Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62989 (KAR)
M/S B.SURESH KUMAR AND CO v. STATE
WP/201133/2025 · 2025-08-29
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62989 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62989 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!" !#"
$ %"&"%%
'%"(
! " #! $ %
! ! ! &
&
! &&!! & '! $& $&
(
" #! &) $ %
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
( !& +
& , ! - $.&
. #% ! /
-
& ! & 0- & ! '
' 1 . &
! # ' 1 . &%
2343565678392:;<6=3>526;?96543565678@8>39956A=3 *7<52378;565@56787<8>6:93:>?6523A5678(7< 523 7>3 7< 96B68:= 97A3>@93 ;33C68D 57 E@:;2 523 79>39 >:53> , 4:;;3> 68 96B3 7 78 523 <6=3 7< =3:983> 968A64:= 6F6= .@>D3 :8> . :6A2@9 GH :==7?68D 523 :44=6A:5678 <6=3> @8>39 3A5678 #%7<5232:9:56H::D:96C:@9:C;2::8265: #<79;27950-%497>@A3>:;439883I@93
- 3 -
56;523A7853856787<523435656783952:5236;
875 :8 :AA@;3> 68 523 A96B68:= A:;3 93D6;5393> GH 93;478>385 747=6A3 78 523 G:;6; 7< 523 <69;5 68<79B:5678=7>D3>GH93;478>38573;478>3857 <6=3>:>35:6=3>A7B4=:68593<39968D57F:967@;8:B3;G:8C :AA7@85 8@BG39; A7>3; >:53 7< 59:8;:A5678 523 :B7@85 52:5 ?:; 59:8;<3993> 35A 57 A78538> 52:5 523 A7B4=:68:85 ?:; A23:53> 5297@D2 78=683 59:>68D 63 8:8>:5262:93:9C3544497B6;68D57D6F3=@A9:56F3 935@98; <79 523 :B7@85; 52:5 ?393 68F3;53> 5 6; 523 <@95239 A785385678 7< 523 4356567839 52:5 3F38 527@D2 ;@A2:AA7@85;:93B3856783>68523<69;568<79B:567852393 6;8793<3938A357523:AA7@854395:6868D575234356567839
7?3F39 :8 :44=6A:5678 @8>39 3A5678 #% 7< ?:; <6=3> :; 439 883I@93 ;33C68D 57 93=3:;3 523 :B7@857<; *(>3G653><97B523:AA7@857<523 435656783957523685396BA@;57>H7<93;478>385723 ;:6> :44=6A:5678 ?:; :==7?3> GH 4:;;68D 523 79>39 >:53> , >693A568D 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A39 57
- 4 -
>3<933J3 523 :B7@85 7< ; *( <97B 523 :AA7@85 7<523435656783923=>68523:8C7<8>6::8>5759:8;<39 523;:6>:B7@8557523:AA7@857<93;478>3857368D :DD963F3> GH 523 ;:B3 523 4356567839 2:; 493<3993> 526; ?96543565678
3:9>96:B:952:=3:983>A7@8;3=<79523 4356567839 :8> B5 9:5 :56= =3:983> 6D2 7@95 &7F398B385 =3:>39 <79 93;478>385 75:53 3;478>385 7 527@D2 ;39F3> ?652 523 8756A3 2:; 93B:683>@893493;3853>39@;3>523B:5396:=;7893A79>
8 F63? 7< 523 96F:= A785385678; @9D3> GH 523 =3:983>A7@8;3=<79G7525234:9563;5234768552:5?7@=> :96;3<79BHA78;6>39:56786;'
!
"
"#$%&&' (' )
* +
,-./*0++ 1
!2 )
- 5 -
3 4 *
* &
56 H:8;?3957523:G7F3476856;68523
<79523<7==7?68D'
""
3;478>385 7 <6=3> 523 <69;5 68<79B:5678 :;
439 883I@93 93<39968D 57 F:967@; 59:8;<39; B:>3 <97B 26; :AA7@85 78 F:967@; >:53;2393:93 4:956A@=:9; 7< ;@A2:AA7@85;?652;43A6<6A8:B3;7<523:AA7@8527=>39; G:8C:AA7@858@BG39;A7>3;>:53;7<59:8;:A5678;
:B7@85; 52:5 ?393 59:8;<3993> B3527> 7< 59:8;:A5678; 35A>B6553>=H523936;8793<3938A357523G:8C:AA7@85 7< 523 4356567839 ?26A2 6; 93<3993> 57 68 523 6B4@D83> 79>39 GH 523 96:= 7@95 ?26=3 >693A568D 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A39 57 >3<933J3 523 :AA7@85 :8> 57 59:8;<39 523 :B7@85 57 523 :AA7@85 7< 93;478>385 7 >B6553>=H 523 4356567839 6; 875 :8 :AA@;3> 68 523 879 23 6; ;@G;3E@385=H8:B3>:;7837<523:AA@;3> 7?3F39656;
;5:53> 52:5 >@968D 68F3;56D:5678 523 :AA7@85 7< 523
- 6 -
