1>6782 ;19 D338 /3H3523= 68 2;3 9643 @/678= 2;12 2;3/309869<350:056/=3/6:2;3141D7/1@026/3431932;3 =3<69023= 1>6782 08 :1B6/ 6: 2;3 <32020683/ ;3 /3H352068 09 782381D43 ;3 /31968 09 90><43 2 09 862 08 =09<723 2;12 <7/97182 26 2;3 6DH352068 :043= DC 2;3 2;0/= /39<68=382 2;3 =3<69023=2;31?1/=1>6782D3:6/32;33:3/385367/2 20990@80:05182 26 86232;122;35410>6:2;3 2;0/=/39<68=382 ?19/3H3523=8532;35410>09/3H3523=2;33:3/385367/2
- 5 -
;1=866<20683E53<226/3431932;31?1/=1>678208:1B6/6: 2;31?1/=33032;3<32020683/;3/30986833=:6/19<350:05 6/=3/ 6: 2;3 26 /343193 2;3 =3<69023= 1>6782 &6/ 2;3 /31968992123=1D6B32;36/=3/<1993=DC2;33:3/385367/2 09401D4326D3932"190=3556/=08@4C0209932I190=3 # ;3
/02 6: 3/206/1/0 09 6/=3/3= ;3 6/=3/ =123= %!!%%!#<1993=DC2;33:3/385367/2B0=3883E7/3" 09 F719;3=;31>6782=3<69023=DC2;39;144D3/343193= 08 :1B6/ 6: 2;3 <32020683/ 1:23/ =73 0=3820:0512068 ?02;08 :67/ ?33A9:/6>2;3/3530<26:53/20:03=56<C6:2;096/=3/ + 397421824C2;3
/02320206809
)* '&"##( &
0926!46(