Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63135 (KAR)
THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. BABU AND ORS
MFA/200944/2023 · 2025-10-30
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63135 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63135 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$ "
#$ !$%! ""
&%' ()
""
*
(
)
! "
#
$ %&
% $
% '
"%
% '
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$ % ( $
%
"%
% )
)
(
$
% ( $
%
"
%
! *
* )
'#
+)!#
( '
)$, (
*
(
)
$ %
%
' $
% '
"%
% '
! #
- 3 -
$
%
'
$
%
"%
% )
(
$
%&
%
'
$
%
"%
*
)
%
! "
)* $
)
-
'#
+)!#
( '
(
)$,
)$. ' /0
(
('
%
- 4 -
%
1(
1( (
$ !%
1(
#
2,&&$) 34 53678 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: D<7?7@4 2&/$& 34 53678 9: ;<7 A6@3B@=;>=87? 7A;32= +)!# 25 ;<7 2;2? 7<3A674 A;
, !52? 4<2?; E;<7 A;F# 973=G @GG?37H78 9: ;<7 I>8GB7=; @=8 @D@?8 8@;78 C@4478 9: ;<7 883;32=@6 7=32? 3H36 (>8G7 @=8 @6@9>?@G3 !52? 4<2?; E;<7 ?39>=@6F# 3= 2)$, 3=A7 ;<7 A<@667=G7 34 ;2 ;<7 4@B7 I>8GB7=; 92;< ;<7 @CC7@64 @?7 <7@?8;2G7;<7?@=8A2BB2=I>8GB7=;34C@4478
@A;4 G3H3=G ?347 ;2 ;<7 5363=G 25 ;<7 @CC7@64 9?3756: 4;@;78 @?7 ;<@; 2= @; @92>; /% ;<7 A6@3B@=; @62=G D3;< 2=7 @663J@?I>= D7?7 C?2A7783=G ;2D@?84 >63 (@=;3 @63=G@?@:@=@ 7BC67 9: D@6J 2= . =7@? 2==@ ?244 @; ;<@; ;3B7 ;<7 8?3H7? 25 @ @I@I7BC27<3A6797@?3=G7G2 .)$.)&+A@B7
- 5 -
D3;< <3G< 4C778 3= ?@4< @=8 =7G63G7=; B@==7? 8@4<78 ;2 ;<7 A6@3B@=; @=8 @663J@?I>= 8>7 ;2 D<3A< ;<7: 92;< 5766 82D= @=8 ;<7 A6@3B@=; 4>4;@3=78 3=I>?374 D<7?7@4 @663J@?I>= 4>AA>B978 ;2 ;<7 3=I>?374 2= , BB783@;76: @5;7? ;<7 @AA387=; ;<7 A6@3B@=; D@4 4<35;78 ;2=3;7824C3;@6@6@9>?@G3D<7?73=<7;22J;?7@;B7=; 5?2B;29:4C7=83=G<>G7@B2>=; ;2D@?84<34;?7@;B7=;<7?752?7;<7A6@3B@=;<@453678@ C7;3;32= >=87? 7A;32= // 25 ;<7 A; 477J3=G A2BC7=4@;32=;D@4C67@878;<@;<74C7=;<>G7@B2>=; ;2D@?84B783A@67KC7=474A2=H7:@=A7A<@?G747;A ) =47?H3A7254>BB2=4?74C2=87=;24;2) <@H7 @CC7@?78 ;<?2>G< ;<73? A2>=476 74C2=87=; 24 @=8<@H7=2;53678;<73?29I7A;32=4D<7?7@4?74C2=87=;
2) =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: 53678 D?3;;7= 4;@;7B7=; 87=:3=G ;<7@H7?B7=;4B@873=;<7A6@3BC7;3;32= & = ;<7 9@434 25 C67@83=G4 25 ;<7 C@?;374 ;<7 6@3B4?39>=@65?@B78;<7344>74@=8;<7?7@5;7??7A2?878
- 6 -
;<7 7H387=A7 <7 A6@3B@=; 3= 2?87? ;2 C?2H7 ;<7 A@47 7K@B3=78<3B4765 @4 '.@=8 @642 7K@B3=78 ;<782A;2? @4 '.
