- 1 - ! "#" $%!#!%% % & &'() &!!(( * !"#! # " !"#! $ % & !"#! # Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"#! $ % ' #& "# ( !)* #+# ++** #+# #++!#+# #+%&)!"*) , - - ( . %. & /012/ 3/4 563347 89 :8934; <07 6;589980= >83/ 3/4 ?0=94=30<:467=4;?01=94:<07@03/3/4A673849838936B4= 1A<07<8=6:;89A096: # 438380=479@48=26??194;096=;#8=7854 0** #+# 0< 6:8B038 A0:8?4 936380= 742893474; <07 3/4 0<<4=?49A1=89/6@:41=;4794?380=9#+ )!" - 3 - *)746;>83/94?380=,0< 8=0!)* #+# A4=;8=2 0= 3/4 <8:4 0< :467=4; 78=?8A6: 8C8: 1;24 6=; 1;;4@8/6:674@4<0743/890173944B8=230D169/ 3/4 ?7858=6: A70?44;8=29 8=838634; 6268=93 3/45 @694; 0= 3/4 <8793 8=<0756380= 28C4= @E 781724AA6 0 6=26=@696AA66769/4338 , 6?39 0< 3/4 ?694 8= @784< 674 3/63 749A0=;4=3 0# @48=2 3/4 8=<0756=3 <8:4; 3/4 <8793 8=<0756380= >83/ 749A0=;4=3 0 A0:8?4 6::428=2 ?05589980= 0< 0<<4=?4 1=;47C678019A70C8980=90< 6974<4774;306@0C4 389 3/4?0=34=380=0<3/48=<0756=33/636??194;096=;# >/0>474467:847545@4790<3/4 0C47=8=201=?8:0<3/4 0?843E 7450C4; <705 3/487 A0939 69 3/4E >474 6?38=2 6268=933/48=3474930<3/40?843E1@94D14=3:E6??194; 0A70F4?34;/8594:<697498;4=36=;6??194;0#69 4?74367E 0< 44769/68C6 8;E6C67;/6B6 6=2/6 6=; ?0=?0?34; 3/4 7490:1380= @E 6<<8G8=2 <6B4 946: 0< 3/4 6=2/6 03/ 3/4 6??194; ?0=9A874; 30243/47 >83/ 6= 8=34=380=30?/463<0724;3/4982=631746=;91@58334;3/4 - 4 - 7490:1380= 30 3/4 998936=3 05589980=47 0< ;1?6380= 4A67354=3 3/474@E ?0558334; 3/4 6<07454=380=4; 0<<4=?49 = 3/4 @6989 0< 3/4 <8793 8=<0756380= >69 742893474; 6=; 8=C493826380= >69 1=;4736B4= 6=; ?/6724 9/443?65430@4<8:4; ! 467; 78 /8C6=6=; 6336=9/4338 :467=4; ?01=94: <07 3/4 A438380=479 78 656;67 /6/6@1;;8= :467=4; 82/ 0173 0C47=54=3 :46;47 <07 749A0=;4=3 0 3634 6=; 78 6F49/ 0;;656=8 :467=4; ?01=94: <07 749A0=;4=3 0# 47194; 3/4 5634786:9 6C68:6@:4 0= 74?07; = C84> 0< 3/4 78C6: ?0=34=380=9 1724; @E 3/4 :467=4;?01=94:<07@03/3/4A6738493/4A08=33/63>01:; 67894<075E?0=98;476380=89 H(/43/47 3/4 ?7858=6: A70?44;8=29 8=838634; 6268=93 3/4 A438380=479 89 :86@:4 30 @4 D169/4; - 5 - 8=C0B8=2 8=/474=3 A0>47 1=;47 94?380= !#" 0< /6738E66278B176B9/665836#+#,IJ ) E 6=9>47 30 3/4 6@0C4 A08=3 89 8= 3/4 K<073/4<0::0>8=2 !! " 3893/49A4?8<8??0=34=380=0<749A0=;4=30# 3/63 A438380=479 /6C4 =03/8=2 30 ;0 >83/ 44769/68C6 8;E6C67;/6B 6=2/6 6:8B038 ??194; 0 A70F4?34; /8594:< 69 3/4 7498;4=3 6=; 6??194; 0# 69 3/4 4?74367E?0=?0?34;3/47490:1380=@E6<<8G8=26<6B4946: 6=; 91@58334; 3/4 7490:1380= 30 3/4 998936=3 05589980=47 /474 >69 ?0=9A876?E @43>44= @03/ 6??194;6=;3/4E/6C4?/4634;3/46=2/6@E3/4876?39 <3478=C493826380=?/67249/443?65430@4<8:4;56B8=2 9A4?8<8? 6::426380=9 6268=93 6??194; 09 6=; # 8= 3/63 74267; 38991@58334;3/633/4968;<6B4946:>69948L4; @E 3/4 =C49382638=2 <<8?47 <705 3/4 A09949980= 0< 6??194; 0 4=?4 3/474 674 5634786:9 30 ?0=93831343/40<<4=?4696::424; - 6 - * 467=4; ?01=94: <07 3/4 A438380=479 ?0=34=;4; 3/63 A438380=479 6:0=2 >83/ 03/479 /6C4 <8:4; (0#+" #+#, 944B8=2 30 D169/ 3/4 74289376380= ?4738<8?63489914;8=<6C0170<749A0=;4=309,30)/4 968; >783 A438380= 89 938:: A4=;8=2 6=; 3/4 8=34785 936E 89 276=34; 6268=93 749A0=;4=3 09, 30 " 7493768=8=2 3/45 <7056AA08=38=26=E=4>A4790=6=; 0736B8=2=4>:06= 6=; 07 94::8=2 6=E 0< 3/4 A70A473849 A47368=8=2 30 3/4 0?843E 13 3/63 ;049 =03 546= 30 96E 3/63 A438380=479 ?6=?0558391?/?7858=6:6?390<?0=?0?38=23/47490:1380= 6=;91@58338=283303/4998936=305589980=47467=4; ?01=94: <07 3/4 A438380=479 /69 =03 4GA:68=4; 3/487 :0?19 936=;83091@58391?/67490:1380= + =;4791?/?87?15936=?49 650<3/40A8=80= 3/63 3/474 89 9370=2 5634786:9 6268=93 3/4 A438380=47930?0=93831343/4?7858=6:0<<4=?46=;8389=036 <83?694<07D169/8=23/4?7858=6:A70?44;8=29 - 7 - ??07;8=2:E 6=9>47 3/4 6@0C4 A08=3 8= 3/4 K6=;A70?44;30A6993/4<0::0>8=2 8 7858=6:A438380=89 !+) &%%( # 8930:0#