Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 63017 (KAR)

KASHIBAI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR

WP/202399/2024 · 2025-11-19

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$% &%'!%!% (!) !" # $ %& ' % % !!! " % % !" # $ ( ') %'"& Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' "" "" ' ' ' * +""!", ,!,"!" - " - '% ' ,!-! $"!! *'& ' . ( $. ( & /010123/4 15 6/724/ 0815 2940 5//:13; 72<<2=13; 4/<1/75 > 559/ ? =410 13 08/ 3?094/ 27 @/40124?41 02 A9?58 08/ /3B245/C/30 6/?413; 32 B?0/B +""!", ?3B ?<52 /3B245/C/30 6/?413; 2 B?0/B ,!,"!" ?5 ?0 33/D94/5 ?3B 6208 1559/B 6E "3B 4/5F23B/30 ?9082410E ?3B B14/@0 08/ 4/5F23B/305 02 /D/@90/ 08/ 5?</ B//B 13 8/4 7?G294 13 4/5F/@0 27 08/ ?<<200/B 10/ 2 C/?59413; ,!D! C/0/45 $"!! 5A70& 13 ?41E?F94 20?3224 ?B?=?3/?<?694?;1H - 3 - " /010123/4 =?5 ?<<200/B 10/ 2 C/?59413; ,!ID!I $"!! 5A9?4/ 7//0& 724 ? @2351B/4?0123 27 5+!!! ?0 ?41E?F94 20?3224 ?B?G?3/ ?<?694?;1 6E 4/5F23B/30 2"?9082410E /010123/4 B/7?9<0/B 13 C?:13; 08/ F?EC/30 /5F23B/30?90824101/5 1559/B ? 3201@/@?<<13;9F2308/F/010123/402F?E?3?;;4/;?0/59C 27 5+ !! ?5 F/4 33/D94/ B?0/B ""! 3 4/5F235/ 02 =81@8 F/010123/4 F?1B ? 59C 27 5!!! ?3B 501<< 4/C?13/B <1?6</ 02 F?E 6?<?3@/ ?C2930 27 5, !! , 2935/< 724 08/ F/010123/4 596C105 08?0 93B/4 08/51C1<?4@14@9C50?3@/508/1G15123 /3@82708152940 13 "*+ B15F25/B 27 23 ", 8?BF/4C100/B08/?FF/<<?3008/4/1351C1<?4<E5109?0/B=108 08?02708/F/010123/48/4/1302F?E?3?BB10123?<59C27 5!!!!! 2G/4 ?3B ?62G/ 08/ /3014/ ?<<20C/30 F41@/ ?<4/?BE F?1B =10813 084// C23085 ?3B 8?B B14/@0/B 08/ 4/5F23B/30?9082410E02/D/@90/08/B//B275?</=10813? - 4 - F/412B2723/C230808/4/?70/4/596C105F/010123/4C?E ?<526//D0/3B/B51C1<?46/3/710 3 4/5F235/ </?43/B @2935/< 724 4/5F23B/30 2" 596C105 08?0 F/010123/4 15 501<< B9/ ?3B <1?6</ 02 F?E 5, !! =81@8 15 4/A914/B 02 6/ F?1B 02;/08/4 =108 130/4/50 ?0 J F/4 ?339C 742C 08/ B?0/ 27 B/C?3B ?5 F/4 33/D94/ =81@8 15 B?0/B ""! 3 ?BB10123 F/010123/4154/A914/B02F?E5!!!!! 759@8?C2930 15F?1B?5B14/@0/B08/3//B79<=1<<6/B23/ 0 15 3201@/B 08?0 4/<E13; 9F23 08/ ?724/5?1B 24B/42708/1G15123 /3@827081529405/G/4?<F/0101235 ?4/ 6/13; 71</B 6E 08/ ?<<200//5 5//:13; 51C1<?4 6/3/710 <<20C/30513C2502708/@?5/58?G/6//3C?B/15/?4<E E/?4527++!815C/?3508/?<<200//5?4/?FF42?@813; 0815 2940 ?70/4 <?F5/ 27 C24/ 08?3 ,! E/?45 ?3B 501<< 5//:13;08/6/3/71027?<<20C/3093B/408/2<B4?0/5 815 2940 @?3320 6/ 26<1G1295 27 08/ 7?@0 08?0 1324B13?0/ B/<?E @29F</B =108 <?D10E 23 08/ F?40 27 08/ - 5 - F/010123/45 @?3320 6/ 08/ F4/C19C 724 08/C 02 5//: 08/ 6/3/710 13?5C9@8 ?5 ?<<20C/30 27 08/ 510/5 93B/4 08/ 5@8/C/ 27 08/ @0 ?3B 9</5 15 02 /3594/ 08?0 0825/ B/5/4G13; @?3B1B?0/5 ?4/ ;1G/3 6/3/710 8/ 49</5 27 ?<<20C/30?5?FF<1@?6</6?@:13++!I558?<<?