- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! " # $ $$ %&'&"( ) $$ %&'&" $ )* "% )"))+ #! $ $ ", "! $ # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ # &")))) ()-)"- $ $ $ # . # " /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 ) 4=90>>/0?=9;=?/2<@34/A?0=7083050=89334/ B6257/83 082 0C012 203/2 &")))) >099/2 <@ 34/ 22=3=:80?/8=:1=D=? 625/082 0?0<6105=E;:1 94:13 F1=<680?GH =8 :()-)"- 9//I=85 /8408A/7/83:;A:7>/8903=:8 4/=8B61/2A?0=708305/2)(@/0197/3C=3408 0AA=2/83 :8 "")"' 082 96930=8/2 51=/D:69 =8B61=/9 / ;=?/2 0 A?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? 9//I=85 A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9)"% ;1:7 34/ 1/9>:82/839 4/ 1=<680? 0;3/1 A:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ /D=2/8A/ :8 1/A:12 0C012/2 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9&'-'% C=34 - 3 - =83/1/93 03 (J >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=K03=:8 + 551=/D/2 <@ 34/ 90=2 0C012 34/ 0>>/??083% A?0=7083409>1/;/11/234=90>>/0?70=8?@A:83/82=853403 34/ 1=<680? /11/2 =8 30I=85 34/ 2=90<=?=3@ :8?@ 03 "J =89>=3/ :; /D=2/8A/ :; 34/ #) L :A3:1 C4: =996/2 M" L =90<=?=3@ /13=;=A03/ 099/99=85 34/ 2=90<=?=3@ 03 'J3:34/C4:?/<:2@3=9;6134/1A:83/82/23403 34:654 34/ A?0=7083 ;=?/2 M"& 3: 94:C 3403 4/ C09 C:1I=85 09 1=D/1 =8 103=<40 83/1803=:80? A4::? 0?0<6105= 082 5/33=85 90?01@ :; 9"&% >/1 7:834 34/ 1=<680? /11/2 =8 8:3 A:89=2/1=85 34/ 907/ :8 34/ 51:682340334/A?0=70834098:3/M07=8/234/9=5803:1@ 3: M"& 8 96>>:13 :; 4=9 A:83/83=:8 34/ ?/018/2 A:689/?;:134/A?0=70834091/?=/2:834/2/A=9=:8:;>/M :613=834/A09/:; C4/1/=8=3409<//84/?23403 N34/2:A67/83901/A:8A?69=D/>1::;:;34/=8A:7/:;34/ A?0=7083O 3 =9 3469 A:83/82/2 3403 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 - 4 - 0C012/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? 682/1 0?? 4/029 =9 :8 34/ ?:C/1 9=2/C4=A41/P6=1/93:<//8408A/21/09:80<?@ & 0D=854/012<:3434/>013=/9082:8>/1690?:; 34/2:A67/839=3=9A?/0134030334/3=7/:;0AA=2/8334/ A?0=7083C0905/2)(@/0190824/C09C:1I=85091=D/1 =8 103=<40 83/1803=:80? A4::? 0?0<6105= : 34=9 /;;/A3 34/ A?0=7083 409 >1:26A/2 M"& =996/2 <@ 34/ /02 093/1 :; 34/ A4::? =996/2 94:C=85 3403 4/ C09 C:1I=85091=D/1=834/90=2893=363=:8;:134/>093341// @/019 082 4/ 409 <//8 >0=2 0 90?01@ :; 9"&% >/1 7:834 ( : <6331/99 4=9 01567/83 34/ A:689/? ;:1 34/ 0>>/??0834091/?=/26>:80A=303=:8=8 1/>:13/2=8A=D=?0>>/0?:'",-:;)))=8C4=A4=3C09 4/?2340334/2:A67/831/5012=85=8A:7/>1::;?=I/90?01@ A/13=;=A03/ 082>0@9?=> 01/ A:8A?69=D/ >1::; :;34/ =8A:7/ :;34/2/A/09/208234/1/C090A:11:<:103=D//D=2/8A/:; 4=9C=;/0820A:%C:1I/1 - 5 - , 4/A:689/?:;34/1/9>:82/83409:>>:9/234/ 907/ :8 34/ 51:682 3403 4/ 409 8:3 /M07=8/2 34/ /027093/1C4:=996/2M"&9: 0?9:=834=9A09/34/@ 40D/ 8:3 /M07=8/2 08@ A:%C:1I/1 082 7:1/:D/1 4/ =9 0 >1=D03/ /7>?:@// 8:3 0 5:D/187/83 /7>?:@// /1/ ;=?