- 1 - !" #! $%!&!%% % ' '()* '!!)) + !" # $ !" %## & #' # ### # ## !" ## "$ # ! ## !" %# & ( # #' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ## #) & ' &*' # *# ##+ # ## ## ##," # # #)$)" # ## # # # # # # ## # ## # *# - # & - #' #./0/121234/567/2489::;6/< 36 94< 24 52=/ 3,"3><956.989503?2:/61912342@9A90;543B 0/4<248341./>2?/3>1./?/954/<<<212349?2C2?;<8/ 94<2@9A90;595/6//D24813E;96.1./:52=249? 053://<2486 2421291/< 9892461 1./= >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97?/;4</5/:12346)$94<)"3>1./4<294/49? 3</ !"&>356.351FG' - 3 - #./ >9:16 3> 1./ :96/ 24 752/> 95/ 1.91 5/6034</41 3 >2?/< 1./ >2561 24>35=91234 B21. <956. 989503?2:/61912342@9A90;598924619::;6/<3613 9??/8248 :3==266234 3> 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97?/ ;4</5 /:12346 )$ 94< )" 3> 1 26 1./ :341/41234 3> 5/6034</4131.919::;6/<3694<.9C/63?<1./ 4349852:;?1;59?0?317/95248;5C/A3!,24>9C3;53> 1./24>35=941#./5/8261/5/<69?/<//<<91/<"") B96/H/:;1/<94<5/6034</413B960;1240366/66234 3> 1./ 692< 0?31 1 26 43B 1./ :341/41234 3> 5/6034</41 3 1.91 9::;6/< 3 .9< >2?/< 1./ 6;21 24 3$")341./>2?/3>1./?/954/<<<212349? /4235 2C2? ;<8/ 94< 2@9A90;5 9892461 9::;6/< 3694<94<5/6034</413>3560/:2>2:0/5>35=94:/ 3>1./985//=/41<91/<""1261./:341/41234 3>9::;6/<31.919::;6/<3694<.9C//H/:;1/< 94 ;45/8261/5/< 985//=/41 >35 69?/ <91/< "" 985//248136/??1./C/5A69=/4349852:;?1;59?0?3124.26 >9C3;5 #./5/>35/ 5/6034</41 3 .96 >2?/< 1./ >2561 - 4 - 24>35=91234 :341/4<248 1.91 9::;6/< 36 94< .9C/ /C/41.3;8./H/:;1/<94;45/8261/5/<985//=/41>3569?/ 34 "" 24 >9C3;5 3> 9::;6/< 3 1./ 69=/ B96 431 753;8.1 13 .26 4312:/ B.2?/ /H/:;1248 1./ 69?/ <//< <91/< "") #./ :9=/ 13 7/ 5/8261/5/< 94< 24C/612891234B96;4</519D/441./=/9412=/9::;6/< 36 94< .9C/ 900539:./< 1.26 3;51 94< 94 241/52= 35</5 3> 619A 3> >;51./5 053://<2486 B96 85941/< C2</ 35</5 <91/< ""$" #./5/>35/ 1./5/ 26 43 >;51./5 24C/612891234241./=911/5 /95< 52 3?=9? ;6.9? 2@9A9D;=95 ?/954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 52 9=9<95 .9.97;<<24 ?/954/< 28. 3;51 3C/54=/41 ?/9</5 >35 5/6034</41 3I191/94<529.941/6./692?/954/<:3;46/?>35 5/6034</413/5;6/<1./=91/529?6345/:35< ) 4 C2/B 3> 1./ 52C9? :341/412346 ;58/< 7A 1./ ?/954/<:3;46/?>351./09512/61./032411.91B3;?<9526/ >35=A:3462</59123426 - 5 - !"#$% A946B/5131./973C/0324126241./ >351./>3??3B248 !! #./>9:163>1./:96/94<1./:341/4123419D/4 7A ?/954/< :3;46/? >35 5/6034</41 3 <26:?36/6 1.91 5/6034</41 3 26 9??/8248 :3==266234 3> 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97?/ ;4</5 /:12346 )$ 94< )" 3> 9892461 9::;6/<3694<34?A341./853;4<1.91./B96431 24>35=/< 973;1 ;45/8261/5/< 985//=/41 >35 69?