Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63032 (KAR)
AKHILESH @ AKLESH S/O RAMESH HOSAMANI v. HANAMANTH S/O SHIVAPPA METAGAR AND ANR
MFA/201995/2023 · 2025-11-28
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63032 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63032 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ %& $
%& "&#"
$$
'#( )
!"#$
%
&'
#
! #( !"$) &*! )++ '
!"#$#
%
&#, *'
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* * #+-&#' *
#)!! '*'
* ##$
"+$ $#) * * *
. * /#++$$$
* 0
*
1
1
& &1
'
# 23/ 455647 89:6;6<=3>9 #+-&#' >? >=>; 623<76/ <= #)!!&26;6394?=6;;6?6;;6:=>4/@=26<=0'24/A669?376:AB=26 <743C49=<247769D39D=26E8:DC69=:4=6:##$54//6:AB .3E4B458;439
>"+$ $#)
- 3 -
*4<=/D3F39D;3/6=>=26?3739D>?=26455647A;36?7B/=4=6: 4;6=24=>9$+#$$#!G269=26<743C49=G4/5;><66:39D>9 C>=>;<B<76 A64;39D ;6D3/=;4=3>9 >!$"" >9 9:3 3E4B458;4;>4:964;4F6;324A4>4:4==24==3C6<;83/6;
E665A64;39D;6D3/=;4=3>9>!)++ A639D:;3F69AB3=/ :;3F6; 4= 4 23D2 /566: 49: 39 4 ;4/2 49: 96D73D69= C4996;
:4/26: => =26 F623<76 >? =26 <743C49= / 4 ;6/87= >? =26 4?>;6/43:4<<3:69==26<743C49=/8/=4396:D;36F>8/39E8;36/49: G4/2>/53=473H6:
- 26<743C49=?376:456=3=3>989:6;6<=3>9#"">?=26<= /66I39D<>C569/4=3>9=G4/5764:6:=24=26/569=/3D93?3<49= 4C>89= =>G4;:/ C6:3<47 6J569/6/ <>9F6B49<6 <24;D6/ 49:
>=26; ;674=6: <>/=/ = G4/ ?8;=26; 5764:6: =24= =26 4<<3:69= ><<8;;6:/>767B>94<<>89=>?;4/249:96D73D69=:;3F39D>?=26 >??69:39DF623<76AB3=/:;3F6;
5>9 /6;F3<6 >? 9>=3<6 =26 ;6/5>9:69= > 45564;6:
=2;>8D2 <>89/67 49: ?376: G;3==69 /=4=6C69= :69B39D =26 4F6;C69=/ C4:6 39 =26 <743C 56=3=3>9 26 ;6/5>9:69= ># :6/53=6 /6;F3<6 >? 9>=3<6 :3: 9>= 45564; A6?>;6 =26 ;3A8947 49:G4/574<6:6J54;=6
- 4 -
9 =26 A4/3/ >? =26 5764:39D/ >? =26 54;=36/ =26 743C/ ;3A8947 ?;4C6: =26 3//86/ 49: =26;64?=6; ;6<>;:6: =26 6F3:69<626;3A8947AB3C58D96:E8:DC69=49:4G4;:24/ 54;=7B477>G6:=26<743C56=3=3>949:267:=24==26<743C49=3/ 69=3=76:=>4<>C569/4=3>9>?/-)-$$$ 47>9DG3=239=6;6/= 4==26;4=6>?"K5449::3;6<=6:=26>G96;>?=26>??69:39D F623<76 => :65>/3= =26 <>C569/4=3>9 4C>89= 47>9D G3=2 39=6;6/=639D4DD;36F6:=265;6/69=45564724/A669?376:
" 26 764;96: <>89/67 ?>; =26 <743C49= 24/ ;43/6: =26 ?>77>G39D<>9=69=3>9/ (
* 4' *3;/=7B =26 <743C49= 4//6;=/ =24= 26 G4/ 64;939D /# $$$ 56; C>9=2 AB :>39D 5;3F4=6 E>A >G6F6; =26 ;3A8947 24/ 6;;6: 39 =4I39D =26 39<>C6 4/ C6;67B 4/ /##+ $ 56;C>9=2 A' 6<>9:7B=26<743C49=24/6J4C396:=26:><=>;4/ 26 ;3A8947 89:6;F4786: =26 <743C49=1/ G2>76A>:B :3/4A373=B 4= K <>9=;4:3<=39D =26 6F3:69<6 >? =26 :><=>; =24= =26 <743C49=/8??6;6:#$K# K:3/4A373=B39;6/56<=>?94/47A>96 ?;4<=8;6
- 5 -
<' 4/=7B :86 => =26 4<<3:69= =26 <743C49= 24/ /8/=4396: D;36F>8/39E8;36/6G4/=;64=6:4/3954=369=?>;456;3>:>?# :4B/F694?=6;:3/<24;D6?;>C=262>/53=4726G4/9>=394 5>/3=3>9 => :3/<24;D6 23/ ;6D874; G>;I 6 24/ /8??6;6: 7>= >? 5439 :8;39D =;64=C69= >9/3:6;39D =26 /4C6 =26 >F6;477 <>C569/4=3>94G4;:6:AB=26;3A89473/>9=267>G6;/3:6
26 ;3A8947 24/ ?4/=696: =26 734A373=B >9 =26 39/8;6:
>G96;>?=26>??69:39DF623<76>9=26D;>89:=24==26:;3F6;>? =26>??69:39DF623<76G4/9>=24F39DF473:49:6??6<=3F6:;3F39D 73<69<64/>9=26:4=6>?4<<3:69=>G6F6;/39<6=26<743C49= 3/ 4 =23;: 54;=B 39 F36G >? 74G 743: :>G9 AB =26 >90A76 85;6C6 >8;= 39 =26 <4/6 >? $$$ # # * ! + 49: 39 =26 <4/6 >? # ) *' ,( + 49: 39 F36G >? *877 69<2 :6<3/3>9>?=23/>8;=39=26<4/6>?) &$ -. "## *
/0
+ 6F69 3? =26 :;3F6; >? =26 >??69:39D F623<76 G4/ 9>= 5> 39D F473: :;3F39D 73<69<6 4/ >9 =26 :4=6 >?
