Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63140 (KAR)
HYDERABAD KARNATAKA EDUCATION SOCIETY v. DARGA-HAZRATH KHAJA BANDANAWAZ RAHEMATTULLA-ALIA AND ORS
CRP/200020/2024 · 2025-12-15
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63140 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63140 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%"" &&
'( &&
'
(
! "
#"
""
$
#
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
! &
$
'(
'#
$#
(
)
*
+
+
! & ,! #
$#
+%%%& #
$%+
$%+ #
# #
#
- 3 -
'
(
! $
%
%
$
' '#
$#
%
! "
#"
""
$
#(
%
%
- 4 -
&
*
+
%
- %-
&! & ,! )
#
+%%%&
$%+
#
#
*
#
'
' .
/%%$%%(0123456574879 /&:;0<5 /%%%$%%( 01 23 456574879 / 07 /$%+ 8==>05?54239;5@A4=B57987445C>5548954+%%%& D81154 23 9;5 8>7898E8 #8F6 >02A78< 8<82A>8=0 0?010/7 8<82A>8=0 G;5>5078695> >565>>54 9/ 81 H9;5 #8F6 - 5 - >02A78<I 6/> 2>5?093J 45C>5507= 9;5 1A09 /6 9;5 D<8079066 78B5<38>=8;8K>89; ;8@8874878:8K8;5B899A<<8 <08 /AK8AKA>= 8<82A>8=0 45C<8>07= 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 9/ 25 9;5 :8F6 D>/D5>93 25</7=07= 9/ D<8079066 071909A90/7 874 =>87907= 45C>55 /6 D5>B87579 07@A7C90/7 >519>80707= 456574879 /1 9/ & 6>/B 0795>65>07= /> /219>AC907= 9;5 D<8079066.1 D58C56A< D/115110/7 874 57@/3B579 /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 874 8<1/ 40>5C907= 456574879 /&9/>5B/?59;52<A59071;5591/?5>9;51A09 D>/D5>93:09;079:/B/79;16>/B9;54895/69;5@A4=B579 87445C>55 % A2@5C9B8995>/61A0901/D571D8C5B581A>07= /7 9;5 7/>9;1/A9; 9/:8>41 5819 % 6559 7/>9;1/A9; 9/:8>41:519(65595819:5199/:8>417/>9;%6559 5819:5199/:8>411/A9;&65599/98<<3B581A>07=%+L 1FA8>5 6559 /A9 /6 8C>51 L =A7981 /6 <874 07 3 /&( :09; 093 A>?53 /%% /6 0<<8=5 >8;B8DA> 8<82A>8=0 2/A7454 /7 5819 23 >5B80707= <874 258>07= A>?53 /&( /:754 23 D<8079066071909A90/7 :519 23 - 6 - D/>90/7 /6 <874 258>07= A>?53 /&( /:754 23 D<8079066 071909A90/787419890/7B807>/847/>9;23>5B80707=<874 /6 A>?53 /&( /:754 23 D<8079066 071909A90/7 1/A9; 23 D/>90/7 /6 <874 258>07= A>?53 /&( /:754 23 D<8079066 071909A90/79/:8>410:8751;8;081D5>9;5D<8079B8D & >05668C91/69;5C8158>59;89' & <8079066071909A90/7 01 8 >5<0=0/A1 :8F6 071909A90/7 874 <874 07 3 /&( B581A>07= 8C>51 L =A7981 01 8 :8F6 D>/D5>93 8998C;54 9/ 9;5 1804 071909A90/7 ;5 18B5 ;8?07= 2557 7/906054 A745> 1A215C90/7 %!