Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63047 (KAR)

MAHADEV AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR

CRL.P/200886/2024 · 2025-08-28

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "! #$!%!$$ $ & &'() &!!(( * !!" # ! $!% ! " & ' ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ! ! !! ! )*+ ! !, ! !! ! ! )*+ & ' ! #- !#. #( ! #! # / ** #0 ! ! ,# ! 1'( 1 ** 1# !! ##! 2 ! , - 3 - ' 2 ! , ( 34 546767"849: ;478< =>>?:4@ ": 6" =8@ 78 "**548@78<"8634A7B4"A634 @@767"8=B ,# =B=;?9=<7 =94 :44C78< 6" D?=:3 634 >97E78=B 59">44@78<: 78767=64@ =<=78:6 634E A"9 634 "AA48>4 5?87:3=;B4 ?8@49 4>67"8: * 1'( 1*=8@*9F1"A 34 A=>6: "A 634 >=:4 78 ;974A =94 63=6 94:5"8@486 " =: >"E5B=78=86 A7B4@ 634 597G=64 >"E5B=786 78 "** ;4A"94 634 97=B "?96 =<=78:6 =>>?:4@ ": 6" =BB4<78< >"EE7::7"8 "A "AA48>4: 5?87:3=;B4 ?8@49 4>67"8: * 1'( 1 * =8@ * 9F 1 "A 6 7: 634 >"864867"8"A63494:5"8@486"63=6:347:634B4<=BBH F4@@4@ F7A4 "A =>>?:4@ " =8@ 63479 E=997=<4 F=: :"B4E87I4@ "8 1** 34 :6=964@ 94:7@78< 78 634 E=697E"87=B 3"?:4 =B"8< F763 =>>?:4@ ": 6" 34H :6=964@@4E=8@78<634E=997=<44J548:4:=8@=>>"9@78<BH - 4 - :*****)F=:5=7@>>?:4@":6"F494694=678< 634 >"E5B=78=86 >9?4BBH ?978< * 94:5"8@486 " ?8@49F486 :?9<49H 6" 634 =8>94=: =6 ":576=B 48<=B?9?34486794E4@7>=B694=6E486F=:;"984;H349 5=9486:>>?:4@":6"3=G48"65=7@=8H6378<67: :6=64@ 63=6 634 =>>?:4@ ": 6" =8@ 3=G4 >"E4 6" 6345=9486=B3"?:4"A94:5"8@486"=8@F=984@3496" ;978<:*****)7A:34F=86:6"94K"78=>>?:4@"78 634E=697E"87=B3"?:4<=78@?978<*=>>?:4@": 6" =8@ =;?:4@ 634 78A"9E=86 78 A7B63H B=8<?=<4 ;H 94A49978< 6" 349 :C78 >"B"?9 =8@ 3?E7B7=64@ 349 >>?:4@ ":6"53H:7>=BBH694=64@349F763>9?4B6H=8@=;?:4@ 78A7B63HB=8<?=<4348634>"E5B=78=863=@;4486"634 E=697E"87=B3"?:4=B"8<F76363479;9"6349:5=9486:=8@ F4BBF7:349:@?978<>6";49*=>>?:4@":6"=8@ =;?:4@349=<=78=8@@4E=8@4@@"F9H>>?:4@": 6"=8@3=G46394=6484@634>"E5B=78=86A"9>78<3496" =;"96634A46?:=8@3=G4;4=648349E49>7B4::BH>>?:4@ " 3=: =B:" =;?:4@ 349 78 A7B63H B=8<?=<4 8 - 5 - *+** @?4 6" :?>3 =>6: "A 634 =>>?:4@ 63494 F=: E7:>=997=<4 8 634 E4=867E4 :34 F=: @7=<8":4@ F763 594<8=8>H @?978< ,?BH *+ =8@ 634 =>>?:4@ :6=964@ @4E=8@78<=@@767"8=B@"F9H=8@=>>?:4@":6"3=G4 ;4=6483498***1634=>>?:4@3=G4"?:64@634 >"E5B=78=86 A9"E 634 E=697E"87=B 3"?:4 =8@ :34 F=: 6=C48 6" 349 5=9486=B 3"?:4 ;H 349 ;9"6349 78>4 6348 :34 7: 94:7@78< =6 =B=;?9=<7 ?978< =H *1 =>>?:4@ ": =8@ A"9>7;BH =;"964@ 634 A46?: ;H =@E787:64978< 34957BB:>>?:4@3=G4=B:"=99=8<4@634:4>"8@E=997=<4 "A=>>?:4@"F763=>>?:4@"8***=6+** 5E =>>?:4@ ": 6" >=E4 6" 634 3"?:4 "A 634 >"E5B=78=86 =;?:4@ =8@ 3=G4 ;4=648 349 =8@ 63494;H >"EE7664@634=A"94:=7@"AA48>4: 34 B4=984@ =<7:69=64 =A649 6=C78< 786" >"8:7@49=67"8 634 =BB4<=67"8: E=@4 78 634 597G=64 >"E5B=786 94>"9@4@ 634 :F"98 :6=64E486 "A 634 >"E5B=78=86=8@6F""6349F7684::4:6""C>"<87I=8>4A"9 634"AA48>4:5?87:3=;B4?8@49 4>67"8:1'( - 6 - 1*=8@*9F1"A =<=78:6=>>?:4@":6" =8@ 478<=<<974G4@;H634"9@496=C78<>"<87I=8>4 634546767"849:;478<=>>?:4@":6"=8@=94;4A"94 637: "?96 :44C78< 6" D?