- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) !"#$ % & ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !"#$ !"#$ % & ) * !' ) ) $&' ) ) $$ (+ $# ) ) ,$$ ! #- $$$$$ !- ) . - 3 - % /012/ 3/4 566457 89 78934: ;0< 5:=89980> ?83/ 3/4 @0>94>3 0; 745<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 65<3849 83 89 35A4> 16 ;0<;8>57:8960957 /89 566457 89 ;874: 5258>93 3/4 B1:2=4>3 5>: 5?5<: :534: $$ 65994: CD 3/4 <8>@8657 4>80< 8E87 1:24 5>: 0==89980>4< ;0< =670D449 0=64>95380>8B5D651<58> 0(+0;$# >4 8<578>2 0 5775665 /01:/5<8 ?0<A8>2 59 5 :<8E4< 1>:4< <4960>:4>3 0 0> /89 5130 C45<8>2 <42893<5380> 0!" !+ =43 ?83/ 5> 5@@8:4>3 0> $(?/874/4?596<0@44:8>230?5<:93/4/01940; <4960>:4>3 09831534:535>>0778E8775245>:919358>4: 2<84E0198>B1<495>::84:0>3/49603/4<4;0<4/89?8;4 :512/34< 5>: =03/4< ;874: 5 @758= 6438380> C4;0<4 3/4 0==89980>4<@758=8>2@0=64>95380>0;9$$$$$ ! ( /4 0==89980>4< @0>98:4<8>2 3/4 4>38<4 4E8:4>@4 0> <4@0<: 2<5>34: @0=64>95380> 0; - 4 - 9,$$ !?83/8>34<49353-65;<0=3/4:5340; 5@@8:4>3 3877 <457895380> 5>: :8<4@34: <4960>:4>3 0 30 :4609833/495=4 22<84E4:CD3/4958:B1:2=4>35>:5?5<:3/4 @758=5>39 /5E4 6<4;4<<4: 3/89 566457 8> ?/8@/ 83 89 @0>34>:4: 3/53 3/4 0==89980>4< /59 35A4> 3/4 8>@0=4 0;3/4:4@4594:599$$$ !64<=0>3/3/012//4?59 45<>8>2 9$$$ ! 64< =0>3/ 5>: 3/4 @0=64>95380> 5?5<:4: CD 3/4 0==89980>4< 89 0> 3/4 70?4< 98:4 /4<4;0<4<4F14934:;0<4>/5>@4=4>30;@0=64>95380> # 45<:3/45<21=4>390;C03/98:49 + /4;0770?8>291C935>3857F149380>90;75??017: 5<894;0<@0>98:4<5380>8>3/89566457 8' /43/4< 3/4 @0=64>95380> 5?5<:4: CD 3/4 0==89980>4< ?83/ 8>34<493 89 0> 6<064< 566<4@85380>0;;5@390<>03G 88' /43/4< 3/4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 785C74 ;0< 65D5>:<4@0E4<D0<:4<G - 5 - " /4 :4@4594:8<578>2 ?59 ?0<A8>2 595:<8E4< 5>:5964<3/4=670D4490=64>95380>@3/898>@0=489 30 C4 35A4> 53 9"$$$ ! 64< =0>3/ 4 ?59 524: D45<95964<H!<460<3/4<4;0<4;0<3/461<6094 0; @57@175380> $- 0; 9"$$$ ! 89 30 C4 35A4> 5>: 83 9/017:C4=17386784:?83/<474E5>3;5@30<0;$##/19 3/4 @0=64>95380> @0=49 30 9($$$ H $## I 9"$##($ ! , /4 0==89980>4< /59 2<5>34: 9$$$ ! 30?5<:9;1>4<574H64>9495>:83>44:9>08>34<;4<4>@4 $ /19 3/4 30357 @0=64>95380> @0=49 30 9"#($ !&9"$##($J9$$$' 45<>4:@01>947;0<<4960>:4>3 0!>91<5>@4 0=65>D @0>34>:4: 3/53 3/4<4 89 >0 :<8E8>2 78@4>@4 >0 ;83>499 @4<38;8@534 5>: >0 64<=83 5>: 83 5=01>39 30 E8075380> 0; 3/4 34<=9 5>: @0>:8380>9 0; 3/4 6078@D 9 91@/ 3/4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D ?59 57<45:D 4H0>4<534: - 6 - ;<0=3/4785C8783DC4;0<43/40==89980>4<5>:3/40<:4<0; 3/40==89980>4<>44:9>08>34<;4<4>@4 45<>4: @01>947 ;0< 3/4 5664775>39 <4784: 160> 3/4 B1:2=4>3 0; 3/4 0>KC74 64H 01<3 8> 3/4 @594 0; 8>?/8@/83?59/47:3/534E4>8> =5334<9 ?/4>3/4<4 89>0 :<8E8>278@4>@4 >91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 785C74 ;0< 65D 5>: <4@0E4<D 0<:4< 9 91@/ 3/4D@5>95389;D3/45?5<:;8<935>:3/4><4@0E4<3/495=4 ;<0=3/40?>4< 45<>4:@01>9475790<4784:160>3/4:4@8980>0; 3/8901<38> !!"#$ !%&'(C43?44>) * 5>: '$ ++ :534: ,$"$( 5>: ! ,$ !, &'( C43?44> ) - ) 5>: '$ .++ :534: 1 2019 ACJ 713 - 7 - "$"$( > C03/ 3/4 @5949 83 ?59 /47: 3/53 3/4 >91<5>@40=65>D894>38374:;0<65D5>:<4@0E4<D0<:4< ( >E84?0;3/45C0E4:8@31=3/8901<3;8>:983 <4590>5C7430:8<4@3<4960>:4>3 0!>91<5>@40=65>D 30 :460983 3/4 5=01>3 0; 9"#($ ! ?83/ 8>34<493 53 - 65 ;<0= 3/4 :534 0; 5@@8:4>3 3877 <457895380> ?83/ 78C4<3D30<4@0E4<3/495=4;<0=3/40?>4<0;3/4E4/8@74 CD:146<0@4990;75?/491C935>3857F149380>90;75?5<4 5>9?4<4:5@@0<:8>27D >3/4<491733/4;0770?8>20<:4<8965994: &8' 66457895770?4:8>65<3 &88' /4 5664775>39 @758=5>39 5<4 4>38374: ;0< 3/4 30357@0=64>95380>0;9"#($ !?83/8>34<49353- 64< 5>>1= ;<0= 3/4 :534 0; 5@@8:4>3 3877 3/4 :534 0; <457895380> 0?4E4< 5964<0<:4< :534:$$3/4 5664775>39 5<4 >03 4>38374: ;0< 8>34<493 ;0< 3/4 :475D4: 64<80: 0; :5D9 8> ;878>2 3/4 566457 0> 3/4 4>/5>@4: @0=64>95380> - 8 - &888' 4960>:4>3 0!>91<5>@4 0=65>D 89 :8<4@34: 30 :460983 3/4 5;0<4958: @0=64>95380> 5=01>3 ?83/8> 0>4 =0>3/ ;<0= 3/4 :534 0; 3/89 B1:2=4>3 ?83/ 78C4<3D30<4@0E4<3/495=4;<0=3/40?>4<0;3/4E4/8@74 CD:146<0@4990;75? &8E' > 91@/ :460983 3/4 5664775>39 5<4 64<=8334: 30?83/:<5?3/44>38<45=01>3570>2?83/8>34<4935@@<14: 0>835964<3/45660<380>=4>3=5:4CD3/4<8C1>57 *+, '&!! ( % 893 07 0