- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' !!%% ' ! " # $ % & % ''($ ')*$ '+(+$ && Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ,+(+$ ! " & - $ # & & $"$# & & '.# / & & '$*$$( $$+ & (+(+' $+' & 0 !!%% ' && % % ! " # - 3 - $ '+(+$$ % & % ''($ ')*$ '+(+$$ ! " & $- )$+ # & & $"$# & & & '$*$$( $$+ & 0 & & 1 - 4 - $ " 1 # 2343 567 .883.94 .:3 ;<93= .>.<?45 523 @=>A3?5 .?= .6.:= <? 7$$+ =.53= $*$$( 8.443=BC5237@:57;:93?<7:<D<9@=>3.?= .9.B@:.><";7:427:5E523:<B@?.9F# ?G@:3=H9.<A.?5.>3=C3.:467:I<?>.4.? 44<45.?5 3.H23: <? 7D3:?A3?5 4H2779 A35 6<52 .? .HH<=3?57?$($.?=;<93=.H9.<A835<5<7?H9.<A<?> H7A83?4.5<7? 7; 4$+' 23 :<B@?.9 .;53: H7?4<=3:<?>3?5<:3A.53:<.97?:3H7:=>:.?53=.?.A7@?5 7;4(+(+'6<52<?53:345.5523:.537;*J8.;:7A523 =.537;835<5<7?5<99:3.9<K.5<7? & >>:<3D3= BC 523 4.<= 7:=3: 523 <?G@:3=H9.<A.?5 8:3;3::3= 52<4 .883.9 <? 62<H2 <5 <4 H7?53?=3=52.5A3.>3:.A7@?54.:3>:.?53=;7:8.<?.?= 4@;;3:<?>97447;.A3?<5<34.?=.947A3=<H.93L83?434.?= - 5 - ?7.A7@?54>:.?53=;7:7523:23.=42@4:3M@3453=;7: 3?2.?H3A3?57;523H7A83?4.5<7? & ?4@:.?H3H7A8.?C.9478:3;3::3=52<4.883.9<? 62<H2 <5 <4 H7?53?=3= 52.5 523 ?4@:.?H3 7A8.?C 2.4 <44@3= ?75<H3 57 523 76?3: 7; 523 D32<H93 .?= :3M@3453= 2<A57;@:?<42523H78C7;=:<D<?>9<H3?H3B@523;.<93=57 =74744@H2.?.=D3:43<?;3:3?H36.4=:.6?.>.<?45 2<A ;7: D<79.5<7? 7; 53:A4 .?= H7?=<5<7?4 7; 523 879<HC 2@4:3M@3453=;7:8.C.?=:3H7D3:C + 5 <4 ;@:523: H7?53?=3= BC 523 ?4@:.?H3 7A8.?C 52.5 .88399.?5 2.4 ?75 3L.A<?3= 523 =7H57: 57 427652.54234@45.<?3=>:<3D7@4<?G@:<34&@:523:527@>2 523:3 .:3 ?7 A3=<H.9 =7H@A3?54 57 4276 23: A3=<H.9 3L83?43457.?3L53?57;4+(+523:<B@?.93::3=<? >:.?5<?> 523 4.<= .A7@?5 23:3;7:3 :3M@3453= ;7: A7=<;<H.5<7?7;5237:=3: * 3.:=523.:>@A3?547;B7524<=34 - 6 - 88399.?5H9.<A.?56.4.>3=C3.:467:I<?> .4 44<45.?5 3.H23: <? 7D3:?A3?5 H2779 <? .9>2.? .?=>355<?>.4.9.:C7;4()'83:A7?52 @5523 4.9.:C 49<8 <4 ?75 ;<93= B3;7:3 523 7@:5 57 8:7D3 23: <?H7A3 23 A35 6<52 .? .HH<=3?5 7? $($ 523:3;7:3 52<4 7@:5 ;<?=4 <5 :3.47?.B93 57 5.I3 23: ?75<7?.9 <?H7A3 .4 4+' 83: A7?52 .4 83: 523 >@<=39<?347;.:?.5.I. 3>.93:D<H34@527:<5C236.4 2748<5.9<K3= ;7: =.C4 .?= 423 ;<93= 523 A3=<H.9 B<994 @?=3: L+ ;7: .? .A7@?5 7; 4+(+' 4 83: 523 7@?= 3:5<;<H.53 ;<93= @?=3: L+ H9.<A.?5 4@45.