- 1 - !" #$% #$%!%&! '( ! " " # " $ % & Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( ' (' ( " ") $ % '& * # + #,'! - .+ ( ( /" /"" - 3 - %( /" & 01234515167128194:;<5045=54>7:4??51@942 =7: * 68 672515>5167 68 7:1= @0=9947A17A 504 6?:4? :=54: # 3=224: ;< 504 =?7=5=B= 5=54 :C17125?=51D4 ?1;>7=9 =5 =9=;>?=A1 %86? 206?5 .504 ?1;>7=9+& 17 3391@=5167 6#,'! E04?4;< 504 =3391@=51678194:;<504?42367:47512=996E4: ?1488=@5268504@=24=?450=55048=504?68504 ?42367:475674?104C>'6044C=17A0=506:E=2 =3361754: =2 22125=75 4=@04? 17 6D4?7C475 @0669 67 4 :14: 67 #* E0194 17 24?D1@4 94=D17A;4017:012E184:=>A054?=7:!C176?267204 :=>A054? 68 504 :4@4=24: 4C396<44 0=2 8194: =7 =3391@=5167 86? =336175C475 67 @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7: 67 04 =3391@=5167 8194: ;< 504 :=>A054? 68 504 :4@4=24:4C396<44E=2E1501750451C491C15<50451C4 504 345151674?2 @6721:4? 04? @=24 86? =336175C475 67 - 4 - @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7: 204 A65 C=??14: 04?486?4 67 , 504 ?42367:475 04?417 0=2 2>;C1554: = ?43?42475=5167 25=517A 50=5 504 @6C3=22167=54 =336175C475 C=< ;4 A1D47 17 012 8=D6>? 04?4=854? 504 :=>A054? 68 :4@4=24: A=D4 = ?43?42475=5167 244B17A 56 A1D4 4C396<C475 56 04? ;?6504? 17 04? 39=@4 04 ?42367:47504?4170=22>;C1554:674C6?4=3391@=516767 # 244B17A =336175C475 67 @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7:042=1:=3391@=5167@=C456;4?4F4@54:;<504 345151674?2 ;< 122>17A =7 47:6?24C475 :=54: * =7: ! 25=517A 50=5 =3391@=5167 8194: ;< 504 ?42367:475 04?417 12 ;4<67: 91C15=5167 417A =AA?14D4: ;< 504 2=C4 504 ?42367:475 0=2 8194: =7 =3391@=5167 ;486?4504=?7=5=B= 5=54 :C17125?=51D4 ?1;>7=9>7:4? 4@5167 , 68 :C17125?=51D4 ?1;>7=9 @5 17 3391@=5167 6#,'! 04 ?1;>7=9 D1:4 6?:4? :=54: # =996E4: 504 =3391@=5167 =7: :1?4@54: 504 345151674?2 56 @6721:4? 504 =3391@=5167 68 504 ?42367:475 - 5 - 86? @6C3=22167=54 =336175C475 417A =AA?14D4: ;< 504 2=C45=540=23?484??4:5012E?1534515167 ! 4=?74: ::15167=9 6D4?7C475 :D6@=54 =334=?17A86?504345151674?2@67547:4:50=5=234?>94 68 504 =?7=5=B= 1D19 4?D1@42 %336175C475 67 6C3=22167=54 ?6>7:2& >942 ,, %86? 206?5 .504 >942 ,,+& 504 :4347:475 8=C19< C4C;4? 68 504 :4@4=24: 4C396<44 0=2 56 8194 =7 =3391@=5167 E15017 674 <4=? 8?6C 504 :=54 68 :4=50 68 504 4C396<44 04 =3391@=5167 8194: ;< 504 ?42367:475 12 ;4<67: 674 <4=? 04?486?4 04 12 765 4751594: 56 ;4 @6721:4?4: 86? =336175C475 67 @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7: >7:4? 504 >942 ,,1506>5@6721:4?17A50123?6D12167504?1;>7=90=2 4??4:17=996E17A504=3391@=5167 4@67:9< 04 @67547:4: 50=5 504 =336175C475 67 @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7: @=7765 ;4 @9=1C4: =2 = C=554? 68 ?1A05 17@4 504 4C396<44 :14: 17 504 <4=? * 504 =3391@=5167128194:=854?50?44<4=?268012:4=50 6E=854? - 6 - 50?44 <4=?2 504< @=7765 @9=1C 50=5 504 8=C19< 68 504 :4@4=24: 12 17 817=7@1=9 @?1212 6721:4?17A 5012 =234@5 68 504C=554?04@67547:4:50=5504345151674?20=D4?1A059< 122>4:50447:6?24C47547@40426>A0586?=996E17A504 34515167 # 94=?74: @6>7249 =334=?17A 86? 504 ?42367:4750=2@67547:4:50=5504=3391@=51678194:;<504 :=>A054?68504:4@4=24:67 12E1501750451C4 91C15 3?42@?1;4: >7:4? 504 >942 ,, D47 =854? 5E6 <4=?2 68 :4=50 68 04? 8=504? 504 345151674?2 0=D4 765 @6721:4?4:04?=3391@=5167<50=551C4204A65C=??14: =7:504?486?404?;?6504?14504?42367:47504?4170=2 56 5=B4 @=?468 504 4751?4 8=C19< 504?486?4504:=>A054? ?1<=7B= =7: ?42367:475 0=D4 2>;C1554: ?43?42475=51672 244B17A?439=@4C475685047=C468?42367:4751739=@468 ?1<=7B= 04?486?4 15 :642 765 =C6>75 56 C=B17A =7< 8?420 =3391@=5167 7 2>336?5 68 012 @675475167 04 ?4914: >367504:4@1216768504 >9947@0686C;=<1A06>?5 68 =A3>? 