- 1 - !!" !#!$ % & $'"$"$ ($) ! ! " # # " $%$& ! Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( ! &)&$ * (&&$ *# )"& ## ! + , # ! -./ 012.2.34 ./ 5.617 89 :;7<=142 >47 3?71?/ 81.4< ><<?.1@17 89 2-1 3?71? 7>217 &)&$ >/ 01? 441A;?1 >/ B166 >/ 3?71? 7>217 (&&$ >/ 01? 441A;?1# 0>//17 .4 3)"& 34 2-1 5.61 35 77.2.34>6.@.6#;7<1>47# >2>6>8;?<. & /;.2 .43'%"&)C>=123815.61789 ?1/0347142-1?1.4><>.4/22-1012.2.341?/342-15.6135 77.2.34>6.@.6#;7<1>47# >6>8;?<.53?2-1?16.1535 =>47>23?9 .4:;4C2.34 >47 0?3-.8.23?9 .4:;4C2.34 32 /;?0?./.4<69 012.2.341?/ -1?1.4 B-3 B1?1 >??>917 >/ 715147>42/ ?1=>.417 >8/142 >47 /;.2 B>/ 71C?117 1A 0>?21B.2-2-153663B.4<3?71? - 3 - ! " # $ % & ' ( &D -1 06>.42.55 /11E.4< >//./2>4C1 35 2-1 ?.>6 3;?223.=061=1422-1 >53?1/>.7 3?71? 5.617 .4 A1C;2.34 12.2.343)"&45;?2-1?>4C12-1?1352-1.=0;<417 3?71? ->/ 8114 0>//17 -1 B>??>42 .//;17 89 2-1 A1C;2.4<3;?27.?1C2.4<2-18>.6.5523.=061=1422-13?71? ->//122-1>6>?=C34/2?>.4.4<2-1012.2.341?/23>00?3>C- 2-./3;?2 &F 1>?417 C3;4/16 >001>?.4< 53? 2-1 012.2.341?/ 34 .4/2?;C2.34/ 35 2-1 3==.//.341? 35 012.2.341? 3 B-3 ./ 01?/34>669 0?1/142 8153?1 2-./ 3;?2 /;8=.2/ 2->2 - 4 - 2-17?>.4><1 6>41 B-.C- ./ 6>.7 .4 2-1 6>47 93%F"35 ?>-=>0;? ./2 >6>8;?<. 3@1? B-.C- 2-1 ?1/0347142 06>.42.55C6>.=/-1?6323D81.4</.2;>217./3?.<.4>669 > >:>E>6;@1 ->2 2-1 6>93;2 ./ ;4>;2-3?.G17 49 >621?>2.343?=1776.4<B.2-2-17?>.4><16>41B3;67->@1 7?>/2.C1551C2/.42->2.2->/>032142.>635>551C2.4<->6535 2-1 7?>.4><1 /9/21= 35 2-1 .29 1 /;8=.2/ 2->2 2-1/1 >/01C2/352-1=>221?C3;67432818?3;<-2232-1432.C135 2-1?.>63;?2>/2-1012.2.341?/715147>42/2-1?1.4B1?1 06>C171A0>?21 &$ 1 5;?2-1? /;8=.2/ 2->2 > ./C12.2.343D'"&F;471??71?*;61D35./ 5.617/11E.4<?1C>66352-11A0>?213?71?B-.C-./0147.4< C34/.71?>2.34 8153?1 2-1 @1?9 />=1 3;?2 B-.C- ./ 2?9.4< 2-1 1A1C;2.34 012.2.34 >/ B166 3B1@1? 2-1?1 ./ 43 .421?.= 0?321C2.34 <?>4217 >/ 2-1?1 B>/ > 716>9 .4 5.6.4< 2-1 />.7 ./C 12.2.34 53? 6>CE 35 E43B617<1 35 2-1 1A 01?21 :;7<=142 >47 71C?11 0>//17 2 ./ ;471? 2-1/1 C3=0166.4<C.?C;=/2>4C1/-1/;8=.2/2->22-1012.2.341?