Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63113 (KAR)

RAMANNA AND ANR v. MALATI J.SHAH AND ANR

MFA.CROB/200011/2019 · 2025-11-05

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"!#$ % "&"'""! " "'' ($) ""& ! " # ! $ " % % $ &% % '( ' )$ " % %)" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ &% % '( * % % $* " " ) * ! +', $''' * # $-*!# # .-$'' '--'# )'--' ) & $ " % % ' )$ " % %)" $ &% % '( ! # ! * " " ) * - 3 - ' * ! "', $('( $)# $ . '' ) $ ) ) '--' .-$'' & ) % % / &! 0123 450 12678094: ;< =012903 >;79:0= <;2 ?;45 450 @124A0: ' 50:04B;1@@01=:120<A=03161A9:4450C7368094 1931B12331403'--'A9 ;.-$''.@1::03?D 450 33A4A;91=09A;2 AEA=7360193 AC1D1@721 !<;2:5;24F4502A?791=G# - 4 - * 0>01:03804BA45191>>A3094;9.'' >=1A8 @04A4A;9 B1: <A=03 ?D 450 @12094: ;< 450 30>01:03 >=1A8A96>;8@09:14A;9;<:($502A?791=1<402 >;9:A302A96 094A20 81402A1= ;9 20>;23 6219403 18;794 ;< :*$BA45A94020:414(H@1<2;8'4;4A== 4503140;<201=AI14A;9 . 0A96 1662A0E03 ?D 450 :1A3 ;2302 ;''$'A:@20<02203?D450 9:7219>0>;8@19D193 81A9=D >;9409303 4514 450 32AE02 ;< 450 E05A>=0 51: 9; 32AEA96 =A>09>0 193 A4 18;794: 4; EA;=14A;9 ;< 4028: 193 >;93A4A;9: ;< 450 @;=A>D 193 450D 120 9;4 =A1?=0 4; @1D 450 >;8@09:14A;9 50 >2;:: ;?C0>4A;9: A9 2;? ;'$' A: <A=03 ?D 450 >=1A8194: A9 B5A>5 A4 A: >;9409303 4514 450 >=1A8194 B1: 6044A96 1 :1=12D ;< :.$@028;9451:@02J:1=12D>024A<A>140?74450 42A?791= 51: 41K09 ;9=D :*$ @02 8;945 193 801602 18;794:B020621940379302450;45025013:19320L70:403 <;209519>08094;<450>;8@09:14A;9 - 5 - 7931=AK B1: 1603 ' D012: 193 B1: B;2KA96 A9 450 <1>4;2D 14 )1:5AB1=A 0 804 BA45 1>>A3094 ;9 .'' 50 >=1A8194: 51E0 @2;37>03 :1=12D >024A<A>140 14 J ?74 450 :180 51: 9;4 ?009 >;9:A30203 0 804 BA45 1>>A3094 ;9 .'' 5020<;20 1: @02 450 67A30=A90: ;< 450 "129141K1 4140 061= 02EA>0: 745;2A4D 450A9>;80;<45030>01:03A:4;?041K0914:.'$@02 8;9450B1:1603'D012:19345087=4A@=A02A:F-G193 50A:094A4=03<;2.H4;B123:<74720@2;:@0>4:193HA: 4; ?0 3037>403 4;B123: @02:;91= 0J@09:0: 1: 50 B1: 798122A031:;94503140;<4501>>A309409>0450=;::;< 30@09309>DB;7=3>;80:4;% :*'$M.HH'-N:..$ - =1A8194 ;: 193 ' 120 450 @12094: ;< 450 30>01:03 09>0 >=1A8194 ;: 193 ' 120 094A4=03 <;2 1 :78;<:.$01>54;B123:<A=A1=>;9:;24A7850D120 1=:;094A4=03<;21:78;<:*$4;B123:>;9E094A;91= 5013:09>04504;41=>;8@09:14A;9B;7=3?01:79302% "* +,-./01+2.,342 0523. ;::;<30@09309>D :..$ - 6 - ' A=A1=>;9:;24A78 :($ * ;9E094A;91=5013: :*$ 3,* . 09>0 450 >=1A8194: 120 094A4=03 <;2 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9 ;< :($ 1=;96 BA45 A94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< H @02 19978 <2;8 ' 4A== 450 3140 ;< 201=AI14A;91:161A9:4:*$1B12303?D45042A?791= ( 012903 >;79:0= <;2 450 9:7219>0 >;8@19D :7?8A4403 4514 450 32AE02 ;< 450 9:7203 E05A>=0 51: 9; 32AEA96=A>09>0193A9EA0B;< 20@;2403 A9 450 9:7219>0 >;8@19D A: =A1?=0 4; @1D 450 >;8@09:14A;9 193 =1402 A4 >19 20>;E02 450 :180 <2;8 450 ;B902;<450E05A>=0 5A: ;724 <A93: A4 201:;91?=0 4; 3A20>4 450 9:7219>0>;8@19D4;@1D450>;8@09:14A;919320>;E02450 :180<2;8450;B902;<450E05A>=0 >>;23A96=D450<;==;BA96;2302% - 7 - ! !A# ;''$' A: 1==;B03 A9 @124, !AA# 2;? ;'$'( A: 1=:; @124=D1==;B03, !AAA# 50 >=1A8194: 120 094A4=03 <;2 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9;<:($1=;96BA45A94020:4 144502140;<H@0219978<2;8'4A== 450 3140 ;< 201=AI14A;9 1: 161A9:4 :*$ 1B12303?D45042A?791=, !AE# 50 9:7219>0 >;8@19D A: 3A20>403 4; 30@;:A4 450 09519>03 >;8@09:14A;9 ;< :($1=;96BA45A94020:4144502140;<H A94020:4 @02 19978 <2;8 ' BA45A9 1 @02A;3;<;908;945, !E# 9:7>530@;:A4?;45450>=1A8194:120 @028A44034;BA45321B450094A2018;7940L71==D .- ('""!) &! A:4;%=;%'