- 1 - ! " # $% # $% ## &'( ) ! " ! " ! # Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $ % & '! %!% ( % % % % ) "* & '!% % ( + + #'( + % ! + **, ! + % !-% % % * * + . + + % /! /! + - 3 - % ' /! ( 012 344536 12 71658 903665:;1:; <05 =>3:<>? $7 9$?45:23<1$: 05 ?31: 9$:<5:<1$: $7 <05 9$>:256 34453@1:; 7$@ <05 9631?3:<2 12 <03< 85953258 3:8>@3:; 3:8> A0$ A32 3;58 3B$>< , C53@2 32 45@ D ) 4$2< ?$@<5? @54$@< 3:8 05 A32 A$@E1:; 32 2>;3@93:5 9><<5@ 3:8 012 1:9$?5 A32 *** - 45@ ?$:<0 !>< <05 @1B>:36 9$??1<<58 3: 5@@$@ 1: <3E1:; 012 1:9$?5 3< "*** -45@?$:<0 05 9$>:256 362$ A$>68 9$:<5:8 <03< @1B>:36 9$??1<<58 3: 5@@$@ 1: 858>9<1:; $:6C <0 <$A3@82 45@2$:365D45:2523:8$>;0<<$03F5858>9<58 <021:95 <05@5 A5@5 25F5: 8545:83:<2 05 7><>@5 4@$2459<2 3< *G12362$:$<3A3@858 653@:58 9$>:256 34453@1:; 7$@ @524$:85:< A$>68 9$:<5:8 <03< <05 @1B>:36 @1;0<6C - 4 - 858>9<58 <0 21:95 $:5 $7 <05 83>;0<5@ 12 36@538C ?3@@1583:820593::$<B5<5@?58328545:83:< 5 7>@<05@ 2>B?1<2 <03< <05 @1B>:36 @1;0<6C <3E5:<051:9$?53:8362$3A3@858<0523?55:95<05 3A3@88$52:$<@5=>1@53:C1:<5@75@5:95 " 3F1:;053@8<05653@:589$>:25634453@1:;7$@ <053445663:<2 32 A56632 <05 9$>:2567$@@524$:85:< <05 4$1:<2<03<A$>683@1257$@9$:2185@3<1$:3@5 # < 12 :$< 1: 8124><5 <03< 399185:< 038 <3E5: 46395 $: ** * 3:8 362$ <05 24591719 9325 $7 <05 9631?3:<2 12 <03< 85953258 A32 A$@E1:; 32 2>;3@93:5 9><5@ 05: <05 399185:< <3E5: 46395 1: <05 C53@ * @1B>:36 $>;0<<$ 03F5 <3E5: <051:9$?5 $7*** - 45@ ?$:<0 1: F15A $7 <05 903@< 4@543@58 BC <05 3@:3<3E3 - 5 - <3<55;365@F1952><0$@1<152B><9$??1<<583:5@@$@1: <3E1:;<0523?53<"*** - 05@51237$@951:<059$:<5:<1$:$7<059$>:256 34453@1:; 7$@ <05 3445663:<2 @5;3@81:; 858>9<1$: 05 @1B>:36$>;0<<$9$:2185@58<05858>9<1$:3< <01:2<538 $7 <0 5F5: <0$>;0 <05 9631?3:<2 3@5 A175 3:8 21D 90168@5: 3:8 :$ 8$>B< $:5 $7 <05 83>;0<5@ A32 ?3@@158 B>< 1: F15A $7 <05 @595:< 859121$: $7 <05 $:HB65 45D $>@< 1: <05 9325 $7 1< 12 93<5;$@19366C 0568 <03< 1: F15A $7 859121$: 1: <05 9325 $7 ?3@@158 83>;0<5@ 362$ 9$?52 A1<01: <05 4>@F15A $7 8545:83:< 05: 2>90 B51:; <05 9325 <05 9$:<5:<1$: $7 <05 9$>:256 34453@1:; 7$@ <05 @524$:85:<-$@4$@3<1$: 93::$<B539954<58 * , '**( " - 6 - , 05@5 12 7$@95 1: <05 9$:<5:<1$: $7 <05 9$>:256 34453@1:; 7$@ <05 3445663:<2 <03< @1B>:36 $>;0< <$ 03F5 858>9<58 $:6C <0 <$A3@82 45@2$:36 5D45:252 $7 85953258 05 @1B>:36 362$ :$< 3A3@858 3:C 7><>@5 4@$2459<23:8<05739<<03<85953258A32,C53@2$6832 45@D )4$2<?$@<5?@54$@<3@5:$<1:8124><5 * 05: 2>90 B51:; <05 9325 <012 $>@< 032 <$ @5F121< <05 9369>63<1$: 3F1:; 9$:2185@58 <05 :$<1$:36 1:9$?532*** -BC3881:;*G327><>@54@$2459<21< 9$?52 <$ ** - 3F1:; 9$:2185@58 <05 23?5 15 ** -BC858>9<1:; <0<$A3@8245@2$:361:9$?521< 9$?52 <$ ,"* - 05 6$22 $7 8545:85:9C 9$?52 <$ "** -',"* -DD ( 05739<<03<<05@53@525F5:8545:83:<26$22 $7 9$:2$@<1>? A$>68 B5 **** - D # 1< A$>68 B5 **** - 43@< 7@$? <03< <$ 2 *** - 12 3A3@858 <$A3@82 7>:5@36 5D45:252 3:8 <@3:24$@<3<1$: 5D45:252 62$ 3< *** - <$A3@82 6$22 $7 52<3<5 0>2 <$<36 9$?45:23<1$:9$?52<$,** - - 7 - 1:95 ?$@5 <03: 21D C53@2 03F5 634258 37<5@ @5:85@1:; $7 859121$: 1: 3445663:<2A$>68B5 5:<1<6587$@3881<1$:$7*G15"*** -$:3A3@8>:85@ 9$:F5:<1$:36 05382 881:; <05 23?5 1< 9$?52 <$ ,** -3:823?51243C3B65A1<01:<5@52<3<<05@3<5 $7 "G 3:8 05:95 A5 03F5 3:2A5@58 <05 4$1:<2 32 3771@?3<1F5 1: 9$?1:; <$ <05 9$:96>21$: <03< @1B>:36 9$??1<<58 3: 5@@$@ 1: :$< 3A3@81:; I>2< 3:8 @532$:3B65 9$?45:23<1$::F15A$78129>221$:?3853B$F5A54322 <057$66$A1:; 1( 4453612366$A581:43@< 11( 05I>8;?5:<3:83A3@883<58**, 4322581:%$ * * BC<05$>@< $7 <05 881<1$:36 5:1$@ 1F16 >8;5 3:8 5?B5@ %1I3C34>@ 12 ?$817158 BC ;@3:<1:; 9$?45:23<1$: $7 ,** - 32 3;31:2< ,**** - A1<0 1:<5@52< $7 "G 3 '*#(""* - 8 - 7@$?<0583<5$745<1<1$:5D954<7$@8563C58 45@1$8 $7 83C2 F185 $@85@ 83<58 *#** 111( :03:958 9$?45:23<1$: 12 43C3B65 A1<01: 21D A55E2 7@$? <05 83<5 $7 @59514< $7 95@<171589$4C$7<012I>8;?5:< 1F( 05 812B>@25?5:< $7 <05 3?$>:< 12 >:36<5@58 *+ &# ( % *+ &( % 12<$6$