- 1 - !" ## $#%#& ' ! " # $$$ %& ' ''' (' $ ) & * ''$ ' & Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' * & ) * % ! + + )' & , * + ) - ++ . )' , * % + ) . ' $ $ ' + ' )'$ - 3 - ' /') ' ' " 012 344536 12 78 905 :5;5<:3<9 = 3>>?15@5: 78 905 AB:>C5<9 3<: :5D?55 :395: % 43225: 1< =, * =< 905 ::191=<36 5<1=? 1@16 )B:>5 3637B?3>1 E01D0 12 D=<;1?C5: 78 905 AB:>C5<9 3<: :5D?55:395:* 43225:1<= & ,=<905 ;165 =; 129?1D9 3<: ?521:1<> ;;1D5? 37=B? =B?9 3637B?3>178E01D09052B19=;9054631<91;;2;=?43?9191=< 3<:2543?3954=225221=<032755<:5D?55 05 37=@5 2B19 12 ;165: 78 905 4631<91;;2 F ?524=<:5<92 = 9= & 05?51< 255G1<> 43?9191=< 3<: 2543?395 4=225221=< 1< 905 ;=66=E1<> 2B19 2D05:B65 4?=45?9152 ! "## " #$ $! # # %! && '&& ' () *+,&- - 4 - D=<95<:1<> 1<95?3615 9039 =<5 :5D5325: F 3663443 032 9E= E1@52 78 <3C5 1<>3CC3 3<: '36G3CC3 05 4631<91;;2 = 9= * :5;5<:3<9 = 3<: C=905? =; 4631<91;;2=3<:&3?5905D016:?5<=;231: 3663443;?=C 012;1?29E1;5F1<>3CC305:5;5<:3<9=129052=< =;231: 3663443;?=C01225D=<:E1;5F'36G3CC3 058 D=<2919B95: 3 )=1<9 1<:B +3C168 05 2B19 4?=45?9152 3?5 3<D529?36 4?=45?9152 05?5 E32 <= 43?9191=< =; 905 231: A=1<9 ;3C168 4?=45?9152 $05< 905 4631<91;;2 ?5HB5295: ;=? 43?9191=< :5;5<:3<92 93G1<> 3:@3<93>5 =; 905 ?5@5<B5 ?5D=?: 293<:1<> 1< 9051? <3C52 :5<15: 905 65>191C395 203?5=;9054631<91;;2D=<29?31<1<>905C9=;1659052B19 * 5;5<:3<9 = ;165: 905 E?1995< 29395C5<9 :5<81<> 905 4631<9 3@5?C5<92 3<: 3:C1995: 905 ?56391=<2014 912D=<95<:5:903963<:1<8=%**3<: 3?5 905 3<D529?36 4?=45?9152 =E<5: 3<: 4=225225: 78 231: 3663443 05 231: 3663443 032 4B?D0325: 905 63<:1<8=C532B?1<>3D?52 >B<9321<905 - 5 - 853? ,,& 3<: 05 032 4B?D0325: 3<=905? 63<: 1< 8= C532B?1<> % 3D?52 *, >B<932 =E5@5? 905 231: 63<: E32 <=9 1<D6B:5: 9 12 D=<95<:5: 9039 905 231: 3663443 :B?1<> 012 61;5 91C5 :1@1:5: 905 4?=45?9152 3C=<>29 012 2=<2 15 :5;5<:3<92 = 3<: 32 366 905 :3B>095?2=; 366344303:C3??15:=<68:5;5<:3<92= 3<: 3<:9051??5245D91@5C=905?2 E5?5 29381<>32A=1<9 ;3C168=6:3<:216@5?=?<3C5<923<:D320E32>1@5<905 :3B>095?2 39 905 91C5 =; 9051? C3??13>5 2 2BD0 9058 03@5<=203?51<9054?=45?91520393245?90543?9191=< :5;5<:3<92 03: CB9395: 9051?2 <3C52 1< 905 ?5@5<B5 ?5D=?:2 <;3D9:5;5<:3<9= 03:2=6:63<:1<8= 9= =<5 37B?3= 1< 95?C2 =; ?5>1295?5: 2365 :55: :395: E01D0 905 4?=45?98 032 <=9 755< 1<D6B:5: 05 ;3905? =; 905 43?9152 43225: 3E38 * 853?2 3>= 3<: C3??13>5 =; 4631<91;;2 = 3<: E5?5 2=65C<1I5: 6=<> 3>= 32 2BD0 9058 3?5 <=9 03@1<> 3<8 203?5 1< 905 4?=45?9152 - 6 - 05 ?136 =B?9 032 ;?3C5: 905 ;=66=E1<> 122B52 . !& !' !! & / & !!0 .!&!' ' !!0 # . !' & ! !& 0 . !& & ! 0 .0 **123 . !' !& ' - !!&& %$ 4 #0 . !' -&!! 0 # . &0 05 4631<91;; =* 5J3C1<5: 32 $ 3<: >=9 5J017195: 21J :=DBC5<92 32 45? J 9= J& 5;5<:3<9 = 5J3C1<5: 32 $ 3<: 3<=905? E19<522 - 7 - 5J3C1<5:32$ 3<:>=95J017195: :=DBC5<923245? J 9= J < 344?5D1391=< =; 905 5@1:5<D5 905 ?136 =B?9 3<2E5?5: 122B5 = 3<: 1< 905 3;;1?C391@5 122B5 = 43?968 1< 905 3;;1?C391@5 122B52 = * 3<: 3::191=<36 22B5 = 3<: 1< 905 <5>391@5 3<:D=<25HB5<968:5D?55:9052B1932B<:5? 5!&- !& 4& # & 6!& /& & !! "## !!- - ( & !! "## ( & " !! "## 4& #6 & !