47@0 17 504 @=24 68 - 7 - ?436?54:17 =7: =926504:4@1216768504=:?=21A06>?517504@=2468 ! " #$ ?436?54: 17 %& '' ( %)% 47@4 04 26>A0586?:12C122=968504E?1534515167 4=?: 504 94=?74: @6>7249 86? 504 3=?5142 =7: 34?>24:504E?153=34?2 51276517:123>5450=5?42367:475+28=504?E=2 E6?B17A =2 22125=75 4=@04? 17 6D4?7C475 2@0669 4 :14: 67 #* E0194 17 24?D1@4 94=D17A ;4017: 012 E184 :=>A054? ?1<=7B= =7: 50?44 C176? 2672 2 34? >9468504>942,,504:4347:475685048=C19<68 504 :4@4=24: 4C396<44 0=2 56 8194 =7 =3391@=5167 E15017 674 <4=? 8?6C 504 :=54 68 :4=50 68 504 6D4?7C475 24?D=757@=2468C176?04C>250=D4=55=174:504=A4 68 <4=?2 E15017 674 <4=? 8?6C 504 :=54 68 :4=50 68 = 6D4?7C475 24?D=75 =7: 04 C>25 C=B4 =7 =3391@=5167 - 8 - E15017674<4=?504?4=854?04:=>A054?68504:4@4=24: 4C396<44 0=2 8194: =7 =3391@=5167 67 E15017 674<4=?8?6C504:=5468:4=506804?8=504?D47=854? 5E6<4=?26881917A504=3391@=5167504345151674?20=D4765 C=:4=336175C47568?1<=7B=67@6C3=22167=54A?6>7: <50=551C4204A65C=??14:=7:504?42367:475E0612 504 267 68 504 :4@4=24: 0=2 56 5=B4 @=?4 68 504 4751?4 8=C19< 04?486?4 :=>A054? 68 504 :4@4=24: 4C396<44 ?1<=7B= =7: ?42367:475 0=D4 8194: ?43?42475=5167 67 , 244B17A 2>;2515>5167 68 504 7=C4 68 504 ?42367:475 17 39=@4 68 ?1<=7B= 04?4=854? 504 ?42367:475 =926 8194: 674 C6?4 ?43?42475=5167 67 # 04 ?43?42475=5167 8194: ;< 504 ?42367:475 @=7765;45?4=54:=2=8?420=3391@=5167512679<244B17A 2>;2515>5167685047=C4 * 1C19=? 122>4 0=2 =?1247 ;486?4 504 6C;=< 1A06>?5 042=1: 122>40=2 ;447?484??4: 56504 >99 47@0 04 >99 47@0 68 504 6C;=< 1A0 6>?5 17 504 @=2468 %2>3?=&0=2049:50=5 - 9 - 2>;24G>475=3391@=516712679<=2>;2515>5167=7:15@=7765 ;45?4=54:=2=8?420=3391@=516704?494D=753=?=A?=302 56*=?44H5?=@54:04?4>7:4?86?4=2<?484?47@4( !" # $ %" # & ' - 10 - & ( ) & * + ,!+-. -)/ ). " & 0 ) & 1 2 1 2 + " - 11 - & 3 1C19=? 122>4 0=2 ;447 @6721:4?4: ;< 504 1A0 6>?568=C19 =:>17! *@=24%2>3?=&=7:504 2=C40=2=926;447?484??4:;<504?1;>7=904?1;>7=9 171526?:4?=53=?=A?=30 6!0=26;24?D4:=2>7:4?( .! 4 $ $ ' 556 ! " #$ +,-# % .%/ 0 )%& ( 7 0 8 ( " $ " 5 - 12 - 9 , / ) .: $ ) / - 13 - 9 $ " " .: ; 9 / $ - 14 - .: $ " 9 9 9 9 , 9 - 15 - 0 < 9 9 & " 5 & < 9 = & - 16 - $ # $ 3 , 6721:4?17A 504 =;6D4 :4@121672 =7: =339<17A 504 3?17@1394 56 504 @=24 67 0=7: 504 4C396<44 :14: 67 #* 04 =3391@=5167 8194: ;< 504 :=>A054? 68 504 :4@4=24: 4C396<44 67 12 E15017 504 51C4 3?42@?1;4:>7:4?>9468504>942,,0472048194: 504 =3391@=5167 204 E=2 >7C=??14: =7: E047 =3391@=5167 E=2 >7:4? 3?6@422 86? =336175C475 67 @6C3=22167=54 A?6>7: 204 A65 C=??14: 17@4 504 ?4236721;1915142 68 5=B17A @=?4 68 504 8=C19< 68 504 :4@4=24: 12 67 504 ?42367:475 504?486?4 :=>A054??1<=7B= =7: 504 ?42367:475 0=D4 8194: 504 ?43?42475=51672 244B17A 86? 2>;2515>5167 68 7=C4 68 504 ?42367:475 17 39=@4 68 - 17 - ?1<=7B= =7: 504?486?4 15 @=7765 ;4 5?4=54: =2 8?420 =3391@=5167 6721:4?17A 5012 =234@5 68 504 C=554? 504 ?1;>7=9 0=2 ?1A059< =996E4: 504 =3391@=5167 8194: ;< 504 ?42367:47504?41704?486?4E4817:764??6?6?1994A=915< 17 504 6?:4? 3=224: ;< 504 ?1;>7=9 47@4 504 E?15 3451516712:4D61:68C4?15=7:1291=;9456;4:12C1224: @@6?:17A9<504?15451516712" 04345151674?2=?4:1?4@54:56@6C39<E150504 6?:4?3=224:;<504?1;>7=9E1501750?44C675028?6C504 :=5468?4@413568@63<6850126?:4? )* '( % )* '!%&!( % 125 6(9 6(#