/65C90/7/69;5#8F6C9,( >56<5C954 89 < /%L /6 9;5 =8K5995 7/9060C890/7 48954 +L,L( ;89 /7 %,&%+ D<8079066 071909A90/7 ;84 07C045798<<3 >5C50?54 8 :097511 1ABB/71 8</7= :09; D;/9/C/D3 /6 8 4/CAB579 C8<<54 HFA028<8I 48954 &,L 07 >4A 874 7=<01;9>871<890/78775M549;5>59/6>/B9;5 /A>9 /6 9;5 44090/78< A70/> 0?0< A4=5 8<82A>8=0 :09;840>5C90/79/D>/4AC59;51804HFA028<8I8749/ =0?55?0457C5071A0907 /%$%901/7<3 9;57 9;5 D<8079066071909A90/7 <58>79 82/A9 8 C<80B 2507=B845239;54565748791:09;>51D5C99/1A09 D>/D5>9328154/79;5HFA028<8I - 7 - &% 7/9;5> 1A09 07 /(L$% ;84 2557 071909A954 23 456574879 / ;A1 9;5 1A09 07 /(L$% 01 60<54 23 456574879 / :;0<5 1A0907 /%$%0160<5423456574879 /% ;89 9;5 1804 1A091 :5>5 C/<<A10?5 1A091 155E07= 45C<8>890/7 /6 /:75>1;0D 874 07@A7C90/7 8=80719 456574879 /& 07 >51D5C9 9/ 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 28154/79;58<<5=544/CAB579C8<<5481HFA028<8I && ;89 456574879 /1 9/ & 9;/A=; C<80B07= 9;50> >0=;9909<58740795>519/?5>9;51A09D>/D5>93;8?5 7/ 15B2<87C5 /6 >0=;9 /?5> 9;5 18B5 ;89 9;5 HFA028<8I48954&,L:81DA>D/>954<3011A54 6>/B9;5/660C5/6D<8079066071909A90/710=754239;5 /660C08< 5C>598>3 2A9 7/9 23 9;5 9;57 8@@848 81;557;899;5>5C098<1/69;51804HFA028<8I8>5 C<58> :;0C; 0740C895 9;5 4/CAB579 2507= 8 C/74090/78< <5815 =>87954 07 68?/A> /6 019>0C9 /7=>511 /BB09955 8<82A>8=0>5D>515795423091 9;57 >5104579 >0 55>574>8890< 6/> 9;5DA>D/15 /6 C/719>AC90/7 /6 874;0 ;8?87 /7 C/74090/7 /6 D83B579 /6 1($ D5> 358> D8382<5 9/ 9;5 D<8079066071909A90/7 ;89 9;/A=; 9;5 >5C098< 1804 4/CAB579 0740C895 D/115110/7 ;8?07= 2557 45<0?5>54 07 68C9 7/ D;310C8< D/115110/7 :81 - 8 - 45<0?5>54 9/ 456574879 /
874 18B5 >5B80754 :09;9;5D<8079066071909A90/7 &( ;89 9;5>5 :81 8 1D<09 07 9;5 C/7=>511 D/<090C8< />=870K890/7 07 ,+, /75 81 E7/:7 81 74087 890/78< /7=>511 ! 874 87/9;5> 01 E7/:7 81 /7=>511 !;897509;5>/69;59://>=870K890/71 ;84 8C954 AD/7 9;5 95>B1 /6 9;5 1804 HFA028<8I 90<< 48958747509;5>/69;5/>=870K890/71;84D804873 <5815 8B/A79 81 1AC; 9;5 D/115110/7 8<:831 >5B80754 :09; 9;5 D<8079066 071909A90/7 ;5 1804 HFA028<8I :81 07 68?/A> /6 019>0C9
/7=>511 /BB0995523091>51045792A9:817509;5>079;5 0740?04A8< 78B5 /6 <895 >0 55>574>8 890< 7/> 07 68?/A> /6 9;5 689;5> /6 456574879 /% 1 1AC; 456574879 /% ;81 7/ 9/ C<80B 873 1/>9 /6 >0=;9 909<5 874 0795>519 /?5> 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 & 0B0<8><3456574879 /&:;/01C<80B07=9;>/A=;
874 A745> 9;5 >5104579 /6 9;5 019>0C9
/7=>511 /BB099559;5<895>055>574>8890<8<1/;817/
9/ C<80B 873 >0=;9 909<50795>519 /?5> 9;51A09D>/D5>93817/>0=;9:81?519540768?/A> /69;51804<895>055>574>8890<
- 9 -
&+
<80B B845 23 456574879 /& 28154 /7 873 8<<5=54 C/7?5387C5 01 0<<5=8< ?/04 874 4/51 7/9 C/760>B 873 >0=;9 909<5 0795>519 AD/7 456574879 /& &L ;89 :09; 9;5 84?579 /6 8>7898E8