4356567839 ?:; >3G653> <79 : ;@B 7< ; *( :8> 65 ?:;<933J3>:=78D?65275239G:8C:AA7@85;:8>523;:B3 ?:; 9347953> 57 523 96:= 7@95 BB3>6:53=H 52393:<539 523:44=6A:567868E@3;5678A:B357G3<6=3>GH93;478>385 7 @8>39 3A5678 #% 7< ;33C68D 685396B A@;57>H7<523;:6>:B7@85 * 5 6; 439568385 57 8753 52:5 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A392:;<6=3>26;934795:;439883I@93 59:8D3=H 523936;93<3938A35778=H523G:8C:AA7@8523=>?652
:8C <79 <933J68D 523 :B7@85 7< ;* 23 934795 >73; 875 93<39 57 523G:8C :AA7@85 7< 523 4356567839 879 26;8:B3:;7837<523:AA@;3> , 5 6; :=;7 439568385 57 8753 52:5 523 =3:983> ;;6;5:85 @G=6A 97;3A@579 2:; <6=3> 26; 7GK3A5678 57 523 :44=6A:5678 ;@GB6553> GH 93;478>385 7 ?26A2 6; <6=3> ?6527@5 :44=6A:5678 7< B68> :; 523 7GK3A5678 93<39; 57 93=3:;37<523F326A=368<:F7@97<523:44=6A:85
- 7 -
( 2396:=7@95?6527@55:C68D6857A78;6>39:5678 :8H7<523;3<:A5;497A33>3>574:;;5236B4@D83>79>39 59:8D3=H 523 6B4@D83> 79>39 93<39; 57 ;36J3> A:;2 7< ; *( :8> 523 ;:B3 G368D 68 523 7@95 A@;57>H 23 96:= 7@95 :=;7 93<3993>57 523 ;57=38 ;36J3> A:;2 68 5237@95A@;57>H57>693A58F3;56D:568D<<6A395793=3:;3 523;:B357523685396BA@;57>H7<93;478>3857 * 65 :443:9; 523 96:= 7@95 2:; :=;7 875 :44=63> 65; B68> 57 523 <:A5; 7< 523 A:;3 879 65 2:; 93<3993> 57 523 :44=6A:56785239347957<5238F3;56D:568D<<6A397957523 7GK3A5678<6=3>GH523=3:983>;;6;5:85@G=6A97;3A@579
2396:=7@952:;<79B3>:8746867852:5523 9347957<523<69;568<79B:8565;3=< *>6;A=7;3;52:5 523 ;36J3> A:;2 G3=78D; 57 93;478>385 7 2393 6;
:G;7=@53=H 87 G:;6; 57 <79B ;@A2 :8 7468678 23 96:= 7@95 2:; :=;7 875 93<3993> 57 523 934795 7< 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A39 ?2393 52393 6; 87 93<3938A3 57 523 G:8C :AA7@85 4395:6868D 57 523 4356567839 239368 >B6553>=H5234356567839?:;875;39F3>?652:8H8756A3
- 8 -
365239 GH 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A39 79 GH 523 96:= 7@95 G3<793 497A33>68D 57 >693A5 523 8F3;56D:568D <<6A39 57 >3<933J3 523 :AA7@85 :8> 57 59:8;<39 523 :B7@85 7< ; *(57523:AA7@857<93;478>3857 3:983> A7@8;3= <79 523 4356567839 2:; 4=:A3> 93=6:8A378523>3A6;6787<526;7@9568 ?2393 523779>68:5338A27<526;7@9523=>684:9:7 :; @8>39' 7
# 1 )
*
8
+ ,
,
*
*
# 9
& 1
*1
*
*
!
' * ) * )
* 7*'
# )
*2 * )
:
1 WRIT PETITION NO.2865/2022 (GM-RES) (D.D.17.10.2022)
- 9 -
./ * &
! ;**5 ./ * *&
! ;**5 ./ &* ! ' )
! ' * ) *
*
*
* * *
* ' * ) * * '* *6 8;46537<;@A2;43A6<6A>693A56786;;@3>GH526;
7@95 523 96:= 7@95 497A33>3> 57 :==7? 523 :44=6A:5678 2@9963>=H ?6527@5 :44=6A:5678 7< B68> ?6527@5 @8>39;5:8>68D 523 <:A5; 7< 523 A:;3 ?6527@5 93<39968D 57 5239347957<5238F3;56D:568D<<6A39:8>?6527@56;;@68D :8H8756A3575234356567839G3<7934:;;68D;@A2:879>39 8>39523;3A69A@B;5:8A3;:B7<523746867852:5523 6B4@D83>79>394:;;3>GH52396:=7@956;52393;@=57<
- 10 -
575:=878:44=6A:56787<B68>656;439F39;3:8>6==3D:=:8> 523;:B36;=6:G=357G3;35:;6>3 AA79>68D=H :8;?39 523 :G7F3 47685 68 523 :8>497A33>574:;;523<7==7?68D'
6 96535656786; 66 23 6B4@D83> 79>39 >:53> , 4:;;3> 68 96B3 7 GH 523 968A64:= 6F6= .@>D3 :8> . :6A2@9 78 523 :44=6A:5678 <6=3> @8>39 3A5678 #%7<6;;35:;6>3 666 < 523 :B7@85 7< ; *( 6; :=93:>H >3<933J3>:8>6;:=93:>H59:8;<3993>57523 :AA7@857<93;478>3857GHF695@37<523 6B4@D83>79>39523;:B36;79>393>57G3 93F3953> G:AC 57 523 :AA7@85 7< 523 4356567839<933<97B:==38A@BG9:8A3;
")* '%%( &! & 6;57'=7'