Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62998 (KAR)
SMT. POOJA v. SMT. MATURA BAI
CRL.P/201187/2025 · 2025-12-12
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62998 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62998 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! ! %& %'() %(( *
! "
##
$
#
#
#
"
%
&#
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
(##
(#)#!)
'
*
$)! *
#!) *
$""!+!#
* *
*
*
*
** !++#
*
!&+!+!#
* ,
* -
*
&
%
#$
)
%
#+
- 3 -
. + . /012345067894850506701:;5/893<=/58>(07(?3@/8> 43>8751379 10:?07=1 188A07=B<31/07= 6C 5/84>6288907=1 071505<589 :; >814679875D65/8>(07(?3@ 3=30715 5/8 93<=/58>(07(?3@ 379 /8> C3D0?; D8D:8>1 07 >?012
6$""!+!# ! *3251?83907=565/823183>831<798> /8 >814679875 @/6 01 5/8 D65/8>(07(?3@ 6C 485050678>
6 /31 071505<589 4>6288907=1 <798> 825067 ! 6C 5/8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728
25 !++# C6> 1/6>5 E5/8 25 !++#F 188A07= >8?08C1 26758D4?3589<798>8250671)G!+!!379!6C5/8
25 !++# 7 5/8 26D4?3075 5/8 >814679875 3118>51 5/35 485050678>
6 01 5/8 ?8=3??; @89989 @0C8 6C /8> 167 376HA<D3> 379 5/35 5/80> D3>>03=8 @31 16?8D70I89 67 G+!!+& 07 3226>93728 @05/ 2<156D1 379 >05<3?1
- 4 -
6:18>J89075/80>26DD<705;501C<>5/8>3J8>>895/355/8 26<4?8@31:?81189@05/393<=/58>67++"!+)
/8 >814679875 3??8=81 5/35485050678>
6 07 26??<1067 @05/ 28>5307 3750(16203? 8?8D8751 ?69=89 3 2>0D073?26D4?3075:8C6>85/86443?6D876?028535067 :;C<>701/07=3C3?18399>8113189675/8130926D4?3075 3231807>0D8
6+!+G23D856:8>8=0158>89C6>5/8 6CC87281 4<701/3:?8 <798> 825067 $G)( 6C 5/8 79037 873? 698 3=30715 5/8 >814679875 /8> 167 379 /8> /<1:379 /8 >814679875 3118>51 5/35 /8> 167 @31 3>>81589379>8D3078907H<90203?2<1569;C6>C6<>93;15 012675879895/357805/8>1/876>/8>/<1:379@8>83@3>8 6C5/8C0?07=6C5/8130926D4?3075379<467?83>707=6C5/8 13D8 5/8; 344>632/89 485050678>
6 188A07= 37 8K4?3735067 226>907=565/8>814679875485050678>
6 3?67= @05/ 485050678>
61! 56 ) 3:<189 5/8D 07 C0?5/;
?37=<3=8 379 2<>5?; 07C6>D89 5/8D 56 4<>1<8 5/80> >8D89081076<>5
- 5 -
$ /8>814679875C<>5/8>267587915/35?8C5@05/ 76 645067 /8> 167 376HA<D3> 070503589 D35>0D6703? 4>6288907=1 07
6$$!+G 188A07= 90116?<5067 6C D3>>03=8 C58>C<??(C?89=8939H<902350675/8*3D0?;6<>5 >8H82589 5/8 48505067 C6> 90J6>28 379 0715839 431189 3 982>88C6>>81505<50676C267H<=3?>0=/5190>82507=485050678> 6 56 >8H607 5/8 D3>053? /6D8 @05/07 678 D675/ /8 >814679875 3??8=81 5/35 9814058 5/8 982>88 35530707= C073?05; 485050678>
6 C30?89 56 26D4?; @05/ 5/8 1309 6>98>5013?163??8=895/35485050678>
6/31071505<589 D<?504?84>6288907=13=307155/81676C>81467987576! 379 /8> C3D0?; D8D:8>1 072?<907= >?012
6!")!+!+ 188A07= D3075873728 012
6!+! 188A07= 37 6>98> >815>30707= 3 182679 D3>>03=8
6!+G 188A07= 43>505067379012
6")!+!#C6>>826J8>;6C3>>83>16C D3075873728 /8 >814679875 3991 5/35 16D8 6C 5/818 4>6288907=1 @8>8 1<:18B<875?; @05/9>3@7 :; 485050678> 6079023507=D3?3C098075875379/3>311D875
- 6 -
#
226>907= 56 5/8 >814679875 485050678>
6 >8H607895/8D3>053?/6D867+)+!+!#4<>1<375565/8 982>88 C6> >81505<5067 431189 :; 5/8 *3D0?; 6<>5 :<5 1/6>5?;5/8>83C58>67++$!+!#1/8402A89<43B<3>>8? @05/ 5/8 >814679875 379 376HA<D3> 5 01 3??8=89 5/35 1667 5/8>83C58> 485050678>
61! 56 ) 3>>0J89 35 8/A3> J0??3=8 3:<189 5/8 >814679875 07 C0?5/; ?37=<3=8 B<3>>8?89@05//8>379C6>20:?;566A485050678>
6:32A 56 5/80> 43>8753?