@=8 G2; 7K<393;78 82A>B7=;4 =@B76: K ;2 K+
= 97<@65 25 ?74C2=87=; 2) 3;4 2553A3@6 D@4 7K@B3=78@4'.@=8G2;7K<393;7882A>B7=;K<7 6@3B4 ?39>=@6 9: ;<7 3BC>G=78 I>8GB7=;
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
7@?=78 A2>=476 52? ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: <@4?@3478;<752662D3=GA2=;7=;32=4%
- 7 -
@ 3?4;6: ;<7 8?3H7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 D@4 =2;<2683=G@H@638@=87557A;3H78?3H3=G63A7=A743=A7;<7 3=4>?78 <@4 H326@;78 ;<7 C263A: A2=83;32= ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=:34=2;63@967;2C@:;<7A2BC7=4@;32= 9
7A2=86: 7H7= ;<2>G< ;<7 A6@3B@=; A6@3B ;<@;
<7 D@4 7@?=3=G 4$. C7? B2=;< ;<7 4@B7 34 =2;
74;@9634<78 9: C?28>A3=G 82A>B7=; <7 ?39>=@6 <@4 @4474478;<73=A2B725;<7A6@3B@=;@;4$.D<3A< 342=;<7<3G<7?4387 A <3?86: <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; 7H7= ;<2>G< ;<7 3=I>?3744>557?789:;<7A6@3B@=;@?7B3=2?3==@;>?7;<7 A6@3B@=; <@4 7K@B3=78 82A;2? @4 '. '. 34 =2; @ ;?7@;7882A;2?@=8<7<@4=2;@4474478;<763B9834@9363;:
=87? ;<747 A3?A>B4;@=A74 ;<7 D<267 928: 834@9363;: @44744789:;<7?39>=@6@;&0342=;<7<3G<7?4387 8 @4;6: <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; A2=4387?3=G ;<7 @G7 @=8 @H2A@;32= 25 ;<7 A6@3B@=; ;<7 2H7?@66 A2BC7=4@;32= @D@?8789:;<7?39>=@634I>4;@=8?7@42=@967@=8<7=A7 42>G<;52?834B344@625;<7@CC7@6536789:;<7A6@3B@=;
- 8 -
/ 7@?=78A2>=47652?;<7A6@3B@=;<@4?@3478;<7 52662D3=GA2>=;7?A2=;7=;32=4% 3 3?4;6:;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:<@4=2;?@3478@=: 29I7A;32=?7G@?83=G;<7H@6383;:25;<78?3H3=G63A7=A725;<7 8?3H7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 @=8 ;<7: <@H7 =2; 4>BB2=78;<782A>B7=;45?2B;<72D=7?25;<72557=83=G H7<3A672?;<753?4;;3B7;<7:<@H7?@3478;<34A2=;7=;32= 9752?7;<342>?;>?;<7?<7A2=;7=878;<@;;<78?3H7?25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 D@4 <@H3=G @ H@638 @=8 7557A;3H7 8?3H3=G 63A7=A7 ;2 ;<@; 7557A; <7 <@4 C?28>A78 ;<7 L7?2K A2C:25;<78?3H3=G63A7=A725;<78?3H7?@62=GD3;<B7B2 33 7A2=86: <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; 8>7 ;2 ;<7 @AA387=;
;<7 A6@3B@=; <@4 4>557?78 G?37H2>4 3=I>?: 7 <@4 7K@B3=78;<782A;2?@4'.=<347H387=A7;<782A;2? <@4 87C2478;<@; A6@3B@=; <@4 4>557?78 &0 834@9363;: ;2 ;<7 D<267 928: <7 ?39>=@6 <@4 @4474478 ;<7 D<267 928:834@9363;:@;&0@=8;<74@B7342=;<762D7?4387 333 @4;6: <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; 8>7 ;2;<7 @AA387=; ;<7 A6@3B@=; <@4 4>557?78 G?37H2>4 3=I>?: 7 D@4 3=C@;37=;
- 9 -
52?@C7?32825,8@:47<@44>557?7862;25C@3=8>?3=G ;?7@;B7=;@=8<7<@4;24>557?;<7>=<@CC3=744@=8C@3= ;<?2>G<2>;<3463572=4387?3=G;<73=I>?3744>4;@3=789: ;<7A6@3B@=;@=8A2=4387?3=G;<7@G7@=8@H2A@;32=25;<7 A6@3B@=;;<7A2BC7=4@;32=@D@?8789:;<7?39>=@6>=87? ;<7<7@84251624425@B7=3;37411C@3=@=84>557?3=G41@=8 2;<7?3=A387=;@67KC7=474@?72=;<762D7?4387@=8<7=A7 42>G<;52?7=<@=A7B7=;25A2BC7=4@;32= + 7@?8 ;<7 67@?=78 A2>=476 52? ;<7 C@?;374 @=8 C7?>478;<7I>8GB7=;@=8@D@?825;<7?39>=@6
; 34 =2; 3= 834C>;7 ;<@; A6@3B@=; <@4 4>557?78 3=I>?3743=@?2@8;?@553A@AA387=;2AA>??782= 8>7 ;2 ?@4< @=8 =7G63G7=; 8?3H3=G 25 ;<7 8?3H7?
