- 1 - ! ! "#! "# !! $%& '( !! )) $%& !! $%& ' ( ! "#" $ ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "$#" % & & ' # (! & ) $) (*&( + *&,& - ( . , ) * **&&( *, + *&,& & (* / & ) ) (!) ) !-' -%)) " * - - * " - - !-' -% " * - 3 - ))' ( !( % ! , ( & &, 0 ) $) - 4 - - + *&,& - ' . , ) 0 * **&&( *, *&,& & + *&,& & ) * !1 &/ / '* ) ) (!) ) !-( -%)) " * - - * " - - !-( -% " * ' ( !( % - 5 - ! , ( & &, 0 ) - + . , ) 0 * *&&( *, + *&,& & *&,&- ) - 6 - ) ) (!) " - - 0 !-( -% "2345 " ) ) " 6 " 6 " ) # 6 " ) ' 70247 87595 ! :;;5:<9 = 5 ) 0 --'-- - >? ) 0 --&%% - :@3 ) 0 -!! - :A5 <=9853 :<0@4 ?=87 0875A - :;;5:<9 = 5 ) 09 -!&( - -% - -&( - -&(' - -&,' - -'!- - -,', - -,'% - -,(- - 1 - ''' - 9=@>5 875A5 :A5 8?0 >0BB0@ C234B5@89 7:D=@4 8?0 3=EE5A5@8 3:859 = 5 9= 5 09 !-' -%:@3!-( -%3:853 - - :@30875A&9F5:A=@4 09 - - ! - - & - - ' - - :@3 ( - - 3:853 - 7 - - -! - FG 875 9:B5A=F2@:<:@3 :<< :A5 :A=9=@4 028 0E9:B5:>>=35@8 )0A FA5D=8G 87595 ! :;;5:<9 = 5 ) 0 --'-- - >? ) 0 --&%% - :@3 ) 0 -!! - :A535>=353FG:95;:A:85>0BB0@ 0A35A :@3 0875A - :;;5:<9 :A=9=@4 028 0E 09 - - ! - - & - - ' - - :@3 ( - -0@- -! - 3:853- -! - :A53=9;09530E FG:95;:A:85>0BB0@0A35A ! 7595 87A55 :;;5:<9 F5=@4 ) 0 --'-- - ) 0 --&%% - :@3 ) 0 - ''' - :A5 E=A98 8?0 FG 875 =@92A5A :@3 A5B:=@=@4 0@5 FG 875 ><:=B:@8 >:<<=@4 =@ H2598=0@ 875 >0BB0@ C234B5@8 :@3 :?:A3 3:853 - - =@ 0 !-' -%:@30 !-( -%;:9953FG875 5@=0A =D=<"23451*:8:34=A=0@8754A02@30E<=:F=<=8G :9?5<<:9H2:@82B - 8 - 5:A3 A= 9;:<<=<5:A@53>02@95<:;;5:A=@4 E0A875:;;5<<:@8=@92A5A=@)0 --'-- - :@3) 0 --&%% - :@3 A= 55A:@:4023: :<=;:8=< <5:A@53 >02@95< :;;5:A=@4 E0A :;;5<<:@89><:=B:@89 =@ ) 0 - ''' - & 75 3:85 0E :>>=35@8 =@D0<D5B5@8 0E D57=><5 35:87 0E 7:IAG: 0 B<: :@3 7:@G: 0 7:IAG: :A5 @08 =@ 3=9;285 75 0@<G 3=9;285 =9 ?=87 A54:A3 80 875 <=:F=<=8G 80 ;:G 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ @ 875 :<85A@:8=D5 >0@8A=F280AG @54<=45@>5 0@ 875 ;:A8 0E 875 3A=D5A 0E 875 :280A=>I97:?:9?5<<:9H2:@82B0E>0B;5@9:8=0@FG875 =@92A5A:95J0AF=8:@8:@3FG875><:=B:@8:9=@:35H2:85 ' A= 9;:<<= =@ F087 875 :;;5:<9 92FB=89 87:8F0878753A=D5A90E8750EE5@3=@4<0AAG:9?5<<:9875 :280 A=>I97:? ?5A5 @08 70<3=@4 :@G D:<=3 :@3 5EE5>8=D5 3A=D=@4 <=>5@95 :8 875 8=B5 0E =@>=35@8 75 0?