- 1 - ! " #$%!$!$ &!' ( &!' ( ! "# $ ! "# % & ''' ( ! "# Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ )* )) + ! "# * )) ' ! "# " )) ! "# % & ' ) , ' ) $ "( ) $$- $$. ) ) ) ) $$# $#$ * ( ! "# % & ''' ( )' ' ) - 3 - -### $ )' ' ) -### )) ! "# " )* )) + ! "# ! "# - * )) ' ! "# . )) ! "# % & ' ) , ' ) .( ) $$- $$. ) ) ) ) * - 4 - ) / ' & / ' ( 0$#-#$# 12 31456 78 9:5 ;591910<5=2 255>1<?9:530440@1<?=541532 !" # $ %" & ' ( ( ) ( # * +, - " ( # ./# 0 1 0$##$#$ 12 31456 78 9:5 ;591910<5= &@:0 12 ;591910<5= 0 1< 9:5 ;=5A10B2 ;591910<( 255>1<? 30440@1<?=541532 - 5 - 2 * 3 & '" # 2 # $ * ! "##!! #" & ." 45 $5 & !4!! * ( # ./# 0 1 $ :5CD25039:5;591910<5=21<709:9:5;591910<2 12 9:D9 9:58 D=5 9:5 545C956 E5E75=2 03 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9:@:1C:C0<212920331A5A144D?52<DE548 2900= :BEED EEDED7D6 6@D6D D<6 DF4D;B= :D9 21<C5 9:5 ;591910<5=2 D=5 9:5 545C956 E5E75=2 03 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9: 9:58 @5=5 9:5 D2;1=D<92 90 C0<9529 30= 9:5 545C910<909:5;02903=52165<9D<61C5=52165<9039:5 2D16 =DE D<C:D8D9: :D9 B;0< 9:5 C0E;45910< 03 31=29 95=E 03 # E0<9:2 =52;0<65<9 0 @D2 =5GB1=56 90 C0<6BC9 9:5 545C910< 30= 9:5 25C0<6 95=E 0< $$# $#$ 0@5A5=D<09131CD910<;=0;021<?901<C4B659:5D30=52D16 - 6 - 9@0 A144D?52 15 DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D @19: 9:5 16D= B<1C1;D4 0=;0=D910< :D6 755< 122B56 0< ##-$#$ D2 ;5= <<5HB=5 :D9 B;0< 9:5 ;=5E125 03 9@0 A144D?52 <DE548 DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D :DA1<? 755< E5=?56 @19: 9:5 16D= B<1C1;D4 0=;0=D910< 9:5 =52;0<65<92 B9:0=19152616<09;=0C55690C0<6BC99:5545C910<2 :5DC9BD4E5=?1<?039:52D16A144D?52@19:9:5 B<1C1;D40=;0=D910<:D2<099D>5<;4DC5:D921<C59:5 5;B98 0EE12210<5= A165 0=65= $$# $#$ :D6 ;=0;025690C0<6BC99:5545C910<230=9:525C0<695=E03 9:5 2900==DED<C:D8D9:D<6:D6<099D>5<<5C522D=8 295;2 ;591910<5=2 :D6 ?1A5< =5;=525<9D910<2 @:1C: :DA5 <09 755< C0<2165=56 9144 6D95 5<C5 9:5 ;591910<5=2 D;;=0DC:56 9:12 0B=9 78 3141<? 9:5 31=29 @=19 ;591910< 1< 0$#-#$#$ " :D9 1< 9:5 E5D<@:145 9:5 661910<D4 5;B98 0EE12210<5= 03 16D= 129=1C9 :D6 122B56 D C0EEB<1CD910< 6D956 $#$#$ #.#$#$ D66=52256 909:5:153H5CB91A5 331C5=03+144DD<C:D8D916D=D2 - 7 - ;5= <<5HB=5 D<<5H56 90 0$##$#$ ;=0;021<? 