5>9807 78B.1 2/<090/7C9,LLD<8079066N071909A90/72507=9;5 78B48> 874 >5<0=0/A1 071909A90/7 ;84 8DD<054 6/> >5=>879 /6 9;5 <874 07 3 /&( B581A>07= 8C>51L=A7981;5<874>02A78<23/>45>48954 ,, C/760>B54 9;5 /CCAD87C3 /6 9;5 D<8079066 N071909A90/7 ;89 9;5 D<8079066$ 071909A90/7 ;84 8<1/ /2980754 C;87=5 /6 <874 A18=5 6>/B 8=>0CA<9A>8< 9/ 7/78=>0CA<9A>8< DA>D/151 23 >45>
/$ $ $,,,,:;0C;:81C8>>054 256/>5 9;5 0=;
/A>9 07 # /&$%( /7 8CC/A79 /6 45B874 /6 C/7?5>10/7 655 :;0C; :81 401D/154/60768?/A>/69;5D<8079066071909A90/7/7 %%%L;A19;5D<8079066071909A90/7;812557 07D/115110/787457@/3B579/69;51A09D>/D5>93 & 56574879 /1 9/ & A745> 9;5 =8>2 /6 1804 4/CAB579 C8<<54 HFA028<8I :5>5 B8E07= ;5C90C 8995BD91 9/ E7/CE/66 9;5 D>/D5>93 /6 9;5 D<8079066 C/719>80707=9;5D<80790669/60<59;51A09A>07=9;5 D57457C3 /6 9;5 1A09 456574879 / 9/ & ;84 5>5C954 C5>9807 907 1;541 1 1AC; 9;5 D<8079 :81
- 10 -
8B5745444090/78<>5<0566/>>5B/?8</69;51;54 :818<1/1/A=;957C59;51A09155E07=6/<</:07= >5<056'
! "
! ! ! #
" ! $%$ &' &% ! ( ) * (" &' "! +,! - . / ! ( )
01!2 . 3 ( )
1! . / ! ( )
01! ( . 3 ( )
1!
4 55
67
"
" 4
8 !
"
! ! ! #
" ! $%$ &' &% ! ( ) * (" &' "! +,! - . / ! ( )
01!2 . 3 ( )
1! . / ! ( )
01! ( . 3 ( )
1! 4 55
67
"
" 4
8 ! )* ( 56574879 /1 874 % 60<54 :>09957 19895B579 C/7957407= 9;89' - 11 - ( ;89 9;5 011A87C5 /6 7/9060C890/7 48954 +L,L( 7/906307= 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 9/ 25 9;5 :8F6 D>/D5>93 01 7/9 207407= 0<07= /6 1A091 07 /1%$%874(L$%0184B09954 (% 90184B099549;89D<8079066071909A90/7;84011A54 HFA028<8I 48954 &,L /:5?5> 9;5 8?5>B5799;899;51804HFA028<8I4047/9C>5895873 >0=;9 0795>519 07 1A09 D>/D5>93 07 68?/A> /6 456574879 /874%01457054;899;5HFA028<8I :81 011A54 23 8 C/BD59579 D5>1/7 ;89 10B0<8> HFA028<81I :5>5 011A54 9/ 40665>579 D5>1/71 ;/:5?5>9;5D<8079066071909A90/7;817/9C;8<<57=54 873/75/61AC;HFA028<81I (& ;89/75/69;5D/>90/71/61A09D>/D5>9301=0?57 9/ 456574879 / :;0<5 9;5 /9;5> 01 =0?57 9/ 456574879 /% 9 01 C/7957954 9;89 9;5 C/7?5387C5B845238@@848 81;557/6D<8079066 071909A90/7 07 68?/A> /6 456574879 /1 874 % 01 ?8<04 874 5C90/7 (& /6 9;5 >87165> /6 >/D5>93 C9C/B51079//D5>890/7 (( ;899;5#8F6>02A78<4047/9;8?5@A>0140C90/781 401DA95:81259:5579;5D<8079066071909A90/7874 9;5 4565748791 :;/ 8>5 19>87=5> 9/ 9;5 :8F6 81 - 12 - 1AC; 1A09 256/>5 9;5 >02A78< :81 7/9 B807980782<5 ( ;89 <895 >0 ;874>815E;8> 890< 874 8@@848 81;557/6D<8079066071909A90/7:5>5C</156>05741 874 AD/7 9;5 >5FA519 B845 23 ;874>815E;8> 890<9;59;578@@848 81;557;84=>87954<5815 /69;51A09D>/D5>936/>9;5DA>D/15/6C/719>AC90/7 /6 /7=>511 660C5 ;89 9;5 1804 ;874>815E;8> 890< :87954 9/ C/719>AC9 8 ;/A15 6/> ;01 /:7 >510457C5:;0C;D>/D/18<:818=>554239;5<895 8@@848 81;557 874 9;5 /9;5> D/>90/7 :81 6/> C/719>AC90/7/68 /7=>511660C5;89456574879 /1 874 % ;84 C/<<5C954 9;5 2A0<407= B895>08<1 6/> C/719>AC90/7 /7 %%,L 8 6/A74890/7 19/75 :81 8<1/ <804 ;5 1A09 60<54 :09; 23 9;5 D<8079066155E07=45C<8>890/7/69;51A09D>/D5>9381 #8F6D>/D5>93017/9B807980782<557C51/A=;9 6/>401B0118</69;51A09 56574879 /& 60<54 8 15D8>895 :>09957 19895B579 C/7957407= 9;89 D>0/> 9/ 5>5C90/7 /6 9;5 907 1;5591 9;5>5 :81 8 C/BD/A74 :8<< 9/:8>41 9;5 5819874:0>5657C07=9/:8>41:5198741/A9;:09;8=895 C/719>AC954 23 456574879 /& ;89 9;5>5 :81 8 10=7 - 13 - 2/8>4/6 456574879 /& 1;/:07= 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 2507= 07 091 D/115110/7 :;0C; :81 =0?57 6/> C/719>AC90/7 /6 874;0 ;8?87 ;5 1A09 :81 7/9 B807980782<5 81 9;5 D<8079066 :817/98@A>0190CD5>1/7874:817/957909<549/ ;/<4 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 A09 D>/D5>93 :81 =0?57 9/ 55>574>8 890< 07 ;01 0740?04A8< C8D8C093 6/> C;8>0982<5 DA>D/156/>C/719>AC90/7/6874;0;8?87079;5B/79;/6 87A8>3 ,L 821/<A95<3 23 <895 354 ;8; /;8BB54 A11807 23 5M5CA907= 75C5118>3 4/CAB579 07 ;01 68?/A> :;0C; 01 </19$B01D<8C54 ;89 @A19 84@8C579 9/ 9;5 1804 D>/D5>93 9;5>5 01 /1D098< :;0C; :81 >A7 23 <895 8@@848 81;5578748695>;014589;23;015<45191/7:;/ 01D>51579<39;58@@848 81;557/9;/69;5B8>58:8>5 82/A9 9;5 4/78907= /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 07 68?/A> /6 55>574>8890<874;01D/115110/7/?5>0987418B52507= =0?57 23 55>574>8 890< 07 ,,L 07 68?/A> /6 456574879 /&;578B5/6456574879 /&;812557BA9895407 9;5 >5?57A5 >5C/>41 81 /:75> 874 D/11511/> 07 9;5 358> ,,71D095/6E7/:07=82/A99;5180468C97509;5>9;5 - 14 - D<8079066 071909A90/7 7/> 873 /6 091 8<<5=54 >5D>51579890?5 C;8<<57=54 9;5 18B5 107C5 <819 , 358>1 ;5 D<8079066 071909A90/7 8CFA051C54 9;5 68C9 /6 456574879 /& D/1151107=9;51A09D>/D5>93821/<A95<3874D>0/>9/0923 55>574>8 890< 81 821/<A95<3 /:75> 57C5 D<8079066 01 519/DD546>/BC<80B07=8748115>907=9;51A09D>/D5>939/ 25/:754874D/1151154230957C51/A=;96/>401B0118<
/69;51A09 + 8154/79;5D<58407=19;5>02A78<6>8B549;5 6/<</:07=011A51' " " , 8 * 4 4 9%% : / ,! ; :/<=<*=%'5%9=)
5! &' &% ! ) *( &'
"! + ,! "
.&9&9' 5! " >
" >
" >
- 15 -
) "
> ? " 6 (
7 @
. &9?%
A +" /)'= ( B 36
"
3 1 * !*,!> $ " ! 6 ! ! 7"
" ! > %
" ! "
> '
"
> 9
" (
( B 3 6
" 7
(B 3
* !C> &
" (
"
(B 36
" 7
( B 3
! D E *
- 16 -
< A" , 8 ( ( !>
"( B 3 6 3 * ! 37
>
"
->
"
" > )
"
> ? )" > $
> %
!
