- 1 - ! " # " $!%&"" $!%&"#&'!!# (") ! " # $ % &""" Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' &"""( ) ! "& ( & ) ) ! " # $ * ( % ''& ''+ , " - '""!'"' '" '"' . / 0 - '"&'"' ' 1/ /2 ( - 3 - 3) 3) ) ! $ 3) % 4 5678 9:75 ;<5757=4 ;<5757=4<: 78 >6?@@<4A74A 56< =:B<: B?5<B '""!'"' ;?88<B CD 56< ?:4?5?E? 5?5< BF74785:?57G< :7CH4?@ ?5 ?@?CH:?A7 74 ;;@7>?57=4 ='" '"' ' :7<II?>58=I56<>?8<?:<56?5:<8;=4B<45=( 6<:<74 6?8 I7@<B ?;;@7>?57=4 C<I=:< ?:4?5?E? 5?5< BF74785:?57G< :7CH4?@ 74 ;;@7>?57=4 ='" '"' >6?@@<4A74A 56< 5:?48I<: =:B<: B?5<B '"&'"' 96<:<74 ;<5757=4<: 6<:<74 6?8 C<<4 5:?48I<::<B 5= 56< ;@?>< =I :<8;=4B<45=(G<456=HA6:7CH4?@6?8A7G<4?>@<?: I74B74A 56?5 56< ?;;@7>?45 :<8;=4B<45 =( 6<:<74 6?8 4= >?8<I=:745<:I<:<4><874><56<5:?48I<:784=5?;:<F?5H:< 5:?48I<: ?4B 56<:< 78 4= ?4D G7=@?57=4 =I 5:?48I<: AH7B<@74<8 4@D =4 56< 8DF;?56<57>?@ A:=H4B 56< - 4 - :7CH4?@ 6?8 ;<:F755<B 56< ;<5757=4<: 5= >=4574H< 74 ?B<;H: =:57>H@5H:< H:8<:D ?@?CH:?A7 57@@ >=F;@<57=4 =I ?>?B<F7> D<?: '"' '"'& 6<:<?I5<: 86< 6?8 5= G?>?5< 56< ;@?>< 5= 56< ;<5757=4<: 6<:<74 6< :<@<G?45 ;?:?A:?;6!:<?B8?8H4B<: J!BF755<B@D 56< ?;;@7>?45 6?8 >=F;@<5<B 56< 5<4H:<7456<;:<8<45;@?><=I9=:E74A4I?>586< 6?8 9=:E<B 74 56< 8?F< ;@?>< I=: F=:< 56?4 ' D<?:888H>656<:<784=7@@<A?@75D745:?48I<::74A 6<:I:=F56<;:<8<45;=856<>=45<457=456?586< 6?84=5=;5<BI=:FH5H?@5:?48I<:?886=947456< 7F;HA4<B =:B<: B=<8 4=5 >=F< 5= 6<: :<8>H< 74 8<5574A ?87B< 56< 8?F< =9<G<: 56< I?>58 ?@8= B78>@=8< 56?5 86< 78 ? 97B=9 ?4B A=5 59= F74=: B?HA65<:8 ;H:8H74A ?4B :<8;<>57G<@D 5 78 56< 8HCF7887=4 =I 56< ?;;@7>?45 56?5 86< 6?8 ?@:<?BD ;?7B 56< I<< I=: 56<7: <BH>?57=4 I=: 56< ?>?B<F7> D<?: '"' '"'& ?4B =4 5678 A:=H4B ;:?D<BI=:>=4574H74A6<:7456<8?F<;@?><57@@56< >=F;@<57=4=I56<?>?B<F7>D<?:'"' '"'&=56 56<A7:@8?:<74?47F;=:5?45;6?8<=I<BH>?57=47< ?4B 967>6 ?:< G<:D >:H>7?@ 74 ?4DC=BD.8 <BH>?57=4?