Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62996 (KAR)
KUM.DOMBALE SHIVANI v. THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
WP/203247/2025 · 2025-12-12
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62996 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62996 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
&"'
!"!#$
%& ' &
$ ' '&
& & & '&
$$##$
' & &&
& '
!(###$
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
'' !"!#$
!"!#$
%&
&'$* '! & '
( +'
' & '
& #$#,#!&
)& '
#+#! ($#"( -
& $)#(#! &
&&
$$,)##$,)(
-
& * ' & '
& '
$ &
'
'
' '
'
& & '* &
'
- 3 -
'
'
&&
& '
. &/010123/4 15 6/724/ 0815 2940 5//:13; 72<<2=13; 4/<1/75
! "#$%&'()(*(&+#, -&,.&/. ( 0 ,1
!! . 2
3
! "#4 2 . ( 0 ,5 !! ! 6
7
"
2
6 ! ! , ! ! 8 ! 7
& ! 9
- 4 -
&/010123/4 15 6/724/ 0815 2940 6/13; >;;41/?/@ 6A08/4/B/C0123278/44/D9/507241559>3C/27323 C4/>EA <>A/4 C/40171C>0/ 6A 4/5F23@/30 2) ?1@/ 24@/4 @>0/@ #$#,#! F42@9C/@ >0 33/G94/
=81C8 15 C23714E/@ 6A 4/5F23@/30 2 ?1@/ /3@245/E/30 @>0/@ $)#(#! F42@9C/@>0 33/G94/ )
/>43/@C2935/<72408/F/010123/4596E10508>0 08/5>1@24@/45F>55/@6A08/4/5F23@/3025)>3@>4/ 0>:13; 1302 C2351@/4>0123 08/ 13C2E/ 742E 5><>4A 27 08/ 7>08/4 27 08/ F/010123/4 =82 15 =24:13; 93@/4 429F C>0/;24A 13 08/ 0>0/ 27 >8>4>5804> =81C8 15 6/13; /GC<9@/@742E08/>FF<1C>61<10A2708/C4/>EA<>A/4>5F/4 08/ C<>4171C>0123 1559/@ 93@/4 08/ 771C/ /E24>3@9E @>0/@ #"#,$,,) >3@ $$### 8/ 79408/4 596E105 08>0 08/ 7>C05 >3@ C14C9E50>3C/5 27 0815 E>00/4 >4/ 5D9>4/<AC2?/4/@6A08/24@/4
F>55/@13
13 08/ C>5/ 27 ! "##$$ % 8/ 596E105 08>0 93@/4 51E1<>4 C14C9E50>3C/5 0815 2940 8>@
- 5 -
D9>58/@ 08/ 1EF9;3/@ /3@245/E/30 1559/@ 6A 08/ >90824101/5 08/4/93@/4 >3@ @14/C013; 08/E 02 4/C2351@/4 08/C>5/2708/F/010123/45
/3C/5//:5724><<2=13;2708/ F/010123
3 4/5F235/ </>43/@ @@10123>< 2?/43E/30 @?2C>0/4/<A13;9F2308/B9@;E/30
&27 08/ 1?15123 /3C8 27 0815 2940 13 $ '
& (( )$ "$$' "#
$$
&596E10508>0513C/>@E100/@<A08/13C2E/27 08/ F>4/305 27 08/ F/010123/4 08/4/13 /GC//@5 08/ <1E10 27 5"##### 08/A >4/ 320 /3010</@ 724 08/ 323 C4/>EA <>A/4 C/40171C>0/ 3 > D9/4A 6A 0815 2940 >5 02 =8/08/4 08/5>1@24@/4=>5134/5F/C027>3/EF<2AE/3093@/408/ /304><2?/43E/30</>43/@ 7>14<A596E10508>008>0 =>5 13 4/5F/C0 27 /EF<2AE/30 93@/4 08/ 0>0/ 2?/43E/30 >3@ 08>0 >5 4/;>4@5 /EF<2AE/30 >0 08/ /304>< 2?/43E/30 08/ 771C/ /E24>3@9E @>0/@ #"#,$,,)501<<82<@508/71/<@ !