<526/C?B/ ?FF<1@?6</ /G/3 =81</ /D0/3B13; ?3E 6/3/710 23 F413@1F</ 27 F?410E 6?5/B 23 F4/@/B/305 3 208/4 =24B5 17 08/ ?<<200//5=/4/320241;13?<<E/3010</B72408/?<<20C/30724 08/ 4/?523 27 08/E 8?G13; ?3E ?<0/43?0/ ?@@2CC2B?0123 F<2008/E58?<<3206/;1G/36/3/7102708/24B/45724C/4/ ?5:13;2308/F413@1F</27F?410E 015130815B14/@0123081529408?B@?<</B9F23 08/ @2935/< 724 4/5F23B/30 2" 02 C?:/ 3/@/55?4E 596C1551235 2B?E</?43/B@2935/<7244/5F23B/302"71</B ? C/C2 ?<23; =108 ? 724C?0 27 ?771B?G10 =81@8 15 F4/5@416/B ?5 F/4 ?43?0?:? 46?3 /G/<2FC/30 $<<20C/30 27 10/5& $C/3BC/30& 9</5 "!! 8/ 5?1B ?771B?G104/?B5?5 - 6 - !"#$%$!& '( )"*+" ,-./!0123 ",4.56 , $7897:;<= >7?",@:A './!0123= BB"C DDDDDDDDDD : 0DDDDDDDDDD( " ,7E DDDDDD FGDDDDDDDD 1H7ADDDDDDDDDDI +H 0 :",@JK7:L( = M C , N ":L 89 "7 ",0CL< - O - P O7KQ ,,"R Q"S T"R$9( !"#$% $!$ 8 O 6P ,,"R $!$ 8 .U" 6P #O " 0V& "O 8& O TQ-: ,,"R 7K 7W"G 7 X 7 7YH "Z : Q"S O [ 0$"R$*9( =7",G"H"\6V 6P]G89 "7",0CL<( = - "^6 "", _*9 "V (DDDDDDD T:L(O+"",I "*" `aHb"7"UG6"-O $:L( =DDDDDDDD"689Q"S;.567897CL<( =6P !"#$%$!'Q"SO [='C<4= Q ,"H&cd "-Q"6ef g "\6H ."$! ,H .U" $!"R 8h: IS " 7" ,"- 17LKf ."C Q0* ."$! ,H Pa0 Q",6@ "K ,- - 7 - i@6V7:L( c "H 7K ."$! ,89 Pa0 Q",6@"- i@6V7$<89 O [ ,- <V7O ":L cd "- :OO '<47O= ":L O [ "C ",4 :O Q"S ",WG S( (j \a O@"-"PaOkHbc/d:L( l=6P !"#$% $! 'Q"S O [= 'C<4= Q ,"H& O [ :"- f?Kf: M :L'=$"7H"C",0:L( $!"RF @'=89Q$6\a4f"."$! S( \a 4m ,- "C7 c/d:L O Q$: ."$! ,H iC6 ":L 7 , ",4 : `73 f?Kf .":L $"7H " 89 CL , cd "- - 7? : n[6Q @J ",4Hb c/d:L( 1 "89 "C ",4"O :O @J S;"- "PaOk 0Q"S<V7O( = "* CVf" ",eC , CV "`a 7:G" ":L ,,"R- "op" ",49" X^7:L( c "H + "* OV ",eC , :Rd.U"7Hb 0 89O [789f<- .56 ,- < 4f 7 , ",4 @J S; ":L" 0q"@JO@"-"PaOkHb c/d:L( O O [ C<4 Q ," 76"R I r :" Q ,","V %:L( !"#$% $! O4f Ps , \:LV O Q"S O [ Q ,"V c/d& t$& ""K ",4 0 O "7C 0"@ Q"S; .56 789f:L( 7YHA $ A X^:7eu - 8 - + 8/ 4/5F23B/30?90824101/5 58?<< 260?13 08/ ?771B?G10 742C 08/ ?<<200//5 13 08/ ?724/5?1B 724C?0 ?3B 58?<< ?<52 /3594/ 08?0 32 08140E F?40E 130/4/50 13 08/ 130/44/;39C 8?5 6//3 @4/?0/B 13 4/5F/@0 02 08/ 510/ 02 =81@808/6/3/7102708153?094/156/13;/D0/3B/B'9408/4 08/@2351B/4?01232708153?094/58?<<6/23<E134/5F/@027 08/?<<200//5=825/?<<20C/308?53206//3@?3@/<</B ! 108 08/ ?62G/ 265/4G?0123 08/ F/010123 15 =10872<<2=13;B14/@0123 1& 8/ F/010123/4 58?<< F?E 08/ 6?<?3@/ 59C 27 5, !! =108 130/4/50 ?0 J F/4 ?339C @?<@9<?0/B742C""!01<<B?0/ 11& 3 ?BB10123 08/ F/010123/4 58?<< ?<52 F?E 5!!!!! ?5 B14/@0/B 6E 08/ 1G15123 /3@8 27 0815 2940 13 08/ ?62G/ 2"!!+"!",B?0/B,! "!" 111& 8/5?1B?C293058?<<6/F?1B=10813?F/412B 27 084// C23085 742C 08/ B?0/ 27 4/@/1F0 27 @/40171/B@2FE27081524B/4 - 9 - 1G& 8/ F/010123/4 58?<< /D/@90/ 08/ ?771B?G10 13 08/ F4/5@416/B 724C ?5 /D04?@0/B 8/4/13 ?62G/ !-+ (%!%) ' 1502<2