" > '
>F
L :/:09751151;8?525575M8B0754/725;8<6/6 9;5 D<8079066071909A90/7 81 # 874 #% 069557 4/CAB57918>5B8>E5481M19/:/:09751151 ;8?525575M8B0754/725;8<6/6456574879181#874 #%06930?54/CAB57918>5B8>E5481M19/
- 17 -
78DD>5C0890/7/65?0457C59;5>02A78<45C>5549;5 1A09 81 1/A=;9 6/> 507= 8==>05?54 9;5 D>51579 >5?010/7 D59090/7123456574879 /1874&817/95482/?5
>0 B559 AB8> 51;D8745 <58>754 570/> /A715< 8DD58>07= 6/> 9;5 4565748791$D59090/75>1 07
/%%%$%%(1A2B0919;89'
;5 >02A78< ;84 7/ @A>0140C90/7 9/ 5795>9807 9;5 1A09819;5>5017/401DA95:09;>5=8>49/789A>5/6 9;5 #8F6 9;89 9;5>5 01 7/ C;8<<57=5 9/ 9;5 4/CAB579HFA028<8I48954&,LD>/4AC54874 B8>E54 81 M 9>871<8954 C/D3 01 B8>E54 81 M 8!;89107C59;5D<8079066071909A90/70915<6 ;81 28154 9;5 1A09 /7 9;5 1804 4/CAB579 23 B8E07= 8?5>B5791 07 D8>8 /6 9;5 D<8079 9;5 D<8079066071909A90/701519/DD546>/B155E07=>5<056 C/79>8>39/9;518B5;89D5>A18</69;5C/795791 /69;518044/CAB579:/A<40740C8959;899;518B5 8DD58>19/2584/CAB579/6C/7?5387C5?5706 09 01 9/ 25 811AB54 81 8 4/CAB579 /6 <5815 /7 D83B579/6C5>9807D>5B0AB9;5>5017/8<<5=890/7 /6?0/<890/7/687395>B1/61AC;<5815609019;5 C815/69;5D<8079066071909A90/79;899;54565748791 8>5/CCAD307=9;5D>5B015181<511551/79;528101
- 18 -
/69;5HFA028<8ID<8079066071909A90/7/A=;99/;8?5 ;84 >5C/A>15 A745> 9;5 D>/?010/71 /6 8>7898E8 A2<0C >5B0151 ?0C90/7 /6 78A9;/>0154 CCAD8791C9!,L( % ;89 M(% 01 8 >5?57A5 4/CAB579 5?0457C07= 9;5D;310C8<D/115110/7/6456574879 /&510451 1A660C0579 7AB25> /6 4/CAB5791 8>5 D>/4AC54 9/ 1;/: 9;5 D;310C8< D/115110/7 /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 2507= :09; 456574879 /1 % 874 & ;89 06 9;5 C<80B /6 9;5 D<8079066 071909A90/7 9;89 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 01 8 #8F6 D>/D5>93 9;5 FA5190/7 /6 D<8079066 155E07= >5=>879 /6 9;5 <874 A745> 9;5 D>/?010/71 /6 8>7898E8
5>9807 78B1 2/<090/7 C9 ,LL :/A<4 7/9 8>015 81 9;5 18B5 >A71 C/79>8>39/58C;/9;5>;5>56/>5;51A2B0919;89 9;5D<8079066N071909A90/70915<6017/9C<58>82/A9091 >0=;9909<58740795>5198749;5>5<0562507=1/A=;9 6/> >5<056 /6 45C<8>890/7 /6 9;01 789A>5 :81 A795782<5 A745> 9;5 68C9A8< C0>CAB1987C51 /6 9;5 C815 :;0C; 9;5 >02A78< ;81 680<54 9/ 8DD>5C0895 57C5 155E1 6/> 8<</:07= 9;5 D59090/7 874 401B0118</69;51A09 , >0 >AD8 8=8> 890< <58>754 C/A715< 8DD58>07=6/>456574879 /&1A2B0919;89456574879 /&
- 19 -
:81 =0?57 D/115110/7 /6 9;5 D>/D5>93 2355>574>8 890< :;/ :81 9;5 />0=078< =>87955 874 5?5> 107C5 9;5 358> ,L 456574879 /& ;81 2557 07 D/115110/7 /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 874 9;A1 D5>65C954 ;01 909<5 2507= 07 A70795>>AD954 /D57 874 C/7907A/A1 D/115110/7 874 57@/3B579/69;51A09D>/D5>93;0181D5C9/69;5B8995> ;817/925578DD>5C0895487498E57079/C/71045>890/723 9;5>02A78<57C5155E16/>8<</:07=/69;5D59090/7
58>45>A1549;5>5C/>41
>/B 9;5 68C91 78>>8954 1A2B0110/71 B845 874 4/CAB5791 B845 8?80<82<5 /7 >5C/>4 6/<</:07= A7401DA95468C915B5>=5' 0! ;89 9;5 1A09 1C;54A<5 D>/D5>9325</7=1 9/ 9;5D<8079066N071909A90/7 00!