/6D8 /8 >814679875 3?16 3??8=81 5/35 485050678>
6 /31 1<:18B<875?; 071505<589 3765/8> 4>6288907= 07 >?012
6)$!+!# 16?8?; 56 /3>311 /8> 379 /8> C3D0?; ; >8C8>>07= 56 5/818 072098751 5/8 >814679875 3118>51 5/35 1/8 /31 1<CC8>89 /<D0?035067 D8753? 2><8?5; 4/;1023? 3=67; 379 8D650673? 9015>811 35 5/8/37916C485050678>
6379485050678>
61!56)/8 5/8>8C6>8188A14>658250676>98>1<798>825067)6C5/8
25!++#>815>30707=5/8485050678>1C>6D26DD05507=3251 6C96D81502J06?87283=30715/8>
- 7 -
" /8 ?83>789 26<718? C6> 5/8 485050678>1 >8058>3507= 5/8 =>6<791 <>=89 07 5/8 48505067 26758791 5/355/84>6288907=1070503589<798>825067!6C5/8 25 !++# 3>8 765/07= :<5 3 26<758>:?315 56 5/8 D35>0D6703? 3792>0D073??050=35067107050358983>?08>:;485050678>
6 ; 4?3207= >8?03728 67 8250671 !C 379 !1 6C 5/8 25 !++# 05 01 1<:D05589 5/35 5/8 26D4?3075 01 765 D30753073:?8 31 3=30715 485050678>
61! 56 ) 31 5/8; 96 765 C3?? @05/07 5/8 3D:05 6C E96D81502 >8?350671/04F 6> E1/3>89 /6<18/6?9F 31 98C0789 <798> 5/8 25 5 01 267587989 5/35 485050678>
61! 56 ) /3J8 78J8> >810989 @05/ 5/8 >814679875 35 37; 46075 6C 50D8 379 D8>8?;
:807=>8?358956485050678>
6237765>8798>5/8D?03:?8 07 3 4>6288907= <798> 825067 ! 8?03728 01 4?3289 67 5/8C6??6@07=982010671
- 8 -
! " # $ % && '
#( & 5 01 C<>5/8> 1<:D05589 :; 5/8 485050678>1- 26<718? 5/35 5/8 >814679875D65/8>(07(?3@ /31 D01<189 5/8 4>6J010671 6C 5/8 25 !++# :; 3>>3;07= 765 67?;
485050678>
6:<53?16/8>8K587989C3D0?;D8D:8>1@/6 78J8>?0J89@05/5/8>8146798755013?163>=<895/355/8 D358>03?1 67 >826>9 072?<907= 5/8 4?83907=1 07 5/8 D35>0D6703? 23181 2?83>?; 98D6715>358 5/35 485050678> 6 379 /8> /<1:379 /3J8 :887 ?0J07= 1843>358?; C>6D 5/8>81467987510728!+)3795/8>8C6>85/88K01587286C 31/3>89/6<18/6?96>96D81502>8?350671/04013:1875501 <>=895/355/826D4?3075013>853?0356>;D831<>807587989 56 /3>311 5/8 485050678>1 379 0C 48>D05589 56 267507<8 @6<?93D6<7556=>6113:<186C4>628116C?3@ ) ?83>789 26<718? C6> 5/8 >814679875 4?3281 >8?03728 67 5/8 H<9=D875 6C 5/8 ??3/3:39 0=/ 6<>507)* )
+
,
-,.&/'#-0 56 2675879 5/35 3
- 9 -
D65/8>(07(?3@ 01 765 4>82?<989 C>6D D307530707= 37 344?0235067<798>5/8 25!++#5013>=<895/355/8 2501 3408286C:878C0203??8=01?3506707587989564>65825@6D87 C>6D96D81502J06?8728379051>8D890813>83J30?3:?8765 67?;56@0J816>93<=/58>1(07(?3@:<55637;@6D37@/6 3??8=8196D81502J06?8728@05/075/896D81502>8?350671/04 /8 ?83>789 26<718? 1<:D051 5/35 485050678>
61!
