- 1 - !! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) ! " # ! $! % & ' ( ! $ !& $) $ #* $' + ***, #&" $' ' ##" ' $ &$ '! $& **-* $ *#( $ $ ' #****** & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #. $ ' $ ' / $ ' $ ! $& 0 $0 1$! $ # 234435 !678495: ;57 ;<;=7 7;:97 **-* >? @;??97 >5 $ 3?- *#( ;57 *#( AB :C9 77>:>35;D >?:=>2: ;57 9??>35? !6789 36=: ;57 77D $ >7;= ?>::>58 ;: ;?;E;F;D;B;5 G3= ?C3=: H:C9 :=>A65;DI" C9@=9?95:;@@9;D>?G>D97;8;>5?::C9!678495: ;57;<;=7>5$ 3 *#(C92D;>4;5:<;?;897# B9;=? ;: :C9 :>49 3G :C9 ;22>795: >529 :C9 2D;>4;5: <;? 4>53= C>? 43:C9= ;? ; 5;:6=;D86;=7>;5 G>D97 2D;>4 @9:>:>35 A9G3=9:C9:=>A65;D?99F>58234@95?;:>353G?#***** ;D358 <>:C >5:9=9?: ? @9= J C9 ?6?:;>597 G=;2:6=9 3G & ;:=:" & K 497>;D @>2357BD9 & =:" 8=;:9 :39 J#- >? :C9 <3657 29=:>G>2;:9 ;57 :C9 32:3= >??697 7>?;A>D>:B29=:>G>2;:96579=J# - 3 - C92D;>4;5:9J;4>597:C932:3=>9&;57 C9 >??697 J# 7>?;A>D>:B 29=:>G>2;:9 ;57 ;??9??97 :C9 7>?;A>D>:B3G:C92D;>4;5:;:,*.:3:C9@;=:>26D;=D>4AA6: :C9?;49<;?53:235?>79=97AB:C9:=>A65;D;57;<;=797; 8D3A;D 234@95?;:>35 3G ?#**** ;57 :C9=9G3=9 =9L69?:97G3=95C;529495:3G:C9234@95?;:>35?@9=:C9 J# 7>?;A>D>:B 29=:>G>2;:9 >: ;GG92:? :C9 ;2:>E>:>9? 3G 7;>DB D>E>58>5;A>D>:B:3?>::>582=3??D98?;57?L6;::>58?@9=:C9 <365729=:>G>2;:9 J#-:C92D;>4;5:?6?:;>597G=;2:6=93G =>8C::>A>;;57G>A6D;<C>2C>?8=>9E36?>55;:6=9C932:3= ;??9??97:C97>?;A>D>:B;?,*.:C9=9G3=9:C>? 36=:G>57?>: =9;?35;AD9:3:;F9# =73G:C9?;49;?#.C92D;>4;5: 49: <>:C ;22>795:35**(*#(6::3@=3E9C>?>52349 C9 C;? 53: G>D97 ;5B >52349 @=33G C9=9G3=9 ;? @9= :C9 86>79D>59? 3G :C9 ;=5;:;F; :;:9 98;D 9=E>29? 6:C3=>:B :C9>523493G:C92D;>4;5:>?:3A9:;F95;:?#* G3= :C9 B9;= *#( 9 <;? ;897 # B9;=? ;57 :C9 46D:>@D>9= >? # , 9= 235:=; D9;=597 2365?9D G3= :C9 5?6=;529 234@;5B?6A4>:?:C;:?>529:C92D;>4;5:C>4?9DGC;??:;:97 - 4 - C>? >52349 3G ?#**** @9= 435:C >5 C>? 2D;>4 @9:>:>35 :C9=9G3=9=9L69?:97:C>? 36=::3235?>79=:C9>523493G:C9 2D;>4;5:;:?#**** @9=435:C 5E>9<3G:C9?6A4>??>353G:C9D9;=5972365?9D G3= :C9 5?6=;529 234@;5B :C>? 