56574879 / C<80B54 091 >0=;9 874 0795>51907>51D5C9/61A09D>/D5>930795>B1 /6874A745>84/CAB579C8<<5481HFA028<8I 48954 &,L :;0C; 01 07 >4A <87=A8=5B8>E5481M9>871<890/7/6 :;0C;01B8>E5481M 8! - 20 -
000! ;5>5 01
401DA95 259:557 4565748791 07
/(L$% 874
/%$% 0?! 56574879 /&C<80B07=;01>0=;9909<5874 0795>519/?5>9;51A09D>/D5>939;>/A=;874 A745>/75>055>574>8890<8748<1/;81 1591 AD C<80B /6 ;5 ;8?07= D5>65C954 9;5 909<5 /7 8CC/A79 /6 ;01 C/7907A/A1 D/115110/7 874 57@/3B579 /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 81 8=80719 1804 55>574>8 890< 8749;5D<8079066N071909A90/7 % ;5>02A78<A745>9;515159/684B0995468C91 ;81D>/C554549/878<3K59;5C815/69;5D8>9051;/A=; 9;5D<807906689D8>8/69;5D<8079;81D<5845482/A99;5 HFA028<8IDA>D/>954<3011A54239;59;57660C5878=5>/6 9;5D59090/75>N071909A90/709;81401987C540915<66>/B9;5 1804 4/CAB579 /7 9;>55 C/A791 0>19<3 9;89 9;5 1804 4/CAB579 :81 7/9 10=754 /> 011A54 23 9;5 8@@848
81;557 5C/74<3 7/ D/115110/7 07 95>B1 /6 9;5 1804 4/CAB579 :81 5?5> 45<0?5>54 /> D8>954 :09; 23 9;5 D<8079066N 071909A90/7 ;0>4<3 9;5 1804 4/CAB579 404 7/9
- 21 -
C>5895 873 >0=;9 909<5 /> 0795>519 07 68?/A> /6 456574879
/ & ;5 68C91 78>>8954 07 9;5 D<8079 8<1/ 0740C895 9;899;5D<8079066<58>7982/A95M01957C5/61AC;4/CAB579 /7<3AD/7>5C50D9/69;5:0975111ABB/719/D>/4AC59;5 18044/CAB5798749/=0?59;55?0457C581011A54239;5 0?0<
/A>9 07 9;5 1A09 60<54 23 456574879 / 8=80719 456574879 /%07 /%$% ( ;5 >02A78< /7 68C91 874 /7 8DD>5C0890/7 /6 5?0457C5 81 1557 89 D8>8=>8D;1%+ %L 874 % /6 9;5 0BDA=754@A4=B579874/>45>;81C/B59/9;5C/7C<A10/7 /6 4565748791 7/9 2507= 82<5 9/ D>/?5 9;53 2507= 07 D/115110/7/69;51A09D>/D5>93
A>9;5> @A1906307= 091 C<80B /6 2507= /:75> 07 D/115110/7 /6 9;5 1A09 D>/D5>93 D<8079066071909A90/7 ;81 >5<054 AD/7 9;5 />45> 48954 ,% D81154 23 9;5 874 >02A78< A745> 9;5 >/?010/71 /6 8>7898E8
5>9807
- 22 -
78B1 2/<090/7 C9 ,LL C/765>>07= 9;5 >0=;9 /7 9;5 D<8079066071909A90/7:;0C;;81>5B80754A7401DA954 + <8079066 N 071909A90/7 ;81 8<1/ >5<054 AD/7 9;5 />45> D81154 23 9;5 0?010/7 57C; /6 9;01
/A>9 07 #>09 DD58< /& /6 %( :;0C; 8>/15 /7 8CC/A79 /6 401DA95/7D83B579/6C/7?5>10/76551874C;8>=51;01 68C9 @A1906051 9;5 C<80B /6 9;5 D<8079066N 071909A90/7 2507= /:75>07D/115110/7/69;51A09D>/D5>938749;518B5;81 >5B80754A70BD58C;54 L ;5>02A78<;819;A1C/B59/9;5C/7C<A10/7/6 D<8079066N071909A90/7;8?07=51982<01;54091>0=;9909<5874 0795>519/?5>9;51A09D>/D5>93:;0<59;54565748791;8?5 680<549/D>/?59;50>>0=;9909<5874D/115110/7
1 >5=8>41 9;5 >5<087C5 D<8C54 23 9;5 4565748791 /7 9;5 4/CAB579 C8<<54 81 HFA028<8I D>/4AC54 89 M 874 8!
