- 1 - !"#$ %#&## # '( ')*+ ('** , ! !"#"$%& "'# #' ( ( ! ) '*!$%!'%'" ( ( ( ( '#$%'%'" Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + ( + ( ,-./,012345.6 47,./8,/69,-0,.1:01.,;6,064 -;;,<6/461;,=4.63,.,:<4/0,/6!6-6, ' 3, ;-<614/,0 <,61614/ 1: =19,0 >? 63, ;48<9-1/-/6 5/0,. ,;614/ "'# 4= 3-.-61?- -2-.1@ 5.-@:3- -/316- '%'& '%'& :,,@1/2 01.,;614/ 64 63, 9,-./,0 -21:6.-6, 64 <-:: 4.0,.: 4/ 63, ,/04.:,8,/6 :,/6 >? 63, A5.1:01;614/-9491;,==1;,.,710,/;,0-6//,B5.,! &61:/,;,::-.?-663,63.,:349064/46,63,:6-6564.? =.-8,C4.@ 247,./1/2 1/=4.8-614/ .,2-.01/2 /4/!;42/1D->9, 4==,/;,: ,;614/ $"" 4= 63, 40, 4= .181/-9 .4;,05., $E&..,F51.,:63-6C3,/1/=4.8-614/1:217,/6463, 4==1;,.!1/!;3-.2,4=-<491;,:6-614/4=63,;4881::14/C1631/ 63, 91816: 4= :5;3 :6-614/ 4= - /4/!;42/1D->9, 4==,/;, 63, 4==1;,. :3-99 ,/6,. 63, :5>:6-/;, 4= 63, 1/=4.8-614/ 1/ 63, - 3 - >44@ 64 >, 8-1/6-1/,0 =4. 63-6 <5.<4:, -/0 :3-99 .,=,. 63, 1/=4.8-/6 64 63, -21:6.-6, 5.63,. :5>!:,;614/ ' 4= ,;614/ $"" ,B<.,::9? =4.>10: - <491;, 4==1;,. =.48 1/7,:612-61/2-/4/!;42/1D->9,;-:,C16345663,<.14.4.0,.4= - -21:6.-6,C343-:<4C,.646.?:5;3;-:,4.64;4881616 =4.6.1-93,:6-6564.?0,:12/1:63,.,=4.,<9-1/1/=4.8-614/ 4= - /4/!;42/1D->9, 4==,/;, 85:6 >, .,;4.0,0 -/0 6.-/:8166,06463,45.6-/0-/?0,;1:14/641/161-6,-<491;, 1/7,:612-614/ 1/ .,:<,;6 4= :5;3 1/=4.8-614/ 85:6 >, 6-@,/ 4/9?5<4/-/,B<.,::A501;1-94.0,. 3, 3-.-61?- -2-.1@ 5.-@:3- -/316- '%'& C31;3 /4C 247,./: <.4;,,01/2: 1/ <9-;, 4= 63, .1/8-66,.:64C31;316-<<91,:.,<.405;,:63,:-8, ,::,/61-9:;3,8,1/,;614/$E,;614/$E$.,F51.,:63, <491;, 4==1;,. 64 ,/6,. 63, 1/=4.8-614/ -/0 64 .,=,. 63, 1/=4.8-/6 64 63, -21:6.-6, -/0 ,;614/ $E' <.4710,: 63-6/4<491;,4==1;,.:3-991/7,:612-6,-/4/!;42/1D->9,;-:, C163456 63, 4.0,. 4= - -21:6.-6,3-71/2 <4C,. 64 6.? :5;3 ;-:,4.;4881616=4.6.1-93,63,.,>?<.,:,.7,:63, 6C1/:-=,25-.0:4=-,/:5.1/263-663,<491;,04/461/161-6, - 4 - 1/6.5:17, 1/7,:612-617, :6,<: 1/ .,:<,;6 4= 9,:: :,.145: ;48<9-1/6:C163456<.14.A501;1-947,.:1236-/0>:,;5.1/2 =4.63,;48<9-1/-/6-;;,::6463,A501;1-9=4.58:463-663, -21:6.-6, 8-? ;4/:10,. C3,63,. 63,., ,B1:6 .,-:4/->9, 2.45/0:=4.01.,;61/21/7,:612-614/4.=4.6-@1/2463,.A501;1-9 :6,<: 3, C4.0: 4= >463 <.471:14/: 85:6 >, .,-0 <5.<4:17,9?63,?<9-;,-/-==1.8-617,056?4/63, -21:6.-6, 64-<<9?31:4.3,.81/06463,.,F51:1614/=4.C-.0,0>?63, <491;, -/0 64 .,;4.0 - ;4/:10,.,0 4.0,. ,163,. 01.,;61/2 1/7,:612-614/0,;91/1/26401.,;61/7,:612-614/C163.,-:4/: 4. 1/01;-61/2 63, =5.63,. <.4;,05.-9 ;45.:, =4. 1/:6-/;, 1::51/2<.4;,::6.,-61/263,8-66,.-:-;48<9-1/65/0,.63, .,9,7-/6 <.471:14/ 4. 01.,;61/2 .,21:6.-614/ C3,., - ;42/1D->9,4==,/;,,8,.2,:4/63,=-;,4=63,8-6,.1-9 "-;6:9,-01/26463,;-:,-.,-:5/0,. 