- 1 - !" #! $ %!#! $ %!"%& " ! !## '&( ) ! " # # $%&%' # (( # (( # ) Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $%&% ' # # *% $%&%' ## %* $%&%' ! &+ #(+ # ('," # ( ( -'!" ( # # ( # ' # # '%* & # # # # ( # # # . # . # - 3 - % ! . # " /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 -'!" <= ;/4 #<;<9 4/0:541:;>&&!/494072=;4994=49948;<21?;/4:;@=<9 1/<9;" /21 A447 =0548 AB ;/4 :520C27;1 :/25547D07D ;/4 E68DC47; 278 2F298 82;48 ' 321148 AB ;/4 470<9 0G05 68D4 278 885 # /25H0 07 # <'%* & (2:;1 D0G07D 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507D <= ;/4 233425 A904=5B 1;2;48 294 ;/2; <7 -*& F/47 ;/4 84:42148 212F292E F21 39<:44807D <7 C<;<9:B:54 A42907D 94D01;92;0<7 <I'& I*- 25<7D F0;/ /01 =2;/49 =9<C 25A29D2;<0829/25H09<287429<770H490:9<112;;/2; ;0C4 <74 <B25 7=0458 C<;<9:B:54 A42907D 94D01;92;0<7 <I'& I&&&%:2C4=9<C<33<10;48094:;0<7072921/ 278 74D50D47; C27749 821/48 2D2071; ;/4 C<;<9:B:54 <= ;/4 84:42148 1 2 94165; <= ;/4 2=<941208 2::0847; ;/4 84:42148 161;20748 D904G<61 07E69041 278 16::6CA48 ;< ;/407E69041 - 4 - ' /4 :520C27;1 =0548 2 34;0;0<7 67849 4:;0<7 ** <= ;/4 :; 144H07D :<C34712;0<7 =<9 ;/4 842;/ <= ;/4 84:4214825<7DF0;/07;4941; 3<7 149G0:4 <= 7<;0:4 ;/4 9413<7847; <1 278 /2G4 23342948 ;/9<6D/ :<67145 278 =0548 ;/409 143292;4 F90;;47 1;2;4C47; 847B07D ;/4 2G49C47;1 C284 07 ;/4 :520C34;0;0<7 % 7 ;/4 A2101 <= ;/4 3542807D1 <= ;/4 329;041 ;/4 520C190A6725=92C48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/4 4G0847:4 /4 90A6725 AB 0C36D748 E68DC47; 278 2F298/21329;5B255<F48;/4:520C34;0;0<7278/458;/2; ;/4 :520C27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< 2 :<C34712;0<7 <= 1* I25<7DF0;/07;4941;2;;/492;4<=*J32 278 8094:;48 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B ;< 843<10; ;/4 :<C34712;0<7 2C<67; 25<7D F0;/ 07;4941; 407D 2DD904G48;/4394147;233425/21A447=0548 * /45429748:<67145=<9;/4:520C27;1/21920148;/4 =<55<F07D:<7;47;0<71 - 5 - 2" (091;5B ;/4 :520C27;1 21149; ;/2; ;/4 84:42148 F21 2D482A<6;B42912;;/4;0C4<=;/42::0847;278/282 C<7;/5B07:<C4<=1'%'>% IABF<9H07D21074C2707 # 278 AB 8<07D ;/4 2D90:65;694 F<9H 278 429707D 1% I 3C <F4G49 ;/4 211411C47; <= C<7;/5B 07:<C4<=;/484:421482;1'% IAB;/490A672501 67E61;0=048278499<74<61 A" 4:<785B 21 349 ;/4 52F 5208 8<F7 AB ;/4 <7@A54 6394C4 <69; 07 ;/4 :214 <= ! *#"!!+ ! , 07 :2141 F/494 ;/4 84:42148 F21 145=I 4C35<B48<994:40G482=0K4812529B272880;0<7<='J<= ;/441;2A501/4807:<C4;<F2981?=6;69439<134:;1@ :" /0985B21349;/4E68DC47;<=;/4<7@A546394C4 <69;07;/4:214<= ! -& + . % . , 42:/ <= ;/4 :520C27;10147;0;548;<:<C34712;0<7<=1 I67849 ;/4/428<=?5<11<=5<G42782==4:;0<7278:<71<9;06C@ - 6 - 8" 21;5B :<71084907D ;/4 2D4 278 2G<:2;0<7 <= ;/4 84:42148 ;/4 <G49255 :<C34712;0<7 2F29848 AB ;/4 90A67250107284L62;4278<7;/45<F491084 0;/ ;/4 2A<G4 :<7;47;0<71 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 1<6D/;;<255<F;/4233425 - ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B/21 :<7;47848;/2; <7 23394:02;0<7<= <925278 8<:6C47;29B 4G0847:4 278 :<71084907D ;/4 2D4 278 2G<:2;0<7 <= ;/4 84:42148 ;/4 <G49255 :<C34712;0<7 2F29848AB;/490A672501E61;2789421<72A54 