- 1 - ! "#$$ !! %$& '( !! ) ' ( ! " ## $%&'(( ! ) " Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )# # (' !(" # ) ) ) (**++ )* )&(,++( - ) ) ) # # # # # )' ( ( +' + . %, , ) /, - 3 - + ) ) ( ) $%&/(( ! " ## $%&'(( ! ) " )# # (' !(" # ) ) ) (**++ )* )+(&++( - ) ) ) # # # # # )#-0 ) # ) ) - 4 - ) 1) ) # 230345678837907:3;<93=>?423@97<A7B406;456 @97<A 834<4<6B0 @27993BC<BC 423 =<0A<0079 6; 423<: @97<A 834<4<6B0 >? 423 @6AA6B DE=CA3B4 =743= (++ 87003= <B )6+(&++( 7B= &(,++( >? 423 ==<4<6B79 3B<6: <F<9 E=C3 7B= )3A>3: )* <D7?78E:7 + )6+(&++( 270 >33B ;<93= >? 423 93C79 :38:303B474<F30 6; 423 =3@3703= $ <==7887 7C3 7:<D7B @97<A<BC @6A83B074<6B <B :3083@4 6; =3742 6; <==78877C37:<D7B<B7:67=4:7;;<@7@@<=3B4 )6&(,++(270>33B;<93=>?423<BDE:3= @97<A<BC @6A83B074<6B<B:3083@4 6; <BDE:<300E047<B3= >? 23:<B7:67=4:7;;<@7@@<=3B4 - 5 - , 0 83: 7F3:A3B40 <B 423 >642 @97<A 834<4<6B0 4274 6B %((++ 74 7>6E4 ,% 8A 423 =3@3703= $ <==7887 7C3 7:<D7B 570 :<=<BC 2<0 A646:@?@93 >37:<BC6*,&**%%7B=2<05<;3$B<47@97<A7B4<B >642834<4<6B057078<99<6B:<=3:7B=523B<4570A6F<BC 4657:=0 EBC7427B ;:6A :DEB7C< F<997C3 423 =3@3703= 570:<=<BC2<0A646:@?@93<B7A6=3:7430833=7B=6B2<0 3G4:3A3 93;4 0<=3 7B= 74 423 4<A3 >E0 *+.*#* (+',@7A3;:6A68860<43=<:3@4<6B<B72<C20833=7B=<B 7:7027B=B3C9<C3B4A7BB3:7B=423=:<F3:6;423>E09604 @6B4:696;423F32<@937B==7023=7C7<B04423A646:@?@93 =E34607<=<A87@4 <==7887=<3=6B42308647B=2<05<;3 0E047<B3= <BDE:<30 <42 :3C7:= 46 423 07<= 7@@<=3B4 7B= =37426; <==78877B=<BDE:<304642307<=B<47423@97<A 834<4<6B07:3;<93= % 3086B=3B4 $ @6:86:74<6B @6B43043= 423 834<4<6B0@6B43B=<BC42744237@@<=3B4270B647479947H3B 897@3707993C3=<B423@97<A834<4<6B0 - 6 - / 23:<>EB79270;:7A3=<00E36(<B>642423 @97<A834<4<6B0796BC5<426423:<00E302307<=<00E36( 83:47<B0468:66;6;:7027B=B3C9<C3B4=:<F<BC6;423>E0 =:<F3:52<@2@7E03=4237@@<=3B4 ' @6AA6B 3F<=3B@3 270 >33B 93= <B >642 423 @97<A 834<4<6B0 >? >642 423 87:4<30 23 @97<A7B4 $ B<47 270 >33B 3G7A<B3= 70 ( 7B= C64 A7:H3= G( 46 G(%23=:<F3:6;423>E0270>33B3G7A<B3=70( 7B=423 38646B4:6993:270>33B3G7A<B3=70+7B= C64A7:H3=G(46(. & 23 :<>EB79 7;43: 237:<BC 423 7:CEA3B40 6B >6420<=307B=788:3@<74<BC4233F<=3B@36B:3@6:=C7F3 ;<B=<BC4274423@97<A7B4027F3;7<93=468:6F3<00E36( <B>642423@97<A834<4<6B0 . 2307<=;<B=<BC6B<00E36(<B>642423@97<A 834<4<6B07B=@6B03IE3B4<79=<0A<00796;423@97<A834<4<6B0 270>33B@27993BC3=<B4238:303B47883790 - 7 - ( 37:= 423 937:B3= @6EB0390 ;6: 423 7883997B40 7B=423:3086B=3B4$@6:86:74<6B (( 37:B3= @6EB039 ;6: 423 7883997B40 56E9= @6B43B= 4274 423 @27:C3*02334 270 >33B ;<93= 7C7<B04 423 =:<F3:6;423>E07B=@68?6;52<@2<074G(+ 52<@2<B=<@7434274(570=:<F<BC423>E0744234<A3 6; 7@@<=3B4 7B= 7@@<=3B4 270 6@@E::3= =E3 46 :702 7B= B3C9<C3B4=:<F<BC6;=:<F3:6;423>E03;E:423:0E>A<40 427404743A3B46;6B3702<>7<:3@6:=3=>?423869<@37B= <40 @68? 