56 ) /3J8 4?3;89 37 3250J8 >6?8 07 07150=3507= 485050678>
6 5/8>8:;3==>3J3507=5/815>30789>8?350671/04:85@8875/8 >814679875 379 /8> 167 8728 3226>907= 56 5/8 >814679875/8>344?02350673=30715485050678>
61!56)01 D30753073:?8 G 3J07=/83>95/8?83>78926<718?C6>:65/10981 379 /3J07= D8502<?6<1?; 8K3D0789 5/8 4?83907=1 379 962<D8751 3J30?3:?8 67 >826>9 5/8 C6??6@07= 460751 3>018 C6>2671098>35067
! - 10 -
! " !#
! $ % # %
!# & '
" ,-.,-/-0,-12 + /8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728 25!++#013>8D8903?379:878C0203??8=01?35067 8732589 @05/ 5/8 3J6@89 6:H8250J8 6C 4>6J0907= D6>8 8CC8250J84>65825067565/82671505<50673?379?8=3?>0=/516C @6D87@/63>81<:H8258956J06?8728@05/075/896D81502 14/8>8 /85358D875 6C:H8251 379831671 8K4>811?; >826>915/355/8 2530D1564>65825@6D87C>6DJ06?8728 E6C 37; A079 622<>>07= @05/07 5/8 C3D0?;F 379 56 182<>8 5/80>>0=/5563?0C86C90=705;=<3>375889<798> >502?81$ #379!6C5/8671505<5067/8 254>0D3>0?;4>6J0981
- 11 -
20J0? >8D89081 C6> 87C6>28D875 6C >0=/51 >8?3507= 56 >81098728 4>65825067 D67853>; >8?08C1 D3075873728 2<1569; 6C 2/0?9>87 379 26D487135067 /8 67-:?8 <4>8D8 6<>5 07 ) 1#1 ) 2 304 && ( 8D4/310189 5/35 5/8 25!++# 01 07587989 56 4>6J098320J0??3@>8D89;564>65825@6D87C>6D3:<10J8 >8?350671/041 379 56 4>8J875 5/8 >82<>>8728 6C 96D81502 J06?8728 07162085; =30707
# ) 5
16
" $278&(0%25/867-:?8 48K6<>5 >8058>35895/355/8 ?8=01?35067 @31 8732589 56 26D:35 5/8 48>J310J8 16203? D87328 6C 96D81502 J06?8728 379 56 13C8=<3>9@6D87@/63>8J0250D16C1<2/J06?87280737; C6>D0D0?3>?;5/839>310=/6<>5071
5
2 ( &&
' 0" 76589 5/35 5/8
25!++#0726>46>3581379=0J818CC82556826DD87935067 6 ! 6C 5/8 6DD05588 G)G @/02/ 7903 >350C08907 <78GG0D0?3>?;5/86D:3;0=/6<>507 7 $
9 #
6 ) : # 2 && '
;) %" 15>81189 5/35 5/8 25 30D1 56 8K5879
- 12 -
1535<56>; 4>65825067 56 @6D87 07 5/8 96D81502 14/8>8 0>>8148250J8 6C 4>64>0853>; >0=/51 871<>07= 5/80> 182<>05;
379 4>8J87507= >8483589 3251 6C J06?8728 /<1 5/8
25!++# 2671505<581 3 4>6=>8110J8 1584 07 15>87=5/8707= 5/8 ?8=3?