@5A 0E 875 :280*A=>I97:? 5@8A29853 875 :280 A=>I97:? 80 875 3A=D5A 359;=85 7:D=@4 I@0?<5345 87:8 75 ?:9 @08 70<3=@4 D:<=3 - 9 - :@3 5EE5>8=D5 3A=D=@4 <=>5@95 :8 87:8 8=B5 )2A875A 98:853 87:8:9;5AJ !875>0@>5A@530<=>57:D5E=<53>7:A45 97558:4:=@988753A=D5A0E875<0AAG:9?5<<:98750?@5A 0E875:280A=>I97:? 0E:A:90?@5A0E875:280A=>I97:? =9>0@>5A@538750<=>57:D5=@D0I53875;A0D=9=0@92@35A 875080A57=><5>8%,,E0A970A8K875>8L 7:8 :;:A8 75 7:9 E2A875A 92FB=8853 87:8 :8 875 8=B5 0E :>>=35@8 =@ 875 :280 875 3A=D5A ?:9 >:AAG=@4 B0A5 87:@ 85@ ;5A90@9 ?75A5:9 875 95:8=@4 >:;:>=8G :9 ;5A 875 A54=98A:8=0@ >5A8=E=>:85 =9 M! ?7=>7 =9 ><5:A<G 5D=35@8 =@ 875 >7:A45 97558 :8 J ! @ D=5? 0E :F95@>5 0E D:<=3 :@35EE5>8=D53A=D=@4<=>5@950E8753A=D5A0E875<0AAG875 A=F2@:<02478807:D55J0@5A:853875@92A:@>50B;:@G EA0B ;:G=@4 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ @ 875 :<85A@:8=D5 9=@>5 875 >7:A45 97558 =9 E=<53 :4:=@98 875 0?@5A 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? E0A D=0<:8=0@ 0E ;A0D=9=0@9 0E 875 >8 875 >0@8A=F280AG@54<=45@>502478807:D5F55@9:33<530@875 3A=D5A 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? 5 E2A875A 92FB=89 87:8 875 A=F2@:< 7:9 :?:A353 5J0AF=8:@8 >0B;5@9:8=0@ 8:I=@4 - 10 - 7=475A =@>0B5 =@ 875 :F95@>5 0E ;A00E 80 87:8 5EE5>8 9 92>78759:B5A5H2=A59A5*>0@9=35A:8=0@ ( @)0 --'-- - 87535>5:9537:IAG: ?:9:453G5:A9:F0D5 @D=5?0E875<:?<:=330?@FG 875 0@6F<5 ;5J 02A8 =@ 875 >:95 0E !"# &N 02478 80 7:D5 F55@ :3353 80?:A39 K)282A5 A09;5>89L 80 875 5J=98=@4=@>0B5=@985:3-N:98:I5@FG875A=F2@:< @ 875 >=A>2B98:@>5 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 FG 875 A=F2@:< A5H2=A59 A5>0@9=35A:8=0@ >>0A3=@4<G 75 902478 80 :<<0? F087 875 :;;5:<9 :@3 5J0@5A:85 875 @92A:@>5 0B;:@G EA0B ;:G=@4 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ 0A =@ 875 :<85A@:8=D5E:985@875>0@8A=F280AG@54<=45@>50@875280 A=>I97:? 5E2A875A92FB=8987:8=@8755D5@887=902A8=9 @08 =@><=@53 80 >0@9=35A 875 ><:=B 0E >0@8A=F280AG @54<=45@>5 875 @92A:@>5 >0B;:@G F5 A595AD53 ?=87 875 <=F5A8G 80 A5>0D5A 875 9:B5 EA0B 875 0?