Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63132 (KAR)
SABIYABANU @ SABIYA SULTANA W/O M.A. EKHALEQ AND ORS v. HARMAIL SINGH S/O CHARAJEET SINGH AND ANR
MFA/200144/2021 · 2025-11-03
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63132 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63132 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ %& $
%& "&#"
$$
'#( )
! ! ""
! "
""
# $$
#%
& '"
" ! (
)"" *
'
+
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
, & %' "
,
,
" ! !(
, '
"-
"" '
" ! !(
)"
*'
(%
"
"
" '
+
""
&*+'
% "
+ ' ##(
" " ',
+
""
,
%(%( " ' ##(
" "
' ,
" .&!&!((/
%0
.& (((((/ 0
"" , '
- 3 -
1,
"
1, , '
& *" 1,
"+
23. 455647 89:6; 6<=3>9 &*+ >? =26 >=>;
'623<76.<=% *26;6394?=6;;6?6;;6:=>4.@=26<=A?>;
.2>;=+ 24. B669 ?376: BC =26 <743D49=. <247769E39E =26 F8:ED69=49:4G4;::4=6:%(%( 54..6:BC=26";7 693>; 3H37 ,8:E6 49:
474B8;4E3 39 ' >##(
4<=. E3H39E ;3.6 => =26 ?3739E >? =26 455647 B;36?7C .=4=6:4;6=24=>9( (4=4B>8=(!5DG269 =26 :6<64.6: I2476J G4. 5;><66:6: 47>9E G3=2 23. ;674=3H6. 39 4 >G6;4 B64;39E ;6E3.=;4=3>9 >"/ (%$(& =>G4;:. 23. 94=3H6 4= =24= D>H6D69= =26 :;3H6; >? =26 7>;;C B64;39E 6E >/( /(% <>D39E ?;>D >55>.3=6 :3;6<=3>9 G3=2 ;4.2 49: 96E73E69= D4996;
49: :4.26: 4E439.= =26 H623<76 >? =26 :6<64.6: . 4
- 4 -
;6.87= >? =26 4?>;6.43: 4<<3:69= =26 :6<64.6: .8.=4396: E;36H>8.39F8;36.49:.8<<8DB6:=>=2639F8;36. 26 <743D49=. ?376: 4 56=3=3>9 89:6; 6<=3>9 ## >? =26 <= .66I39E <>D569.4=3>9 ?>; =26 :64=2 >? =26 :6<64.6:47>9EG3=239=6;6.=
5>9 .6;H3<6 >? 9>=3<6 =26 ;6.5>9:69= > 45564;6: =2;>8E2 <>89.67 49: ?376: G;3==69 .=4=6D69= :69C39E =26 4H6;D69=. D4:6 39 =26 <743D 56=3=3>9
26 ;6.5>9:69= >:6.53=6.6;H3<6>?9>=3<6:3:9>=45564;
B6?>;6=26
;3B894749:G4.574<6:6K/54;=6
! 9 =26 B4.3. >? =26 5764:39E. >? =26 54;=36. =26 743D. ;3B8947?;4D6:=263..86.49:=26;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=26 6H3:69<6
26
;3B8947 BC 3D58E96: F8:ED69= 49: 4G4;:24.54;=7C477>G6:=26<743D56=3=3>949:267:=24= =26 <743D49=. 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 <>D569.4=3>9 >? .&!&!((/47>9EG3=239=6;6.=4==26;4=6>?%054 49: :3;6<=6: =26 ;6.5>9:69= > => :65>.3= =26 69=3;6
- 5 -
<>D569.4=3>9 4D>89= 47>9E G3=2 39=6;6.= 639E 4EE;36H6:=265;6.69=45564724.B669?376:
# 26764;96:<>89.67?>;=26<743D49=.24.;43.6:=26 ?>77>G39E<>9=69=3>9. 4+ 3;.=7C =26 <743D49=. 4..6;= =24= =26 :6<64.6: G4. 4E6:4B>8=(C64;.4==26=3D6>?=264<<3:69=6<64.6:
G4. >G96; >? 7>;;36. 49: G4. E6==39E .(((((/ => .(((((/ 39<>D6 ?;>D =26 7>;;36. 56; C64; 6 G4. 47.> G>;I39E 4. 494E6; 39 >4:G4C. 49: E6==39E .474;C>?.!(((/5D8==26
;3B894724.4..6..6:
9>=3>94739<>D6>?=26:6<64.6:4..((((/G23<23. >97>G6;.3:6 B+ 6<>9:7C 4. 56; =26 74G 743: :>G9 BC =26 >9AB76 85;6D6 >8;= 39 =26 <4.6 >? *$" +
, 39 <4.6. G26;6 =26 :6<64.6: G4. .67?/ 6D57>C6:>;;6<63H6:4?3K6:.474;C494::3=3>9>?(0>? =26 6.=4B73.26: 39<>D6 =>G4;:. @?8=8;6 5;>.56<=.A 3. - 6 -
G4;;49=6:G269=26:6<64.6:G4.B67>G=264E6E;>85>? ( C64;. 26
;3B8947 24.