36=: >? ;: D>A9=:B :3 :;F9 D95>95:E>9<;57:38=;5:M6?:234@95?;:>35:3:C92D;>4;5:? >5 ;DD :C9 43:3= ;22>795: 2D;>4? &C95 :C9=9 >? 53 >52349 @=33G :C>? 36=: >? =9DB>58 35 :C9 2C;=: @=9@;=97 AB :C9 ;=5;:;F;:;:998;D9=E>29?6:C3=>:B>:>?G3=:C9 36=: :3235?>79=<C>2C9E9=>?A959G>2>;D:3:C9>5M6=97C9=9G3=9 235?>79=>58 :C9 G;2: :C;: >: >? ; A959G>2>;D D98>?D;:>35 :C>? 36=:G>57?>:=9;?35;AD9:3:;F9:C9>523493G:C92D;>4;5: ;:?#* @9=435:C9529:C9D3??3GG6:6=99;=5>58 2;@;2>:B>?;?6579=0 ?#* )#)#)#.N?*-* - C9 2D;>4;5: C;? G>D97 J#( J* ;57 J*:3?C3<:C;:C9C;??@95:;?643G?**** :3<;=7? 497>2;D 9J@95?9? 35?>79=>58 :C9 ?;49 :C9 :=>A65;D C;? ;<;=797 ; ?64 3G ?#*#(* :3<;=7? - 5 - 497>2;D 9J@95?9? ;57 >: 5997? 53 >5:9=G9=9529 9 <;? C3?@>:;D>O97 G3= 9>8C: 7;B? 35?>79=>58 C>? ;89 @9=>37 3G C3?@>:;D>O;:>35;573:C9==9D9E;5:G;2:3=?:C>? 36=:G>57?>: =9;?35;AD9:3;<;=7;?643G?**** :3<;=7?@;>5;57 ?6GG9=>58 ?*** :3<;=7? D3?? 3G ;495>:>9? ;57 ?**** :3<;=7? :=;5?@3=:;:>35 9J:=; 536=>?C495: ;57 ;::957;5:2C;=89?94>8C:C;E953:<3=F97G3=;:D9;?: 435:C? 9529 ; ?64 3G ?(* >? ;<;=797 :3<;=7? D3?? 3G >52349 76=>58 D;>7 6@ @9=>37 9529 :C9 :3:;D 234@95?;:>35>?;?6579=0 !* +,-./01+2.,342 0523 # 3??3GG6:6=99;=5>582;@;2>:B ?*-* $97>2;D9J@95?9? ?#*#(* ;>5;57?6GG9=>58 ?**** , 3??3G;495>:>9? ?*** =;5?@3=:;:>35 9J:=; 536=>?C495: ;57 ;::957;5: 2C;=89? ?**** - 3?? 3G >52349 76=>58 D;>7 6@ @9=>37 ?(* 3,* . 6 9;=597 2365?9D G3= :C9 5?6=;529 234@;5B ?6A4>:? :C;: :C9 234@95?;:>35 8=;5:97 AB :C9 :=>A65;D >? 79@3?>:97A9G3=9:C9:=>A65;D 223=7>58DB:C9G3DD3<>583=79=0 - 6 - >" C9;@@9;D>?;DD3<97>5@;=:+ >>" C9 2D;>4;5: >? 95:>:D9 :3 :3:;D 234@95?;:>353G?-,*** ;D358<>:C>5:9=9?: ;: :C9 =;:9 3G -. @9= ;5564 G=34 :C9 7;:9 3G @9:>:>35 :>DD :C9 7;:9 3G =9;D>O;:>35 ;? ;8;>5?: ?#**** + >>>" C9 5?6=;529 234@;5B >? 7>=92:97 :3 79@3?>: :C9 95C;5297 234@95?;:>35 3G ?*,*** ;D358<>:C>5:9=9?:<>:C>5;@9=>373G 359435:CG=34:C97;:93G:C>?3=79=+ >E" 5 ?62C 79@3?>: :C9 2D;>4;5: >? @9=4>::97:3<>:C7=;<:C995C;5297234@95?;:>35 ;4365:;D358<>:C>5:9=9?:;22=69735>: .-6 &%!! ( $ >?:30#D30 0!