- 1 - ! "!# $%! !!## &'( ) !"! # $ % & '"(!" # $&&& % ) ) !*($!% ) "!"!+ , !*"!( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) - ) % $ - )% ./0 122314 /0 56 7.3 841/91:7 8144/:; /: <=307/>: 7.3 ?=@;93:7 1:@ 1A1B@ @173@ "!"!+ /: >!*"!( 21003@ 56 7.3 >7>B 88/@3:70 41/90 B/5=:14 >, 17 /?162=B1 A.3B356 7.3 841/9 237/7/>: C/43@ =:@3B 387/>: ! ($%>C7.387/0@/09/003@567.3?=@;93:7.>4@/:;7.17 7.31223441:7.10C1/43@7>2B>D37.3:3;4/;3:83 31B@ B/ 19@12=B 431B:3@ 8>=:034 12231B/:; C>B 7.3 1223441:7841/91:7 1:@ B/ &1E.1:@E/ 1:@B/1:=B431B:3@8>=:03412231B/:;C>BB302>:@3:7 >B2>B17/>: ( :0.>B78>921007.3>B@3B21003@567.3B/5=:14 B3<=/B30 B3@373B9/:17/>: 1:@ B38>:0/@3B17/>: .3 B/5=:14 1C73B 2431@/:;0 CB193@ 7.3 /00=30 21B7/8=41B46 00=3 >! A./8.B31@010=:@3B - 3 - ! " #!$% & '' ( )! $! )) )$# ' * ) + $%, - ' =B/:; 7.3 8>=B03 >C 7.3 1B;=93:70 B/ 191@12=B5B>=;.77>7.3:>7/83>C7./0>=B77.177.3841/9 237/7/>:C/43@567.3B/@3B>C7.39>7>B8684381937>53144>A3@ /: 21B7 1:@ 7.3 8>923:017/>: .10 533: 017/0C/3@ 56 7.3 >B2>B17/>: >A3D3B /7 /0 1: =:C>B7=:173 /:8/@3:7 >C 7.3 2/44/>:B/@3B7.30193.10:>7533:8>:0/@3B3@567.3B/5=:14 .3 B/5=:14 A./43 1:0A3B/:; 00=3 >! .>4@/:; 7.17 7.3 1223441:7 .10 C1/43@ 7> 2B>D3 7.3 :3;4/;3:83 @/09/003@ 7.3 841/9 237/7/>: 7 /0 1 037743@ 2>0/7/>: >C 41A =:@3B 387/>: ! ($% >C 7.3 87 7.3B3 /0 :> <=307/>: >C 2B>D/:; 7.3 :3;4/;3:83 10 .10 533: .34@ 56 7.3 >:F543 23G >=B7 /: - 4 - !:D/3A>C7.3@/87=941/@@>A:567.3>:F543 23G>=B77.3C/:@/:;>C7.3B/5=:14B3<=/B307>5303710/@3 10 3BB>:3>=0 /:83 7.3 3:7/B3 122314 A10 @/09/003@ A./43 1:0A3B/:; 7.3 3:7/74393:7 >C 841/9 7.3 0193 B3<=/B30 B3 8>:0/@3B17/>:567.3B/5=:14 88>B@/:;467.3122314/0.3C/:@/:;>C 7.3 B/5=:14 >: 00=3 >! /0 037 10/@3 /: D/3A >C 387/>: ! ($% >C 7.3 87 .3 91773B /0 7> 7.3 B/5=:14 >:46 C>B <=1:7/C6/:; 7.3 8>923:017/>: C>B A./8. 7.3 841/91:71223441:7/03:7/743@/:73B90>C41A /:837.391773B/0>C7.3631B""7.3B/5=:14/0 B3<=3073@ 7> @/02>03 >CC 7.3 91773B A/7./: 1 23B/>@ >C 0/G 9>:7.0CB>97.3@173>CB383/27>C8>26>C7./0>B@3B * 3;/07B6 /0 @/B3873@ 7> 03:@ 518E 7.3 3:7/B3 B/14 >=B738>B@A/7./:7A>A33E0CB>97.3@173>CB343103>C7.3 8>26 1 (2019) 12 SCC 395 - 5 - .31223441:71:@7.3B302>:@3:7H>B2>B17/>:1B3 @/B3873@7>12231B53C>B37.3B/5=:14>:*!""A/7.>=7 A1/7/:;C>B1:6C=B7.3B:>7/83567.3B/5=:14 + .3B/5=:140.14491E31443:@31D>B7>@/02>03>CC 7.391773BA/7./:0/G9>:7.0CB>9*!"" !*+ & ( % /07>!4>&