Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 62969 (KAR)

SHAMANNA AND ORS v. PRABHU AND ANR

MFA/202604/2024 · 2025-11-05

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %!& ' ! " # $ % ! & & $ '' !' & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ (!!! " # $ ) $% '' #% '$ ' * & * !!! $& &' $ ! '& ' &*$+ + ,& # -./011203./142524426789-2:30.;0<9/0=0.</9 9-2 &>6=;2<9 0<6 0?046 60926 !!! 10//26 .< $ @ ! 78 9-2 66.9.@<03 2<.@4 .A.3 &>6=2 0<6 &' @>49 .604 #5@4 /-@49 B9-2 94.7><03C% /22D.<= 2<-0<:2;2<9@59-2:@;12</09.@< <2;904A09-.;29?.9-0::.62<90<6/>552426 50903.<E>4.2/0<6?-.32@<9-2?089@@/1.903/>::>;7269@ 9-2 .<E>4.2/ 30.;0<9 @ ./ 9-2 ->/70<6 @5 9-2 62:20/26 - 3 - 0<6:30.;0<9@/0<60429-2:-.3642<@59-262:20/26 -28 5.326 0 :30.; 129.9.@< 725@42 9-2 94.7><03 /22D.<= :@;12</09.@< @5 /! !! !!! 03@<= ?.9- .<9242/9 09 9-2 4092@5F1240<<>;54@;9-26092@5129.9.@<9.339-26092 @5 4203.G09.@< -2 94.7><03 05924 :@</.624.<= 9-2 2<9.42 2A.62<:2 @< 42:@46 -0/ 0?04626 0 />; @5 / H! !!! 03@<= ?.9- .<9242/9 09 9-2 4092 @5 (F 124 0<<>; 54@; 9-2 6092@5129.9.@<9.339-26092@54203.G09.@<2.<=0==4.2A2678 9-2 /0.6 &>6=;2<9 0<6 0?046 9-2 :30.;0<9/ 142524426 9-2 142/2<9011203 9 ./ :@<92<626 9-09 9-2 62:20/26 04A09-. ?0/ 6@.<=307@>4?@4D0<6204<.<=0/>;@5/!! 1246089 ./ 03/@ :@<92<626 9-09 <@ 0;@><9/ 042 =40<926 ><624 9-2 -206@55>9>4214@/12:9/-2425@42 42I>2/9269-./@>495@4 2<-0<:2;2<9@59-2:@;12</09.@< 204<26 :@></23 5@4 9-2 42/1@<62<9 @ </>40<:2:@;10<8:@<92<6269-09 0/1246-04046 -24 6092@57.49-.//-@?<0/!!H((-26-04046./<@9 ;04D26 725@42 9-2 94.7><03 -2 ;29 ?.9- 0::.62<9 @< - 4 - !!<9-21@/9;@492;421@49 -240=2./;2<9.@<26 0/ 8204/2<:2 -240=2./9@72:@</.624260/1249-2 1@/9;@492; 421@49 0<6 9-2 ;>39.13.24 ./ B C -2 :30.;0<9/ -0A2 <@9 5.326 0<8 .<:@;2 14@@5 @5 9-2 62:20/26 -2 62:20/26;29?.9-9-20::.62<90<66.26.<9-28204! -2425@42 0/1249-2=>.623.<2/@59-204<090D090922=03 24A.:2/>9-@4.98 -24.<:@;2./9@7290D2<09/ ! F./9@72066269@?046/5>9>4214@/12:9/0<6 46./9@ 72 626>:926 9@?046/ 124/@<03 2J12</2/ 2<:2 9-23@// @5 6212<62<:8?@>36720/><624+ / ! K F 46 L L F M /! ( !!! 30.;0<9@./2<9.93265@4/ !!! 9@?046/ 3@//@5:@</@49.>;0<6:30.;0<9@/0<604203/@2<9.9326 9@/ !!! 20:-><6249-2-206@51042<903:@</@49.>; -2 :30.;0<9/ 042 03/@ 2<9.9326 9@ 0 />; @5 /! !!! 9@?046/ :@<A2<9.@<03 -206/ 2<:2 9-2 9@903 :@;12</09.@< ?@>36720/><624+ - 5 - ( )*+,-./)0,*120 .301 @//@56212<62<:8 /! ( !!! @// @5 :@</@49.>; #/ !!! L% / !!! @<A2<9.@<03-206/ /! !!! 1*( , 4 ( 204<26 :@></23 5@4 9-2 </>40<:2 :@;10<8 />7;.9/ 9-09 9-2 :@;12</09.@< 0;@><9 0?04626 78 9-2 94.7><03-0/722<621@/.926725@429-294.7><03 ::@46.<=38 9-25@33@?.<=+ #.% -2011203./033@?26.<1049) #..% -2 :30.;0<9/ 042 2<9.9326 9@ 9@903 :@;12</09.@< @5 / !!! 03@<= ?.9- .<9242/9099-24092@5(F1240<<>;54@;9-26092 @5 129.9.@< 9.33 9-2 6092 @5 4203.G09.@< 0/ 0=0.</9 / H! !!! 0?04626789-294.7><03) #...% -2 </>40<:2 :@;10<8 ./ 6.42:926 9@ 621@/.9 9-2 2<-0<:26 :@;12</09.@< @5 / !!! 03@<=?.9-.<9242/9?.9-.<@<2;@<9- 54@;9-26092@59-./@4624) - 6 - #.A% <621@/.9 9-2:30.;0<9@ 0112330<9 @ 03@<2 ./ 124;.9926 9@ ?.9-640? 9-2 2<9.42 0;@><903@<=?.9-.<9242/90::4>26@<.9 /6 #% & $ ./9@+3@+!