C>3D8@6>A 07587989 56 1/08?9 @6D87 C>6D 96D815023:<18379182<>85/80>C<793D8753?90=705;
798> 825067 !3 6C 5/8 25 37 E3==>08J89 48>167F 072?<981 37; @6D37 @/6 01 6> /31 :887 07 3 96D81502>8?350671/04@05/5/8>8146798753793??8=815/35 1/8 /31 :887 1<:H82589 56 96D81502 J06?8728 /8 25 <798>825067!C98C0781E96D81502>8?350671/04F:>639?; 313>8?350671/04:85@88748>1671@/6?0J86>/3J83537; 460756C50D8?0J8956=85/8>0731/3>89/6<18/6?93793>8 >8?3589 :; 267137=<0705; D3>>03=8 6> 5/>6<=/ >8?350671/041 07 5/8 735<>8 6C D3>>03=8 39645067 6> 31 C3D0?; D8D:8>1 ?0J07= 56=85/8> 07 3 H6075 C3D0?; /8 8K4>811067 E>814679875F6>0=073??; >815>0258956 37 E39<?5 D3?8 48>167F <798> 825067 !B /31 <798>=678 10=70C02375 8J6?<50673>; 0758>4>8535067 7 . $
- 13 -
. # ) 8
) . 2 ,76 < & %((%2 5/8 67-:?8 <4>8D8 6<>5 15><2A 96@7 5/8 @6>91E39<?5D3?848>167F31:807=2675>3>;565/86:H825 6C 5/8 ?8=01?35067 5/8>8:; @098707= 5/8 12648 6C E>814679875F56072?<9837;48>1670>>8148250J86C=8798> 3=30715@/6D5/83==>08J89@6D37188A1>8?08C ! /898C07050676CE1/3>89/6<18/6?9F07825067 !1 8726D431181 37; /6<18/6?9 @/8>8 5/8 3==>08J89 @6D37 ?0J81 6> /31 ?0J89 07 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 0>>8148250J8 6C 6@78>1/04 6> 505?8 379 072?<981 4>648>5; :8?67=07=565/8H6075C3D0?;6C@/02/5/8>814679875013 D8D:8>/867-:?8<4>8D86<>507 &
, :
, :
2 ,76 & 0=(" 6J8>><?89 5/8 >815>0250J8 0758>4>8535067 07 6 ;
5
;
23(40&&<=379/8?95/358J87@/8>85/8 1/3>89 /6<18/6?9 :8?67=1 8K2?<10J8?; 56 5/8 /<1:379 6> 37; >8?350J8 6C 5/8 /<1:379 05 2671505<581 3 E1/3>89 /6<18/6?9F0C5/83==>08J89@6D37/31?0J895/8>807073 96D81502 >8?350671/04 6718B<875?; 5/8 1535<56>; 379
- 14 -
H<90203? C>3D8@6>A H6075?; 8D4/3101 5/35 10158>1 @096@1 D65/8>193<=/58>16>@6D8707?0J8(07>8?350671/041@/6 /3J8 >810989 07 3 1/3>89 /6<18/6?9 3>8 3?? 87505?89 56 07J6A85/84>658250J8<D:>8??36C5/8 25 7 5/8 4>81875 2318 05 01 37 39D05589 46105067 67>826>95/35485050678>
6015/893<=/58>(07(?3@6C5/8 >814679875@/8>831485050678>
61!56)3>8/8>43>8751 10:?07=1 379 65/8> >8?350J81 @/6 /3J8 76 D35>0D6703? 6> 96D8150278K<1@05/5/8>814679875/8D358>03?14?3289 67>826>92?83>?;079023585/355/8>814679875267507<8156 >81098 @05/ /8> /<1:379 35 5/8 D35>0D6703? /6D8 @/0?8 485050678>
66@07=56?67=1537907=D3>053?90126>9@05/ /8>/<1:379376HA<D3>/31:887?0J07=1843>358?;379 01 39D05589?; 765 >810907= 805/8> @05/ 5/8 >814679875 6> @05//8>/<1:379 $ 5@6<?9:82><203?56>8C8>56>814679875-16@7 3J8>D8751 07 5/8 825067 ! 344?0235067 5/8 >8?8J375 46>50676C@/02/018K5>32589:8?6@L
- 15 -
E()
% # #
* +&
+
# * +& ,# ! -
! !# * +&
. '
* +&
#
* +&
/ )
(0 $
! !# ! * +& * +&
1 #* %
!#- #
* +& ! 2
3 4 )
# * +& '
- 16 -
3 ! #
* +& ' % # , !