270 >33B 8:6=E@3= 74 G& 523:3<B 023 270 <=3B4<;<3=423=:<F3:6B>3<BC0265B4623:70423=:<F3:6; 423>E0744234<A36;7@@<=3B47B=23:>E04<@H34@6993@43= >?423869<@352<@2<087:46;423@27:C3*0233452<@2270 >33B A7:H3= 74 G' 3 ;E:423: 0E>A<40 4274 <B 423 <BIE304 A727J7: 74 G(( 423:3 <0 A3B4<6B 6; >E0@7E0<BC4237@@<=3B47B=6B36;4235<4B300>?B7A3 7B4602 570 7906 8:303B4 74 423 4<A3 6; <BIE304 87B@27B7A7 )3:39? >3@7E03 423 8<99<6B :<=3: <BDE:3= $ B<47 <B 23: @6A897<B4 $ G+ 270 B64 04743= 4274 423 - 8 - F32<@9352<@2@7E03=4237@@<=3B4<0423>E06B4274>70<0 423:<>EB792703::6B36E09?6>03:F3=4274423>E0<07><C <B0<J37B=7078<99<6B:<=3:6EC244627F3033B4274423 F32<@93@7E03=7@@<=3B4<07>E07B==6E>43=<BF69F3A3B4 6;423>E0<4242303238:7?3=;6:79965<BC4237883790 7B=0344<BC70<=3423;<B=<BC06;423:<>EB796B<00E36( <B>642423@7030 (+ 37:B3= @6EB039 ;6: :3086B=3B4 $ @6:86:74<6B 56E9= @6B43B= 4274 6B 788:3@<74<BC 423 3B4<:3 3F<=3B@3 423 :<>EB79 270 :<C249? C<F3B ;<B=<BC0 6B <00E3 6( <B >642 @97<A 834<4<6B0 23 =:<F3: 6; 423 >E0 270 >33B 3G7A<B3= 70 ( 7B= 23 270 C<F3B 04743A3B4 70 83: G(46423869<@3+$ 38646B4:6993:04743=7>6E4 423A6F3A3B46;423>E07B=3B4:?7B=3G<046;423>E0<B <D7?78E:7$7>930257:6B0<=3:<BC4233B4:?6;423>E0 74 ,%% 8A <4 <0 @937: 4274 423 7@@<=3B4 27= B64 47H3B 897@3 74 ,% 8A 70 7993C3= 423 =<047B@3 >34533B 7>930257: >E0*047B= 7B= 423 0864 6; 7@@<=3B4 <0 7>6E4 B37:9?%46/HA03;E:423:04743=427442304743A3B4 - 9 - 6; 6B3 702<>7< 270 B64 >33B 8:6=E@3= >E4 23: ;E:423: 04743A3B4270>33B8:6=E@3=74G&2307<=702<>7< 7B= 7B460252627=@<43=703?35<4B30030<B423@27:C3* 02334 27F3 B64 >33B 3G7A<B3= 3 ;E:423: 0E>A<40 4274 =:<F3: 270 ;<93= 7 834<4<6B EB=3: 3@4<6B ,&+ 6; : >3;6:3 42<0 6E:4 7B= <B 4274 23 270 @27993BC3= 423 @27:C3*02334 3 ;E:423: 0E>A<40 4274 423 @:<A<B79 @703 :3C<043:3= 7C7<B04 423 =:<F3: <0 04<99 83B=<BC ;6: 4:<79 6B0<=3:<BC 799 42303 7083@40 423 :<>EB79 270 :<C249? C<F3B ;<B=<BC 6B <00E3 6( 7B= =<0A<003= 423 @97<A 834<4<6B0 ( 7F<BC 237:= 423 937:B3= @6EB039 ;6: 423 7883997B407B=423:3086B=3B442<06E:427083:E03=423 <A8ECB3=@6AA6BDE=CA3B47B=:<796E:4:3@6:=0 (, 23 =3@3703= $ <==7887 7C3 7:<D7B 570 :<=3: 7B= 2<0 5<;3 $ B<47 <0 8<99<6B :<=3: 6B A646:@?@93 >37:<BC6*,&**%%6B%((++7B=7442744<A3 7 >E0 >37:<BC 6*+.*#*(+', @7A3 ;:6A 68860<43=<:3@4<6B7B==7023=4642307<=A646:@?@937B= - 10 - =:<F3: 6; 423 07<= >E0 =:6F3 423 >E0 <B 7 :702 7B= B3C9<C3B4 A7BB3: 7B= 7@@<=3B4 270 47H3B 897@3 B37: 423 97B= 6; 27B=:7887 2<97:2744< 6; 7HHEB=< F<997C3 23 07<= <==7887 7C3 7:<D7B =<3= 6B 423 0864 7B= 2<0 5<;3$B<470E047<B3=<BDE:<302307<=B<474235<;36; 423 =3@3703= ;<93= @6A897<B4 423 @68? 