Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63028 (KAR)
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. ABU TURAB S/O ABDUL AZIZ AND ANR
MFA/200390/2021 · 2025-11-03
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63028 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63028 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$%&
&&
'"( )* && +
'"(
)
*
! "
#$$
% $%
! &
'()
$ (*
! "
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
+ $ (*
#$ ! % & , %
&& - & %$ $$ & . * *- **$ % /*( % . $ $
+)
*
+ $ (*
$
% &&
$+ && $$ % '(*
#$$ . %
- 3 -
! " (*
! &
'()
! " (*
#$ % $% & , %
&&- & %$ & . * *- ** $ % /*( % . $$ & . %
0 .$
%
12 344235 67 & 8 **-(-* 69 :; <12 =536>37<37?<1234423567 &8 **)**69:;<12 79@A37=2 8>437; 3B3679< <12 93>2 C@?B>27< 37? 3D3A??3<2?* *- **43992?:;<122768A6E65.@?B2 37? 3?B6A FG8A 918A< HA6:@735IJ 67 % 8 /*(
- 4 -
12:A62GG3=<98G<12=3923A2<13<=536>37<>2< D6<1 37 3==6?27< 87 * *- 37? 9@9<3672? BA62E8@9 67C@A629 27=212G652?=536>42<6<687:2G8A2<12A6:@735 =536>67B =8>42793<687 8G 9 ****** GA8> <12 A29487?27<9 12A6:@735=8796?2A67B<1227<6A2>3<2A6359 3E3653:5287A2=8A?13?3D3A?2?39@>8G9 -*** D6<167<2A29<3<K42A377@>GA8><12?3<28G42<6<687<655 A2356L3<687 37? ?6A2=<2? A29487?27< 8 79@A37=2 8>437;<893<69G;<123D3A?3>8@7< BBA62E2?:;<12 936?C@?B>27<<129234423593A2G652? 23A72? =8@7925 G8A <12 34425537<=536>37< =87<27?2? <13< <18@B1 <12 =536>37< D39 23A767B 9 **** 42A>87<1 <12A6:@735 139 <3M27<12 93>2 3< 9 (*** D6<18@< 37; :3969 < 69 G@A<12A =87<27?2? <13< <12 =8>42793<687 3D3A?2?:;<12 A6:@735 @7?2A 355 123?67B9 3A2 87 <12 52992A 96?2 D16=1 A2N@6A29 67<2AG2A27=2:;<1698@A< <693598=87<27?2?<13<?@2 <83==6?27<3567C@A629=536>37<9@9<3672?KD1852:8?;
?693:656<;<12A6:@7353992992?<1293>23<K875;37? - 5 -
3D3A?2?>23BA2=8>42793<687@7?2A355123?9<12A2G8A2 A2N@29<2?G8A27137=2>27<
/
7 <12 344235 :; <12 79@A37=2 8>437; 6< 69 942=6G6=355;=87<27?67B<13<<12A6?2A8G<12>8<8A=;=52D39 78< 13E67B E356? 37? 2GG2=<6E2 A6E67B 6=2792 37? 6< 3>8@7<9 <8 :A23=1 8G <2A>9 37? =87?6<6879 8G <12 4856=; @7?2A2=<687/)8G % =< 27=26<69=87<27?2? <13< <12 79@A37=2 8>437; 69 78< 563:52 <8 43; <12 =8>42793<687398A?2A2?:;<12A6:@735
23A? 3AB@>27<9 8G :8<1 96?29 67 :8<1 <12 344235937?42A@92?<12>3<2A63593E3653:5287A2=8A? ?>6<<2?5; 6< 9 3 =392 8G 78 A6E67B 6=2792
27=2 39 42A <12 ?2=69687 8G 42O 8@A< 67 <12 =392 8G
<12 79@A37=2 8>437; 69 ?6A2=<2? <8 43; <12 =8>42793<687 <8 <12 =536>37< 3< <12 G6A9< 679<37=2 37? <12A23G<2A A2=8E2A <12
1 *(*(
- 6 -
93>2GA8>A29487?27<8
==8A?67B5;<12344235G652? :;<1279@A37=28>437;69<8:23558D2?6743A<
-
942A8@7?2A<6G6=3<2O $/=536>37<139 9@9<3672? GA3=<@A2 8G <6:63 37? G6:@53 37? 3598 67C@A629 <8 8<12A43A<98G<12:8?; 12=536>37<D393?>6<<2?67<12 18946<35 G8A ?3;939 42A O $- P 69=13AB2 @>>3A;
$8=<8A139699@2?693:656<;2A<6G6=3<23942AO $) 3==8A?67B<8D16=1<12=536>37<9@GG2A2?K42A>3727< ?693:656<;<8<1258D2A56>:37?<12A6:@735139=8796?2A2? 8G <12 93>2 39 G@7=<68735 ?693:656<; K 169 8@A<G67?978A23987<867<2AG2A2D6<1<12936?8A?2A
(
536>37< 9<3<2? <13< 12 D39 23A767B 9 **** 42A >87<1 :@< 12 139 78< G652?