4<<3:69==269/8;49<6>C549B3/734A76=>54B<>C569/4=3>9
- 6 -
=>=26<743C49=4==26?3;/=39/=49<6G3=273A6;=B=>;6<>F6;=26 /4C6?;>C=26>G96;>?=26>??69:39DF623<76 3=2 =26 4A>F6 <>9=69=3>9/ =26 764;96: <>89/67 />8D2= =>477>G=26455647 + 9=26>=26;249:=26764;96:<>89/67?>;=269/8;49<6 >C549B24/;43/6:=26?>77>G39D<>89=6;<>9=69=3>9/ (
* 4' *3;/=7B =26 4//6;=3>9 >? <743C49= =24= 26 G4/ 64;939D /# $$$ 56;C>9=2;6C439/89/8A/=49=34=6::86=>74<I>? :><8C69=4;B6F3:69<69=264A/69<6>?5;>>?>?39<>C6=26 ;3A894724/4 6:=2639<>C6>?=26<743C49=9>=3>9477B A' 6<>9:7B=26;3A8947<>9/3:6;39D=2639E8;36//8/=4396:
AB =26 <743C49= 49: 6F3:69<6 >? =26 :><=>; 24/ ;3D2=7B 4 6:=26G2>76A>:B:3/4A373=B4=K <' 23;:7B<>9/3:6;39D=2639E8;36//8/=4396:AB=26<743C49= 49: <>9/3:6;39D =26 4D6 49: 4F><4=3>9 >? =26 <743C49= =26 >F6;477 <>C569/4=3>9 4G4;:6: AB =26 ;3A8947 3/ E8/= 49: ;64/>94A7649:3=:>6/9>=G4;;49=39=6;?6;69<6
=3/9>=39:3/58=6=24==26:;3F6;>?=26>??69:39DF623<76 G4/ 9>= 24F39D F473: :;3F39D 73<69<6 4/ >9 =26 :4=6 >? =26
- 7 -
4<<3:69= G23<2 4C>89=/ => F3>74=3>9 >? =26 =6;C/ 49:
<>9:3=3>9/ >? =26 5>73<B 69<6 =26 ;3A8947 24/ ;3D2=7B 6J>96;4=6:=269/8;49<6>C549B?;>C734A373=B49:?4/=696: 734A373=B>9=26>G96;>?=26>??69:39DF623<76 3=2 =26 4A>F6 <>9=69=3>9/ =26 764;96: <>89/67 />8D2= =>:3/C3//=26455647 L ! 64;:=26764;96:<>89/67?>;=2654;=36/49:56;8/6:=26 E8:DC69=49:4G4;:>?=26;3A8947
) = 3/ 9>= 39 :3/58=6 =24= =26 <743C49= 24/ /8/=4396: 39E8;36/39=26;>4:=;4??3<4<<3:69=><<8;;6:>9$+#$$#!:86 => ;4/2 49: 96D73D69= :;3F39D >? =26 >??69:39D F623<76 AB 3=/ :;3F6;
1$ #$ 26<743C49=<743C/=24=26G4/64;939D/# $$$ 56; C>9=28=2624/9>=5;>:8<6:49B:><8C69=/=>/8A/=49=34=6 23/<743C26;6?>;639=264A/69<6>?5;>>?>?39<>C69>=3>947 39<>C624/=>A64 6:<<>;:39D=>=26D83:67396/3//86: AB=264;94=4I4=4=66D476;F3<6/8=2>;3=B?>;4<<3:69=/ ><<8;;6: 39 =26 B64; $#! 9>=3>947 39<>C6 /2477 A6 =4I69 4=
- 8 -
/##+ $ 5C26;3A894724/;3D2=7B4 6:=26/43: 39<>C6
## / 56; G>89: <6;=3?3<4=6 =26 <743C49= 24/ /8/=4396: ?;4<=8;6>?94/47A>9674<6;4=6:G>89:>F6;76?=8556;73A49: <2394I39D39=><>9/3:6;4=3>9=26:65>/3=3>9>?=26:><=>;49:
39E8;36/ C69=3>96: 39 =26 G>89: <6;=3?3<4=6 =26 G2>76 A>:B :3/4A373=B <49 A6 =4I69 4= K 26 <743C49= 3/ 4D6: 4A>8= - B64;/4==26=3C6>?=264<<3:69=49:C87=35736;45573<4A76=>23/ 4D6 D;>85 3/ @#!0 28/ =26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: ?>;