6; 52<@2 <0 74 G+ B 423 >70<0 6; 423 07<= @6A897<B4 :<A3 6(++270>33B:3C<043:3=7B=<B423#423@703 <0:3C<043:3=7C7<B04423=:<F3:6;EBHB65BF32<@93B423 07<= @6A897<B4 423 07<= B<47 270 04743= 4274 7 F32<@93 @7A3 ;:6A 7>930257: 0<=3 7B= <4 =7023= 46 423 A646:@?@93 7B= 423 =:<F3: 570 =:<F<BC <4 <B 7 2<C2 0833= 7B=<B7:7027B=B3C9<C3B4A7BB3:B42307<=@6A897<B4 423 07<= B<47 270 B64 04743= 4274 423 07<= F32<@93 52<@2 @7E03=4237@@<=3B4<0423>E0<3>E0 (% 37:B3= :<>EB79 @6B0<=3:<BC 423 7083@4 4274 @6A897<B7B4<078<99<6B:<=3:7B=>E0<0<B><C<B0<J3023 6EC244627F3033B<47B=A3B4<6B<B23:@6A897<B470>E0 7B==6E>43=<BF69F3A3B46;423>E0<B4237@@<=3B4 - 11 - (/ 23 @27:C3*02334 @68? 6; 52<@2 <0 74 G(+ <B=<@7434274<4<0;<93=7C7<B04423=:<F3:6;423 >E0<3($ 2<F7B7B=06<:727F7B7B=423:37:3 456 3?35<4B30030 @<43= <B 423 07<= @27:C3*02334 6( <0 B<47 423 5<;3 6; 423 =3@3703= 7B= 6+ <0 7B4602 7997887 7B@2C7F< * (+ 7B= 7B6423: <0 702<>7< 2:<027<92<HH6=<$((23@68?6;;E:423:04743A3B4 6;07<=702<>7<270>33B8:6=E@3=74G&23:<>EB79 270 B64 @6B0<=3:3=423 @27:C3*023347B=4233F<=3B@36; (6B9?@6B0<=3:3=4237083@442744233?35<4B3003046 423 7@@<=3B4 27F3 B64 >33B 3G7A<B3= 23 :<>EB79 270 897@3=AE@2:39<7B@36B4233F<=3B@36;(=:<F3:7B= +$ 38646B4:6993:7B=B6B*04743A3B46;=30@:<84<6B 6;423F32<@93>?423@6A897<B7B4$B<473F3B426EC2023 <0 423 3?35<4B300 23 :<>EB79 270 B64 47H3B <B46 @6B0<=3:74<6B 4274 6B 423 0864 423 2E0>7B= 6; 423 07<= B<47=<3=<B4237@@<=3B47B=0E>03IE3B4464274023270 ;<93=7@6A897<B4 - 12 - (' 37:B3= @6EB039 ;6: 423 7883997B40 56E9= @6B43B=4274B6:A799?42356A3B 6B7A646:@?@930<46B 6B30<=3;7@<BC4657:=093;47B=F32<@93@6A<BC;:6A;:6B4 0<=37:306A34<A30B64F<0<>93464238<99<6B:<=3: (& F3B423@6A897<B4C<F3B>?42346423 <D7?78E:7 70 83: G(+ <0 7;43: 426EC24 7B= ;<93= 7;43:B37:9?,A6B4206;4237@@<=3B4 (. 6B0<=3:<BC 799 42303 7083@40 <4 <0 @937: 4274 3F<=3B@36B:3@6:=<0B640E;;<@<3B446C<F3;<B=<BC6B<00E3 6(7B=87:4<30:3IE<:3=46>3C<F3B6886:4EB<4?46937= ;E:423: 3F<=3B@3 06 70 46 3B7>93 423A 46 3G7A<B3 3?35<4B30030 @<43= <B 423 @27:C3*02334 7B= 6423: 3F<=3B@3 + BF<356;4237>6F3423A7443::3IE<:3046>3 :3A7B=3= 46 423 :<>EB79 ;6: C<F<BC ;E:423: 6886:4EB<4<30 46 423 87:4<30 46 937= ;E:423: 3F<=3B@3 B F<35 6; 423 7>6F3423@6AA6BDE=CA3B487003=<B)6+(&++( 7B= )6&(,++( :3IE<:30 46 >3 034*70<=3 B 423 :30E94423;69965<BC - 13 - 64242378837907:3799653= 23 <A8ECB3=@6AA6B DE=CA3B4=743= (++ 87003= <B )6+(&++( 7B= &(,++( >? ==<4<6B79 3B<6: <F<9 E=C3 7B= )3A>3: )* <D7?78E:7<0034*70<=3 23 A7443:0 7:3 :3A7B=3= 46 423 :<>EB79 5<42 7 =<:3@4<6B 46 C<F3 6886:4EB<4? 46 >642 423 87:4<30 46 937=;E:423:3F<=3B@3 23 87:4<30 7:3 =<:3@43= 46 78837: >3;6:3 423 :<>EB79 6B ((++% 5<426E4 7B4<@<874<BC 7B? 6E:4B64<@3 *' %$$& # <046( 96(. 4H