/ 432->@.4<>621?4>21?1=179->@1>00?3>C-172-./3;?2 - 5 - &' 4 ?1/034/1 2-1 61>?417 C3;4/16 B-3 ->/ 1421?17 C>@1>23? 53? 2-1 ?1/0347142/ /;8=.2/ 2->2 2-1 012.2.341?/ -1?1.4 ->@1 <.@14 ;471?2>E.4< 8153?1 2-1 1A1C;2.4< 3;?2 /11E.4< 2.=1 53? ?1C34/2?;C2.34 35 >621?4>217?>.4><1>47$7>9/2.=1./<?>421753?2-1/>.7 0;?03/1 .4C12-1?1./434C3=06.>4C1352-1.=0;<417 3?71? ->/ 8114 0>//17 ?1H;.?.4< 43 .421?51?14C1 14C1 /11E/7./=.//>6352-1B?.2012.2.34 &( 1>?71?;/172-1?1C3?7/ &% 1C1//>?9 >2 2-./ :;4C2;?1 23 4321 2->2 .5 >/ >661<17 89 2-1 012.2.341?/ > 6>93;2 .4 B-.C- 2-1 ?1/0347142./C6>.=.4<-1?063223->@1/.2;>217./53?=17 34 > >:>E>6;@1 B-.C- .2/165 ./ .=01?=.//.861 ?1H;.?1/ 0?381 .423 2-1 =>221? 5.A.4< ?1/034/.8.6.29 >47 >CC3;42>8.6.296.1/>22-1355.C1?/>47>;2-3?.2.1/B-3->@1 86.//5;6692;?4172-1.?86.471912.6643B - 6 - &) 3B1@1?.4@.1B352-11A0>?21:;7<=142>47 71C?11->@.4<81140>//17>47=./C166>413;/0?3C117.4</ ./ 0147.4< C34/.71?>2.34 2-./ 3;?2 ?15?>.4 5?3= =>E.4< >495;?2-1?38/1?@>2.34.42-1=>221? & >@.4</>.72->22-1.4214/.29352-1.=0>C2.4 2-1 1@142 35 ?1=3@>6 35 2-1 7?>.4><1 >/ 061>717 >83@1 >6/3 C>4432 81 .<43?17 1.2-1? -1 0?.@>21 ?.<-2 0.2217 ><>.4/22-10;86.C?.<-2/2-16>221??1H;.?1/0?151?14C1.4 2-1C3661C2.@1.421?1/2350;86.C>26>?<1 4 2->2 @.1B 35 2-1 =>221? 2-./ 012.2.34 ./ B.2-2-153663B.4<7.?1C2.34/ -1 ?.>6 3;?2 8153?1 B-3= 2-1 ./C 12.2.34 3D'"&F ./ /2>217 23 ->@1 8114 5.617 89 2-1 012.2.341?/ >47 0147.4< C34/.71?>2.34 /->66 2>E1 ;0 2-1 />.7 =>221? >47 7./03/1 35 2-1 />=1 .4 >CC3?7>4C1B.2-6>B >/ 1A017.2.3;/69 >/ 03//.861 B.2-.4 &D =342-/ 5?3= 2-1 7>21 35 ?1C1.02 35 C1?2.5.17 C309 35 2-./ 3?71? .66 /;C- 2.=1 2-1 0?3C117.4</ .4 1A1C;2.34 0?3C117.4< .4 3)"&/->6681E102.4>819>4C1 - 7 - -./ 3?71? ./ 0>//17 .4 C34/.71?>2.34 35 2-1 /;8=.//.34/=>71892-161>?417C3;4/1653?2-1 012.2.341?/ .4 2-1 01?/34>6 0?1/14C1 35 2-1 3==.//.341?>00?./.4<>83;22-1/1?.3;/41//35 ?1=3@>6 35 2-1 7?>.4><1 >47 >6/3 23 >@3.7 ;423B>?71@142;>6.2.1/232-10;86.C>26>?<1 -1 0>?2.1/ >?1 >2 6.81?29 >6/3 23 1A063?1 2-1 03//.8.6.29 35 >=.C>861 ?1/36;2.34 35 2-1 =>221? B-.C-./6152232-1B./73=352-10>?2.1/ "*+ ($"$) '! ## ./2363