& /& & !! 7!- *!& & 8 - 8 - & 5;5<:3<9=751<>9052=<=; 3663443;?=C 01225D=<:4?5;5??5:90534453605+1?2944566395=B?9 ;?3C5:;=66=E1<>4=1<92;=?192D=<21:5?391=< . 9 &:) - :0 . !!&& & &!!&0 # .0 % < ?5344?5D1391=< =; 905 C3995? 905 +1?29 44566395 =B?9 032 3<2E5?5: 4=1<92 = 3<: 1< 905 <5>391@5 3<: D=<25HB5<968 :12C1225: 905 344536 D=<;1?C1<> 905 AB:>C5<9 3<: :5D?55 43225: 78 905 ?136 =B?951<>3>>?15@5:9054?525<9344536 53?<5: D=B<256 ;=? 905 :5;5<:3<9 = 3445663<9 93G1<> 9012 =B?9 90?=B>0 905 ?5D=?:2 2B7C192 9039 905 ?56391=<2014 759E55< 905 43?9152 <=9 751<> 1< :124B95905?136=B?93<:905+1?2944566395=B?903@5 ;3165:9=344?5D13959054?1=?43?9191=<903903:93G5<463D5 759E55<905 :5;5<:3<92 = 3<: ?54?525<95:78 9051? - 9 - ?5245D91@5 C=905?2 3;95? 905 :5C125 =; 3663443 039 1< 95?C2 =; 905 43?9191=< ;3C168 4?=45?9152 E5?5 :1@1:5: 759E55< 905 9E= 2=<2 2 2BD0 905 ?136 =B?9 3<: 905 +1?29 44566395 =B?9 =B>09 <=9 9= 03@5 ?5=45<5: 905 C3995?3<::5D?55:9052B19322=B>09;=?52B7C1929039 905?5@5<B5?5D=?:2E5?5362=CB9395:1<;B?905?3<D5=; 231:43?9191=<5;5??1<>9=3@5?C5<9C3:51<3?3=*=; 905E?1995<29395C5<9052B7C1929039905:5;5<:3<9= 03: ?3125: 905 D=<95<91=< 9039 905 3663443 C3??81<> 012 C=905? '36G3CC3 3;95? :5C125 =; 012 ;1?29 E1;5 1<>3CC305?5;=?59054?52BC491=<=;:5;5<:3<9= 3445663<9 751<> 905 1665>191C395 D016: 362= D3<<=9 75 2B2931<5: 05?5;=?5 05 2B7C192 9039 905 2B7293<9136 HB5291=<=;E=B6:3?125;=?D=<21:5?391=< , 53?:5?B25:905?5D=?:2 9905=B925919129=75255<9039231: 3663443 E32 905 =E<5? =; 905 2B19 4?=45?9152 5 03: C3??15: 1<>3CC3 3<: '36G3CC3 05 4631<91;;2 = 9= * 3<: C=905?=;4631<91;;2=3<:&3<::5;5<:3<9= 3?5905 - 10 - D016:?5< 7=?< 9= 3663443 ;?=C 012 ;1?29 E1;5 1<>3CC3 05 :5;5<:3<9 = 12 7=?< 9= 3663443 ;?=C 012 25D=<: E1;5'36G3CC30=B>01<905E?1995<29395C5<9393?3 =* 3< 3995C49 12 C3:5 78 :5;5<:3<9 = 9= D=<95<: 9039 3;95? 905 :5390 =; 1<>3CC3 3663443 03: C3??15: '36G3CC390523C5:=52<=9293<:9=3<86=>1D+1?2968 :5;5<:3<9 = 3173<<3 E0= 12 3:C1995:68 7=?< 9= 3663443;?=C012;1?29E1;51<>3CC3128=B<>5?78 853?29=:5;5<:3<9=E0=127=?<9= 3663443;?=C012 25D=<:E1;5'36G3CC35D=<:6819129051?D32590393;95? 905 :5C125 =; 3663443 9051? ?5245D91@5 C=905?2 ?54?525<95: 9051? 1<95?5292 3<: 905 43?9191=< E32 5<95?5: 1<9= 01?:68 32 93G5< <=95 =; 78 905 ?136 =B?9 39 3?3 =*% =; 192 AB:>C5<9 :5;5<:3<9 = E0= 5J3C1<5: 01C256;32$0323:C1995:903905129052=<=;25D=<: E1;5 =; 3663443 3<: 012 ;3905? 03: C3??15: 012 C=905? '36G3CC3 :B?1<> 905 61;591C5 =; 1<>3CC3 05?5;=?5 905D=<95<91=<93G5<1<905E?1995<29395C5<9393?3=* ?B<2 D=<9?3?8 9= 905 3;=?5231: 3:C1995: ;3D9B36 3245D92 3<:905@5?8=<5:54=2191=<=;:5;5<:3<9= - 11 - 2 ?5>3?: 905 43?9191=< 12 D=<D5?<5: 905 ?136 =B?9 3<: 905 +1?29 44566395 =B?9 03@5 D=<DB??5<968 ;=B<: 9039 :5;5<:3<9 = 032 ;3165: 9= 4?=@5 905 4?1=? 43?9191=< 78 4?=:BD1<> 3<8 3DD5493765 5@1:5<D5 3@1<> 056:90B203@54?=D55:5:9=366=9905203?52=<90573212 =;<=91=<3643?9191=< = 2B7293<9136 HB5291=< =; 63E E=B6: 3?125 ;=? D=<21:5?391=<DD=?:1<>68905;=66=E1<>. 05344536D=<;1?C1<>905AB:>C5<93<: :5D?55 43225: 78 905 ?136 =B?9 3<: 905 +1?29 44566395 =B?9 (% $& " )) 129=6=