<?3= =3?57.D397: ;:.H5@:3 7; @883: .?53:<7: 53352 .?= 7523: <?G@:<34 7D3:;.H37?@883: .?= 9763: 9<8 H2<? ?3.: 93;5 3C3 7? 23.= 93;5 I?33 .?= 7? 7523: 8.:54 7; 523 B7=C 62<H2.:3>:<3D7@4<??.5@:3483:=<4H2.:>34@AA.:C, L4236.4.=A<553=7?$($.?==<4H2.:>3=7? ($232.44@45.<?3=<?G@:C7D3:;.H37?@883: .?=9763:9<AB88399.?5H9.<A.?52.4?753L.A<?3=523 - 7 - =7H57:.44@H2523M@345<7?7;.44344<?>523=<4.B<9<5C7: >:.?5<?>;@5@:33.:?<?>H.8.H<5C=734?75.:<43 ( ?D<367;523.B7D3=<4H@44<7?H7?4<=3:<?>523 ?.5@:37;<?G@:<3452<47@:5;<?=4<5:3.47?.B9357.6.:= .?.A7@?57;4'@?=3:52323.=?G@:<34 ) 23 :<B@?.9 >:.?53= 4' ;7: 8.<? .?= 4@;;3:<?> 4$' ;7: 9744 7; .A3?<5<34 .?= 4+(+' ;7: A3=<H.9 3L83?434 .?= <5 ?33=4 ?7 <?53:;3:3?H3.?=52<47@:5;<?=4<5:3.47?.B9357>:.?5.? .A7@?5 7; 4' ;7: 3L5:. ?7@:<42A3?5 5:.?487:5.5<7?.?=.553?=3=H2.:>34 $ 23A<>25?752.D3.553?=3=.?C7523:67:I.5 93.45 ;7: . 83:<7= 7; 567 A7?524 523:3;7:3 4$+' "+L#576.:=497447;<?H7A3=@:<?>9.<=@883:<7= $$ ? .99 523 575.9 H7A83?4.5<7? H7A34 57 4$++(+'6<52<?53:345 .5 523:.537; *J 83: .??@A ;:7A523=.537;835<5<7?5<99:3.9<K.5<7? - 8 - $ 23:<B@?.9239=52.5:3487?=3?574$.?= .:3 G7<?59C .?= 43D3:.99C 9<.B93 57 8.C 523 H7A83?4.5<7? .?= =<:3H53= 523 ?4@:.?H3 7A8.?C 57 =3874<5 523 .A7@?5 @5 .4 83: 523 H7?53?5<7? 7; 523 ?4@:.?H3 7A8.?C523:3<4?7=:<D<?>9<H3?43.44@H2?7.A7@?5 6.4 =3874<53= 5<99 57=.C 3?H3 52<4 7@:5 ;<?=4 <5 :3.47?.B9357=<:3H5523?4@:.?H37A8.?C57=3874<5523 H7A83?4.5<7?6<52<?53:345 $ 23 H7A83?4.5<7? .6.:=3= BC 523 :<B@?.9 <4 A7=<;<3=.4@?=3: ()*+ ,-./0.+ $?G@:<34 ' .<?.?=4@;;3:<?> ' 7447;.A3?<5<34 $' 3=<H.93L83?434 +(+' +:.?487:5.5<7? 3L5:. ?7@:<42A3?5 .?= .553?=.?5 H2.:>34 ' * 7447;3.:?<?>=@:<?>9.<=@8 83:<7=;7:567A7?524 $+' /)1 & - 9 - HH7:=<?>9C 523 .88399.?5 <4 3?5<593= ;7: . 575.9 H7A83?4.5<7?7;+&.4.>.<?454(+(+' $ ?523:34@95523;79976<?>7:=3:<48.443= <# 752.883.94.:3 - <<# 23 .88399.?5H9.<A.?5 <4 3?5<593= ;7: 575.9 H7A83?4.5<7?7;4$++(+' 6<52<?53:345.5 *J 83: .??@A ;:7A 523 =.53 7; 835<5<7? 5<99 :3.9<K.5<7? <<<# ?4@:.?H3 7A8.?C <4 =<:3H53= 57 =3874<5 4$++(+' 6<52 <?53:345 .5 523 :.53 7; *J 6<52<?$A7?52;:7A523=.537;52<47:=3:.?= .5 9<B3:5C 57 :3H7D3: 523 4.A3 ;:7A 523 76?3: 7;523D32<H93 <D# ? 4@H2 =3874<5 H9.<A.?5.88399.?5 <4 83:A<553=576<52=:.65233?5<:3.A7@?5.97?> 6<52<?53:345.HH:@3=7?<5 +*& 2%!! 3 $ <457$97