90 :046 545C910< 90 9:5 =52165<9 D<6 1C5 =52165<9 ;0292 03 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9: 5HC4B61<? DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D 144D?52 < 3B=9:5=D<C5 9:5=503 D <091C5 03 9:5 E5591<? @D2 122B56 0< #!#$#$ D2 ;5= <<5HB=5;=0;021<?90C0<6BC99:5545C910<909:5;0292 03 =52165<9 D<6 1C5 =52165<9 03 9:5 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9:0<.#$#$ D9##DE:12C0<29=D1<56 9:5;591910<5=90D;;=0DC:9:120B=9783141<?9:525C0<6 @=19;591910< 5D=<56 C0B<254 30= 9:5 ;591910<5=2 =5195=D91<? 9:5DA5=E5<92D<69:5?=0B<62B=?561<9:5D30=52D16@=19 ;591910<2A5:5E5<9482B7E1929:D99:0B?:9:5=52;0<65<9 B9:0=19152:DA520B?:990E5=?5DF4D;B=D<6 6@D6D A144D?52 1<90 9:5 16D= B<1C1;D4 0=;0=D910< 9:5 ED995= :D2<09;=0C556563B=9:5=52B7E1929:5=530=59:59@0 A144D?52 2:D44 75 655E56 90 =5ED1< ;D=9 03 9:5 2900= =DED<C:D8D9: 495=<D91A548:52B7E1929:D91<95=E2 035C910<2"D<6.039:5'D=<D9D>DB<1C1;D40=;0=D910< - 8 - C9 B<914 C0<2919B910< 03 9:5 0=;0=D910< 9:5 545C956 E5E75=22:D44C0<91<B590:0469:50331C5:5=530=59:5 ;591910<5=2:5=51<751<?9:5545C956E5E75=2039:5=DE D<C:D8D9: D=5 5<919456 90 ;D=91C1;D95 1< 9:5 ;=0C522 03 545C910< 90 9:5 ;029 03 =52165<9 D<6 1C5=52165<9 03 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9: 5<C5 255>2 30= <5C522D=8 0=65=21<9:12ED995= - 5=54152B;0<9:51<95=1E0=65=;D2256789:5 00=61<D95 75<C: 03 9:12 0B=9 1< 0$#$#$#$ ;=06BC56 D9 <<5HB=5 D<6 2B7E192 9:D9 B<65= 21E14D= 3DC92219BD910<9:120B=9:D629D8569:5545C910< . 5D=<56 C0B<254 =1 0B=12: ':D2:DE;B= D;;5D=1<? 30= =52;0<65<9 I 0=;0=D910< D<6 +144D D<C:D8D9 3B=<12:52 C0;152 03 <09131CD910<2 ;5=9D1<1<? 90 E5=?1<? 9D>1<? 0A5= 03 DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D A144D?52 1<90 9:50=;0=D910<031980316D=1<95=E2035C910<2" ## #D<6 #039:5'D=<D9D>DB<1C1;D40=;0=D910< C9 .- 5 2B7E192 @165 ;B741CD910<2 @5=5 122B56 7530=5 E5=?1<? 9:5 D30=52D16 9@0 A144D?52 1<90 9:5 - 9 - 0=;0=D910< 03 198 03 16D= 2 3D= 7DC> D2 #"$#$ D<607F5C910<2@5=5CD445630=:5=5:D2755<<0612;B95 0= =52129D<C5 3=0E D<80<5 @:0E205A5= EBC: 4522 9:5 ;591910<5=2 :5=51< 395= C0E;45910< 03 9:5 2D16 ;=0C522 D<61<C0E;41D<C5@19:4D@9:52D16A144D?5229006E5=?56 @19:9:50=;0=D910<031980316D=D<6D<09131CD910<1< 9:12 =5?D=6 :D2 755< 122B56 B=2BD<9 90 9:5 D70A5 ;=0C522 9:5 :153 H5CB91A5 331C5= 03 +144D D<C:D8D9: 16D= :D2 122B56 D< 331C1D4 5E0=D<6BE 6D956 $!