@5A 0E 875 0EE5@3=@4D57=><5= 5 875<0AAG 1 -(' ',- - 11 - , <:>=@4 0FC5>8=0@9 80 875 92FB=99=0@ 0E 875 <5:A@53 >02@95< :;;5:A=@4 E0A 875 =@92A5A =@ F087 875 :;;5:<9 A= 55A:@4023: :<=;:8=< E0A 875 :;;5<<:@89><:=B:@89 =@ ) 0 - ''' - ?=87 :<< D575B5@>592FB=8987:8875=@92A5A5J>5;80@8754A02@3 0E =@D0I=@4 0E ;A0D=9=0@9 2@35A 875 >8 FG 875 ;0<=>5 :4:=@98 875 3A=D5A 0E <0AAG 7:9 @08 <53 :@G 5D=35@>5 80 970? 87:8 875 0?@5A 0E 875 D57=><5 =@ E:>8 >:28=029<G 7:D=@4 I@0?<5345 A54:A3=@4 875 E:>8 87:8 3A=D5A ?:9 @08 ;099599=@4 5EE5>8=D5 :@3 D:<=3 <=>5@95 359;=85 5@8A29853 875 D57=><5 =@ 875 7:@39 0E 875 3A=D5A 7:8 :;:A8 875 35>5:953:A587587=A3;:A8=59808750EE5@3=@4D57=><5:9 875G :A5 875 =@B:859 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? 7:8 :;:A8 B5A5 =@D0I=@4 0E ;A0D=9=0@9 2@35A 875 >8 0@ 875 0?@5A 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? ?=<< @08 ;A0D=35 : 4A02@3 80 875 =@92A5A 80 >0@85@3 87:8 875 3A=D5A 0E 875 0EE5@3=@4 D57=><5 >0@8A=F2853 80?:A39 875 @54<=45@>5 75 0@6F<5 ;5J 02A8 =@ 875 >:95 0E !" $% & - 12 - ! !'" (" :8 ;:A:4A:;7 0 , 7:9 ><:A=E=53 87:8 =@ 875 :F95@>5 0E 875 ;A00E 0E A:97 :@3 @54<=45@8 3A=D=@4 0@ 875 ;:A8 0E 875 3A=D5AA=35A 0E 875 D57=><50AB080A>G><5@0@5J=985@>50E<=>5@95=895<E B:G @08<5:380:E=@3=@40E@54<=45@>5:9A54:A39875:>>=35@8 8070<387:8875A5=9:>0@8A=F280AG@54<=45@>50@875;:A8 0E8753A=D5AA=35A0E8759:=30EE5@3=@4D57=><5 % 0E:A:9H2:@82B=9>0@>5A@53875A=F2@:<=@ 0 !-' -% ?7=>7 =9 >:<<53 =@ H2598=0@ =@ ) 0 --'-- - ;A0;5A<G >0@9=35A53 875 >:95 0E 875 ><:=B:@89:@3:?:A353:;;A0;A=:85>0B;5@9:8=0@:9E:A:9 :33=@4 -N 80?:A39 K)282A5 A09;5>89L =9 >0@>5A@53 0 E:A:9875=@>0B5=9>0@>5A@53875A=F2@:<7:9@088:I5@ 875 =@>0B5 E=J53 2@35A 875 >7:A8 ;A5;:A53 FG 875 :A@:8:I: 8:8554:< 5AD=>592870A=8G0E87=902A8E0A 970A8 K L 70?5D5A =8 7:9 8:I5@ 875 =@>0B5 :8 875 A:85 0E 9 ----* ;5A B0@87 75 :>>=35@8 ?:9 0E 875 G5:A -% 9 ;5A 875 >7:A8 875 =@>0B5 E=J53 E0A 875 2 (2008) 12 SCC 436 - 13 - G5:A -%=9:8 9 ! &-*;5AB0@87 70247875A5=9 @0:;;5:<FG875><:=B:@8970?5D5A875G:A55@8=8<53E0A :;;A0;A=:85 >0B;5@9:8=0@ ?=87=@ 875 B5:@=@4 0E C298 >0B;5@9:8=0@ @ D=5? 0E ;A0D=9=0@ 2@35A A35A $ 2<5 0E 87=9 02A8 B:G >0@9=35A 875 >:95 FG A5*3585AB=@=@4 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :@3 :?:A3 :;;A0;A=:85 >0B;5@9:8=0@ - 0 E:A :9 :;;5:< =@ ) 0 - ''' - =9 >0@>5A@5387535>5:953?:9:453!