=85 :; 2:A67/83 =9 8:3 96;;=A=/83 082 =3 =9 ;:1 34/ >/3=3=:8/1 3: /M07=8/ 34/ /7>?:@/1 3: >1:D/ 34/ 2:A67/83 <63 4/ ;0=?/2 3: 2: 9: 4/1/;:1/ 09 >/1 34/ 56=2/?=8/9:;34/ 018030I0303//50?/1D=A/9634:1=3@ 34/ 1=<680? 409 1=543?@ 099/99/2 4=9 =8A:7/ 09 9"",&%>/17:834082=38//298:=83/1;/1/8A/ ' /018/2A:689/?;:134/0>>/??083;6134/19303/2 340334/0>>/??08340996930=8/270?%68=3/2;10A361/:;?/;3 467/169 / C09 0 21=D/1 <@ >1:;/99=:8 4/1/;:1/ 4/ A:83/82/2 3403 34/ 2=90<=?=3@ 099/99/2 <@ 34/ 1=<680? 09 "J=9:8?:C/19=2/ - 8 :<9/1D=85 34/ =8B61=/9 96930=8/2 34/1/ =9 1/26A/2 7:D/7/839 03 1=543 94:6?2/1 082 ?/;3 /?<:C082 1/26A/2>:C/1:;769A?/9:;?/;394:6?2/10821=543/?<:C - 6 - 4/1/;:1/ A:89=2/1=85 34/ 80361/ :; :AA6>03=:80? :; 34/ 0>>/??083 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 30I/ 34/ ;68A3=:80?2=90<=?=3@09"&J=893/02:;"JAA:12=85?@ 34/?:99:;;6361/=8A:7/A:7/93: "",&M")M",M"&JQ9&-&&% " :C0129/2=A0?/M>/89/934/1=<680?51083/2 9)-"%082=38//298:=83/1;/1/8A/0934/1/=98: 2=9>63/1/5012=8534/07:683 "" / C09 4:9>=30?=K/2 ;:1 ;=D/ 20@9 /8A/ A:89=2/1=85 34/ 80361/ :; =8B61=/9 082 >/1=:2 :; 4:9>=30?=K03=:8 34=9 A:613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 08 07:683:;9%;:1>0=808296;;/1=859)% ;:1 ?:99 :; 07/8=3=/9 082 9% ;:1 31089>:1303=:8 /M3108:61=947/83082033/82083A4015/9 ") / 7=543 8:3 40D/ 033/82/2 4=9 C:1I 03 ?/093 ;:10>/1=:2:;341//7:834934/1/;:1/9&)& "",& M!=93:</51083/2682/134/4/02?:99:;=8A:7/261=85 - 7 - ?0=2 6> >/1=:2 082 08 07:683 :; 9)% =9 3: </ 022/23:C0129;6361/7/2=A0?/M>/89/9 " 8 0?? 34/ 3:30? A:7>/8903=:8 A:7/9 3: 9,'+-%C=34=83/1/930334/103/:;(J>0;1:734/ 203/:;>/3=3=:83=??34/203/:;1/0?=K03=:8 "+ AA:12=85?@ 34/ 0C012 :; 34/ 1=<680? =9 7:2=;=/209682/1 )*+, -./01/, ":99:;;6361/=8A:7/ &-&&% )0=808296;;/1=85 % :99:;07/8=3=/9 )% +/2=A0?/M>/89/9 )-"% &1089>:1303=:8 /M310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 A4015/9 % (:99:;/018=85261=8534/?0=2 6>>/1=:2;:1(7:8349 &)&% ,:99:;$6361/8A:7/ )% 0*2 3!!45 8 7:2=;=A03=:8 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 0 3:30? A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,'+-% =/ /8408A/2 A:7>/8903=:8:;9"-&"% "& 834/1/96?334/;:??:C=85:12/1=9>099/2 - 8 - =! 4/0>>/0?=9 ==! 4/ 0>>/??083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 0 3:30? A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,'+-% 0?:85 C=34 =83/1/930334/103/:;(J>0;1:734/203/:; >/3=3=:83=??1/0?=K03=:8 ===! 4/ 1/9>:82/83 L 896108A/ :7>08@ 0?1/02@ 2/>:9=3/2 34/ 0C012 07:683 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680?34/1/;:1/1/9>:82/83:)=92=1/A3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ /8408A/2 A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9"-&" C=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; (J C=34=8:8/7:834;1:734/203/:;34=9:12/1 =D! 8 96A4 2/>:9=3 >/3=3=:8/1 =9 >/17=33/2 3: C=34210C34//83=1/07:6830?:85C=34=83/1/93 0AA16/2:8=3 ,+5 %$' # =93:"?:-(