# $#$ =5;0=91<? C0E;45910< 03 E5=?1<? ;=0C522 03 AD=10B2 A144D?52 1<C4B61<? DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D 03 2900= D<C:D8D9:5D420=535=290D1=CB4D=6D956-$#$$ 122B56 78 9:5 0A5=<E5<9 03 'D=<D9D>D =5?D=61<? D E5E75=C5D21<?90759:5E5E75=039:5;D<C:D8D9B;0< E5=?1<? 03 9:5 A144D?52 1<90 9:5 40CD4 706152 :B2 :5 2B7E1929:D99:5;=0C52203E5=?1<?039:5259@0A144D?52 1<909:51980=;0=D910<0316D=:DA1<?9D>5<;4DC51<9:5 ED<<5= ><0@<90 4D@ ;591910<5=2 CD<<09 C4D1E 90 75 9:5 E5E75=2 03 9:5 2D16 9@0 A144D?52 751<? 5<919456 90 - 10 - ;D=91C1;D95 1< 9:5 545C910<2 90 9:5 =52165<9 D<6 1C5 =52165<9 03 9:5 2900= =DE D<C:D8D9: 5<C5 255>2 30=612E122D4039:5;591910<2 ! 5D=65=B2569:5=5C0=62 :5 3DC92 <D==D956 D70A5 60 <09 =5GB1=5 =5195=D910< B331C5 90 29D95 9:D9 DF4D;B= A144D?5 D<6 6@D6DA144D?5@:1C:@5=5:19:5=90;D=903 2900==DE D<C:D8D9:DA529006E5=?56@19:9:51980=;0=D910<03 16D= 1< 95=E2 03 9:5 09131CD910< 6D956 #"$#$ D<6 9:5;=0C52203:D<61<?0A5=039:52DE529006C0E;45956 D2 5A165<C56 78 9:5 331C1D4 5E0=D<6BE 6D956 $!# $#$ 122B56 78 9:5 :153 H5CB91A5 331C5= 03 +144D D<C:D8D916D= # 5C910<2 ## # D<6 # 03 9:5 B<1C1;D4 0=;0=D910< C9 ;=0A1652 30= C0<25GB5<C52 03 E5=?1<? 03 144D?52;D=903D<:C:D8D91<904D=?5B=7D<D=5D2=5D62 D2B<65= % # 6( 7 6 # 7 - 11 - * * 6( 7# 568 9( :,& 4;;7 6 # 7#* # 5 4 & 68 9 ( :, & 4 ;;74 # #, * 5 & 4 6 # 74 2 4 3 6+ 56' ( 7 6+9 ( < ( , 7 * , * " # + # $ 6' ( =7 4 # 4 4 * 4 #, # 4* 6 # 7 " & 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 # 4 4 4 6 8 9 ( :, & 4 ;;74 # # * # 4 4 & # 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 # 4 4 4 & " & # 4 4 4 * 4 6 8 9 ( :, & 4 ;;74 # # * # & & # # ## # # # - 12 - * # # # & & * # # * & 4 * * & * # #, * #, # 3 (* # 4#, * '* * * 4 4 4 # 2 * * * 2 # * # * * * # * 4 4 * * # 9 * # * * 4 4 " & # # # # # " & # 4 # # 4 # # 6 # 7 " & # # # # # # 6 # 7 4 " , & 4 * 4 - 13 - # * & 4 # * # * # & " 9 > * & 4 & 4 # 6 # 7 # '* # % # 6 7 6 # 7 6 7 6 # 74 & 68 9 ( :, & 4 ;;7 # #, * 5 & 4 6 # 74 2 3 56' ( =7 * 6' ( 7 # '* 4# 4 " # # 6' ( 7 * 4 4 4 6 # 7 * " # # # & 4# " * 6' ( 7 # '* 4# 4 ! 6 # 7 & 6?