5 0 666666)
+
#* +& #
$( ,7! . #18 #(/
'
* +& $
% *
& &! &
% '
! #
! # 8
'
&! &
! # !# & ! &
*
&
& &
- 17 -
% *
& )
#
1 * 1 9: 1 * ($/ ! ,7! ;*.1 1 8 # ! %
#! <=
>
# 5 01 8J09875 5/35 485050678>
6 78J8> ?0J89 @05/5/8>814679875D65/8>(07(?3@0731/3>89/6<18/6?9 16 31 56 2>8358 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 26758D4?3589 <798> 8250671 !3 379 !C 6C 5/8 25!++# /8 >814679875 2358=6>023??; 153581 5/35 485050678>
6 >810989 @05/ /8> /<1:379 35 ;98>3:39 C6> 4<>1<07= /0=/8> 89<235067 379 5/8>83C58> 9<8 56 D3>053? 90126>9 J6?<753>0?; ?8C5 5/8 26D437; 6C /8> /<1:379 379 :8=37 >810907= @05/ /8> 43>8751 35 <D73:39 J87 07 !+) @/875/8>814679875>8B<81589/8>56>81098@05/5/8D07
- 18 -
093> 485050678> 6 <78B<0J623??; 982?0789 379 267507<8956>81098@05//8>43>8751/84?83907=1C<>5/8> >8J83? 5/35 3?5/6<=/ 3 982>88 C6> >81505<5067 6C 267H<=3? >0=/51@3143118967G+$!+!!485050678>
6>8H60789 /8> /<1:379 67?; 67 !)+!+!# 379 153;89 C6> 3 :>08C 48>069 :8C6>8 9013=>88D8751 3>618 67 ++$!+!# 5 01 67?;5/8>83C58>37939D05589?;355/8071537286CD3>053? 15>0C85/35485050678>
61!56)3??8=89?;23D8568/A3> 56 53A8 485050678>
6 :32A /818 C325<3? 3118>50671 <78B<0J623??; 8153:?01/ 5/35 485050678>
6 @31 7805/8> >810907=@05/5/8>81467987576>1/3>07=3/6<18/6?9@05/ /8> 35 37; >8?8J375 46075 07 50D8L 76> /3J8 485050678> 61!56)8J8>>810989@05/5/8>8146798756>:6>7837; 96D81502>8?350671/04@05//8>/81535<56>;>8B<0>8D875 6C26/3:05350676>1/3>89/6<18/6?9@/02/010790148713:?8 C6> D307530707= 3 48505067 <798> 825067 ! 01 5/8>8C6>8 @/6??;3:1875
" 7 5/8 2675>3>; 5/8 825067 ! 48505067 9012?61815/355/81676C5/8>814679875>8109811843>358?;
- 19 -
C>6D :65/ 485050678>
6 379 5/8 >814679875 C<>5/8> 78=3507= 37; 3??8=35067 6C 96D81502 J06?8728 622<>>07= E@05/07 5/8 C3D0?;F 31 87J013=89 :; 5/8 25 /8 >814679875-1 =>08J3728 01 4>89023589 67?; 67 622310673? B<3>>8?1 379 5/8 C325 5/35 485050678>
61! 56 ) ?358> 3226D437089 485050678>
6 @/02/ :; 76 15>852/ D8851 5/8 ?8=3? 5/>81/6?9 <798> 8250671 !3 !C !B 379 !1 887 07 5/8 26758K5 6C D<?504?8 4>06> ?8=3? 4>6288907=1 070503589 :; 485050678>
6 1<2/ 31 5/8 825067 $G)( 26D4?3075 D3075873728 4>6288907=1 379 5/8>81505<5067?050=350675/84>81875325067<798>825067 !