75C5118>3 9/ >565> 9;5 1804 4/CAB579:;0C;>584181A745>' - 23 - O>871<890/76>/B>4A9/7=<01;<87=A8=5 )028<8D>5D8>5423/660C5/65C>598>3C/BB09955/K8A778:8>8AKA>= A<28>=8;8>55649&1987A8>3,L < //6)028<85=0195> 8B5 689;5> 78B5 8=5 8=5 8195/CC'P$/ % 878255>574>8890<>5104579 019 /7=>511 /BB09955A<28>=8 <8C5:;5>5<87401=0?57 & 0<<8=5 8;B870DA>8 F 74 019 A<28>=8;8>556 8B5/6</C8<093 ( E>8B A798 109A8954 89 9890/7 /84 A<28>=8 A>D/15/6=>879 /> /719>AC90/7/6874;0;8?87 57=9; >58 + />9;/A9;9/:8>41819'%6559 />9;/A9;9/:8>41#519'(6559 #049; L 819#5199/:8>41 />9;'%6559 819#5199/:8>411/A9;'&6559 A>D/15/6=>K79 />C/719>AC90/7/6874;0;8?87 819 , />90/7/63 /&(25</7=19/8>=8;1; #519 />90/7 /6 3 /&( P C5B579 >/84 9/:8>4119890/7 /A748>051 />9;' />90/7/63 /&(/68>=8;;8>556 /A9; % />90/7 /6 3 /&( P /84 9/:8>41 0:875;8;0 /71045>890/7 6/> ;8?07= D/115110/7 & A2@5C99/D83B579/6358><398M51 5B8>E1 ( 1 D5> />45> /6 8K8>89; 8@@848 81;557 )028<8 49 &9; 87 ,L 07 60<5 7/L$,L <874 9/98<<3 B581A>07= %&,,!1F34107 3 /&( 109A8954 89 8;B870DA>8 A<28>=8 9890/7 >/84 D/115110/7 /6 9;5 <874 01 45<0?5>54 A745> 9;0145541A2@5C99/D83B579 /6 358><3 98M51 1($ Q % D8015 D5> 38>4 9;01 )028<801=0?57 >871<895423 7:8>3D019 /A>9 >5B0151A<28>=8R , 5>A18</69;518044/CAB5790740C89519;891A09 D>/D5>93 :81 DA>D/>954<3 =0?57 9/ /75 55>574>8 890< >5104579 /6 019>0C9 /7=>511 8>93 A<28>=8 6/> - 24 - C/719>AC90/7/6874;0;8?87/7D83B579/6D>5B0AB/6 1($D5>877AB % 58>754570/> /A715<6/>9;5D59090/75>680><3 1A2B0919;899;/A=;9;518044/CAB57901>5<054AD/70901 7/9 D/1102<5 9/ 81C5>9807 81 9/ :;0C; /6 9;5 93D51 /6 C/7?5387C5C/795BD<8954A745><8::/A<418044/CAB579 68<<07 5?5>9;5<511;51A2B0919;89;8125579;5D>8C90C5 6/> C/765>>07= 9;5 >0=;9 909<5 874 0795>519 23 9;5 />0=078< /:75>0768?/A>/69;5D5>1/719/:;/B09:81=>879545 5BD;890C8<<3 1A2B091 9;89 9;5 1804 4/CAB579 7/9 2507= 401DA9549;5D<8079066071909A90/701519/DD546>/BD<58407= 8739;07=C/79>8>39/9;518B5 % ;518041A2B0110/7C877/9258CC5D9546/>9;5 >581/719;899;5B/45/6C>58907=$C/7?5307=/69;5>0=;9 909<5 874 0795>519 /> 5M907C90/7 /6 9;5 18B5 07 873 0BB/?82<5 