4::6: >97C !0 39.=64: >? (0
<+ 23;:7C 4. 56; =26 74G 743: :>G9 BC =26 >9AB76 85;6D6 >8;= 39 =26 <4.6 >? $" *.85;4+ =26<743D49=.4;669=3=76:?>;.!(((/=>G4;:.@7>..>? 6.=4=6A49:.!(((/=>G4;:.@?896;476K569.6.A
:+ >8;=27C 4. 56; =26 F8:ED69= >? =26 >9AB76 85;6D6 >8;= 39 =26 <4.6 >? -# + . &
. ,64<2>?=26<743D49=.3.69=3=76:=><>D569.4=3>9 >?.((((/89:6;=26264:>?@7>..>?7>H649:4??6<=3>9 49:<>9.>;=38DA
6+ 4.=7C <>9.3:6;39E =26 4E6 49: 4H><4=3>9 >? =26 :6<64.6: =26 >H6;477 <>D569.4=3>9 4G4;:6: BC =26 ;3B89473.394:6J84=649:>9=267>G6;.3:6 3=2 =26 4B>H6 <>9=69=3>9. =26 764;96: <>89.67 .>8E2==>477>G=26455647
- 7 -
& 9 =26 >=26; 249: =26 764;96: <>89.67 ?>; =26 9.8;49<6 >D549C 24. ;43.6: =26 ?>77>G39E <>89=6;/ <>9=69=3>9. 4+ 3;.=7C 6H69 =2>8E2 <743D49=. <743D6: =24= 26 G4. >G96: 7>;;36. 49: 26 G4. 64;939E .(((((/ => .(((((/56;C64;624.9>=5;>:8<6:39<>D6=4K ;6=8;9>;B49I.=4=6D69==>.2>G=24=2624.4939<>D6 >?.(((((/=>.(((((/56;C64;49:2624.9>= 5;>:8<6:49CB49I.=4=6D69==>.2>G=24=26G4.64;939E .!(((/56;D>9=24.4.474;CG>;I39E4.4D494E6;
39 >4:G4C. 26;6?>;6 =26
;3B8947 24. ;3E2=7C 4..6..6: =26 D>9=27C 39<>D6 >? =26 :6<64.6: 4. .((((/56;D>9=2 B+ 6<>9:7C .39<6 =26 <743D49=. 24H6 9>= 6.=4B73.26:
=26 39<>D6 >? =26 :6<64.6: =26C 4;6 9>= 69=3=76: ?>; <>D569.4=3>9=>G4;:.@?8=8;65;>.56<=.A <+ 23;:7C >9 455;6<34=3>9 >? >;47 49: :><8D69=4;C 6H3:69<6 49: <>9.3:6;39E =26 4E6 49: 4H><4=3>9 >? =26
- 8 -
:6<64.6: =26 >H6;477 <>D569.4=3>9 4G4;:6: BC =26 ;3B89473.F8.=49:;64.>94B76 :+ 4.=7C3973E2=>?=263H3.3>969<2:6<3.3>9>?=23. >8;=39=26<4.6>? &" - # # # ' ./
0 . $
. (=26;4=6>?39=6;6.=4G4;:6:BC=26
;3B8947 4=%054>9=26<>D569.4=3>94D>89=3.>9=2623E26; .3:6 3=2 =26 4B>H6 <>9=69=3>9. =26 764;96: <>89.67 .>8E2==>:3.D3..=26455647
64;: =26 764;96: <>89.67 ?>; =26 54;=36. 49:
56;8.6:=26F8:ED69=49:4G4;:>?=26
;3B8947
% = 3. 9>= 39 :3.58=6 =24= I2476J :36: 39 ;>4: =;4??3< 4<<3:69= ><<8;;6: >9 ( ( :86 => ;4.2 49:
96E73E69= :;3H39E >? :;3H6; >? 7>;;C B64;39E 6E >/ ( /(%
- 9 -
( H69 =2>8E2 =26 <743D49=. 24. <743D6: =24= :6<64.6: G4. 64;939E .!(((/ 56; D>9=2 4. 4 494E6; G>;I39E 39 >4:G4C. 49: .(((((/ => .(((((/ 39<>D6 ?;>D =26 7>;;C 56; C64; 6K<65= 5;>:8<39E =26 76==6; 3..86: BC >4:G4C. =26C 24H6 9>=5;>:8<6: 49C .474;C <6;=3?3<4=6 49: 9>= 5;>:8<6: =26 B49I.=4=6D69=>;39<>D6=4K;6=8;9=>.2>G=24=26G4. E6==39E39<>D6>?.(((((/=>.(((((/56;C64; >9.3:6;39E=264E6>?=26:6<64.6:49:23.4H><4=3>9G6 4;6 >? =26 >5393>9 =24= D>9=27C 39<>D6 >? =26 :6<64.6:
24.
