Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63095 (KAR)
IFFCO TOKIO GEN. INS. CO. LTD., v. PUSHPA @ PUSHPAVATI AND ORS
MFA/201106/2021 · 2025-12-10
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63095 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63095 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$"
#$ $%
""
&%' (
! " #
$
%
! $
&
"' () (
*
&
' (* (
'
"
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+ '+ (+(
"
*',, ' ' ,,
"
- %
! .*/ + $
0 !$
1
"
+
" (0***
*'*
+
+
"
( ( 2
+
2
+ +
- 3 -
$ ! ( 2
+
$
345 677869 :;<8= 8>?4@; 0 !$ @A ?38 @?@= 834>985>?1!38=84;6A?8==8A8==8<?@65B?38>?A@= 53@=?$ 365 C88; A498< CD ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D >36998;F4;F ?38 G:<FE8;? 6;< 6H6=< <6?8< 0*** 76558< CD ?38 =4;>4769 8;4@= 4I49 +:<F8 6;< 696C:=6F44; @*'*
* 6>?5 F4I4;F =458 ?@ ?38 A494;F @A ?38 677869 C=48A9D 5?6?8< 6=8 ?36? @; * 6? 6C@:? 0 6E H38;
?38 <8>8658< @E6538J36= '@ 656;;6 69@;F H4?3 345 A=48;<5H657=@>88<4;F?@H6=<5D<8=6C6<4;6=C86=4;F =8F45?=6?4@;
@ *',, ?@7:=>3658C:54;8554?8E5 6;<H38;>6==86>38<;86==6C3:<8I6;J6=6>34;8@; 696C:=6F4-8<6E=@6<6??36??4E8<=4I8=@A?38564< >6=<=@I8?38>6=4;634F35788<6;<4;=6536;<;8F94F8;? E6;;8= 6;< <6538< ?@ ?38 :5 H34>3 H65 7=@>88<4;F 4; A=@;?@A?38>6=56=85:9?@A?386A@=8564<6>>4<8;??38
- 4 -
<8>8658< 5:5?64;8< F=48I@:5 386< 4;G:=485 6;< <48< @;
57@? 38 >964E6;?5 A498< 6 78?4?4@; :;<8= 8>?4@; ,, @A ?38 >? 588J4;F >@E78;56?4@; A@= ?38 <86?3 @A ?38 <8>8658<69@;FH4?34;?8=85? ) ;7:=5:6;>8@A?38;@?4>8=857@;<8;? @56;<* 36I8 67786=8< ?3=@:F3 ?384= >@:;589 6;< A498< H=4??8;
5?6?8E8;? <8;D4;F ?38 6I8=E8;?5 E6<8 4; ?38 >964E 78?4?4@;
; ?38 C6545 @A ?38 7986<4;F5 @A ?38 76=?485 ?38 964E5=4C:;69A=6E8<?38455:856;<?38=86A?8==8>@=<8< ?38 8I4<8;>8 38 =4C:;69 CD 4E7:F;8< G:<FE8;? 6;< 6H6=<36576=?9D699@H8<?38>964E78?4?4@;6;<389<?36? ?38 >964E6;?5 6=8 8;?4?98< ?@ 6 >@E78;56?4@; @A 5*1*'69@;FH4?34;?8=85?6??38=6?8@A,K76 6;< <4=8>?8< ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D ?@ <87@54? ?38
- 5 -
>@E78;56?4@;
6E@:;? 69@;F H4?3 4;?8=85? 84;F 6FF=48I8<?387=858;?677869365C88;A498<
, 38986=;8<>@:;589A@=?38;5:=6;>8@E76;D365 >@;?8;?8< ?36? ?38 >6='@AA8;<4;F I834>98 C86=4;F =8F45?=6?4@;
@ *',, 4567=4I6?8I834>983@:F3 ?38586?4;F>676>4?D@A?38>6=45A4I878=5@;554L78=5@;5 H8=8 ?=6I894;F 4; ?38 564< >6= 38=8A@=8 38 >@;?8;<8< ?36? ?38 >964E6;?5 6=8 ;@? 8;?4?98< A@= 6;D >@E78;56?4@;
A@= ?38 <86?3 @A <8>8658< @E6538J36= H3@ H65 6; 4;E6?8@A?38I834>988A:=?38=>@;?8;?8<?36?8I8;?38 6<<4?4@;697=8E4:E@A5*'45>@998>?8<78=76558;F8= 38=8A@=8 38 >@;?8;<8< ?36? :9?4E6?89D ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D45946C98?@76D5'6578=96H
0 ; 5:77@=? @A 345 >@;?8;?4@; 38 365 =8948< :7@; ?38 G:<FE8;? @A @;C98 78L @:=? 4; ?38 >658 @A
=87@=?8< 4;
!"