0;/ ;/4 2A<G4 :<7;47;0<7 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 1<6D/;;<801C011;/4233425 & 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148;/4E68DC47;2782F298<=;/490A6725 > ; 01 7<; 07 80136;4 ;/2; 212F292E 8048 07 ;/4 9<28 ;92==0: 2::0847; <::69948 <7 -*& 864 ;< 921/ 278 74D50D47; 90807D <= ;/4 <==47807D G4/0:54 AB 0;1 90849 /4 90A6725 /21 90D/;5B 21141148 ;/4 C<7;/5B 07:<C4 <= ;/4 - 7 - 84:42148 21 1'% I 349 C<7;/27890D/;5B 8486:;48 ;/<=;/407:<C4<=;/484:42148=<93491<7254K347141 <;/42=<94120807:<C4'J/21;<A428848<72::<67; <= =6;694 39<134:;1 07 G04F <= ;/4 52F 5208 8<F7 AB ;/4 <71;0;6;0<7 47:/ <= ;/4 6394C4 <69; 07 /#" !0 !16392" /61 ;/4 C<7;/5B 07:<C4 :<C41 ;< 1%% I !1'% M 'J" 07:4 ;/494 294 84347847;10;012339<3902;4;<8486:; ;/<=;/407:<C4 <=;/484:42148;<F29813491<7254K34714127894C20707D 2C<67;/21;<A4;2H4721/01:<7;90A6;0<7;<;/4=2C05B /484:42148F212D482A<6;B42912;;/4;0C4<=;/4 2::0847;278C65;03504923350:2A54;</012D4D9<6301?@ /61 ;/4 :520C27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< :<C34712;0<7 <= 1 2 !1%%NNN' " <7 2::<67; <= ?5<11<=84347847:B@ 7 2880;0<7 ;/4 :520C27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< :<C34712;0<7 <= 12 <7 2::<67; <= ?5<11 <= 41;2;4@ 278 :<C34712;0<7 <= 12 <7 2::<67; <= ?=6749254K347141@ - 8 - 7G04F<=;/452F52088<F7AB;/46394C4<69;07 ;/4 :214 <= / !0 !16392" :520C27; < F0=4 <= ;/4 84:42148 01 47;0;548 =<9 :<C34712;0<7 <=12 67849;/4 /428<= .5<11<= 13<6125:<71<9;06C.:520C27;<1<7<=;/484:4214801 47;0;548=<9:<C34712;0<7<=1267849;/4/428 <=?5<11<=32947;25:<71<9;06C@278:520C27;<1'278 32947;1 <= ;/4 84:42148 294 47;0;548 =<9 :<C34712;0<7 <= 12 42:/ 67849 ;/4 /428 <= ?5<11 <= =05025 :<71<9;06C@ /61 ;/4 :520C27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< ;/4 =<55<F07D :<C34712;0<7 345617896:6;5< ;95<56857;1 3:6896 '1( <11<=84347847:B %-'' (6749254K347141 % <11<=41;2;4 % <11<=13<6125:<71<9;06C <11<= 2947;25:<71<9;06C - 9 - <11<=(05025:<71<9;06C & 87= ' 7;/494165;;/4=<55<F07D<984901321148 2" /4233425017==>5;9647<8 A" /4E68DC47;<=;/4520C190A672501C<80=048 :" /4:520C27;129447;0;548;<2;<;25:<C34712;0<7<= 1 2212D2071;1* I2F29848 AB;/490A6725 8" /4 716927:4 <C327B 01 8094:;48 ;< 843<10; ;/4 :<C34712;0<72C<67;25<7DF0;/07;4941;2;*J32 =9<C ;/4 82;4 <= =0507D <= ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7 ;055 ;/4 82;4<=94250O2;0<7F0;/0723490<8<=10KF44H1=9<C ;/482;4<=94:403;<=2:<3B<=;/01E68DC47; 4" 7 94134:; <= 233<9;0<7C47; 01 :<7:49748 :520C27; <0147;0;548=<9'%J:520C27;<0147;0;548=<9 'J+ :520C27; <' 9413<7847; <' /49407 01 47;0;548=<9%J278:520C27;< 9413<7847;< - 10 - /49407 01 47;0;548 =<9 J <= ;/4 :<C34712;0<7 2C<67; 6; <= ;/4 1/294 <= :520C27; < 9413<7847;<1'27804F0=4=2;/49278C<;/49 <=;/484:42148%J1/255A4H43;07=0K48843<10;07 27B72;0<7250O48A27H=<923490<8<=%B4291278;/4 94C20707D%J1/255A49454214807;/409=2G<69/4 1/294 <= 1<7 <= ;/4 84:42148 1/255 A4 H43; 07 =0K48 843<10;=<923490<8<=%B4291 =" 7G04F<=;/4<984982;48'%321148AB;/01 <69; ;/4 :520C27;1 294 7<; 47;0;548 =<9 07;4941; <7 ;/447/27:48:<C34712;0<7=<9;/48452B483490<8<= 82B107=0507D;/4233425 !;2 '#!( % !;2 '"%& "( % ## 01;<5<%%