D>/D5>93 01 =/?5>754 A745> 9;5 D>/?010/71 /6 >87165> /6 >/D5>93 C9 >584 :09; 9;5 D>/?010/71 /6 5C90/7 L /6 9;5 74087 5=019>890/7 C9 :;0C; :5>5 07 D<8C5 BAC; D>0/> 9/ 011A87C5 /6 9;5 4/CAB579 81 9;89 /6 - 25 - DA>D/>954 HFA028<8I 81 D5> M ;5>56/>5 5?57 06 9;5>5 01 873 8B20=A093 :09; >5=8>4 9/ 9;5 789A>5 /6 9;5 4/CAB5799;518B5C877/925>584079/874C/719>A549/ ;8?5 C>58954 873 >0=;9 909<5 /> 0795>519 07 68?/A> /6 9;5 4565748791 />5M907=A01;07= 873 C/>>51D/7407= >0=;9 909<5 />0795>51907>51D5C9/69;51A09D>/D5>93079;5D<8079066 071909A90/7 %% 7?05:/6456574879 /1874%C<80B07=874 84B09907=9;50>>0=;9909<58740795>519079;51A09D>/D5>93 9/ 25 9;>/A=; 874 A745> 1804 4/CAB579 HFA028<8I 18B5 ;8?07=2557011A54239;5D<8079066071909A90/79;53C877/9 159AD8C/79>8>3D<58401DA907=9;5>0=;9909<5/>0795>519 /69;5D<8079066N071909A90/7 %& 56574879 /&:;/198E51;01C<80B/?5>9;5 D>/D5>93 9;>/A=; 874 A745> 9;5 DA>D/>954 =>87955 78B5<3 55>574>8 890< A745> 9;5 1804 HFA028<8I C877/9 ;8?587325995>909<59;87:;89;011/C8<<54=>879/>;84 6552<5D<58/684?5>15D/115110/7159AD;817/5665C9/7 9;59>A5/:75>78B5<39;5D<8079066N071909A90/70781BAC; - 26 - 811AC;8D<58:81159AD/7<38=8071955>574>8890<7 873 5?579 456574879 /& ;81 7509;5> D<58454 7/> 51982<01;549;55<5B5798>307=>5405791/6D<58/684?5>15 D/115110/7 %( ;/A=;8>=AB579:81844>51154:09;>5=8>49/ 9;5 >5FA0>5B579 /6 D<8079066N071909A90/7 155E07= =>879 /6 /CCAD87C3>0=;9A745>9;578B12/<090/7C99;01 /A>9 4/7/96074098DD>/D>08959/84?5>99/9;518B50781BAC; 819;54565748791817/95482/?58>57/9159907=AD873 84?5>15 >0=;9 909<5 /> 0795>519 9/ 9;89 /6 9;5 D<8079066N 071909A90/7 7 873 5?579 4565748791 ;8?5 7/ </CA1 9/ FA5190/7 9;5 D>/D>0593 /> /9;5>:015 /6 9;5 1804 />45> 07 9;515D>/C55407=1 % ;5 >02A78< ;81 84?5>954 9/ 874 84@A40C8954 AD/7 9;5
011A51 9;89 :5>5 6>8B54 6/> 091 C/71045>890/7 ;5>02A78<9;A1079;5C/71045>54?05:/69;01 /A>9;81 C/BB09954 7/ 5>>/> /> 0<<5=8<093 07 D81107= 9;5 0BDA=754 @A4=B579874/>45> - 27 - %+ />9;586/>51804>581/71D59090/71680<8749;5 18B5 8>5 A4=B579 874 />45> D81154 23 9;5 >02A78<01C/760>B54 )' *""+ % # 019 /'< /'+ '