25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 37 @I@I 7BC2 7<3A67 97@?3=G 7G2 .)$.)&+<74C7A353AA@4725;<7A6@3B@=;34 ;<@;@42=;<78@;725@AA387=;;<78?3H7?25;<72557=83=G H7<3A67D@4<2683=G@H@638@=87557A;3H78?3H3=G63A7=A7;2 8?3H7 ;<7 4@38 H7<3A67 <7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: <@4 =2;
B@87 @=: 7552?;4 ;2 4>BB2= ;<7 2D=7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=G
- 10 -
H7<3A67 ;2 C?2H7 ;<@; 8?3H7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 D@4 =2; <2683=G @ H@638 @=8 7557A;3H7 8?3H3=G 63A7=A7 2? ;<7 53?4;;3B7=4>?@=A72BC@=:34?@343=G;<34344>79:563=G ;<7@CC7@69752?7;<342>?;H7=2;<7?D347;<7A2>=476 @CC7@?3=G52?;<7A6@3B@=;<@453678@B7B27=A6243=G;<7 L7?2KA2C:258?3H3=G63A7=A725;<78?3H7?25;<72557=83=G H7<3A6737@9>3:@=;A67@?6:4<2D4;<@;8?3H7?D@4 <2683=G ;<763A7=A7 5?2B , ;2 ) <7 @AA387=; 2AA>??78 2= @4 2= ;<7 8@;7 25 @AA387=;;<78?3H7?25;<72557=83=GH7<3A67D@4<@H3=G@ H@638 8?3H3=G 63A7=A7 <7?752?7 ;<7 ?39>=@6 <@4 ?3G<;6:
5@4;7=78 ;<7 63@9363;: 2= ;<7 3=4>?7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=G H7<3A67 , <7 A6@3B@=; A6@3B4 ;<@; <7 D@4 7@?=3=G 4$. C7? B2=;< 7 <@4 =2; C?28>A78 @=: 82A>B7=;;2C?2H7<343=A2B7<7?752?73=;<7@947=A7 25C?225253=A2B7=2;32=@63=A2B7<@4;297@4474478 4 C7? ;<7 G>38763=74 344>78 9: ;<7 @?=@;@J@ ;@;7 7G@6
7?H3A74 >;<2?3;:52?;<7@AA387=;;@J7=C6@A73=;<7:7@? - 11 -
;<7=2;32=@63=A2B7<@4;297;@J7=@;4+$. CB 4 C7? D2>=8 A7?;353A@;7 ;<7 A6@3B@=; <@4 4>4;@3=78 &0 D<267 928: 834@9363;: <7 82A;2? 3= <34 7H387=A7 <@4 4;@;78 ;<@; ;<7 A6@3B@=; <@4 4>557?78 834@9363;: 25 &0 ;2 D<267 928: <7?752?7 ;@J3=G 3=;2 A2=4387?@;32= ;<7 87C243;32= 25 ;<7 82A;2? @=8 3=I>?374 B7=;32=78 3= ;<7 D2>=8 A7?;353A@;7 ;<7 ?39>=@6 <@4 ?3G<;6: ;@J7= ;<7 D<267 928: 834@9363;: @; &0 <7 A6@3B@=; 34 @G78 @92>; :7@?4 @; ;<7 ;3B7 25 ;<7 @AA387=;@=8B>6;3C637?