/>4@&/495/@08/4/C24@5
- 6 -
( 815294093@/41@/301C><7>C055109>01232708/ E>00/4=8/4/>C>3@1@>0/=82=>5F4/F>413;020>:/9F 08/ C1?1< 5/4?1C/ /G>E13>0123 02 6/ C23@9C0/@ 6A 08/ /304>< 2?/43E/30 8>@ >FF42>C8/@ 0815 2940 6/13;
>;;41/?/@ 6A 08/ 51E1<>4 5109>0123 27 815 4/D9/50 724 1559>3C/ 27 323 C4/>EA <>A/4 C/40171C>0/ 6/13; 4/B/C0/@ /7/4413; 02 08/ 771C/ /E24>3@9E @>0/@ #"#,$,,) 1559/@ 6A 08/ 2?/43E/30 27 3@1> >3@ 79408/4 C<>4171C>0123 @>0/@ $$### 0815 2940 8>@ F>55/@ 08/ 72<<2=13;24@/4 : !! : $ +#+#"&,
" ( 0 ,"
$
+#% +#&,
" ( 0 ,;
:
<
5= +! +
=
< >
/
?6
8 +! 22 ( 0 ,) ! !! ! ! +
0
- 7 -
+
22 ?6
'
!! :
! ! ! < > &+! 6 9
+ 8/ 1?15123 /3C8 27 0815 2940 13 105 24@/4 @>0/@ #)$#! F>55/@ 13 410 FF/>< 2)#$#! C233/C0/@ =108 1?1< 230/EF0 &/010123 2+#! 7943158/@6A08/</>43/@ >0F>4> $8>5265/4?/@>5 93@/4 2 < ! < > / 8
!! 6
!! !! = ! +6! @
' 6 ?6
:8
< > !! 6 '
?6
A
=B9
" '9408/4 >0 F>4> $" 08/ 1?15123 /3C8 8>5 265/4?/@>593@/4 / <
< > / ! ! 6 ! 6
?6 8 ! !! B9
- 8 -
, </>4<A 08/4/ 15 32 C2304>@1C0123 13 08/ ?1/= 0>:/3 6A 08/ 1?15123 /3C8 27 0815 2940 =108 4/;>4@ 02 08/>FF<1C>61<10A27771C//E24>3@9E@>0/@#"#,$,,) =108 08/ ?1/= >5 0>:/3 6A 0815 2940 13 105 />4<1/4 24@/4 @>0/@)##"#13410&/0101232((+#$>5320/@ >62?/ $# &/010123/4 6/13; 51E1<>4<A 5109>0/@ =82 15 13 4/D914/E/30 27 08/ 323 C4/>EA <>A/4 C/40171C>0/ /3>6<13;
8/4 02 93@/40>:/ 08/ F4/F>4>0123 724 4/C4910E/30 F42C/55 273123&96<1C/4?1C/2EE1551236//G0/3@/@=10808/ 51E1<>46/3/710 CC24@13;<A08/72<<2=13;
> 8/=410F/01012315'') 6 8/ 1EF9;3/@ 3@245/E/30 @>0/@ #$#,#! 13 2 #+#! ($#"(1559/@6A4/5F23@/302)F42@9C/@ >5 33/G94/
>3@ >3208/4 3@245/E/30 @>0/@ $)#(#!
13 2$$,)##$,)(
- 9 -
1559/@ 6A 4/5F23@/30 2 F42@9C/@ >5 33/G94/ >4/D9>58/@ C 8/ 4/5F23@/305 >90824101/5 >4/ @14/C0/@ 02 4/C2351@/4 08/ C>5/ 27 08/ F/010123/4 724 1559>3C/ 27 323 C4/>EA <>A/4 C/40171C>0/ 0>:13; 1302 C2351@/4>0123 08/ 771C/ /E24>3@9E @>0/@ #"#,$,,) 1559/@ 6A 08/ 2?/43E/30 27 3@1> >3@ 08/ <>4171C>0123 @>0/@ $$### F42@9C/@ >0 33/G94/ @ 01579408/4C<>4171/@08>008/F/010123/458><< 596E10 59C8 @/C<>4>0123 >5 E>A 6/ 4/D914/@ 13 79408/4>3C/ 0208/C<>4171C>0123 >0 8>F0/4 G 27 08/ 2EE931C>0123 @>0/@ $$##$ 1559/@ 6A 08/ 2?/43E/30 27 3@1> 9C8 C2351@/4>0123 58><< 6/ E>@/ =10813 > F/412@ 27 )# @>A5 742E 08/ @>0/ 27 794315813; 27 4/D914/@13724E>01236A08/F/010123/45
- 10 -
/ 8/ F/010123/45 >4/ >0 <16/40A 02 71</ 74/58 4/D91510123 13 C2EF<1>3C/ =108 08/ 771C/ /E24>3@9E<>4171C>0123 4/7/44/@ 02 >62?/ 6/724/08/C23C/43/@4/5F23@/30
() &""' %
1502$<2( &