#, * 4 '* # 0 @ 0 8 9 @ & 4 ;$5 - 14 - 8 9& ;$5 # # # & 7 + * 8 9@ & 4 ;$5# 6 7 5 # 7 # 3 (* 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4# & 6 7 # # # # * # 4 * & # 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4# & A 56 # 7 # 4 2 4 3 # 56 # 7 8 9 @ & 4 ;$5 # # # # * & , # * & " # 6 # 7 # # " 6 # 7 # @ @ & * 6 # 7# ! @ & " - 15 - 6 4 * $ 8 9@ & 4 ;$5 # 4 @ 04 4 # # & ;;67 567+ *44 * 8 9 @ & 4 ;$5 # # &* 0 # $ ;;7 # 4 4 # 6 # 7 * 6 # 7 4#, # 4* " 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4# 4 # * # * & 4 # 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 # 4 & " # 4 4 * 8 9@ & 4;$5 # # * # & " # # # # 6 # 7 # # # * # # # & " - 16 - # 6 # 7# # " # # # 4# # " , # # # 6 # 7 6 # 7 # # # 4 " 9 * 6 # 7 # # * & 4 * * & 4 * # #, * # 3 (* # 4 #, * '* 4 * * 4 4 4 # 2 * * * 2 # * # * * * # * 4 4 * * # 9 * # * * 4 6 # 7 4 65 & 0 # # & # # - 17 - 0 * 6(* # * # # B # 4 # # # # * 0 @ 0 # # # # # # # # # ? C7 + 4 # 0 @0 # # * # 71 :B2;5=B2D4039:5D30=52D16;=0A1210<2@0B46 1<61CD95 9:D9 B;0< 1<C4B210< 03 D<8 D<C:D8D9 D=5D D<8 A144D?52 D<8 =5A5<B5 A144D?5 1< =52;5C9 03 D<8 ;D<C:D8D9 D=5D 1<90 9:5 4D=?5= B=7D< D=5D 9:5 =DE D<C:D8D9 03 2BC: 40CD4 D=5D 0= ;D=9 9:5=503 2:D44 C5D25 90 5H129 0<25GB5<9@:5=5039:5545C956E5E75=2032BC:A144D?52 0= ;D=9 03 9:5 =DE D<C:D8D9: 2:D44 C5D25 90 75 9:5 E5E75=2 9:5=503 :12 12 C4D=13156 78 D C1=CB4D= 6D956 -$#$$545AD<9;0=910<03@:1C:=5D62D2B<65= - 18 - !"#$%& '( ) *+,) -&./ 0)1 )23 '( ' ) * 45 6*& 7 8&/ )39)& )0 + :& 0)1; #<% '(=> ?+@5 A5 & '( B ) C , =D)=> E)&/F G-))& B H IJ/ )&/K)B IJ/ ) & ' 0)1- .#L% H IJ/ )&/K)=> &/M& M8) B H IJ/ )&/K+9() )&/K)=>N)OP BE )&/K0& G)35 LP8 Q P8 *-& R; R; 4S) R H P@ R B ( J & #&9 &; KT0 R;) RN)2Q. &/9)&% GL)& '( -0 R 2)3*& R IJ/ )&/K) IJ/ )=> ? 0)1 - -0 R 2)3*& RC IJ/ )&/K) 0& ' . B ):=> M8) R; NP R E)&/K R :=> - IJ/ B ) P)U9 &.J 0)1VW $ )=0E9:5D70A5;=0A1210<2034D@<09131CD910<D C1=CB4D= 19 12 C45D= 9:D9 A144D?52 DF4D;B= D<6 6@D6D :DA1<? 755< E5=?56 @19: 9:5 4D=?5= B=7D< D=5D <DE548 9:5 198 0=;0=D910< 03 16D= 9:5 2D16 A144D?52 29006 E5=?56D<69:540CD4D=5D:D2C5D256905H129C0<25GB5<9 03 @:1C: 9:5 ;591910<5=2 <0 E0=5 CD< C4D1E 90 75 9:5 545C956 E5E75=2 03 9:5 2D16 A144D?52 751<? 541?1745 90 - 19 - C0<9529 9:55<2B1<? 545C910< 909:5 ;02903 =52165<9 D<6 1C5=52165<903 2900==DED<C:D8D9:;=0;02569075 :5460<.#$#$ < 9:D9 A15@ 03 9:5 ED995= 9:5 =54153 20B?:9 1< 9:5;591910<2CD<<0975?=D<956 CC0=61<?48;591910<2D=5 612E12256 !)( &$!$' % ' 129040" 9;>