37; 67=8>2 4A88G 9 <12 3==6?27< 69 8G <12 ;23A *- 39 42A <12 =13A< 699@2? :; <12 '3A73<3M3 <3<2 2B35 2AE6=29 @<18A6<;<1698@A<?22>96<344A84A63<2<8A2399299<12 67=8>2 8G <12 =536>37< 3< 9 ** 42A >87<1
==8A?67B5; <12 =536>37< 69 27<6<52? G8A 5899 8G G@<@A2 23A767B=343=6<;39@7?2A
- 7 -
9 -*OO(OKQ9 (*-** )
12 =536>37< D39 <A23<2? 39 6743<627< 67 <12 18946<35G8A?3;9 88M67B<8<1273<@A28G67C@A62937? 8<12A A252E37< G3=<8A9 <169 8@A< G67?9 6< A239873:52 <8 3D3A? 37 3>8@7< 8G 9 **** G8A >2?6=35 2O427929, 9 ****G8A436737?9@GG2A67B,9 ***G8A58998G 3>276<629, 37? 9 **** G8A <A37948A<3<687 3<<27?37< 37? 2O<A3 78@A691>27< =13AB29 88M67B <8 <12 73<@A2 37? 92A68@97299 8G 67C@A629 <12 =536>37< >6B1< 78< 13E2 3<<27?2? 37; D8AM 3<5239< G8A >87<19 127=2 12 69 27<6<52? G8A 9 *-* G8A 5899 8G 67=8>2 ?@A67B 536? @4 42A68? * 12 =8>42793<687 3D3A?2? :; <12 A6:@735 69 >8?6G62?39@7?2A 5 8
23?9 D3A?:;<12 A6:@735 D3A?:;<169 8@A<
$36737?9@GG2A67B 9 **** 9 ****
2?6=35O427929
9 ****
- 8 -
899 8G G@<@A2 23A767B=343=6<; 9 )** 9 (*-** / A37948A<3<687 2O<A3 78@A691>27< 37? 3<<27?37< =13AB29 9 /** 9 ****
8998G3>276<629 9 **** 9 ***
899 8G 67=8>2 ?@A67B 536? @4 42A68? 9 /** 9 *-* 8<35 9 -** 9 /* 12A2D655:227137=2>27<8G9 ()*
7<12A29@5<<12G8558D67B8A?2A6943992? 6 8<1 <12 3442359 3A2 ! "
66 12 =536>37< 69 27<6<52? G8A <12 27137=2? =8>42793<687 8G 9 ()* D6<1 67<2A29< 3< K 42A 377@> GA8> <12 ?3<2 8G 42<6<687<655<12?3<28GA2356L3<687
666 12 79@A37=2 8>437; 69 ?6A2=<2? <8 ?24896< <12 27<6A2 =8>42793<687 3>8@7<
- 9 -
3587B D6<1 67<2A29< D6<167 872 >87<1 GA8> <12 ?3<2 8G <169 C@?B>27< 37? 69 3< 56:2A<; <8 A2=8E2A<1293>2GA8>A29487?27<8
6E 7 9@=1 ?24896< <12 =536>37< 69 42A>6<<2?<8D6<1?A3D<1227<6A23>8@7<3587B D6<167<2A29<3==A@2?876<
E 12 3>8@7< 35A23?; ?24896<2? 69 <8 :2<A379G2AA2?<8<12A6:@735
'&( %
69<8 58 // .