&G5:A9:88758=B50E :>>=35@8 92AD=D53 FG 7=9 ?=E5 90@9 :@3 B0875A 5 ?:9 ?0AI=@4:9:>00<=5:@35:A@=@4:8 9 !----*;5AB0@87 75 A=F2@:< 7:9 8:I5@ 875 =@>0B5 :8 9 ----* ;5A B0@87?7=>7=9:4:=@98875K 6>7:A898:853 9 92>7 875 9:B5 A5H2=A59 A5>0@9=35A:8=0@ :@3 A5*3585AB=@:8=0@ :@3 :>>0A3=@4<G 902478 80 :<<0? 875 :;;5:<E=<53FG875:;;5<<:@89><:=B:@89FG3=9B=99=@4F087 875:;;5:<9E=<53FG875:;;5<<:@8O=@92A5A - 14 - :D=@475:A3875<5:A@53>02@95<:;;5:A=@4E0A 875;:A8=59;5A2953:<<875:;;5:<;:;5A9:9?5<<:98A=:< 02A8A5>0A3875>0BB0@;0=@8987:8?02<3:A=95E0A02A >0@9=35A:8=0@:A5:92@35A ! " " # $ 2A :@9?5A 80 875 :F0D5 ;0=@89 E0A >0@9=35A:8=0@:A5:92@35A 0=@8 :A8<G*=@*:EE=AB:8=D5 0=@8 :A8<G*=@O:EE=AB:8=D5E0A875E0<<0?=@4/ 75:;;5<<:@8*=@92A5A=@F087875:;;5:<9=9F5E0A5 87=902A80@8754A02@39 - 15 - ! )=A98<G8753A=D5A0E8750EE5@3=@4<0AAG?:9@08 70<3=@4 5EE5>8=D5 :@3 D:<=3 3A=D=@4 <=>5@95 9 92>7 875 @92A:@>5 0B;:@G =9 @08 <=:F<5 80 ;:G >0B;5@9:8=0@ =@ D=5?0EFA5:>70E;0<=>G>0@3=8=0@9 5>0@3<G87595:8=@4 >:;:>=8G 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? =9 ;<29 ! :9 ;5A 875 ?75A5:9875A5?5A585@;5A90@98A:D5<=@4=@8759:=3:280 A=>I97:? :88758=B50E:>>=35@8 7=A3<G8750<=>57:D5 =@D0I53;A0D=9=0@92@35A875>8:4:=@988750?@5A0E 875 :280A=>I97:? ?7=>7 ><5:A<G970?9 87:88753A=D5A0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? ?:9 @08 70<3=@4 :@G 3A=D=@4 <=>5@95 :9 0@8753:850E:>>=35@8 992>7757:9:<90>0@8A=F2853 80 875 :>>=35@8 )02A87<G 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 FG 875 A=F2@:< =9 5J0AF=8:@8 :@3 =9 A5H2=A53 80 F5 A532>53 )=E87<G9=@>5875A5=9D=0<:8=0@0E;0<=>G>0@3=8=0@9<=F5A8G F5 A595AD53 80 A5>0D5A >0B;5@9:8=0@ EA0B 875 0?@5A 0E 0EE5@3=@4<0AAG 5 7:D5 40@5 87A0247 875 5@8=A5 A5>0A39 59;5>=:<<G9;089I58>7E=<53FG8750<=>5:4:=@988753A=D5A 0E8750EE5@3=@4D57=><5 8=945AB:@580B5@8=0@87:8:<< - 16 - 875;A0D=9=0@92@35A875:A5=@D0I53:4:=@988753A=D5A 0E8750EE5@3=@4<0AAG8759;089I58>7><5:A<GA5D5:<987:8 875:>>=35@8?:90@8755J8A5B5<5E89=350E875A0:30@ 8753=A5>8=0@875:280A=>I97:??:9;A0>553=@4875<0AAG ?:9 >0B=@4 =@ 875 0;;09=85 3=A5>8=0@ 7:3 40@5 80 875 5J8A5B5 ?A0@4 9=35 = 5 A=478 9=35 ?75A5:9 875 :280 A=>I97:? ?:9 ;<G=@4 0@ 875 5J8A5B5 <5E8 9=35 =@ 85AB9 0E 8758A:EE=> 2<59 @87595>=A>2B98:@>59=8=98753A=D5A0E 875 <0AAG ?70 =9 A59;0@9=F<5 E0A 875 :>>=35@8 5A5<G =@D0I=@4 ;A0D=9=0@9 0E >8 :4:=@98 875 0?