@CC63A@967;2<34@G7G?2>C34EF <>4 ;<7 A6@3B@=; 34 7=;3;678 52? A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))$. !4+MMM&0# 2= @AA2>=; 25 16244255>;>?73=A2B71 <7 =@;>?7 25 3=I>?374 4>GG74;4 ;<@; ;<7 A6@3B@=;B>4; <@H7 977=>=87??74;@=8 ;?7@;B7=;52? @ C7?32825;<?77B2=;<4<7?752?7;<7A6@3B@=;347=;3;678 52? A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4)$. !4+M) B2=;<4# >=87?;<7<7@8E6244253=A2B78>?3=G6@38>CC7?328F
- 12 -
>7 ;2 ;<7 @AA387=;;<7A6@3B@=;<@4 4>557?78 G?37H2>4 3=I>?374 @=8 @642 >=87?G2=7 4>?G7?: 7 <@4 4>557?7862;25C@3=8>?3=G;?7@;B7=;@=8<7<@4;24>557? D3;<;<7834@9363;:4;@;789:;<782A;2?;<?2>G<2>;<346357 2=4387?3=G ;<7 4@B7 D7 7=<@=A7 ;<7 A2BC7=4@;32= @D@?878 9: ;<7 ?39>=@6 >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 1C@3= @=8 4>557?3=G415?2B4$.;24&$.@=8>=87?;<7 <7@8 25 16244 25 @B7=3;3741 5?2B 4$. ;2 4&$.
) 2=4387?3=G ;<7 =@;>?7 25 3=I>?374 ;<7 A2BC7=4@;32=@D@?8789:;<7?39>=@6>=87?2;<7?<7@84 34I>4;@=8?7@42=@967 & <>4 ;<7 A6@3B@=; 34 7=;3;678 ;2 ;<7 52662D3=G A2BC7=4@;32=%
+,-./012.3.4-5 42-5-.1-04/ /06054-4 7819- 5273.0: &/' /06054-4 78192/ 351 &/' @3=@=84>557?3=G4
& 783A@67KC7=474 / /
- 13 -
228=2>?34<B7=; A2=H7:@=A7@=8 @;;7=8@=;A<@?G74
244253=A2B78>?3=G 6@38>CC7?328
) 24425@B7=3;374
& 244255>;>?73=A2B7 )& )) >;>?7B783A@67KC7=474
10: ; ;
=;<7?74>6;;<752662D3=G2?87?34C@4478%
@# <7@CC7@6340::6-42.,051 9# <7 I>8GB7=; 25 ;<7 6@3B4 ?39>=@6 34 B2835378 A# <7 A6@3B@=; 34 7=;3;678 ;2 @ ;2;@6 A2BC7=4@;32=25/;( 8# <7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: 34 83?7A;78 ;2 87C243; ;<7 A2BC7=4@;32= @B2>=; @62=G D3;< 3=;7?74; N /0 C@ 5?2B ;<7 8@;7 25 5363=G 25 ;<7 A6@3B C7;3;32= ;366 ;<7 8@;7 25 ?7@63L@;32= D3;<3= @ C7?328 25 43K D77J4
- 14 -
5?2B ;<7 8@;7 25 ?7A73C; 25 A2C: 25 ;<34 I>8GB7=; 7# = H37D 25 ;<7 2?87? 8@;78 ) C@4478 9: ;<34 2>?; ;<7 A6@3B@=; 34 =2;
7=;3;678 52? 3=;7?74; 2= ;<7 7=<@=A78 A2BC7=4@;32=52?;<7876@:78C7?32825&+, 8@:43=5363=G;<7@CC7@6
4( &" ' $
4( &!$%!' $
34;2% 62%-