/ <91/< "" B.2:. B96 692< 13 .9C/ 7//4 /H/:;1/< 7A 9::;6/<3694<24>9C3;53>9::;6/<3245/60/:1 3>1./C/5A69=/0?31B.2:.B9663?<24.26>9C3;5;4</59 5/8261/5/<69?/<//< - 6 - ! /954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 :341/4</< 1.91 1./ 985//=/41 5/>/55/< 13 7A 9::;6/< 3 <91/< "" B96 24 >9:1 431 94 985//=/41 >35 69?/ 24:/ 9::;6/< 36 94< .9< 9C92?/< ?394 6;:. 9 <3:;=/41 :9=/2413/H261/4:/24:/1./5/8261/5/<69?/<//<B96 /H/:;1/< 24 >9C3;5 3> 5/6034</41 3 1./5/ B96 43 3::96234 13 82C/ </192?6 973;1 6;:. <3:;=/41 2=2?95 </>/4:/B9619D/47A9::;6/<3694<241./6;2124 3$") #.26 >9:1 26 431 <260;1/< 7A ?/954/< :3;46/?>355/6034</413*./49::;6/<3694< .9C/ 9?5/9<A /H/:;1/< 1./ 69?/ <//< 24 >9C3;5 3> 5/6034</41 3 24 5/60/:1 3> 0?31 24 E;/61234 94< 1.91 9::;6/< 36 94< 95/ :341/61248 1./ 6;21 24 3$") 9::/01248 1./ 3B4/56.20 3> 5/6034</41 33C/51./0?3124E;/61234<3431>24<94A5/963413 24C3D//:12346)$94<)"3>98924611./=#./5/ 95/ 43 :3842J97?/ 3>>/4:/6 =9</ 3;1 13 5/8261/51./9>1/524C/612891/24131./69=/ - 7 - $ /954/< :3;46/? >35 5/6034</41 3 0?9:/6 5/?294:/341./</:262343>1./ 34G7?/0/H3;51241./ :96/ 3> 24 6;00351 3> .26 :341/412341.91/C/41.3;8.1./3>>/4:/24E;/612345/>/56 139:2C2?<260;1/9>1/55/82615912343>24C/61289123426 137/:34<;:1/<7A1./4C/612891248>>2:/5#./?/954/< :3;46/?0?9:/65/?294:/3409598590.36"94<3>1./ 692<@;<8=/4113:341/4<1.911./24C/6128912489;1.3521A 6.3;?<0537/24131./=911/5973;1 =91/529?24 053C248 1./ :3==266234 3> 1./ 3>>/4:/ 94< 24 1./ =/94 12=/6;:.26431?297?/137/E;96./< #./ >9:16 24 1./ 973C/ 692< :96/ 94< 24 1./ 05/6/41 :96/ 95/ /4125/?A <2>>/5/41 96 495591/< 24 09598590.3!3>1./692<@;<8=/413>1./ 34G7?/0/H 3;51 #./ 34G7?/ 0/H 3;51 ./?< 1.91 B./4 :3842J97?/ 3>>/4:/ 26 =9</ 3;1 24 1./ 24C/612891234 26 13 7/ ;4</519D/4 7A 1./ 4C/612891248 1 " ) - 8 - >>2:/51>3;4<>9;?1B21.1./35</53>1./ 28.3;5124 E;96.248 1./ :52=249? 053://<2486 /C/4 7/>35/ 4C/612891248 >>2:/5 24C/612891/6 2413 1./ =911/5 #./ >9:16 94< :25:;=6194:/6 495591/< 24 1./ 692< :96/ 95/ /4125/?A <2>>/5/41 94< 69=/ :94431 7/ 900?2/< 24 1./ 05/6/41 :96/ C/4 9>1/5 83248 1.53;8. 1./ >2561 24>35=9123443:3842J97?/3>>/4:/26=9</3;1 130/5=211./24C/612891234241./=911/5 /4:/9=3> 1./ 3024234 1.91 5/8261591234 3> 94< :34124;91234 3> :52=249? 053://<248 9892461 1./ 0/121234/56 26 24 97;6/ 3> 053:/663>?9B#./5/>35/946B/51./973C/03241241./ 94<053://<1309661./>3??3B248 #./:52=249?0/12123426 #./ :52=249? 053://<2486 2421291/< 9892461 1./ 0/121234/569::;6/< 36 94< 24 52=/ 3," 3> <956. 9895 03?2:/ 6191234 2@9A90;5 >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97?/ ;4</5 /:12346 )$ 94< )" 3> 43B - 9 - 0/4<248341./>2?/3>1./?/954/<<<212349?2C2?;<8/ 94<2@9A90;526./5/7AE;96./< !,* '%%) & # 2613 ?3 #