@5A 0E 875 :280 A=>I97:? >02<3 @08 4=D5 : 9;:>5 E0A 875 =@92A5A 80 955I E0A >0@8A=F280AG @54<=45@>5 :4:=@98 875 3A=D5A 0E :280A=>I97:? 9A=478<G>0@85@353FG875<5:A@53>02@95< :;;5:A=@4 E0A 875 ><:=B:@89*:;;5<<:@89 =@ 875 >0@@5>853 :;;5:<87:8@0@*5J=985@>50E<=>5@95?=<<@084=D5A=47880 875 @92A:@>5 0B;:@G 80 >0@85@3 87:8 875 3A=D5A 7:9 >0@8A=F285380?:A39875:>>=35@8 7=9;09=8=0@0E<:?7:9 F55@9588<53FG8750@LF<5;5J02A8=@!"$% &92;A: 0E:A:987595:8=@4>:;:>=8G=9>0@>5A@53=8 - 17 - =9 @08 875 >:95 0E 875 @92A:@>5 0B;:@G 87:8 875 :>>=35@87:90>>2AA53325805J>553=@495:8=@4>:;:>=8G=@ 875 :280 A=>I97:? ?7=>7 =9 875 >:295 E0A :>>=35@8 75 :280 A=>I97:? ?:9 ;<G=@4 0@ 875 5J8A5B5 <5E8 9=35 0@ =89 ?:G 8 =9 875 3A=D5A 0E 875 <0AAG ?70 7:9 40@5 0@ 875 5J8A5B5A=4789=350E875A0:3:@3>:2953875:>>=35@8 & 0E:A:9875>0@85@8=0@;<:>53FG=@92A5A87:8 875 3A=D5A 0E <0AAG ?:9 @08 70<3=@4 D:<=3 :@3 5EE5>8=D5 3A=D=@4<=>5@95:992>7875:F90<285<=:F=<=8GF5=@85AE5A53 ?=874A:@8=@4<=F5A8G80A5>0D5AEA0B=@92A53 5E=@3E0A>5 =@ 875 :A42B5@8 :3D:@>53 FG 875 <5:A@53 >02@95< A= 9;:<<= 87:8 =@ D=5? 0E <:? <:=3 30?@ FG 875 0@LF<5 ;5J 02A8 =@ 875 >:95 0E )) ( $% %* 3 87:8 =@ 875 :F95@>5 0E <=>5@95 875 =@92A5A =9 <=:F<5 80 9:8=9EG 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ ;A=B:A=<G :@3 ?=87 <=F5A8G 80 A5>0D5A 875 9:B5 EA0B 875 0?@5A 0E 875 D57=><5 ?75@ 875 87=A3 ;:A8G ><:=B =9 =@D0<D53=@8753=9;285 >>0A3=@4<GA595AD=@49:=3<=F5A8G 3 -,! !-, - 18 - 875 @92A:@>5 0B;:@G =9 3=A5>853 80 ;:G 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ ;A=B:A=<G 875A5:E85A A5>0D5A EA0B =@92A53 @ 87595 >=A>2B98:@>59 :<< 875 4A02@39 8:I5@ FG 875 :;;5<<:@8 * @92A:@>5 0B;:@G :A5 <=:F<5 80 F5 A5C5>853 :@3 :>>0A3=@4<G A5C5>853 70<3=@4 ;0=@8 0 K;:A8<G =@ :EE=AB:8=D5L ' 0 E:A :9 875 H2:@82B 0E >0B;5@9:8=0@ =9 >0@>5A@53 =@ ) 0 --'-- - 875 A=F2@:< ?7=<5 :33=@4 E282A5 ;A09;5>89 7:9 >0BB=8853 :@ 5AA0A 870247 7:9 A5>0A353 : E=@3=@4 87:8 875 35>5:953 ?:9 :453 - G5:A9 70?5D5A 8:I5@ 875 E282A5 ;A09;5>89 :8 -N @ 85AB9 0E 875 <:? <:=3 30?