01 765/07= :<5 3 >853?0356>; D831<>8 07587989 56 26<758>325 5/618 4>6288907=1 /8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728 25 01 3 >8D8903? ?8=01?35067 8732589561/08?9@6D87C>6DJ06?8728@05/07396D81502 185507=L05237765:8<18907J8>18?;:;3D65/8>(07(?3@56 07050358 4>6288907=1 3=30715 3 93<=/58>(07(?3@ ?0J07= 1843>358?; D<2/ ?811 3=30715 /8> 43>8751 10:?07=1 6> >8?350J81 @/6 /3J8 76 96D81502 78K<1 @05/ 5/8
- 20 -
>814679875 /8 3:18728 6C C6<79350673? 4?83907=1 26<4?89@05/5/8>814679875-16@739D0110671 ?83J8176 96<:55/355/84>6288907=107>0D073?012
6$""!+!# 3>8 @/6??; <75873:?8 379 2671505<58 37 3:<18 6C 5/8 4>628116C?3@ & 7 1<2/ 20>2<D1537281 5/8 C6<79350673? >8B<0>8D875 6C 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 31 98C0789 <798> 825067!C6C5/8 2573D8?;5/355/83==>08J8948>167 3795/8>814679875D<15/3J8?0J8956=85/8>0731/3>89 /6<18/6?9012671402<6<1?;3:1875/81535<56>;12/8D8 6C 5/8 25 !++# 01 07587989 56 4>65825 @6D87 @/6 3>8 J0250D1 6C 96D81502 J06?8728 @05/07 5/8 96D81502 14/8>8 379 5/8 ?8=01?350J8 98C0705067 6C E3==>08J89 48>167F <798> 825067 !3 4>89023581 5/8 8K0158728 6C 3 1<:101507= 6> 4315 96D81502 >8?350671/04 @05/07 3 1/3>89 /6<18/6?9 /8>8C6>8 @/87 5/8 93<=/58>(07(?3@ 01 765 >810907= @05/ 5/8 >814679875 379 /31 78J8> ?0J89 56=85/8> @05/ 485050678>
61!56)3537;460756C50D85/8>814679875 237765 07J6A8 825067 ! 6C 5/8 25 56 188A 3 4>65825067
- 21 -
6>98><798>825067)4>6/0:0507=3?087350676C4>648>5081 :8?67=07= 56 /8> C3D0?; 76> 237 1/8 2?30D 26D487135067 :;3??8=07=4/;1023?6>D8753?5>3<D33=3071548>1671@05/ @/6D1/81/3>817696D81502>8?350671/04 ) /8 25 !++# 9681 765 26758D4?358 20J0? >8D89081 :807= 16<=/5 :; 3 D65/8>(07(?3@ 3=30715 3 93<=/58>(07(?3@ ?0J07= 1843>358?; D<2/ ?811 3=30715 5/8 93<=/58>(07(?3@-1 43>8751 6> 10:?07=1 @/6 3>8 26D4?858 15>37=8>1565/81/3>89/6<18/6?9/8D8>88K01587286C 15>30789D35>0D6703?>8?350671:85@887485050678>
6379 /8>/<1:379237765:;0518?C267C8>H<>019025067<798>5/8
25 !++# 07 C3J6<> 6C 5/8 >814679875 43>502<?3>?; @/87 5/8167/0D18?C01>810907=3@3;C>6D5/8>8146798759<8 568D4?6;D8753795/84?83907=19676598D6715>35837;
325 6C 96D81502 J06?8728 26DD05589 @05/07 5/8 96D81502 C>3D8@6>A 26758D4?3589 :; 5/8 25 6718B<875?; 5/8 344?0235067C0?89:;5/8>814679875<798>825067!6C5/8
25 !++# 1<CC8>1 C>6D 3 C<793D8753? ?32A 6C D30753073:0?05; 31 5/8 81187503? 07=>8908751 6C E3==>08J89
- 22 -