<>C569/4=3>9 >? . 23 &/##+ $M#M#!M K' >9 4<<>89=>?17>//>??8=8;639<>C61
# 26 94=8;6 >? 39E8;36/ 39:3<4=6/ =24= =26 <743C49= C8/= 24F6A66989:6;;6/=49:=;64=C69=?>;456;3>:>?-C>9=2/ >9/6N869=7B =26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: ?>; <>C569/4=3>9 >? . 3 &/##+ $M- C>9=2/' 89:6; =26 264: @7>// >? 39<>C6:8;39D743:8556;3>:0
#- 26 <743C49= G4/ 2>/53=473H6: 4/ 49 3954=369= ?>; C>;6 =249#:4B/39=262>/53=4749:/8A/6N869=7B;6<63F6:?8;=26;
=;64=C69= 86 => =26 4<<3:69= =26 <743C49= 24/ /8??6;6: D;36F>8/39E8;36/49:47/>89:6;D>96/8;D6;B>9/3:6;39D=26
- 9 -
5;>7>9D6: 5439 :8;39D =;64=C69= 4/ G677 4/ =26 56;C4969= :3/4A373=B<6;=3?36:AB=26:><=>;4C39<7396:=>69249<6=26 <>C569/4=3>94G4;:6:AB=26;3A894789:6;=26264:>?15439 49: /8??6;39D/1 ?;>C /-$$$$ => .23 49: 89:6; =26 264: >? 17>// >? 4C693=36/1 ?;>C /#$$$$
=> .,3
# >9/3:6;39D =26 94=8;6 >?
39E8;36/ =26 <>C569/4=3>9 4G4;:6: AB =26 ;3A8947 89:6; >=26; 264:/ 3/ E8/= 49: ;64/>94A76
# 28/ =26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: => =26 ?>77>G39D <>C569/4=3>9
4567./897:7;60 ;9606786/;. ./</0;6; =>8?6 09=:7/@ '.( ./</0;6; =>8?9.:08 '.( 43949:/8??6;39D/ -$$$$
"$$$$ 6:3<476J569/6/ #! $$ #! $$ *>>:9>8;3/2C69= <>9F6B49<649:4==69:49= <24;D6/ # $$ # $$ >//>?39<>C6:8;39D743: 8556;3>: ! $$ - $
- 10 -
>//>?4C693=36/ #$$$$ $$$$ >//>??8=8;639<>C6 #$# $ #")$$ >//>?/67?<>9?3:69<649:
49J36=B>94<<>89=>? :3/?3D8;6C69= $$$ $$$ 8/@
,! :7;6;
,!2
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
- 11 -
#+ 9=26;6/87==26?>77>G39D>;:6;3/54//6:
4' 264556473//@@<6;975/08 A' 26E8:DC69=>?=26743C/;3A89473/C>:3?36: <' 26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: => 4 =>=47 <>C569/4=3>9 >? .,!23 :' 26 9/8;49<6 >C549B 3/ :3;6<=6: => :65>/3= =26 <>C569/4=3>94C>89=47>9DG3=239=6;6/= "K 54 ?;>C =26 :4=6 >? ?3739D >? =26 <743C 56=3=3>9 =377 =26 :4=6>?;6473H4=3>9G3=239456;3>:>?/3JG66I/?;>C=26 :4=6>?;6<635=>?<>5B>?=23/E8:DC69= 6' 269/8;49<6>C549B3/4=73A6;=B=>;6<>F6;=26/43:
<>C569/4=3>9 4C>89= ?;>C =26 >G96; >? =26 >??69:39D F623<76 M?' 26 ;3A8947 3/ :3;6<=6: => ;6764/6 =26 4C>89= 39
?4F>8;>?=26<743C49=4?=6;:86F6;3?3<4=3>9
;3 '$ ( &
;3 '"&#"( &
3/=>#7> M9/6;=6:F3:624CA6;>;:6;:4=6:$ # $