=:3 634 >97E78=B 59">44@78<: 78767=64@=<=78:6634E 4=9@ 97 =@=<=8>37 B4=984@ >"?8:4B A"9 634546767"849:=8@ 97"5=B97:38==@=GB4=984@7<3 "?96"G498E486 B4=@49A"963494:5"8@486") 6=64 L=8@ 7:: 7B?A=93=8=I B4=984@ >"?8:4B A"9 94:5"8@486 " 49?:4@634E=6497=B:"894>"9@ 8 G74F "A 634 97G=B >"864867"8: ?9<4@ ;H 634 B4=984@>"?8:4BA"9;"636345=9674:6345"78663=6F"?B@ =97:4A"9EH>"8:7@49=67"87: !"#$% * Corrected vide Court order dated 09.09.2025 - 7 - H=8:F496"634=;"G45"7867:& 0A"9634A"BB"F78< !! + 34 546767"849: 349478 =94 =>>?:4@ ": 6" =8@ 634H =94 634 A=6349 E"6349 ;9"6349 =8@:7:649"A =>>?:4@ " 34 597G=64 >"E5B=786 A7B4@ ;H 634 >"E5B=78=86)94:5"8@486 " E=C4: :54>7A7> =BB4<=67"8 =<=78:6 =>>?:4@ " =8@ =<=78:6 =>>?:4@ ": 6" 6"<46349 3494 =94 "E87;?: =8@ <4849=B =BB4<=67"8: =<=78:6 =>>?:4@ ": 6" =8@ :6=678< 63=6 =BB 634 =>>?:4@ 3=G4 =;?:4@ =8@ 694=64@ 634 >"E5B=78=86 F763 >9?4B6H>>?:4@":=8@;478<634;9"6349=8@:7:649 "A=>>?:4@"=94:=7@6"3=G4=;?:4@63494:5"8@48678 A7B63HB=8<?=<4=8@@4E=8@4@=@@767"8=B@"F9H=B"8<F763 "6349 =>>?:4@ 5=96 A9"E 63=6 63494 =94 8" :54>7A7> =BB4<=67"8: 6" >"8:676?64 =8H "A 634 "AA48>4 6 7: :6=64@ 63=6634=>>?:4@";478<634E=9974@:7:649"A=>>?:4@ "7:94:7@78<:45=9=64BH 78>463494=94"8BH;=B@=8@ <4849=B=BB4<=67"8:=<=78:6=>>?:4@":=8@=E"A - 8 - 634"5787"863=6634>97E78=B59">44@78<:78767=64@=<=78:6 634E A"9 634 =A"94:=7@ "AA48>4: 7: 78 =;?:4 "A 59">4:: "A B=F 6" 594::?97I4 =>>?:4@ ": 6" 6" =<944 A"9 634 649E: 3494A"94 634 >97E78=B 59">44@78<: 78767=64@ =<=78:6634E7:B7=;B46";4D?=:34@ 34 =BB4<=67"8: E=@4 =<=78:6 =>>?:4@ ": =8@ ;478< 634 A=6349 =8@ E"6349 "A =>>?:4@ " 7: :54>7A7> F763 94A4948>4 6" 634 @=64 =8@ 67E4 34 :F"98 :6=64E486 "A 94:5"8@486 " =8@ 6F" "6349 F7684::4: F494 94>"9@4@ ;H 634 97=B "?96 34 6F" F7684::4: 4J=E784@"8;43=BA"A94:5"8@486"=948"6634A=E7BH E4E;49: "A 94:5"8@486 " ;?6 634H =94 "?6:7@49: 6 >=88"6 ;4 E=@4 "?6 A9"E 634 :F"98 :6=64E486 "A 634:4 F7684::4: 63=6 634H =94 634 4H4)F7684::4: 6" =8H "A 634 "AA48>4:>"EE7664@;H=>>?:4@":=8@86494:678<BH 634;9"6349=8@"6349A=E7BHE4E;49:"A94:5"8@486" =948"64J=E784@6":54=C=;"?6=>>?:4@":=8@A"9 3=G78<>"EE7664@=8H"A634"AA48>4 - 9 - 1 8G74F"A634=;"G4=8:F49634=;"G45"786 M =8@ 59">44@ 6" 5=:: 634 A"BB"F78< =( 34546767"87: ;( 34 546767"8 A7B4@ ;H 546767"849 ":L =8@ L 7: 3494;H >( 34 >97E78=B 59">44@78<: 78767=64@ =<=78:6 634 546767"849L": N =>>?:4@ " =8@ 94<7:6494@ A"9 634 "AA48>4 5?87:3=;B4 ?8@49 4>67"8: 1'( 1 * =8@ * 9F1"A 78"**548@78<"8 634A7B4"A634 @@B,#"?96=B=;?9=<77: 3494;HD?=:34@ !+) &$$( % !7:6" B" * Corrected vide Court order dated 09.09.2025