48>167FE>814679875F379E1/3>89/6<18/6?9F3>87805/8> 4?8398976>8153:?01/89 G 23>8C<? 8K3D0735067 6C 5/8 4?83907=1 379 D358>03?1 67 >826>9 2?83>?; 98D6715>3581 5/35 5/8 >8?08C1 16<=/5:;5/8>814679875075/8344?0235067<798>825067 ! 6C 5/8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728
25 !++# 3>8 @/6??; D01267280J89 379 ?8=3??;
<71<153073:?80716C3>315/8;48>530756485050678>
61!56 )@/63>85/843>875110:?07=1379>8?350J816C485050678> 693<=/58>(07(?3@ /8 25 <798> 825067!3?0D051 5/81535<16C37E3==>08J8948>167F563@6D37@/6016> /31 :887 07 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 @05/ 5/8 E>814679875F @/0?8 825067 !C 98C0781 3 E96D81502 >8?350671/04F 31 678 >8B<0>07= 5/35 5/8 43>5081 D<15 /3J8 ?0J8956=85/8>3537;460756C50D80731/3>89/6<18/6?9 0A8@018 825067 !B 3C58> 5/8 3<5/6>05350J8 0758>4>8535067 07 . $
. # ) 8
) .
3 428K437915/88K4>811067 E>814679875F56072?<9837;48>1673=30715@/6D>8?08C01
- 23 -
16<=/5:<5150??1<:H825565/82679050675/351<2/48>167 D<15 /3J8 :887 07 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 @05/ 5/8 3==>08J89@6D3775/84>818752318485050678>
61!56 )3>839D05589?;15>37=8>1565/81/3>89/6<18/6?96C5/8 >814679875L5/8;/3J878J8>>810989@05/5/8>814679875 76> 1/3>89 37; 96D81502 3>>37=8D875 5/35 @6<?9 :>07= 5/8D@05/075/81535<56>;3D:056C396D81502>8?350671/04 /8 25 !++# 9681 765 48>D05 >6407= 07 6C 767(>8109875 >8?350J81D8>8?;:823<185/8;3>8>8?3589565/893<=/58>( 07(?3@L 76> 9681 05 873:?8 5/8 >814679875 56 188A 1@88407= 4>65825067 6>98>1 4>6/0:056>; 90>8250671 3=30715 3?087350676C /8> C3D0?; 4>648>5081 6> 26D487135067C>6D 48>1671 @/6 /3J8 76 96D81502 78K<1 6> 4>6K0D05; 26758D4?3589<798>5/8 25 !+ /8 48505067 @/87 J08@89 07 5/8 :32A9>64 6C 5/8 39D05589 C3251 <7D0153A3:?; >8J83?1 051 >853?0356>; 2/3>3258> /8 >826>9 1/6@1 5/35 485050678> 693<=/58>(07(?3@ /31 071505<589 D<?504?8 4>6288907=1 3=30715 5/8 >814679875-1 167 379 /01 C3D0?; 072?<907= 3
- 24 -
2>0D073? 26D4?3075 <798> 825067 $G)( 6C 3 D3075873728 48505067 D35>0D6703? ?050=35067 379 65/8> D0128??3786<1 4>6288907=1 3>0107= C>6D D3>053? 90126>9 @05//8>/<1:379501075/0126758K55/355/8>814679875 07158396C>815>02507=/8>=>08J3728/312/61875607J6A8 4>6288907=1 <798> 5/8 25 !++# 3=30715 765 67?; 5/8 93<=/58>(07(?3@:<53?16/8>8750>843>8753?C3D0?;@/02/ 67 5/8 C328 6C 05 079023581 37 3558D45 56 4>811<>0I8 6> 26<758>3255/8?8=3?15841070503589:;485050678>
6/8