@ FG 8750@6F<5 ;5J02A8 =@ 875 >:95 0E !"48759:B502478807:D5F55@8:I5@ &N9=@>5875 -N>02<3F5:33530@<G=@>:959?75A5=@875;5A90@9:A5 ?=87=@875:454A02;0EK-LG5:A9:@3K-L:@3:F0D5875 E282A5 ;A09;5>829 80 F5 :3353 =9 &N 9 92>7 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 A5H2=A59 A5*3585AB=@:8=0@ 4 2009 ACJ 1298 - 19 - 0?5D5A =8 >:@@08 F5 <098 9=478 87:8 875 A=F2@:< 7:9 8:I5@=@>0B5:8875A:850E 9 ----*;5AB0@87:9;5A K 6 875 =@>0B5 E=J53 E0A 875 G5:A -% =9 :8 9 ! &-*;5AB0@87 70247875><:=B:@89:A5@08=@ :;;5:<F282@35A8755J;A599=0@KC298>0B;5@9:8=0@L875G :A55@8=8<5E0A8757=475A=@>0B5F28E0A875A5:90@:9875 ><:=B:@89 :A5 @08 =@ :;;5:< ?5 :A5 0E 875 >0@9=35A53 0;=@=0@87:8875>0B;5@9:8=0@:?:A353FG875A=F2@:<=E A58:=@53 ?02<3 B558 5@39 0E C298=>5 :9 875 ><:=B F5=@4 0@5 2@35A 875 F5@5E=>=:< <54=9<:8=0@ >>0A3=@4<G A58:=@9 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 FG 875 A=F2@:< )0A 875 E0A540=@4A5:90@9?5;:99875E0<<0?=@4 = 75:;;5:<=9 +,,) == 75C234B5@8:@3:?:A33:853 - - =@0 !-' -%;:9953FG 5@=0A=D=< "2345 :@3 * :34=A= =9 75A5FG B03=E=53 80 875 5J85@8 A595AD=@4 <=F5A8G 80 875 =@92A5A 80 A5>0D5A 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ E:985@530@=8EA0B875=@92A53 - 20 - === 75:B02@8=@35;09=897:<<F58A:@9B=8853 80 875 >0@>5A@53 A=F2@:< E0A87?=87 E0A 3=9F2A95B5@8 =D 75 :;;5<<:@8 O @92A:@>5 0B;:@G =9 ;A=B:A=<G<=:F<58035;09=8875>0B;5@9:8=0@ ?=87 <=F5A8G 80 A5>0D5A 875 9:B5 EA0B 875 0?@5A0E875D57=><5 D 75 :;;5<<:@8 * @92A:@>5 0B;:@G =9 3=A5>853 80 35;09=8 875 F:<:@>5 >0B;5@9:8=0@:<0@4?=87875=@85A598:9;5A 875 ?:A3% F5E0A5 875 >0@>5A@53 A=F2@:< ?=87=@ ' ?55I9 EA0B 875 3:85 0E A5>5=;8 0E >0;G0E87=90A35A D= 75 3=9F2A95B5@8 :9 ?5<< :9 875 :;;0A8=0@B5@8 =9 :9 ;5A 875 0A35A 0E 875 A=F2@:< D== 00A35A:980>098 ))' *+, ' ( 9 ;5A 875 A5>0A3 875 35>5:953 ?:9 :453 !& G5:A9 :9 0@ 875 3:85 0E 35:87 :@3 92AD=D53 FG 7=9 ?=E5 - 21 - 87A55 90@9 :@3 B0875A 9 ;5A 875 ><:=B:@89 35>5:953 ?:9 ?0AI=@4 :9 : >00<=5 :@3 5:A@=@4 :8 9 !----* ;5A B0@87 70?5D5A 875 A=F2@:< 7:9 >0@9=35A53 875 =@>0B5 9 ----*;5AB0@87=@:F95@>50E;A00E0E=@>0B5 9 ;5A875=@>0B5E=J532@35A875>7:A8;A5;:A53FGK 6 =9:8 9 ! &-* ;5AB0@87E0A875G5:A -%90E:A:9 :@2@9I=<<53<:F02A=9>0@>5A@53 @D=5?0E8759:B5875 =@>0B5B298F5>0@9=35A53:8 9 ! &-*;5AB0@87 9 87535>5:953F5=@4?