@ >?:<<: 785H:C74A 56<F 74 56<F7BB@<=I56<<BH>?57=4D<?:97@@B<I7475<@D6?G< ? C<?:74A =4 56<7: 85HB7<8 678 I?>5 4<<B8 >=487B<:?57=4 4 I?>5 56< >@?H8< !$+% =I 56< 5:?48I<: AH7B<@74<8 ;:=G7B<8 I=: <K5<487=4 =: - 5 - 86=:5<474A =I 5<4H:< 74 56< >?8< =I 97B=9 6< ?;;@7>?45 C<74A ? 97B=9 9756 59= B?HA65<:8 78 <@7A7C@< 5= A<5 56< C<4<I75 =I 5678 >@?H8< 6=HA6 56<:< 78 4= :<85:7>57=48 =4 5:?48I<::74A ? ;:=C?57=4<: 74 56< >?8< =4 6?4B 56< >?8< =I 56< ?;;@7>?454<<B8>=487B<:?57=46<>=45<457=456?5 56< (56 <8;=4B<45 I?56<: 78 8HII<:74A I:=F 6<?@56 788H<8 >?4 4=5 C< B<47<B CH5 6< C<74A ? D=H4A F?4 >?4 ?55<4B 5= 678 I?56<: 5:<?5F<45 I=: 8=F< F=:<;<:7=B?86<78B=74A?8=I4=9=:<=G<:75 788HCF755<B56?56<6?8?C:=56<:?@8=5=5?E<>?:< =I 678 I?56<: 6< ;:?D<: =I 56< ?;;@7>?45 5= >=4574H< 6<: 57@@ >=F;@<57=4 =I 56< ?>?B<F7> D<?: '"' '"'&?4B?I5<:56?586< 97@@G?>?5<56<;=85 74I?G=H:=I56<<8;=4B<45=(788H85?74?C@<=4 56< A:=H4B 56?5 86< 78 ? 97B=9 ?4B 6<: 59= B?HA65<:8 ?:< 85HBD74A 56< ?4B ?4B =4@D I<9 F=4568 ?:< @<I5 I=: >=F;@<57=4 =I 56<7: :<8;<>57G<>@?88<8L 5 56< =;<:?57G< ;=:57=4 =I 56< =:B<: =I 56< :7CH4?@56<:<784==C8<:G?57=456?556<:<8;=4B<45=( 6?8 5= G?>?5< 56<;=85 74 I?G=H: =I56< ;<5757=4<:6<:<74 <5757=4<:.8A:7<G?4><78=4@D74:<8;<>5=I56?574G7<9=I 56<=C8<:G?57=4F?B<7456<;?:?!=I56?5=:B<:I5<:56< >=F;@<57=4 =I ?>?B<F7> D<?: =I 56< B?HA65<: =I 56< :<8;=4B<45 =( 6<:<74 56< ;<5757=4<: F?D C< ;<:F755<B - 6 - 5= 5?E< >6?:A< 74 ?B<;H: =:57>H@5H:< H:8<:D ?@?CH:?A7>>=:B74A@D56<=:B<:;?88<BCD56<:7CH4?@ B?5<B '""!'"' 74 ;;@7>?57=4 ='" '"' 78 F=B7I7<B5=56?5<K5<45I5<:>=F;@<57=4=I56<?>?B<F7> D<?: '"' '"'& 56< :<8;=4B<45 =( 6?8 5= G?>?5< 56< ;=8574I?G=H:=I56<;<5757=4<:6<:<74 ( 6<:<8;=4B<45?H56=:757<8?:<B7:<>5<B5=F?E< ?>>=FF=B?57=4I=:56<;<5757=4<:5=>=4574H<7456<;@?>< ;H:8H?45 5= 56< 5:?48I<: =:B<: B?5<B '"&'"' ?I5<: >=F;@<57=4=I56<?>?B<F7>D<?:'"' '"'& 75656<?C=G<=C8<:G?57=456<9:75;<5757=478 "*+ (") & "*+ (#&'!!#) & 785=@=(