- 1 - !" # $# % ## # &! &'() !& (( * !" # $ # !" % %# !" " & % !" #% !" Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % !" ' % !" # !" ( ) $ * $$ $$ $!' # & %% & # !" ( ) + #* "# ,* & - ! #!#" !! #!#" "% "' %" %#% %")* !" ! & ". - 3 - & / )* ! #!#" ,,* / & 0 ) 0* 12341 516 785569 ,: ;,:56< =29 8<7,::,2> ?,51 516 @2>:6>5 2= ;689>6< @23>:6; =29 516 A895,6: ,5 ,: 58B6> 3A =29=,>8;<,:A2:8; # 16 A65,5,2>69: C6,>4 8@@3:6< 2: 52 896 :66B,>452D38:1516@9,7,>8;A92@66<,>4:,>,5,856<848,>:5 5167 ,> 9,76 2 ! #!#" 2= 2;437C8E 2;,@6 585,2> ,F8G8A39 <,:59,@5 964,:5696< =29 516 2==6>@6: A3>,:18C;6 3><696@5,2>:"%"'%"%#%%"!"! 968< ?,51 6@5,2> ". 2= ><,8> 6>8; 2<6 ! )=29 :1295 H/* >2? A6><,>4 2> 516 =,;6 2= 9,>@,A8; ,I,; 3<46 )9>*2395,F8G8A39 - 4 - % 689<9,2,>8B15898<8=;689>6<@23>:6;=29 516 A65,5,2>69: 8>< 9, 878<89 1818C3<<,> ;689>6< ,41 2395 2I69>76>5 ;68<69 =29 96:A2><6>5 2 J 5856 6:A2><6>5 2# 512341 :69I6< ?,51 >25,@6 18: 9678,>6< 3>96A96:6>56< 693:6< 516 78569,8;: 2> 96@29< " > I,6? 2= 516 9,I8; @2>56>5,2>: 3946< CG 516 ;689>6<@23>:6;=29C251516A895,6:516A2,>55185?23;< 89,:6=297G@2>:,<6985,2>,: !" G8>:?69525168C2I6A2,>5,:,>516 =29 516=2;;2?,>4 6:A2><6>5 2# 18: =,;6< 516 =,9:5 ,>=29785,2> ?,51 2;437C8E A2;,@6 :585,2> ,F8G8A39 - 5 - <,:59,@5 8;;64,>4 5185 2> !"! #!#" 85 !! A7 ?1,;6:16?8:,>169123:68;2>4?,51169<8341569 8@@3:6< 2 @876 8>< :58956< 8C3:,>4 169 ,> =,;51G ;8>43846 &16> 516 =,9:5 ,>=2978>5 D36:5,2>6< 516 1,4118><6< 8@5: 2= 516 8@@3:6< 8;; 516 8@@3:6< =297,>4 5167:6;I6: ,>52 3>;8?=3; 8::67C;G 8C3:6< 169 ,> =,;51G ;8>43846 ,>:,:5,>4 169 52 I8@856 516 123:6 8>< 516G 18I6 A3;;6< 169 @;2516: ?,51 8> ,>56>5,2>52235984616972<6:5G8><@83:6<,>F39,6: 16G18I6@9,7,>8;;G,>5,7,<856<16952465516123:6 I8@856< >516>6K5<8G:16?6>55251612:A,58; 425596856<8><:3C:6D36>5;G=,;6<516=,9:5,>=29785,2> ?,51 2;437C8E A2;,@6 ,F8G8A39 @@29<,>4;G @87652C6964,:5696< 5 ,: 516 @2>56>5,2> 2= ;689>6< @23>:6; =29 516A65,5,2>69:518596:A2><6>52#1696,>,:8@@3:6< 2" ,> 9,76 2" #!#" 2= 2;437C8E A2;,@6 - 6 - :585,2>,F8G8A39?1,@1?8:964,:5696<2>516C8:,: 2= 516 =,9:5 ,>=29785,2> ;2<46< CG A65,5,2>69 2% 1696,>16@2AG2=516=,9:5,>=29785,2>8><516 ,> 9,76 2" #!#" ,: A92<3@6< C6=296 516 2395 @@29<,>4 52 ?1,@1 516 ,>@,<6>5 18< 2@@3996< 2> #!!#!#" ?1696 516 ,>=2978>5 C6,>4 A65,5,2>69 2%1696,>=,;6<516=,9:5,>=29785,2>848,>:58@@3:6< 2: 52 :585,>4 5185 8@@3:6< 2 51696,> ?8: 568:,>4 8>< 1898::,>4 516 <8341569 2= 516 ,>=2978>5 8>< 516 25169 8@@3:6< =297,>4 5167:6;I6: ,>52 3>;8?=3; 8::67C;G 8C3:6< 516 ,>=2978>5 8>< 25169: ,> =,;51G ;8>43846 8>< 8::83;56< 5167 ?,51 18><: 1696CG 516G 18I6 @277,556< 516 2==6>@6: A3>,:18C;6 3><69 6@5,2>: "% "' %" %#% %#" %" %" !" ! 8>< ". 2= 8>< 3><69 6@5,2> # 2= 516 9256@5,2> 2= 1,;<96> =927 6K38; ==6>@6: @5 #!# 5 ,: 516 @2>56>5,2> 2= ;689>6< - 7 - @23>:6;=29516A65,5,2>69:51858:8@23>569C;8:5516 A96:6>5@27A;8,>5@87652C6=,;6< ' ;689>6<,4123952I69>76>5 ;68<69=2996:A2><6>5218:A92<3@6<516@2AG2= 516 ?23>< @695,=,@856 52 :12? 5185 96:A2><6>5 2# 1696,> 18< :3:58,>6< ,>F39,6: 8>< :16 18< 58B6> 5968576>5?,515161,:529G2=8::83;5 16 ?23>< @695,=,@856 <,:@;2:6: @277,::,2> 2= 516 2==6>@6 CG 516 A65,5,2>69: ,>@6 51696 896 78569,8;: 52 @2>:5,5356 516 2==6>@6:8:8;;646<872=5162A,>,2>5185,5,:>25 8 =,5 @8:6 52 D38:1 516 @9,7,>8; A92@66<,>4: ,>,5,856< 848,>:5516A65,5,2>69: . @@29<,>4;G 8>:?69 516 8C2I6 A2,>5 ,> 516 8><A92@66<52A8::516=2;;2?,>4 - 8 - 16@9,7,>8;A65,5,2>,: +) &##( % ,:52;2%% $