=87=@K-6G5:A9:88758=B50E35:87 -NA5H2=A5380F5:335380?:A39 E282A5 ;A09;5>89 75 35>5:953 ?:9 :453 K!&L G5:A9 0@ 875 3:85 0E 35:87 :9 92>7875:;;A0;A=:85B2<8=;<=5A?02<3F5K'L:98:I5@FG 875A=F2@:< @D=5?0E:33=@4-N80?:A398755J=98=@4 =@>0B5 :8 9 ! &-* ;5A B0@87 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 FG 875 A=F2@:< A5H2=A59 A5>0@9=35A:8=0@ >>0A3=@4<G 875 :;;5:< E=<53 >:<<=@4 =@ H2598=0@ 875 H2:@82B FG 875 =@92A5A A5H2=A59 80 F5 A5C5>853 :@3 875 :;;5:< E=<53 FG 875 :;;5<<:@89><:=B:@89 A5H2=A59 80 F5 :<<0?53;:A8<G - 22 - , @87:8D=5?0E875B:885A0@A5*3585AB=@:8=0@ 875 :;;5<<:@89 :A5 5@8=8<53 E0A 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :9 E0<<0?9 - .*,/012.+/*34+ 15+3 / 0990E5;5@35@>G ! &- M -N J J ' J ! '( --* 0990E98:85 &---* ! 0990E)2@5A:<J;5@959 &---* 0990E0@90A8=2B 9 ----J& -----* & -N 59>:<:8=0@ E0A 87A55 >0B;<5853G5:A9 8=B59 P 9 -----M!---- Q !----J ---!G5:A9 M!G5:A9R 85AB9 '---* )67 ' % >>0A3=@4<G 875 ><:=B:@89 :A5 5@8=8<53 E0A : 92B0E/ )67 ':9:4:=@98/ 6) ' - )0A 875 E0A540=@4 A5:90@9 ?5 ;:99 875 E0<<0?=@4 = 75 :;;5:< E=<53 FG 875 :;;5<<:@8 O @92A5A :9?5<<:9><:=B:@89:A5 +,,) - 23 - == 75:;;5:<E=<53FG875:;;5<<:@89*=@92A5A=9 :<<0?53*=@*;:A8 0@<G 80 875 5J85@8 0E B03=EG=@4 875 C234B5@8 :@3 :?:A3 0E 875 A=F2@:< 80 ;:G 875 >0B;5@9:8=0@ ?=87 <=F5A8G80A5>0D5A8759:B5EA0B875=@92A53 0E<0AAG === @ ) 0 --&%% - 875 :B02@8 =@ 35;09=8 97:<< F5 8A:@9B=8853 80 875 >0@>5A@53 A=F2@:< E0A87?=87 E0A 3=9F2A95B5@8 =D 75 :;;5<<:@8 * @92A:@>5 0B;:@G =9 3=A5>853 80 35;09=8 875 F:<:@>5 A5* 3585AB=@53 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :<0@4 ?=87 875 =@85A598 98:853 % F5E0A5 875 >0@>5A@53 A=F2@:< ?=87=@ 9=J ?55I9 EA0B 875 3:85 0E A5>5=;80E>0;G0E87=90A35A D 75 >0B;5@9:8=0@ :?:A353 FG 875 A=F2@:< =9 A5*3585AB=@53 80 / )67 ' :9 :4:=@98 / 6) ' =@ 0 %-( -% :@3 97:<< >:AAG =@85A598 :8875A:850E'N;5A:@@2BEA0B8753:85 0E;58=8=0@98=<<A5:<=S:8=0@ - 24 - D= 75 3=9F2A95B5@8 :9 ?5<< :9 875 :;;0A8=0@B5@8 =9 :9 ;5A 875 0A35A 0E 875 A=F2@:< D== 00A35A:980>098 ,' $!& # ,' $& # =980 <0 (