=> B6 4..6..6: 4= .(((/ 56; D>9=2 39.=64: >? .((((/=4I69BC=26
;3B8947
26<743D49=. 24H6 9>= 5;>:8<6:49C :><8D69=. => 5;>H6=26:4=6>?B3;=2>?=26:6<64.6:39<6:6<64.6:
G4. 4E6: 4B>8= ( C64;. =26
;3B8947 24. ;3E2=7C <>9.3:6;6:!0>?=2639<>D6>?=26:6<64.6:?>;?8=8;6 5;>.56<=. 28. =26 39<>D6 <>D6. => .!(((/
26 D87=35736;45573<4B76=>=264E6E;>853.@!A39<6=26;6 4;6 .3K :6569:69=. =2 >? =26 39<>D6 24. => B6
- 10 -
:6:8<=6:=>G4;:.23.56;.>9476K569.6.<<>;:39E7C=26 <743D49=.4;669=3=76:?>;<>D569.4=3>9>?.(!(((/ *.!(((LL!L+ >9 4<<>89= >? @7>.. >? :6569:69<CA
9 4::3=3>9 =26 <743D49=. 4;6 69=3=76: => <>D569.4=3>9>?.!(((/>94<<>89=>?@7>..>?6.=4=6A 49: <>D569.4=3>9 >? .!(((/ >9 4<<>89= >? @?896;47 6K569.6.A
9H36G>?=2674G743::>G9BC=2685;6D6>8;=39 =26 <4.6 >? *.85;4+ <743D49= > 3. 69=3=76: ?>; .((((/ ?>; @.5>8.47 <>9.>;=38DA <743D49= >. 49: ! 4;6 69=3=76: => .((((/64<289:6;=26264:>?@54;69=47<>9.>;=38DA 49: <743D49= ># 3. 69=3=76: => .((((/ 89:6; =26 264:>?@?37347<>9.>;=38DA
28. =26 <743D49=. 4;6 69=3=76: => =26 ?>77>G39E <>D569.4=3>9
- 11 -
12345678494:3; :83;34736:5 194784 '5( >..>?:6569:69<C (!((( 896;476K569.6. !((( >..>?6.=4=6 !((( 5>8.47<>9.>;=38D ((((
"4;69=47<>9.>;=38D #(((( 37347<>9.>;=38D (((( 76<
/
! 9=26;6.87==26?>77>G39E>;:6;3.54..6:
4+
264556473. B+
26 F8:ED69= >? =26 743D. ;3B8947 3. D>:3?36:
<+
26 <743D49=. 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 =>=47 <>D569.4=3>9 >? 5
/0
4. 4E439.= .&!&!((/ 4G4;:6: BC =26 ;3B8947
:+ >77>G39E =26 F8:ED69= >? =26 3H3.3>9 69<2 >? =23. >8;= 39 =26 <4.6 >? @,
A *.85;4+ =26 69249<6:
<>D569.4=3>9 .2477 <4;;C 39=6;6.= 4= #0 56;4998D
- 12 -
6+
26 9.8;49<6 >D549C 3. :3;6<=6: => :65>.3= =26 <>D569.4=3>9 4D>89= 47>9E G3=2 39=6;6.= ?;>D =26 :4=6 >? ?3739E >? =26 <743D 56=3=3>9 =377 =26 :4=6 >? ;6473M4=3>9 G3=239456;3>:>?.3KG66I.?;>D=26:4=6 >?;6<635=>?<>5C>?=23.F8:ED69=
?+ 26 455>;=3>9D69= :65>.3= 49: ;6764.6 >? 4D>89= .2477 B6 D4:6 39 =6;D. >? =26 4G4;:>?=26
;3B8947
E+ 9 H36G >? =26 >;:6; :4=6: (%( 54..6:BC=23.>8;==26<743D49=.4;69>= 69=3=76: ?>; 39=6;6.= >9 =26 69249<6:
<>D569.4=3>9?>;=26:674C6:56;3>:>? :4C.39?3739E=26455647
:0 '$ ( &
:0 '"&#"( &
" 3.= >7 >