3, ;48<9-1/-/6 3,.,1/9402,0- C.166,/ ;48<9-1/6 4/ '*$%'%'" -99,21/2 63-6 ;,.6-1/ 1/017105-9: C,., 5//,;,::-.19?1::51/263.,-6:64318<4/.,;,1<64=63,:-10 ;48<9-1/663,A5.1:01;614/-9491;,5634.161,:,B-81/,063, - 5 - /-65.,4=63,-99,2-614/:-/01::5,0-/,/04.:,8,/6/461/2 63-663,4==,/;,:01:;94:,063,.,1/-.,/4/!;42/1D->9, *<<9?1/263,->47,:,669,0:6-6564.?:;3,8,6463, =-;6: 4= 63, <.,:,/6 ;-:, 63, 6-614/ 45:, ==1;,. 3-: <,.=4.8,0 31: :6-6564.? 056? >? ,/6,.1/2 63, :5>:6-/;, 4= 63, ;48<9-1/-/6G: 1/=4.8-614/ 1/ 63, :6-614/ 01-.? -/0 >? 6.-/:81661/2 - .,F51:1614/ 64 63, 9,-./,0 -21:6.-6, 4/ '*$%'%'"H 1/ 041/2 :4 63, <491;, C,., <.,;950,0 =.48 ,8>-.@1/25<4/-/?1/7,:612-614/1/63,->:,/;,4=-/4.0,. =.48 63, -21:6.-6, 6 63,.,=4., >,;-8, 1/;58>,/6 5<4/ 63, 9,-./,0 -21:6.-6, 4/ .,;,1<6 4= 63, .,F51:1614/ 64 ;4/:10,.63,8-6,.1-9<9-;,0>,=4.,31864-<<9?31:A501;1-9 81/0 64 C3,63,. 63,., ,B1:6 .,-:4/->9, 2.45/0: 64 >,91,7, 63-6-/4==,/;,3-:>,,/;488166,0-/0C3,63,.-01.,;614/ =4. 1/7,:612-614/ :34590 1::5, -/0 63,/ 64 <-:: - ;9,-. .,-:4/,0-/01/6,.94;564.?4.0,..,;4.01/231:;4/;95:14/ 8,., ,/04.:,8,/6 -;@/4C9,021/2 .,;,1<6 C163456 ,B-81/-614/ 4= 63, 8-6,.1-9 -/0 C163456 .,;4.01/2 .,-:4/: ,163,. <,.81661/2 4. .,=5:1/2 1/7,:612-614/ 4. 1/01;-61/2 -/? -96,./-617,:6,<=.5:6.-6,:63,<.46,;617,<5.<4:,4=,;614/ - 6 - $""' .,;614/ $E' -/0 9,-7,: 63, 1/=4.8-/6.,8,019,::4.63,:,.,-:4/:63,=-195.,64<-:: -/,B<.,::-/0.,-:4/,04.0,.4/63,.,F51:1614/1:-;9,-. <.4;,05.-9 9-<:, C-..-/61/2 A501;1-9 1/6,.7,/614/ 3, -21:6.-6, 85:6 >, 01.,;6,0 64 0,;10, 63, 8-66,. -=.,:3 1/ -;;4.0-/;,C1639-C-/064.,;4.031:;4/;95:14/:1/C.161/2 :463-663,<-.61,:3-7,-0,=1/1617,-/0.,71,C->9,4.0,. E,/;,631:45.6<-::,:63,=4994C1/2 3,<,61614/1:-994C,0 3, 9,-./,0 !001614/-9 1719 (502, -/0 ( -9->5.-21 1: 3,.,>? 01.,;6,0 64 ;4/:10,. 63, .,F51:1614/ 0-6,0 '*$%'%'" =4.C-.0,0 >? 63, 6-614/ 45:, ==1;,. //,B5.,! -/0 64 <-:: - .,-:4/,0 4.0,. :6.1;69? 1/ ;4/=4.816? C163 63, <.4;,05., 8-/0-6,0 5/0,. ,;614/ $""' 4= 63, 40, 4= .181/-9 .4;,05., $E& -/0 63, ;4..,:<4/01/2 ,;614/ $E' 4= 63, 3-.-61?- -2-.1@ 5.-@:3--/316-'%'& - 7 - 3,9,-./,0 -21:6.-6,:3-99-<<9?31:A501;1-981/064 63, 8-6,.1-9 <9-;,0 >,=4., 318 -/0 .,;4.0 -<<.4<.1-6, =1/01/2: -: 64 C3,63,. 63, ;1.;58:6-/;,: C-..-/6 -/ 4.0,. <,.81661/2 1/7,:612-614/ 0,;91/1/2 :5;3 <,.81::14/ 4. -04<61/2-/?463,.;45.:,<,.81::1>9,1/9-C 3,,21:6.?1:01.,;6,064=4.63C163.,65./63,4.121/-9 .,F51:1614/ <.405;,0 >,=4., 631: 45.6 -=6,. .,6-1/1/2 - <3464;4<? =4. 63, .,;4.0 :4 -: 64 ,/->9, 63, <,61614/,. 64 <9-;,63,:-8,>,=4.,63,9,-./,0 -21:6.-6,=4./,;,::-.? 4.0,.: -+ '##* & 1:64'94$#