# $
- 6 -
!%& =87@=?8<4; '( ))38=8A@=838 5@:F3? A@= 699@H4;F ?38 677869 6;< 695@ >@;?8;<8< ?36? 54;>84?456;>?7@94>D6;<4?45;@?6?34=<76=?D>964E?38 ;5:=6;>8@E76;D45;@?946C98?@76D6;D>@E78;56?4@;
986=;8<>@:;58967786=4;FA@==857@;<8;?
@ @H;8=@A?38@AA8;<4;FI834>98365>@;?8;?8<?36??38 @AA8;<4;FI834>9845>@I8=8<H4?3I694<4;5:=6;>87@94>D;
6<<4?4@; ?@ ?38 5?6?:?@=D 946C494?D ?38 4;5:=6;>8 >@E76;D 365 >@998>?8< 8L?=6 7=8E4:E @A 5*' 78= 76558;F8= 345456>@;?=6>?:69@C94F6?4@;:;<8=?384;5:=6;>87@94>D ?@ 76D >@E78;56?4@; ?@ ?38 4;E6?8 H3@ H65 ?=6I894;F 4;
?38 >6= A?8= >@;54<8=4;F ?38 8I4<8;>8 6<<:>8< CD ?38 76=?485 6;< L4;5:=6;>8 7@94>D ?38 =4C:;69 365 =4F3?9DA65?8;8<?38946C494?D@;?38;5:=6;>8@E76;D8 A:=?38= >@;?8;?8< ?36? ?38 G:<FE8;? =8948< :7@; CD ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 A@= ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D 45 ;@? 67794>6C98?@?38A6>?5@A?38>65885:CE4?5?36??38=845 ;@E8;?4@;4;?387@94>D94E4?4;F?38>@E78;56?4@;76D6C98
- 7 -
?@ 76558;F8= 6? 5' 8;>8 38 5@:F3? A@= <45E45569@A?38677869
1 86=< ?38 986=;8< >@:;589 A@= ?38 76=?485 6;< 78=:58<G:<FE8;?6;<6H6=<@A?38=4C:;69
? 45 ;@? 4; <457:?8 ?36? ?38 <8>8658< @E6538J36= <48<4;=@6<?=6AA4>6>>4<8;?@>>:==8<@; *<:8?@ ?38 =653 6;< ;8F94F8;? <=4I4;F @A ?38 <=4I8= @A ?38 >6= C86=4;F=8F45?=6?4@;
@ *',, 8H65?=6I894;F4; ?38564<>6=69@;FH4?3345A=48;<5656;4;E6?8?45695@ ;@? 4; <457:?8 ?36? ?38 @AA8;<4;F >6= H65 >@I8=8< H4?3 6 I694<4;5:=6;>87@94>D
5 78= ?38 4;5:=6;>8 7@94>D 7=@<:>8<6? L ?38 ?@?69 7=8E4:E >@998>?8< CD ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D 45 5*,':?@AH34>3?38C654>7=8E4:E455' 98F69 946C494?D ?@ ?38 <=4I8= 45 5' 78=5@;69 6>>4<8;? !$>@I8=?@?3876558;F8=:;<8=;<46;@?@=6=4AA, 455*'6;<>@I8=?@?38@H;8=<=4I8=455' 4;>8?38;5:=6;>8@E76;D365>@998>?8<5*'A=@E
- 8 -
?38 76558;F8=5 4? 45 6 >@;?=6>?:69 946C494?D @; ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D ?@ 76D >@E78;56?4@; ?@ ?38 4;E6?85 @A?38>6=:=?38=6578=,4;?38>658@A<86?3?38 5>698@A>@E78;56?4@;45K
* @;54<8=4;F ?38 8I4<8;>8 796>8< @; =8>@=< 6;< L ?38 =4C:;69 365 =4F3?9D 389< ?36? ?38 ;5:=6;>8 @E76;D 45 946C98 ?@ 76D ?38 >@E78;56?4@; 38=8 45 ;@ 8==@= @= 4998F694?485 4; ?38 @=<8= 76558< CD ?38 =4C:;69 >>@=<4;F9D?386778695?6;<5! )* &"' $
)* & $% ' $
45? @(9 @( ,