25 !++# :807= 3 :878C0203? 1535<58 8732589 56 4>65825 @6D87 C>6D 96D81502 J06?8728 @05/07 5/8 96D81502 14/8>8 237765 :8 <189 31 3 566? C6> 1855?07= 48>1673? 126>816>C6>9>3==07=0756?050=3506748>1671@05/@/6D76 96D81502>8?350671/048K0151<798>8250671!3!C!B 379 !1 6718B<875?; 5/8 >8?08C1 16<=/5 3=30715 485050678>
61! 56 ) 3>8 C<793D8753??; 6<51098 5/8 C>3D8@6>A 6C 5/8 25 >8798>07= 5/8 48505067 @/6??; <75873:?8379373:<186C5/8?8=3?4>62811
- 25 -
! 7 ?0=/5 6C 5/8 1535<56>; 12/8D8 6C 5/8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728 25 !++# 379 5/8 H<90203? 4>676<728D8751 =6J8>707= 051 0758>4>8535067 05 :826D81 3:<79375?; 2?83> 5/35 5/8 4>81875 4>6288907=1 3>8 C<793D8753??; D01267280J89
44?;07= 5/818 @8??(1855?89 4>07204?81 56 5/8 C3251 6C 5/8 4>81875 2318 5/8 >814679875D65/8>(07(?3@ 237765 :8 5>835893137E3==>08J8948>167F76>237485050678>
61! 56):85>8358931E>8146798751F@05/075/8D83707=6C5/8
25 !! /8 39D05589 C325<3? 46105067 01 5/35 5/8 >814679875 >810981 1843>358?; @05/ /8> /<1:379 07 /8> D35>0D6703?
/6D8 @/0?8 /8> 167/<1:379 6C 485050678> 6 01 ?0J07= 3@3; C>6D :65/ 5/8 >814679875 379 485050678>
6 /8>826>91 C<>5/8> 8153:?01/5/35 9<8 56 D3>053?90126>9485050678>
6/31:887?0J07=1843>358?; 379/31765>810989@05/5/8>814679875C6>18J8>3?;83>1 /818 20>2<D1537281 <7D0153A3:?; 8153:?01/ 5/35 5/8>8 01 76 1/3>89 /6<18/6?9 76 26/3:0535067 379 76 96D81502
- 26 -
>8?350671/04 :85@887 5/8 >814679875 379 485050678>
6 379 28>5307?; 7678 @05/ 485050678>
61! 56 ) @/6 3>8 D8>8?; /8> 43>8753? >8?350J81 7 5/8 3:18728 6C 5/8 C6<79350673? 8?8D8751 6C 3 96D81502 >8?350671/04 5/8 >814679875-13558D455607J6A8825067!6C5/8 25!++# 56 188A 4>65825067 6>98>1 4>6/0:056>; 90>8250671 3=30715 3?087350676C/8>C3D0?;4>648>508137926D487135067C>6D 5/8 485050678>1 C3??1 1B<3>8?; 6<51098 5/8 1535<56>; C>3D8@6>A ! 1 2671015875?; /8?9 07 5/8 H<9=D8751 20589 3:6J8 5/8 25 01 >8D8903? 765 4<7050J8 379 051 D82/3701D1 237765 :8 15>852/89 :8;679 5/8 ?8=01?350J8 075875 56 8726D4311 43>5081 @/6 3>8 15>37=8>1 56 5/8 1/3>89 /6<18/6?9 /8>8C6>8 5/8 4>81875 48505067 <798> 825067!6C5/8 25!++#0716C3>31054>6288913=30715 485050678>
6 31 @8?? 31 485050678>
61! 56 ) 01 765 D30753073:?8 379 2671505<581 37 3:<18 6C 5/8 4>62811 6C ?3@ 226>907=?;5/8460751C6>2671098>35067
610379 003>8371@8>89075/8,
9 >87285/8C6??6@07=
- 27 -
/8>0D073?8505067013??6@89 /84>6288907=1 07 >?012
6$""!+!#487907=67 5/8 C0?8 6C5/80J0? <9=8379 * 6<>5 /3?A0 C0?89 <798> 5/8 4>6J0106716C825067!6C5/8 >65825067 6C 6D87 C>6D 6D81502 06?8728
25 !++#3>8/8>8:;B<31/89
.) %!!( $
015
6!? 6#+